Mafia Game: Cheers/Frasier Theme

[omgwtfbbqpwned]

If Gory turns innocent, then I would clearly be an insane cop.

Or much much much more likely, you are a mafia/neutral with an ability to avoid one lynch.

 

[Jcakes1]

If I was scared to be taken out by OMG I'd want to move from that spot at as well - I think we all would. If I were Gory, I think I'd want to get a townie to vote in last. It'll be interesting to see his willingness towards that vote.

If Gory turns innocent, then I would clearly be an insane cop.

The problem is that what is going to happen is everyone will just vote / unvote and so on and so forth. Doesn't really help the town in anyway. That said I wasn't really thinking about your result on Mal, so from that point of view it might be best he doesn't take the hit.

 

[MartinLong]

Or much much much more likely, you are a mafia/neutral with an ability to avoid one lynch.

If I were to fake claim, don't you think I'd go for a role that hasn't been outed yet? There still are doubts b/c I am a claimed-unproved cop since Sath was one. Making a claim of another role would be far more beneficial to me as it would be more believable to others and has a chance to out a power role).

And who is to say it's only a one-shot ability? The only history we have of a Governor or "Lawyer" is from the SP game, which had some new dynamics to the role found on mafiascum. Also, what about lynchproof - bulletproof, but for lynches, and it's not an x-shot ability.

 

[flubbucket1]

I also find Mal's avoiding of the #1 position very very scummy.

Maybe we should try to convince Goryani to take the last position, I mean he is locked anyway.

Or you could just "fix" your broken vote.

I did see it, but I am not willing to put myself on the lock just yet. By my count OMG is at L-1 and I think Goryani can possibly lock and take the retribution hit, which ends up better for all of us.

I am also not sure how strict Thyiad is going to be regarding who takes the bullet, some hosts will kill of the person that first took it to L regardeless of unvotes, so until we hear from Goryani i would recommend that noone lock OMG.

I would make a LAMIST remark but that might seem catty, and how is that beneficial for "all of us??"

If I were to fake claim, don't you think I'd go for a role that hasn't been outed yet? There still are doubts b/c I am a claimed-unproved cop since Sath was one. Making a claim of another role would be far more beneficial to me as it would be more believable to others and has a chance to out a power role).

And who is to say it's only a one-shot ability? The only history we have of a Governor or "Lawyer" is from the SP game, which had some new dynamics to the role found on mafiascum. Also, what about lynchproof - bulletproof, but for lynches, and it's not an x-shot ability.

What ability?? Is that the ability you say you don't have??

 

[Jcakes1]

I would make a LAMIST remark but that might seem catty, and how is that beneficial for "all of us??"

You're right it is not better for all of us. I am sure you and your buddies would prefer to see multiple people die rather than a locked player take the hit wouldn't you?

Also why make a Lamist remark when you can imply it, that is much more fun :whistling:

 

[Jcakes1]

What ability?? Is that the ability you say you don't have??

Oh and if you actually read the entire post you quoted, it would be obvious that he is referring to the lawyer ability that he is speculating saved him.

But why bother reading, when you can have so much fun spreading doubt on the claimed cop......

 

[coju]

If I was scared to be taken out by OMG I'd want to move from that spot at as well - I think we all would. If I were Gory, I think I'd want to get a townie to vote in last. It'll be interesting to see his willingness towards that vote.

If Gory turns innocent, then I would clearly be an insane cop.

I'm surprised it takes the cop to mention this possibility (unless one other did that I missed.)

Well, I'm above the 2 constructive posts per day quota, and I'm not voting omg. So, I'll see y'all next day phase I reckon!

[hide] ...

 

[Autti]

Oh and if you actually read the entire post you quoted, it would be obvious that he is referring to the lawyer ability that he is speculating saved him.

But why bother reading, when you can have so much fun spreading doubt on the claimed cop......

How can you not doubt the claimed cop.

For a start we have already had one cop die, so the chances of having a second are slim. Secondly, he was mysteriously saved after a lynch yesterday and it was agreed he was the most scummy, and only claimed after having been locked. Thirdly he only has 2 investigation results, so it's hardly clear cut he is the cop.

I find accepting his word as fact stupid at this point. Goryani will reveal a lot of information for us, so until the next day, it's very understandable to not trust him.

 

[Autti]

Also if Goryani flips town, you could/are scum. I'm surprised its taken someone so long to mention this.

Is it normal to have 2 cops in a game?

 

[Jcakes1]

How can you not doubt the claimed cop.

For a start we have already had one cop die, so the chances of having a second are slim. Secondly, he was mysteriously saved after a lynch yesterday and it was agreed he was the most scummy, and only claimed after having been locked. Thirdly he only has 2 investigation results, so it's hardly clear cut he is the cop.

I find accepting his word as fact stupid at this point. Goryani will reveal a lot of information for us, so until the next day, it's very understandable to not trust him.

I am not saying I don't doubt him, I am saying glib is up to his old tricks of trying to take things out of context. It was pretty obvious that ML was referring to the ability that saved him (not his own ability).

I agree everything will become a lot more obvious once Goryani flips.

 

[Jcakes1]

Is it normal to have 2 cops in a game?

I wouldn't say it is normal, but it has happen, there was a game fairly recently that had a day cop and a night cop (I think it was CGs dreaming god / power roles game).

 

[flubbucket1]

It was RlyehExiled's game. And I'm glad you're not lurking as much as you were earlier. I'm still suspicious of you though...

 

[flubbucket1]

Regular cop. Role cop. What's so unusual about that?

You've got a boat load of people in this bar and we can't all claim to be VT now can we??

 

[Goryani]

The lynch of Gory will help to determine what's going on.

Actually, it won't.

Rabble Rouser: I found that on the wiki. Might explain why we have two lynches? If it is so, then we better really hurry to get omg lynched with vote 2.

I don't understand this. Link to Rabble Rouser. If the Rabble Rouser helps mafia, why is it good to use it on a player no one seems to find scummy enough to lynch via the regular method?

 

[Goryani]

Mod's a Mod!

I've only made it to 526, but has ML been confirmed as [highlight]SANE[/highlight] before goryani gets locked?

Negative. No one bothered to ask that question before I was locked. No one bothered to hear my thoughts before I was locked. An entire mafia team could have quick hammered what they saw as a convenient "follow the cop" result.

Also, you can't confirm a sane/insane cop with 2 diverging investigations and no death flip on either investigation. In this case, it's impossible to confirm without lynching either me or Mal or possibly ML (not sure if sane/insane would show on flip).

 

[Goryani]

Some people have casted doubt (we all should, of course), but no one has actually outright claimed ML to be wrong, including Gory himself.

I'm pretty sure no one but me raised the insane point. Some said that if I don't flip scum then ML is scum, but those people aren't wondering what that says about Malevolent.

 

[Autti]

Actually, it won't.

Why is that?

 

[Jcakes1]

It was RlyehExiled's game. And I'm glad you're not lurking as much as you were earlier. I'm still suspicious of you though...

Yeah sorry about that, it was not deliberate lurking. I just started a new job and am fairly busy. I'll try to post a bit more, but it can be difficult (otherwise the only time I can post is at night when noone else is ....)

 

[Goryani]

Yes, let us use vote 2 on Goryani...It will give you a chance to save your scumbuddy. You are painfully obvious, scum.

I take it you disagree with those suggesting a guilty cop verdict is a good candidate for vote 2?

Not going well? There is a Guilty result on a player and it is not going well?

From the brink of disaster to going well in the span of a lynch save and a couple night kills. Lulz.

 

[Goryani]

You say you wouldn't even give ML the chance. Does that mean you're ignoring the possibility of there being a bus driver? I've only been in 2 other games, but a bus driver has been in both, I think. Still, if a bus driver had switched Gory with someone, then no doubt he would have admitted to it if he didn't think Gory was scum.

If there was a bus driver switch, they would have switched ML with someone to protect him.