Re: City Mafia Game Thread
Claim: Coroner from Indianapolis, IA
Targets:
CG, no info (figured it was worth a shot, and he said I could only target dead people)
kegs, town vanilla (only option)
Sathoris, town Jailkeeper (higher pick than kegs, I had him pegged as special win condition after he was so focused on town names, but I was more curious when Ankeli had that role)
Vote: FredOfErik
Him or flub today is what I would enjoy seeing happen.
Most likely scenario: Mafia killed the vigilante last night (who also got off a kill) and are stealing his role.
Ryleh do you believe FoE that Laarz was mafia? Gwahir do you?
I have given this a lot of thought and I think FoE is town. I think it is unlikely that TC or Gory lied about their roles with the rolecop and role thief in play. Also, they were two high priority targets after claiming info roles. Laarz I thought was pretty scummy, and Pyro claimed his role was ninja. So unless Pyro and FoE are both scum, that is true. That leaves us no vig who could have been killed last night. Also, if I had been the vig, Larrz would top my list of people to go after yesterday.
I personally don't think outing the sk is the best idea. if we do, the "one"Mafia knows who to kill tonight. If that Mafia is well embedded as "town"then imo we could be on trouble.
If we keep the sk, accidently lynch a townie, we (if sk is siding with town) have an extra chance of killing a Mafia tonight.
Then, there is always yet possibility that the sk is Mafia. If that's the case, then we're doubly screwed. So, my concensious, would be to lynch the sk... But Idk..
Disagree on all counts. We find anyone who is antitown, we get rid of them, SK or mafia. Whichever is the more sure bet. I would much rather kill an SK than take a 50/50 shot at someone else. If the SK is mafia, all the better for us as there is one less person who is anti-town to deal with numbers wise.
Role: bus driver, however I could just as easily have said VT and it would have proven what? Role reveal is foolish and now gives the mafia more information.
Targets?
I find you to top my list of antitown targets. I was hoping you would claim jailer, but either a faction opposed to you made that claim or you just saw through my plan. But then you come up with a claim and give no info on what you did.
Vote: flubbucket
I'm far from sure TC was mafia. One of the things I've been wondering about is Gwaihir's role. I can see him waiting for everybody to claim before he would come out if he is the coroner. If that's the case he could probably shine some light on it.
How is everybody's feelings about RE?
-he's been lurking almost the entire game
-if we were to take the theory that SK had a high/mid pick, he and Gwaihir are the only options
-he made one post this day phase - no mention of suspects, and a vague claim that can only be tested by lynching him
I'm feeling more and more confident, that he is the SK. If not, I still wouldn't rule out the possibility of him being mafia.
Rlyeh: who do you want to lynch and why?
Yes, you hit it on the nose. Yes, I realize that my claim is shaky as an antitown could have the exact same info, assuming my two investigations came from the same team killing. I chose coroner because I expected only one kill a night, I didn't give SK a second glance, and didn't think many others would either. In this game, choice is everything and I figured that mafia would have reason to hide behind who they killed. This was another reason why I went after Pyro so hard the first day - I wanted mafia to be scared of claiming questionable roles, and hopefully lie in a way I could catch. My other option was rolecop, but I figured that would already be taken, even before watcher and tracker.
As for RE, I completely did not catch any breadcrumbs. I think he is a likely option for SK, with the other one being coju - what better claim than a bomb to avoid being lynched when you are nightkill immune? Testing that is a scary proposition though. Overall, I still think flubbs has the highest chance of being scum, as my vote goes to him.
