Re: Y.A.W.P's Warcraft Themed Pen 'n Paper RPG style Mafia Game Game Thread
In the event Feysal dies in the fight, the lynch votes will change from 5/6 to 4/5. The same people needed to lynch now will still need to lynch later (minus Feysal). If Nolecub dies as well, the lynch votes will still be 4/5. If Nolecub is a cultist, Sathoris could still be lynched. However, if Nolecub isn't a cultist, Sathoris won't be lynched if there are still 3 cultists left.
Vote: Sathoris
Sathoris has a long way to go to prove himself pro-town. "I'm Rexxar" is about as believable this game as "I'm a cop, Feysal is anti-town." Without backing up claims, it's assumed the claimer isn't telling the truth. There's too much information floating about to trust blindly.
One other thing to think about: When do parties enter into the picture?
If Feysal and Uraj are telling the truth, yes. If they aren't, as you imply, then no.
Yes, I've got inside information too. I tried to convince the rest reasonably but you kept lucking out. No matter, my role was created to take matters into my own hand and that is exactly what I will do.
Do tell. I'm always receptive.
I admit Feysal's initial claim caused me to seriously consider it a fake. Nothing he said about Gorny wasn't already known or could be proven. Gorny dropped enough hints about being a rogue, several players picked up and commented on it. The backstabbing comment fits any rogue, so it wasn't much of a prediction but could easily look like one. The 4/1/1 stats were first mentioned by me but could be guessed by the cultist recruiter as well. Feysal never mentioned being an Adventurer. Neither has Uraj. That seemed odd to me, though it's probably some aspect of the game I don't know about yet. The names were detailed enough to be believable, but obscure enough a duplicate was doubtful. Again, if he was a recruiter, he could know about choosing names already, so the name wasn't definitive. The nights receiving dossiers correspond with nights having a night kill (at the time) so they could have been obtained via night kill (obviously, Gorny wasn't night killed, but it was possible the townie recruiter was). The links in the roles I've already brought up, and no one aside from Feysal has commented on, though I see you followed the pattern. The revelation about the townie recruiter has yet to be proven true, and it can't be disproved without the townie recruiter coming forward. For all we know, the cult have severely weakened the town already and just need that piece of information to win. Sacrificing one or more cultists to draw out that winning info would be a smart play.
Uraj's claim wasn't prefect either. His name and role are similar enough to Feysal's that it could be faked. Noodle was night killed, so it's easy to assume he was pro-town. Only another cop or townie recruiter would be able to refute the result. A no result is common enough in our games it is more likely to put suspicion on the person investigated than the investigator. Standing up for Feysal is assumed if they are both faking it. Mafia standing up for someone they know to be pro-town is easy if only Uraj is faking it. Knowing nurman's result is a valid prediction. However, the prediction and fight could be nothing more than an elaborate method of throwing a fellow cultist under the bus. What a tactic, if so.
Since Uraj stood up for Feysal, Feysal isn't likely to be anti-town without Uraj also being anti-town. Fighting Feysal implies you also want to fight Uraj, or vote him. That's quite a pair of claims to disprove (and quite a pair of claims to fake!). Sathoris, if you want to reveal some of this inside information to enlighten us, I'm all ears. But the burden is on you.
that seems really bloody powerful...
