Re: Halloween Saw themed Mafia game.
This game has a way of being damned confusing. I've tried to see if there was some mistake somewhere, and I cannot find any. The latest point by Uraj that ITY indicated he knew YAWP had been switched before YAWP said anything is compelling. I don't want to lynch ITY, nor do I want to be lynched. Yet I need to find an explanation for why our results were contradictory.
I now have an idea that fits in Saw, allows both me and ITY to be telling the truth, and explains why there are three cops. I have no real evidence to support it, only a gut feeling I may be on the right track. Here goes.
Looking at the
wiki page of Saw characters, there are several mentions of different characters being framed for crimes. Most significantly, Eric Matthews framed several people, and Mark Hoffman framed Peter Strahm as a Jigsaw apprentice. I suggest the theory that Bad Ash, as Hoffman, may have been a
mafia framer. By day three when he was lynched, Bad Ash may have framed as many as three people, and if Marahumm was one of them, that would explain the anti town result I got of him. If this theory is true, YAWP would now be shown as anti-town if investigated, despite still being neutral.
This would explain three cops. We could all be sane, but the framer could screw with our investigation results, making us suspect each other when our results do not match. This would leave me as the weakest cop, since my results would be most susceptible to being corrupted.
As I said, I have no proof of any of this. But, I have to admit that the players my results appear to condemn have not acted guilty, so I have no choice but to question the accuracy of my results. ITY may see this as an opening to attack me, giving myself a way out. Please don't, I am simply trying to understand this mess we're in.