OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Despite admitting to being a rival scumbag trying to usurp the rightful ruler of this town, you make something of a point. I was crucified when I was the cop two rounds ago because everyone thought I was revealing after the fact (due to my bad luck, and not wanting to out power roles). However, I doubt goltar is much chance of falling into this trap on day 1.

Of course, we all know why you really want the name: because it would reveal either a rival cop or a family power role, both advantageous to your cronies (unless of course it was one of your cronies goltar spied).
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Serdash- A NCP bandwagon vote. In these games he can be a smart-alleck, but his ONLY post in this thread wasn’t harsh at all. He jumped on someone early when others did, then tried to make it light-hearted (chalked with a smiley usually absent from his posts) and a lame joke. Mafia posting early enough to remain low-key, but quickly disappearing to let others take the heat.


Sorry, mafia this mafia round started right around the time a few other things did. I assure you my inactivity is for good reason, and I'm going to try to be more active as the game progresses. You might notice I'm low to post in your own game over at the Com Forum. Things should smooth over soon, though and I'll be back to my nonsensical "urmom" posts.

GG?

Though I suppose "I've been busy" is usually the lamest and most overused excuse in these games, so I won't try to convince you further. Hopefully night 2 will reveal a few more things anyways.



 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

I've read though this since yesterday and I've got a few ideas.

My joke vote for Naz is about to be changed.

Unvote: Nazdakka

The first day or two are pretty much coin flips but after the overwhelming amount of posts, I'm ready to make a serious vote.

For basically posting pages and pages of over-bearing, dull, unhelpful pieces of incomprehensible drivel.

You haven't possibly got a clue what is going on this early in the game, but I do think you're trying Amans trick of claiming role after role after role, keeping the town confused while you gut us. Not this time, mate.

Vote Liquid Evil
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

I find it funny that the only people that have voted me are the ones I named as potentially good mafia targets. That's right. Get me gone quickly before I get rid of any more of you.

Sir Lister of Smeg said:
As to Liquid's allegiations, since there is no point in denial anymore, yes I am mafia.

Even AFTER there's a confirmed target.

Lister just went from the safe bet to the ONLY bet.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Goltar, you should not give out the name you found. I spent the last 30 minutes or so trying to come up with a good ruse to get more anti-town people out of the way using the information you have, but the risk of you finding a pro-town role is just bigger. As far as we know at least 11 people were active last night and that's not counting the people who might have been drinking and haven't said anything yet. The more people are awake, the more chance you find a townie. The main problem with not giving out the information is that it could be lost. I can protect you this night, but then tomorrow you HAVE to come out not to waste the information. At least it will give the snoop and the goon a free shot.

Here's a nice one:
I do think NOONE should be drinking this evening. With goltar's information tomorrow it will increase the chance of fake claims, but it will also give the anti-town factions a free kill because the doc can only protect one person at the time. If you think you'll be the only one, then go ahead without saying anything, but for now I think we should sleep with one eye open.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

PureSummon- Late to vote with a mysterious unvote. Hasn’t brought much to the table in terms of posts but wants us to think he knows more than he’s letting on. Needs to come forward with his thoughts or get killed. Maybe townie.

Where did I have this mysterious unvote? I mentioned in my previous posts that I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt and see where it goes, but the more you talk the less I believe you. You say that I seem to be hiding something, but point out no reason why you think this or where you read that into my posts. At this point in the game, lynching you will tell us as much, if not more, than lynching Smeg. I agree with Nac in that the only people, or at least the majority of them, that you seem to label as possibly anti-town are those who have voiced some suspicion of you.
unvote
Vote: Liquid
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

unvote: Lister
Vote: Liquid

Fixed.

Please remember to include the name of your previous votee as well when unvoting. I'll let this one slide, but the next person will only get a "doesn't count" from me.



 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Even if you falsely believed I was 95% mafia, why would you vote me over someone that just admitted to being 100% mafia?

I've gotten more votes when Smeg admitted his guilt instead of earlier when I seemingly jumped on him no reason from earlier. Why?

So for those of you that believe I'm mafia, was Smeg my teammate I just sold out or did I randomly pick one of the 3/23 other group? (I'm not falsifying evidence as a detective, Smeg admitted on his own accord)
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

The voting behavior amuses me. Liquid starts of the day by voting for Smeg. Lots of people join that vote. Barely a page ago Smeg comes out and confesses to being mafia (while trying a quite absurd ploy to try and frame liq as mafia as well...). And suddenly people change their vote to Liquid?

Liq has claimed a townie role, and has stated he has used his one time ability already.
He plays a really high risk game if he has any other role then he has claimed for now, since the snoop only needs to check on him once some night to find out whether he is mafia or not. Therefore, especially since Lister confesses to being mafia, I am inclined to believe Liquid.

Thyiad's vote change makes her even more suspicious to me.
Naz comes up with a plan. In response, without offering any argumentation, you vote for him. Now, you come back and say it was a joke vote(Excellent townie behaviour that... *sarcasm dripping from the keyboard*). Instead you vote for Liq, for reason of posting...
'incomprehensible drivel'.

Certainly liquid posted a lot, but that lot seems quite comprehensive and to the point to me. Based on the opinions of several other posters, if you truly vote for liquid due to his long posts that are incomprehensible, that vote should have gone to me, for solely that reason.

Puresummon: Liq tries to sum up his suspicions in a few rules for everyone. No one in that list gets a precise reason for why Liq feels that way. I think he did that in order to keep the list as comprehensible as possible.

Oh. And Muzz specifically asked to unvote with a name. Please do the gm the courtesy to stick to his rules.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

@Merlin - TLDR
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

pure, I saw your reply before I went grocery shopping and thought: yeah that is actually a very good point, if we lynch lister we're down a mafia but still don't know about LE, but if we lynch LE we'll be sure about them both.
I was going to back it up with this post and vote for LE, untill I thought about the long run. Yes, knowing LE's side is nice, however killing a confirmed mafia will give a higher chance of getting less kills at night sooner. Look at it this way: if we kill lister tomorrow (or even later), his mafia faction has more people in it thus able to stay around longer (even if we off them one after another) resulting in more night kills.

Day 1: lynch lister.
Night 2: listers faction kills someone.
Day 2: lynch one of listers associates.
Night 3: listers faction kills someone.
Day 3: lynch the final member of listers clan.

OR

Day 1: lynch LE (who will not be in the same faction as lister. I think.)
Night 2: kill
Day 2: lynch lister
Night 3: kill
Day 3: lynch listers clan member #2
night 4: kill <--- extra kill
Day 4: lynch last of listers group

So, you're right about lynching LE for more information, but killing lister is still the better choice in my opinion.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

I'm really not keen on having the doctor protect me, when there are more important roles to protect. But, if I have that name still, I am a possible threat that should be eliminated, and if an attempt is made and the doctor protects me, that wastes at least one night kill. From the latest batch of posts, I'm becoming more convinced that I've got a bad guy's name. Sint, you just hinted at being the doctor. If you are, then you are more important and should protect yourself. I'm going to take a chance and reveal that I saw NacRuno last night. If the doctor thinks he's on our side, I'd highly recommend protecting him. Either way, he's likely to be a target tonight for at least one side, as he's obviously not with the other bad guys.

For those who like to skim (which I admittedly did this morning, since I'm in a rush right now):

I saw NacRuno active last night.

As for who to lynch tonight. Stick with Lister. He's admitted to being a bad guy. If he dies, that's one less person for anybody drinking to chance seeing, and we don't need that ability wasted on a known enemy.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

TLDR = Too Long; Didn't Read. Ok, I get it.

Sint, two rival factions apart from Don Diablo's family means they also have a chance to kill each other. Just look back at the first night victims. Further on, your hypothetical night kill list seems highly unlikely to me.

@thanks Liq, but I searched the web and found the answer. :P
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Since I believe goltar has done exactly what I did, NacRuno is the safest bet tomorrow (the odds are still on our side concerning the ratio of town power roles and mafiosos) and his own lack of presence in this thread since he was ousted only serves to condemn him further. He was suspicious before and now he's clearcut mafioso as far as I'm concerned. If Sint is the doc like he claims (and if he isn't, the real doc should step forward immediately for a weak power role:mafia trade), then I'd encourage you not save NacRuno tonight in case the other mafia group wants to do him in for us. Probably not, but we can hope.

Also, does anyone have a clue what Thyiad is on? She's not herself and since there's not a Village Idiot this game, I'm unsure what she's trying to accomplish (other than maybe bringing down the average IQ level of the thread content.)
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

Thyiad is tired of speculation. Don't tell me you've ascertained a number of roles on day 1. Because if you do, you are lying. How you can manage that many posts with so little information.

My theory: I'm dead tonight and you and Sint are Mafia. Based on my TLDR voting strategy it's you, Sint and Merlin as a trio.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

A quick heads-up, so no one has any excuses for posting after sundown: day will end in ~20 minutes.
 
Re: OT: SPF mafia round 7 - Return to Salem

If Thyiad is tired of speculation, she shouldn't be playing a mafia game. That's what these things are made of.
 
Back
Top