Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Ankeli said:
Fair? Life rarely is. These games... even more seldom.

From my point of view scummy is assuming that you'd kill for the mafia when no such thing was mentioned. I even gave examples. If I were mafia why would I want to kill you? You're drawing heat and attention away from them if you're not one of them. Or korialstraz, who's also been the center of attention at points.
Click to expand...
When other people have assumed that the NK ability is mafia aligned you haven't jumped on them. Are just targeting easy town lynches to bandwagon and hide? Why do I attract a vote immediately when others don't warrant even a response.

Also concerning your power, you make no claim as the details but expect us to believe your information, for instance doesn't the Marcia learn who the powers of who they NK? Giving you the convenient position to claim a position even you saw you haven't seen before and be pro-town all at the same time. Thus ensuring nobody will contradict you. Awfully scum like.

Also why didn't you post at night? Your reason was weak at best. Can't you benefit from the dream if your the dreamer?

Mind games also? I'm happy to answer questions but wanting everyone to blurt out who they would NK isn't that just going to muddy the waters and allow you to accuse away the following day with such information after you NK.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

What are you talking about, flub? I didn't capitalise the "f", what more could you want?
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Yay, I got credit for trying! :jig: I guess that means flub and I aren't married :wink:

At the risk of answering spurious and opportunistic sniping, my avatar was chosen before the role PMs went out and is part of a series of avatars that began before the previous mafia game started.
Just FYI. :yes:
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I'll break this up.

Autti said:
When other people have assumed that the NK ability is mafia aligned you haven't jumped on them. Are just targeting easy town lynches to bandwagon and hide? Why do I attract a vote immediately when others don't warrant even a response.
Click to expand...

No one who answered the question assumed so. The discussion whether one of the 2 deceased last night was mafia or not was completely separate from my question. That is why you attracted the vote, along with what I said about you yesterday.

Autti said:
Also concerning your power, you make no claim as the details but expect us to believe your information, for instance doesn't the Marcia learn who the powers of who they NK? Giving you the convenient position to claim a position even you saw you haven't seen before and be pro-town all at the same time. Thus ensuring nobody will contradict you. Awfully scum like.
Click to expand...

I do not expect anyone to take it at 100% face value. It's something to consider for everyone. And yes, the mafia generally learns the powers of the ones they kill. I already stated this myself, in quite the sarcastic manner, as I knew it to be a thing that everyone would think of.

Autti said:
Also why didn't you post at night? Your reason was weak at best. Can't you benefit from the dream if your the dreamer?
Click to expand...

Wasn't the dreamer already decided to be just an "entity", not a player, by RE in the signup thread? That's how I recall it, and hence I've found the conversations regarding "it" being a person silly. However weak my reason was, that was my reason, and the reason why I stated the reason (lol) was to answer the question "why didn't you post at night?" pre-emptively. I could've just as well lied and told you I was out getting hammered, or afk for the duration.

Autti said:
Mind games also? I'm happy to answer questions but wanting everyone to blurt out who they would NK isn't that just going to muddy the waters and allow you to accuse away the following day with such information after you NK.
Click to expand...

Muddy the waters, yes. For the mafia. And somewhat for the doctor. But in a game of power roles, I consider that to be a good thing.



 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Ankeli said:
Autti, could you elaborate on what you promised earlier, please?

I'm up for some mindgames with the mafia, so a question for everyone. If you could kill one person the following night, who would you kill? If you had the doc powers, who would you protect?

Personally I would swing the gun towards Autti or Korialstraz, perhaps even Noodle for being his usual quiet self. And I would save myself. Bastard me.
Click to expand...

Brilliant.

Ankeli said:
Now that's an interesting reply. First off Asrrin is dead. I think you're mixing him up with me, but I never claimed coroner. Just something along those lines. I even mentioned I've never seen the role before. You would also deliberately target pro-town roles, even though I didn't mention "if you were mafia, who would you kill?" and just asked "who would you kill". The fact that you assumed it as if you were mafia intrigues me.

Too many slips.

Vote: Autti

I'd still like to hear more kill / save decisions.
Click to expand...


Yip an easy assumption....

Autti said:
Sorry but if your intending to convict me via bad wording, that is hardly fair. You said playing mind games with mafia and night kill. So yes I assume mafia, I didn't know that townies have a night kill ability. TBH that's a tough break

Im not saying your vote isn't founded, but sealing the deal because I misread your question when I'm openly answering them for you. That's pretty scummy.
Click to expand...


Ankeli said:
Fair? Life rarely is. These games... even more seldom.

From my point of view scummy is assuming that you'd kill for the mafia when no such thing was mentioned. I even gave examples. If I were mafia why would I want to kill you? You're drawing heat and attention away from them if you're not one of them. Or korialstraz, who's also been the center of attention at points.
Click to expand...


OY and what's this from the "new guy"



Autti said:
When other people have assumed that the NK ability is mafia aligned you haven't jumped on them. Are just targeting easy town lynches to bandwagon and hide? Why do I attract a vote immediately when others don't warrant even a response.

Also concerning your power, you make no claim as the details but expect us to believe your information, for instance doesn't the Marcia learn who the powers of who they NK? Giving you the convenient position to claim a position even you saw you haven't seen before and be pro-town all at the same time. Thus ensuring nobody will contradict you. Awfully scum like.

Also why didn't you post at night? Your reason was weak at best. Can't you benefit from the dream if your the dreamer?

Mind games also? I'm happy to answer questions but wanting everyone to blurt out who they would NK isn't that just going to muddy the waters and allow you to accuse away the following day with such information after you NK.
Click to expand...

How do you know the Mafia learn the powers of the ones they NK??

Have you been Googling the jailkeeper as well??


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

...and for the record LozHinge the Unhinged your avatar is outstanding. No one appreciates B/W anything anymore (punk kids)
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Ankeli said:
No one who answered the question assumed so. The discussion whether one of the 2 deceased last night was mafia or not was completely separate from my question. That is why you attracted the vote, along with what I said about you yesterday.
Click to expand...
Yet it's the same inference. Your reasoning of guilt is I assumed NKing being mafia, which it generally is and others were talking about NKing being mafia yet you don't question them. Or do you only target those that you directly post to. Seems awfully convent that you only bother to target the one corroborating with your investigation and I'm actively trying to exonerated self. Let's not worry about others who made the same assumption.

I do not expect anyone to take it at 100% face value. It's something to consider for everyone. And yes, the mafia generally learns the powers of the ones they kill. I already stated this myself, in quite the sarcastic manner, as I knew it to be a thing that everyone would think of
Click to expand...
Nc yet you chose to anyway, when really it helps us in now way. Why didn't you keep the information secret and use it to a counter a claim. What was your motive for revealling this "information" it hasn't helped at all, other than scoring you townie points.



Wasn't the dreamer already decided to be just an "entity", not a player, by RE in the signup thread? That's how I recall it, and hence I've found the conversations regarding "it" being a person silly. However weak my reason was, that was my reason, and the reason why I stated the reason (lol) was to answer the question "why didn't you post at night?" pre-emptively. I could've just as well lied and told you I was out getting hammered, or afk for the duration
Click to expand...
.
As others have alluded to maybe the mafia have to pick a dream and hence be the dreamer. Doesn't seem far fetched at all.

Being afk would have attracted attention though, particularly with your previous days activity. This way it yet again seeks to conceal your identity and gain townie points. You don't think mafia could have preemptively explained that as well? Your course of action yielded the town nothing and and is incredibly suspicious. If you were unable to post at night wouldn't you use the exact same excuse you came up with. Coupled with the timing of your "information" all the deflect information away from you.


Muddy the waters, yes. For the mafia. And somewhat for the doctor. But in a game of power roles, I consider that to be a good thing.
Click to expand...
You don't think it will muddy the waters for the town? How will your plan benefit the town?


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

flubbucket said:
Brilliant.




Yip an easy assumption....







OY and what's this from the "new guy"





How do you know the Mafia learn the powers of the ones they NK??

Have you been Googling the jailkeeper as well??
Click to expand...
I don't actually understand half your post. But yes i have heavily relied upon the Mafia wiki for my information. Where else would I get it as a newbie?
Also I never claimed I know, if you note that was question mark at the end of the sentence. Glib with misuse of quoting yet again.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I'll leave out the parts where you just run in circles, trying to chase your own tail, knowing that it is still in fact the guilty one.

Autti said:
Yet it's the same inference. Your reasoning of guilt is I assumed NKing being mafia, which it generally is and others were talking about NKing being mafia yet you don't question them. Or do you only target those that you directly post to. Seems awfully convent that you only bother to target the one corroborating with your investigation and I'm actively trying to exonerated self. Let's not worry about others who made the same assumption.

Nc yet you chose to anyway, when really it helps us in now way. Why didn't you keep the information secret and use it to a counter a claim. What was your motive for revealling this "information" it hasn't helped at all, other than scoring you townie points.

You don't think it will muddy the waters for the town? How will your plan benefit the town?
Click to expand...

1. Now did they make that assumption? Why, as mafia, would they target you or Korialstraz? Let's ask the ones that answered, which one did you assume I wanted to know, who you'd kill as you, or as mafia?

2. I already reflected on the timing.

3. I hate answering questions with more questions, but how will it make the towns job (voting) more difficult? Whereas the mafia has to consider the people who have been presented, have to consider whether they'll even comment on the subject, have to take into account who people have said they'd protect etc.

I think you've dug your grave. I'll be the first one setting a red rose on it if you turn up pro-town, but I find that highly unlikely.



 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Dear fellow players, I'm very sorry, but there is a D3 open beta this weekend, and I've been starving for it for three god-damned years, and there is no way I'm not going to spend every single minute playing it. I will check this thread regularly (mostly when I get up to refill on ice tea), but I won't be reading thoroughly as I have so far... the open beta ends on Monday, so I hope I don't get replaced for this.

Now, regarding the game... I still think we should go either for Glib or Krasus, they are obviously on opposite ends of the spectrum, so if we lynch one, we relatively confirm the others. Also, I agree with Glib's "Family Portrait" thing, and if you read the entire thread, you'll find it has been consistent all along (no time for links), so it's very likely they are cult, mafia or masons. Either way, my vote stays on Krasus for the time being. I'll check back later, a holla.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Valhauros said:
Dear fellow players, I'm very sorry, but there is a D3 open beta this weekend, and I've been starving for it for three god-damned years, and there is no way I'm not going to spend every single minute playing it. I will check this thread regularly (mostly when I get up to refill on ice tea), but I won't be reading thoroughly as I have so far... the open beta ends on Monday, so I hope I don't get replaced for this.
Click to expand...

Ditto. 101010



 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Valhauros said:
Dear fellow players, I'm very sorry, but there is a D3 open beta this weekend, and I've been starving for it for three god-damned years, and there is no way I'm not going to spend every single minute playing it. I will check this thread regularly (mostly when I get up to refill on ice tea), but I won't be reading thoroughly as I have so far... the open beta ends on Monday, so I hope I don't get replaced for this.

Now, regarding the game... I still think we should go either for Glib or Krasus, they are obviously on opposite ends of the spectrum, so if we lynch one, we relatively confirm the others. Also, I agree with Glib's "Family Portrait" thing, and if you read the entire thread, you'll find it has been consistent all along (no time for links), so it's very likely they are cult, mafia or masons. Either way, my vote stays on Krasus for the time being. I'll check back later, a holla.
Click to expand...

Enjoy, it's great!


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

What question? One of these? Because I don't... get them.

1. Did whoever that killed Asrrin then just killed the mafia hitman?
2. Cause you didn't get another ability from Asrrin, just his permanent NK ability. Does this mean the hitman gets passed on to the next mafia man, who then either gains the hitman in addition or loses his original ability.
3. I'm wondering about this because usually mafia have no designated hitman anymore, they just chose one each night. And considering we all have a power role this game, wouldn't a sole NK ability for a mafia member not be considered a power role?

1. I don't know. How would I know?
2. I don't know. How would I know?
3. I don't know. How would I know?

Your questions made no sense, as I shared everything essential regarding information gain about my role, and you could clearly see I don't get a) roles or b) alignments. Just the powers of the dead people, and if multiple people die, I don't know which belonged to who.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Ankeli said:
I'm up for some mindgames with the mafia, so a question for everyone. If you could kill one person the following night, who would you kill? If you had the doc powers, who would you protect?

Personally I would swing the gun towards Autti or Korialstraz, perhaps even Noodle for being his usual quiet self. And I would save myself. Bastard me.
Click to expand...

To answer the question. Hmmm... I think I would've killed flubb. Or actually considering the recent posts maybe even Autti. I'd save Ankeli or Gory.

Ankeli, you're starting to convince me that Autti is in fact scum, and not making noob misstakes. You and your laser targeting! >_< *thinks back to SG themed game*


As for the bolded part, do docs often get to save themselves? I've rarely seen it. :scratchchin:

Valhauros said:
Dear fellow players, I'm very sorry, but there is a D3 open beta this weekend, and I've been starving for it for three god-damned years, and there is no way I'm not going to spend every single minute playing it. I will check this thread regularly (mostly when I get up to refill on ice tea), but I won't be reading thoroughly as I have so far... the open beta ends on Monday, so I hope I don't get replaced for this.
Click to expand...

Woot!? :jig:


Sorry guys but I'll be in the same boat as Val. I've waited for this game ever since 07! I'll do my best to read and reply, as well as vote. Don't count on me doing much more than helping to secure a lynch the town wants though!


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Well, I'm not gonna play D3 at all - however, I will probably get drunk.

@Glib's "family portrait": I have no connection to any of the mentioned players. I simply stated that I found you more scummy than Autti. That's starting to change, but more on that in a bit. I do however see your point (not including my self), and your posting this day phase have made me feel better about you. You're still in my top three suspects, but Autti and maybe Korial aren't looking too good.

Ankeli is making me more or more convinced that Autti is scum. In any case, he seems like one of the most obvious targets. I'm cool with lynching him.

Vote: Autti
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

@ank's last question: given my initial answer it is pretty obvious that I interpreted it as "who I would kill", not "who I, as mafia, would kill".
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top