Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

[RlyehExiled]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Votes as of #521

Korialstraz(2): Caluin Graye, Valharous
Ankeli(1): Sathorsis
Flubbucket(2): (2): Koral, Loz
Autti(1): Flubbucket

10 to lynch

34 hours left by my count.

 

[Goryani]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I'm actually not Dr Breen this round, and thank you for bringing up that painful memory /LOL

Just pointing out that Ankeli's revelation this game isn't fundamentally different than his revelations in that game. There is no such thing as "too crazy even for Ankeli."

P.S. Your avatar scares me.

 

[Autti]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Here is a nice family portrait. I only wish Autti were here as well. He is mentioned quite prominently though.

Defending family members.



More defending of family

And more family defending family.


Well I voted for him yesterday and I'm voting him today.


Vote:Autti

Sorry I'm back now, on iPad, computer won't be up for a week. Glib everyone here thinks I'm suspicious because I've made some bad mistakes. But I haven't done anything note worthy the last few days. If anything deserves attention it was your moment with Jcakes and Skjolde over the locking vote.

If anyone has any questions for me I'd be happy to answer them

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Last I might say on this cause I dont want it to be a distraction for the town...but we obviously dont know what the dream did for the mafia. It did something. They got to choose it! They would know that the town could talk at night, and got something because of this if I am interpreting it correctly.

I am assuming the everyone can post at night was obviously not the only thing they got out of it, otherwise why would they choose it? They probably didnt assume people would role reveal cop O_O. I dont think this would be chosen as the only benefit of the dream, unless they had X amount of options and had to choose this one early on to save more powerful ones later on?

This is wild speculation, but, seriously...

I dont think it is far fetched to think that to have this be the dream option that someone wouldnt be allowed to post. It would be a major downside to the dream, yes, but arent the dreams without some sort of negative consequence insanely OP?

Do we know they choose the specific dream? Perhaps it is a random number generator type thing.

Can't help but think RlyehExiled might want to save a little surprise for his own enjoyment.

My thought on this is that they probably have a general description but don't really know what it does, the real overpowered thing would be if they had an exact read out of what each dream does, if that was the case then they could pretty much manipulate the game to their situation based on the previous day's events. There has to be at least some randomness to it I would hope, but definately not a random number generator extreme.

Just pointing out that Ankeli's revelation this game isn't fundamentally different than his revelations in that game. There is no such thing as "too crazy even for Ankeli."

P.S. Your avatar scares me.

So we essentially have two players (coju and ankeli) that can say whatever they want and its either to scummy to be scum or too crazy to be crazy? Sounds dangerous to me.

Also, even though this isn't all seriousness in last game I thought Val's avatar was evil and look how that turned out, I think this is a solid lead. :crazyeyes:

 

[Caluin Graye]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Sorry I'm back now, on iPad, computer won't be up for a week. Glib everyone here thinks I'm suspicious because I've made some bad mistakes. But I haven't done anything note worthy the last few days. If anything deserves attention it was your moment with Jcakes and Skjolde over the locking vote.

If anyone has any questions for me I'd be happy to answer them

I have a couple questions.

If a person gets a lot of heat on one day and then decides to curb their amount of posts the following, would you call that scummy, townie, or indicative of neither?

Ignoring flubbucket for a moment, whom do you find the most suspicious and would rather see lynched today?

 

[Autti]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Instinctively I would say scummy. It appears that people are hesitant to vote someone if they are not posting do defend themselves, there is no answer to their (inquisitor) questions and hence are unlikely to vote on gut instinct. Thus it gives a good opportunity to survive.

Equal,y though a role like the doctor could possibly do it to hopefully prevent him having to claim to save and be NK'd.

I don't think I have stopped posting though, we're only 12 hours in and I have been very active so far.

Korial. He's yet to convince me of his alignment. Unless he can convince me why we shouldn't lynch him I'd like to see him go. Although I'd also like to know who Goryani is going to investigate as glib is shady to say the least

 

[Kestegs]

Also, even though this isn't all seriousness in last game I thought Val's avatar was evil and look how that turned out, I think this is a solid lead. :crazyeyes:

I like where this is heading!


So autti is claiming doc? :scratchhead:

 

[Autti]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

No not at all. I was answering the question, and I think in some circumstances a townie would do that. However my choice certainly wasn't a deliberate one so if CG was trying to indirectly to incriminate myself I disagree as I've been active and briefly went offline.

 

[Ankeli1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Autti, could you elaborate on what you promised earlier, please?

I'm up for some mindgames with the mafia, so a question for everyone. If you could kill one person the following night, who would you kill? If you had the doc powers, who would you protect?

Personally I would swing the gun towards Autti or Korialstraz, perhaps even Noodle for being his usual quiet self. And I would save myself. Bastard me.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I'm up for some mindgames with the mafia, so a question for everyone. If you could kill one person the following night, who would you kill?

I would kill you. It will always be you. Every time.

Never forgive. Never forget. VENDETTA.

 

[Ankeli1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I would kill you. It will always be you. Every time.

Never forgive. Never forget. VENDETTA.

Then who would you save, were you the doctor? I'd like to get as many of these out there during the day phase to mess with the mafia minds.

 

[Autti]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Autti, could you elaborate on what you promised earlier, please?

I'm up for some mindgames with the mafia, so a question for everyone. If you could kill one person the following night, who would you kill? If you had the doc powers, who would you protect?

Personally I would swing the gun towards Autti or Korialstraz, perhaps even Noodle for being his usual quiet self. And I would save myself. Bastard me.

Sorry ill go find that post but first I'll answer this one.

Id kill Goryani or Assrin (iirc he claimed coroner) two powerful roles (assuming their claim) and good candidate they would be obvious though, so something a little bit more sinister I'd throw a spanner in the works by killing a lurker like BA (assuming he isn't scum) just go confuse everyone.

Protect? Much tougher question. Again the cop would be an obvious candidate. Can the doctor self protect?

 

[Ankeli1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Now that's an interesting reply. First off Asrrin is dead. I think you're mixing him up with me, but I never claimed coroner. Just something along those lines. I even mentioned I've never seen the role before. You would also deliberately target pro-town roles, even though I didn't mention "if you were mafia, who would you kill?" and just asked "who would you kill". The fact that you assumed it as if you were mafia intrigues me.

Too many slips.

Vote: Autti

I'd still like to hear more kill / save decisions.

 

[Autti]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Well I haven't really helped the town so far, I'll admit that. But neither has anyone else really as at the end of the day we still just have 4 dead people with 1 possibly being mafia. Not the best defense but when measure against everyone else efforts is pretty comparable. I didn't vote for Skj either, suspicious yes, guilty well no. Although I am hesitant to vote people anyway unless there is heavy evidence.

Anynother questions?

 

[Autti]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Sorry but if your intending to convict me via bad wording, that is hardly fair. You said playing mind games with mafia and night kill. So yes I assume mafia, I didn't know that townies have a night kill ability. TBH that's a tough break

Im not saying your vote isn't founded, but sealing the deal because I misread your question when I'm openly answering them for you. That's pretty scummy.

 

[FredOfErik]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Sorry for being a bit lurkish. RL is getting in the way.

Turns out to be pretty entertaining. At least from my point of view. For better or worse I think I'm going to remember this game for a while.

That I understand.

I'm up for some mindgames with the mafia, so a question for everyone. If you could kill one person the following night, who would you kill? If you had the doc powers, who would you protect?

CG. Just because. No. It's a difficult question but most likely Glib (kill). If not then Autti. Since we only have to outed roles my protect decision would be between you and Gory. I think Gory's claim seems a bit more bulletproof that your's, so I'd probably choose him.

---

Sorry for mentioning Gory's idea about BA/Val earlier. It was apparently not Gory's theory but Asrrin's. That Asrrin got NK'd doesn't necessarily destroy the theory, but as (if we are to trusk Ank) there's a 50/50 chance he was scum, I'm not so intrigued by it anymore.

 

[Ankeli1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Sorry but if your intending to convict me via bad wording, that is hardly fair. You said playing mind games with mafia and night kill. So yes I assume mafia, I didn't know that townies have a night kill ability. TBH that's a tough break

Im not saying your vote isn't founded, but sealing the deal because I misread your question when I'm openly answering them for you. That's pretty scummy.

Fair? Life rarely is. These games... even more seldom.

From my point of view scummy is assuming that you'd kill for the mafia when no such thing was mentioned. I even gave examples. If I were mafia why would I want to kill you? You're drawing heat and attention away from them if you're not one of them. Or korialstraz, who's also been the center of attention at points.

 

[Ankeli1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

but as (if we are to trusk Ank) there's a 50/50 chance he was scum, I'm not so intrigued by it anymore.

Not quite so high, could've been a vigilante as well. I can't distinct the two with my ability.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Mind games eh? Hm, who to kill, who to kill...Val, for the obvious reason of winning the last game and his continually lurky play style that continues into this game as well. But no, in actuality if it came down to it today? Probably in this order Autti, Korial/flubb (interchangeable), BA. You may ask why BA? His posts just seem a little different from last games play style although I could be wrong. Absolutely no new information would have to come up between now and then though and we know that won't be the case.

In terms of who to save? It would have to be between Gory and Ank, I would really prefer to get more solid confirmation on one of them before doing so obviously and I hope to find out more about them today in general through the course of the day.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Also, this discussion between Ank and Autti has been progressing quite interestingly and I'm going to be sure to follow up tomorrow with my thoughts (its 3:30 AM now where I am, can't sleep).