OT: The SPF Mafia Game Round Three

Suspicion List through day 4:

GoHabsGo
Jaago
water_moon
skunkbelly
Sir Lister of Smeg
muzzz
goltar25
Rashiminos

This is the day Nikon and Sint got in a big spat, with Nikon making a bunch of stretches that I tended to ignore since I was in "Nikon is cop" mode. Upon reassessment, I'm going to wager Nikon made a successful village idiot gambit which resulted in his lynch day 5.

GoHabsGo
Pro-town: he wishes
Anti-town: lurked out a busy day

Jaago
Protown: he wishes
Anti-town: 636, 694

water_moon
Pro-town: she wishes
Anti-town: 627

skunkbelly
Pro-town: he wishes
Anti-town: lurked out a busy day, but with a reason

Sir Lister of Smeg
Pro-town: 629, 646, 650, 668
Anti-town: nothing!

muzzz
Pro-town: 674, 685
Anti-town: nothing!

Any Questions?
 
Suspicion List through day 5:

GoHabsGo
Jaago
water_moon
skunkbelly
Sir Lister of Smeg
muzzz
goltar25
Rashiminos

Nikon got lynched, and I made the final vote. I regret that decision.

GoHabsGo
Pro-town: nothing there but a vote
Anti-town: lurker detected

Jaago
Protown: yeah right
Anti-town: 710, 728, 764, 770, 772

water_moon
Pro-town: 749
Anti-town: 714, 750

skunkbelly
Pro-town: mere votage
Anti-town: lurker detected

Sir Lister of Smeg
Pro-town: 757
Anti-town: 715,744

muzzz
Pro-town: 719, 745
Anti-town: nothing!

Any Questions?
 
Suspicion List through day 6:

Jaago
water_moon
GoHabsGo
skunkbelly
Sir Lister of Smeg
muzzz
goltar25
Rashiminos

Sint gets lynched, Jaago's reasoning is lacking, water_moon confuses Cop and Crooked Detective in her roleplay.

Jaago
Pro-town: not really
Anti-town: 787, 801, 807, 809, 813, 824

water_moon
Pro-town: talk about not true
Anti-town: 798, 817

GoHabsGo
Pro-town: nope
Anti-town: 785

skunkbelly
Pro-town: mere votage
Anti-town: lurker detected

Sir Lister of Smeg
Pro-town: not a good day in smegland
Anti-town: 790

muzzz
Pro-town: 814, 822, 826, 827
Anti-town: nothing!

Any Questions?
 
Suspicion List through day 7:

Jaago
water_moon
GoHabsGo
skunkbelly
Sir Lister of Smeg
muzzz
goltar25
Rashiminos

Thyiad bandwagoned.

Jaago
Pro-town: 839
Anti-town: 853

water_moon
Pro-town: lurk
Anti-town: mcgurk

GoHabsGo
Pro-town: lurk
Anti-town: mcgurk

skunkbelly
Pro-town: 861
Anti-town: 847, 851

Sir Lister of Smeg
Pro-town: not much to go on
Anti-town: nope

muzzz
Pro-town: 845
Anti-town: nothing!

Any Questions?
 
Suspicion List before day 9:

Jaago
water_moon
GoHabsGo
skunkbelly
Sir Lister of Smeg
muzzz
goltar25
Rashiminos

Moar bandwagoned.

Jaago
Pro-town: mafia don't help the town
Anti-town: 893 (this is BS), 895, 911

water_moon
Pro-town: lurking
Anti-town: "roleplaying"

GoHabsGo
Pro-town: 875
Anti-town: one-track mind

skunkbelly
Pro-town: if he didn't lurk so much
Anti-town: I'd be happier

Sir Lister of Smeg
Pro-town: if he didn't lurk so recently
Anti-town: he'd be clear

muzzz
Pro-town: 878, 890, 900, 909, 914, 916
Anti-town: If this guy is mafia, he's just damn awesome. Might as well be confirmed townie.

Any Questions?

Just a little bit more re-reading to do, I think I can get to a vote tonight.
 
Rashiminos said:
It's been over 24 hours, and neither Sir Lister of Smeg nor water_moon have stopped by to say hello...
Click to expand...
No because I came in for the 10 minutes I had last night and decided to wait for your monster post. I have a 5 month old whom I am getting ready to take on an airplane by my self to go visit the grandparents, one of whom decided that the day we were going drive 4 hours to see her won't work after all and never mind that it's a week away. Meanwhile, I've got a list about 4 pages long of stuff to do before Monday. Sorry, but this GAME is a low priority.

Frankly, it's sad but my best defense for not being mafia is I don't have the time, the nights would last as long as the days.

Also, I'm not sure why the assumption is being made, but it seems to me that we very well might have gotten all but one mafia, by picking some one to jail (note to self: add "bail out hubby" to list) they can certainly confuse the issue enough to keep folks from lynching them.

My RPing has been soly baised on why a real live person would do without the metaknowledge, ie. not knowing that there ARE roles much less how many or what they are. Speaking of which: Just to clairfy skool, but once the mafia's all dead we'll be told, yes?

I think I'll revert to my earlier line of thought because I don't feel like over-analizing the reasons for the re-worded posts and go with rash. He was implying he was the witness at the begining, not another person. And when I called him on it he never even tried to clairify, until now that he's going through all the posts and others might bother to notice that little detail also.

Vote: RASH



 
Rashiminos said:
Vicious rumors about me claiming to be things I never claimed to be. Let me clarify this post:

I recognized at some point on that day that my incompetence was creating unnecessary confusion and that I was amenable to be taken out should the mafia come a-packing (as opposed to a special role -hint-). Day 2 found me with clearer purpose and better suspects, so my interest in my survival was renewed. That confusion is evident now since I'm a primary suspect for some people, and in many cases just because of those three sentences. I was not trying to imitate the witness at the time, but again I was being incompetent on that day.
Click to expand...

Oh but I did clarify, I'll excuse you though.


 
Taking this off the top:

Rashiminos: Why haven't you lynched me yet, is there a little voice inside your head that keeps saying I somehow am not one of them? I've been wrong all over the place. Okay, self-loathing over. If you can't find it in you to lynch me, then perhaps that little voice is connected to some little ears and little eyes or something. Moving on...

Goltar25: as he is imprisoned, it's kind of hard to say speculation about him is relevant, wait for tomorrow

Muzzz: He's been busting people for bad logic circa day 2, it's a wonder his attempts to lynch me haven't had more success. I'm about 99% sure he is a townie.

Sir Lister of Smeg: When I got off on a tangent, I started to see every one of his posts as suspicious. He's had consistent posts, but he has been lurking the last few days. Not going to be confident about a vote on him.

skunkbelly: when not finding excuses to lurk, makes insightful posts, he's making a thorough examination of the reasons goltar would be imprisoned

GoHabsGo: at first he was making poorly reasoned arguments, but he kind of stuck to the same person while doing so, not that sure he's mafia

water_moon: lurk and roleplay..., I'm not sure she's not using her inability to stay with the thread to her advantage. I was thinking about voting her.

Jaago: Okay, we all know who you were trying to get to join you on that wagon, namely me. Not going to fall for it. You lack of reasoning in post 923 resembles the amount of reasoning every time you've made or changed your vote the last 9 days. GoHabsGo is on to something here. When you attack someone, you provide a less coherent argument than the person you arguing against and then don't press the matter. I can be sure about a vote on you.

I have to
Vote: Jaago

The rest of the town can do what it wants.
 
I'm sorry to hear about Sitro.

As to my absence on this day so far, due to the new year I was too busy stuffing myself at other people's places.
On another note, my drop in activity which started about two weeks ago was due to me finally finding work.

I must say I'm quite surprised the crooked cop got active again, I had hoped we had already ridded ourselves of him/her.
So what do we learn from Goltar's imprisonment?
Not much, apart from him not being the crooked cop.
I'm tempted to think this actually means he's a townie, the reason being that for the mafia having relatively to the number of townies a larger number of votes than with a mafioso imprisoned is at this stage quite a large advantage. An advantage that probably offsets the disadvantage they get of having relatively a larger number of mafioso lynch candidates.

At this point, Jaago and Rashiminos have returned to being most suspicious in my eyes. Muzzz still rings a bell. Water_Moon, Skunkbelly, GoHabsGo, and Goltar25 are suspicious purely by not saying a lot that might incriminate them, this mostly goes for Water_Moon and Goltar25.

I'm going to go with Rashiminos today.

vote: Rashiminos
 
The townsfolk who is voting rash,


please think this over. At the moment, Rash is about to be voted out. If he is mafia it would mean that you and other people voting Rash can't be mafia. Also, it would mean that the remaining mafia would consist Rash and a combination of me, muzz and goltar.

Have you noticed that rash voted me?
What about Goltar being in prison?
Or muzz being so hesitant about his voting, because he doesn't want to miss?

Do those things have any meaning at all? They do.

Is Rash the only mafia remaining? He can't be. He voted for every lynch we have had by far.

Suppose that Rash is not mafia. Who would you think would hop in the bandwagon to get him lynched? Other townies? Mafia?

Mafia.

Suppose there are three mafia left. Why would there be less? I know there are no less. You should know it, too. All of our lynches have been too easy.

Is there any reason for any mafia to not vote Rash? Rash already had two votes when Lister and w_m hopped to the bandwagon without any reasoning of their own. Who was the other guy besides you to vote Rash? Has he not been flying under the radar the whole game, making some seemingly insightful posts here and there. Do those posts actually tell you anything? Are they just a cover-up?

Haven't lister and w_m trying to make themselves look like townies by meaningless posts lately? If they were townies, would they need to?

Why aren't other people voting for Rash? Because they know that missing today is fatal.

Please, GoHabsGo, change your vote before it's too late.
 
water_moon said:
No because I came in for the 10 minutes I had last night and decided to wait for your monster post. I have a 5 month old whom I am getting ready to take on an airplane by my self to go visit the grandparents, one of whom decided that the day we were going drive 4 hours to see her won't work after all and never mind that it's a week away. Meanwhile, I've got a list about 4 pages long of stuff to do before Monday. Sorry, but this GAME is a low priority.

Frankly, it's sad but my best defense for not being mafia is I don't have the time, the nights would last as long as the days.

Also, I'm not sure why the assumption is being made, but it seems to me that we very well might have gotten all but one mafia, by picking some one to jail (note to self: add "bail out hubby" to list) they can certainly confuse the issue enough to keep folks from lynching them.

My RPing has been soly baised on why a real live person would do without the metaknowledge, ie. not knowing that there ARE roles much less how many or what they are. Speaking of which: Just to clairfy skool, but once the mafia's all dead we'll be told, yes?

I think I'll revert to my earlier line of thought because I don't feel like over-analizing the reasons for the re-worded posts and go with rash. He was implying he was the witness at the begining, not another person. And when I called him on it he never even tried to clairify, until now that he's going through all the posts and others might bother to notice that little detail also.
Click to expand...

Oh well, might as well vote what my gut felt better about before w_m's post. The problem with these statements is the things going on in her life do not stop her from being mafia if her partners in crime are the ones doing the killing. Then she argues that we have gotten all but one mafia, but does not say who the two lynched mafia might have been. Why is she roleplaying in a way that doesn't look like she's playing the game (metaknowledge)? That's probably the exact image she wants you to think. Did she really believe skoolbus would give out hints to people's roles? I think she knew better. She was fishing for reactions under a consistent guise. Maybe if we have gotten a mafia already, you'll know where to look tomorrow.

Unvote: Jaago
Vote: water_moon


 
If I had to figure the scum trio right now: water_moon (ms. swoop in and vote as the first action today), Jaago, sir lister of smeg (mr. swoop in and vote as the first action today)
 
did you read the third line of text or the next post?

Mafia is w_m skunk and lister. The order in which we might lynch them doesn't matter. The only thing that matters is whether we lynch them or not.
 
I.e. we need to get the good ol' bandwagon rolling. Maybe muzzz and gohabs will hop in, maybe they won't. It's up to them now.

The day is drawing to a close, too.
 
You do realize I still believe you are mafia, you're going to have to do better than that if we're going to be voting the same person.
 
To be honest, I don't care much anymore. If you really want to vote me out, by all means, go for it. I only hope GoHabs will realize that you aren't mafia. If not, all is lost anyway.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top