OT: Mafia game
- Thread starter Aman
- Start date
Liquid_Evil
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Ya know Thy, I flipped a coin between you and Gorny the first night. You're lucky you weren't head. A 1st night cop kill would have been completely awesome.
(and yes, yes, you're always right)
Ya know Thy, I flipped a coin between you and Gorny the first night. You're lucky you weren't head. A 1st night cop kill would have been completely awesome.
(and yes, yes, you're always right)
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Nice going all!
I was VERY surprised to last as long as I did. The biggest mistake I made was thinking the game was over if I got Orphan lynched the previous day.
The 2 to lynch threw me off - newbie mistake! I had pretty much used up all my excuses to end the game then, when it was a no-lynch I expected I had no chance. Orphan already had me pegged and SiTro was pretty sure too. I though MAYBE killing Pure would nudge SiTro to my side but never expected it to work. If I had killed either of them I'm sure Pure would have figured it out since they were already against me.
My other mistake was killing off Ray, the other Mafia member, a bit too early. I was afraid he might kill me but in retrospect I should have kept him around a bit longer to get more kills on the town. Of course I wasn't even sure he was part of the other mafia group, but it seemed that way. If he actualy was the Cop he needed to die anyway.
The GG/X note with Ray was to finger the Genova Gang, plus make InetigentX a suspect. My other notes ment nothing. By this point in the game most should have seen that the notes were a ruse to point townies away from the real villians.
Gotta thank Liquid for being a great partner in crime! If I had a little more experaince (and time) I probably would have done a bit better.
Thanks to Aman too - smoothly run game and you stuck to the rules (which has to be done!)
Nice going all!
I was VERY surprised to last as long as I did. The biggest mistake I made was thinking the game was over if I got Orphan lynched the previous day.
The 2 to lynch threw me off - newbie mistake! I had pretty much used up all my excuses to end the game then, when it was a no-lynch I expected I had no chance. Orphan already had me pegged and SiTro was pretty sure too. I though MAYBE killing Pure would nudge SiTro to my side but never expected it to work. If I had killed either of them I'm sure Pure would have figured it out since they were already against me.
My other mistake was killing off Ray, the other Mafia member, a bit too early. I was afraid he might kill me but in retrospect I should have kept him around a bit longer to get more kills on the town. Of course I wasn't even sure he was part of the other mafia group, but it seemed that way. If he actualy was the Cop he needed to die anyway.
The GG/X note with Ray was to finger the Genova Gang, plus make InetigentX a suspect. My other notes ment nothing. By this point in the game most should have seen that the notes were a ruse to point townies away from the real villians.
Gotta thank Liquid for being a great partner in crime! If I had a little more experaince (and time) I probably would have done a bit better.
Thanks to Aman too - smoothly run game and you stuck to the rules (which has to be done!)
Re: OT: Mafia game
The problem with the method I used towards the end is that you need to wait a good number of days to get anything that you could possibly use to make a conclusion with. Before then it's just too random.
Even Day 5 was early to bring it in. Also, if you look back, you could use it to make a number of points for the case that I was mafia. In the end it wasn't useful enough on its own to point to any one person.
The problem with the method I used towards the end is that you need to wait a good number of days to get anything that you could possibly use to make a conclusion with. Before then it's just too random.
Even Day 5 was early to bring it in. Also, if you look back, you could use it to make a number of points for the case that I was mafia. In the end it wasn't useful enough on its own to point to any one person.
Liquid_Evil
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
I was plenty sure and you did good with his death. He was actively seeking to kill you and since Bob appearred to support me so much, Ray mistakenly thought he was my partner. Who's to say that the next night he wouldn't have found you? Right choice imo. Killing alone safely beats killing others with the chance that you yourself might die.
I was plenty sure and you did good with his death. He was actively seeking to kill you and since Bob appearred to support me so much, Ray mistakenly thought he was my partner. Who's to say that the next night he wouldn't have found you? Right choice imo. Killing alone safely beats killing others with the chance that you yourself might die.
I thought we did pretty decent for both of our first mafia attempts. I'll try and live longer next time. Live and learn I guess. :wink3:
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Liquid
The last night kill (Pure) was to get the town down another player - I new I wouldn't survive the next day with both Orphan and SiTro on to me... as I said I was hoping SiTro might take it as Orphan killing Pure sine he voted against him - real weak but I knew I was done for anyway.
If i left him alive I'd have been locked anyway.
Liquid
The last night kill (Pure) was to get the town down another player - I new I wouldn't survive the next day with both Orphan and SiTro on to me... as I said I was hoping SiTro might take it as Orphan killing Pure sine he voted against him - real weak but I knew I was done for anyway.
If i left him alive I'd have been locked anyway.
BobTheWarrior
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
@Thyiad - noted. Should've listened to you earlier, won't be making that mistake again.
@Liquid - The first night cop kill is awesome. Unfortunately, I was the cop that game. DiiLegend put the dagger in me before I had a chance to do any sleuthing. Lame.
@Aman - great game. Thanks. :thumbsup:
@Thyiad - noted. Should've listened to you earlier, won't be making that mistake again.
@Liquid - The first night cop kill is awesome. Unfortunately, I was the cop that game. DiiLegend put the dagger in me before I had a chance to do any sleuthing. Lame.
@Aman - great game. Thanks. :thumbsup:
Re: OT: Mafia game
From Post #160
That’s why you listen to Zhao. Liquid was a dead giveaway, just by looking at his posting habits. I could tell with Ray because he was pouring on the false logics near the end of the day.
I was pretty upset Bob shifted the momentum last minute to NoClub. I couldn’t believe he was so gullible; he was probably the only townie that truly supported Liquid. Really Bob, you should carefully read Liquid’s posts, not just laugh at them.
Thanks for the host Aman.
Edit: For the record I thought Bob was the Village Idiot. His support for Liquid was too blatent, for him to be his partner. So I thought Bob had a feeling Liquid was Mafia and so when Liquid would be lynched and show his role, he'd be the easy lynch for the next day, and meet his win condition.
From Post #160
Zhao said:
That’s why you listen to Zhao. Liquid was a dead giveaway, just by looking at his posting habits. I could tell with Ray because he was pouring on the false logics near the end of the day.
I was pretty upset Bob shifted the momentum last minute to NoClub. I couldn’t believe he was so gullible; he was probably the only townie that truly supported Liquid. Really Bob, you should carefully read Liquid’s posts, not just laugh at them.
Thanks for the host Aman.
Edit: For the record I thought Bob was the Village Idiot. His support for Liquid was too blatent, for him to be his partner. So I thought Bob had a feeling Liquid was Mafia and so when Liquid would be lynched and show his role, he'd be the easy lynch for the next day, and meet his win condition.
Last edited:
Liquid_Evil
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
@ ZY-
1) Give Bob a break.
2) Nobody laughs at me.
3) You never *really* knew. :wink3: (edit: until the coroner claim at least)
@ ZY-
1) Give Bob a break.
2) Nobody laughs at me.
3) You never *really* knew. :wink3: (edit: until the coroner claim at least)
Re: OT: Mafia game
When you tried to push the crappy logic on why you voted for me, I was 75% sure. When you did the false claim - 95% sure.
When you tried to push the crappy logic on why you voted for me, I was 75% sure. When you did the false claim - 95% sure.
Re: OT: Mafia game
I tried to tell everyone to vote for Liq the first day! My initial heal was going to be for Gorny but I switched at the last minute. When I left on the first day it looked like Liq was a goner. Unfortunately, the pace of the game quickened immensley and I was unable to deflect any of the accusations.
Good game though well played.
I tried to tell everyone to vote for Liq the first day! My initial heal was going to be for Gorny but I switched at the last minute. When I left on the first day it looked like Liq was a goner. Unfortunately, the pace of the game quickened immensley and I was unable to deflect any of the accusations.
Good game though well played.
BobTheWarrior
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
*sobs*
It's all my fault. I suck at this game!
*runs to my room*
:tongue:
Seriously Zhao. I did read Liquid's posts. And yours. Several times. I decided Liquid was the one to trust. He was posting a lot and I was worried that a townie was going to get lynched by the quiet mob because he was posting a lot. Happens most every game. I decided this game should be different, and I wasn't going to be part of the quiet mob.
I was overwhelmed by the amount of seemingly valueable information he was giving us. Having a blind start to the game made it difficult to figure out not only who the mafia were, but what the townies' roles could be as well.
Coroner seemed plausible, and I didn't see anything in Liquids posts to make me believe he wasn't telling the truth. He had a lot to say in a recent SPF game (where I read all his posts, too) so I had a good baseline to compare.
*sobs*
It's all my fault. I suck at this game!
*runs to my room*
:tongue:
Seriously Zhao. I did read Liquid's posts. And yours. Several times. I decided Liquid was the one to trust. He was posting a lot and I was worried that a townie was going to get lynched by the quiet mob because he was posting a lot. Happens most every game. I decided this game should be different, and I wasn't going to be part of the quiet mob.
I was overwhelmed by the amount of seemingly valueable information he was giving us. Having a blind start to the game made it difficult to figure out not only who the mafia were, but what the townies' roles could be as well.
Coroner seemed plausible, and I didn't see anything in Liquids posts to make me believe he wasn't telling the truth. He had a lot to say in a recent SPF game (where I read all his posts, too) so I had a good baseline to compare.
Re: OT: Mafia game
Liquid basically wanted to quick lynch me because I didn't hadn't posted alot. He was also exaggerating. If that didn't set off alarm bells, I don't know what would have.
As a general rule:
Towie: Ask questions, makes guesses, altogether should sound uncertain of oneself.
Mafia: Makes statements without any inquiries. Exaggerates, bends or outright creates facts. Sometimes gets fixated on a target.
Liquid basically wanted to quick lynch me because I didn't hadn't posted alot. He was also exaggerating. If that didn't set off alarm bells, I don't know what would have.
As a general rule:
Towie: Ask questions, makes guesses, altogether should sound uncertain of oneself.
Mafia: Makes statements without any inquiries. Exaggerates, bends or outright creates facts. Sometimes gets fixated on a target.
Crowd Control
Banned
Re: OT: Mafia game
Wow! Not really the outcome I had predicted. I really thought Bob's hands were dirty with blood. It seems I was only right on Ray being part of the other Mafia group. I was starting to suspect Orph too, when the last day came. There are Mason's who backstab and I might 've been the unlucky victim of that
. But it all turned out good after all.
I want to thank all for being part of such a good game. I was pleased to be on the non-host side again, though you can expect another host of this game from me sooner or later. Thanks Aman for good, thorough hosting. And thanks for the SPF dudes and dudettes for bringing some new (very sharp) tactics to the game.
Wow! Not really the outcome I had predicted. I really thought Bob's hands were dirty with blood. It seems I was only right on Ray being part of the other Mafia group. I was starting to suspect Orph too, when the last day came. There are Mason's who backstab and I might 've been the unlucky victim of that
. But it all turned out good after all.I want to thank all for being part of such a good game. I was pleased to be on the non-host side again, though you can expect another host of this game from me sooner or later. Thanks Aman for good, thorough hosting. And thanks for the SPF dudes and dudettes for bringing some new (very sharp) tactics to the game.
IntelligentX
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Heh, I know liquid is mafia.
He suspects me for no obvious reason, and even my dumb brain knows something is wrong there.
Heh, I know liquid is mafia.
He suspects me for no obvious reason, and even my dumb brain knows something is wrong there.
Liquid_Evil
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Even if I was townie I would have tried to lynch you. I'm always leary of those that can't (or refuse) to think for themselves.
Kudos on "spotting" me though. :wink3:
Even if I was townie I would have tried to lynch you. I'm always leary of those that can't (or refuse) to think for themselves.
Kudos on "spotting" me though. :wink3:
Re: OT: Mafia game
Or in my case is a cop.
Aman are you running another one like this, I'd like to see that.
Or in my case is a cop.
Aman are you running another one like this, I'd like to see that.
Liquid_Evil
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Well sign me up to host one here, then. Where's the list of people currently in line to host?
Well sign me up to host one here, then. Where's the list of people currently in line to host?
