(KindofMafia) Assassin in the Castle!

[Gwaihir]

Flip flop between Sath+kegs disagreed to Sath+kegs agreed?

Yeah, that was poorly worded. I was pointed out Sath and kegs seemed to disagree with me, where I said scum hunting is still involved and that both Sath and kegs seemed to disagree with that.

Also I think there is still scum hunting involved here. Still works similar to a mafia game in this regard with a small killing faction trying to hide from a larger town one. Harder to separate as assassin has no teammates, but other things still apply like lynching a lurker, and with only one assassin, we only need to pick correctly once.

You and kegs seem to disagree, which I find odd. When humans are playing a game like this I think you can always do better than random with good reads on people.

Yes, because I wasn't sure he was a guard yet.

So you chose to say goodbye sir to someone you thought was an assassin? Seems more likely something you would say to a guard. Good riddance maybe but not good sir.

 

[Solar Ice]

I'm trying to imagine Sathoris' statements from the perspective of him being the assassin and I'm feeling uneasy. Is Sathoris manipulating everyone?

Vote: Sathoris

 

[Caluin Graye]

Current vote count before I head to bed:

Sathoris [3]: kestegs; pharphis; Solar Ice
Bad Ash [2]: Goryani; omgwtfbbqpwned
Goryani [1]: Sathoris
kestegs [1]: Gwaihir

Not voting: Bad Ash

 

[Bad Ash]

It seems as if its not Sath than we might have some possibilities open up to us.

Vote: Sathoris

 

[Kestegs]

Yeah, that was poorly worded. I was pointed out Sath and kegs seemed to disagree with me, where I said scum hunting is still involved and that both Sath and kegs seemed to disagree with that.

So you chose to say goodbye sir to someone you thought was an assassin? Seems more likely something you would say to a guard. Good riddance maybe but not good sir.

I said what I said, and I'm not explaining it any further.

 

[Sathoris]

This is ridiculous. Think for a second about what motives I would have were I the assassin.

 

[pharphis]

If it's not Sath then I think it's Gwaihir. I'm only a little uneasy about Bad Ash and Solar.

 

[Kestegs]

This is ridiculous. Think for a second about what motives I would have were I the assassin.

*thinks about sath wanting to kill the king*

If it's not Sath then I think it's Gwaihir. I'm only a little uneasy about Bad Ash and Solar.

I love this list, except I haven't gotten that feeling from solar.

 

[Sathoris]

*thinks about sath wanting to kill the king*

If that were the case wouldn't you think I'd follow my own advice instead of alerting the guards what to look for?

Hmm?

 

[Kestegs]

If that were the case wouldn't you think I'd follow my own advice instead of alerting the guards what to look for?

Hmm?

Mad that your plan to look like town is backfiring?

 

[pharphis]

If that were the case wouldn't you think I'd follow my own advice instead of alerting the guards what to look for?

Hmm?

I already explained why following your own advice is no better than not following your own advice, because you drew attention to it. Just like I drew some conclusions about peoples' reactions to my list, I can no longer use that to determine who else is a guard or not.
^This is also more or less my answer to Gory's confused face.

@Kestegs, I sort of get that feeling from Solar because of his question about the list, and similarly to Bad Ash. Not crazy uneasy, though.

 

[Sathoris]

Mad that your plan to look like town is backfiring?

View attachment 2566

gghf

 

[Sathoris]

I already explained why following your own advice is no better than not following your own advice, because you drew attention to it

What is this I don't even.

 

[pharphis]

What is this I don't even.

Because you said it was in the assassin's best interest to lurk, lurking is now even less reliable as a tell.
I don't really know how else to explain it lol. I feel like my newest explanation makes less sense.

Maybe the easiest way to sum it up is rephrasing what I said originally.
You're the assassin so of course you're going to say that lurking is in their best interest, because you're not being a lurk.

 

[Sathoris]

You're the assassin so of course you're going to say that lurking is in their best interest, because you're not being a lurk.

If I were the assassin I'd just lurk and not mention anything and I'd be coasting instead of getting lynched now.

Occam's razor

 

[Kestegs]

If I were the assassin I'd just lurk and not mention anything and I'd be coasting instead of getting lynched now.

Occam's razor

That wouldn't be your style. Then you would get lynched anyways.

 

[Sathoris]

That wouldn't be your style. Then you would get lynched anyways.

So, stealthing would get me lynched. Actively trying to search for the assassin by mentioning stealthing is getting me lynched.

 

[Solar Ice]

There is still time to change votes, if need be. I am becoming less and less certain that Sathoris is the man were looking for. Kestegs is my number 1 suspect at this point, and one I'd rather lynch today.


Unvote: Sathoris
Vote: kestegs


I will switch back if neccessary.

 

[Solar Ice]

I guess there is no interest Today.




Unvote: kestegs
Vote: Sathoris

 

[Kestegs]

Everyone disappeared at the most important time it seems.

15 minuets to day end if I've got the time right.