(KindofMafia) Assassin in the Castle!

[Gwaihir]

Who's scum hunting? And this is totally different, there is no association, no powers, no nothing. Goodbye sir.

So because I disagree with sath I am scum? I don't get your logic there.

I was saying I disagree with both you and Sath about scum hunting.

Sath seems to be of the idea that scum hunting is not very useful, and you seem to agree with him from your post above. To me this seems like a hope to get lucky plan instead of try to get rid of the assassin plan, and makes me suspicious.

Also, the goodbye sir just seemed like an odd thing to say.

 

[Kestegs]

I was saying I disagree with both you and Sath about scum hunting.

Sath seems to be of the idea that scum hunting is not very useful, and you seem to agree with him from your post above. To me this seems like a hope to get lucky plan instead of try to get rid of the assassin plan, and makes me suspicious.

Also, the goodbye sir just seemed like an odd thing to say.

Okay, I see your point. Scum hunting is just vastly different from normal mafia is what I meant. I think the longer the game goes on the easier it will be to scum hunt though.

And yes, it was a weird thing to say. I had a reason to say it, but I've forgotten what it was by now.

 

[Caluin Graye]

omgwtfbbqpwned replaces ThunderCat. Thank you, OMG, for stepping in. Much appreciated.

Edit -
Though you'll have to clear out some PM space in order to get your role.

 

[pharphis]

Alright, now that I'm back from my lab. . .
@Sath, that was the worst reason I've ever heard to vote Gory, so vote: Sathoris

@Everyone else, I misunderstood what TC said ages ago about CG replacing him. I thought he meant CG himself would be the replacement for TC, which is why I thought it was obvious he would not be the assassin (because CG knows who the king is). Now that OMG is the replacement this makes a lot more sense to me. Add OMG onto my list, then, and remove kestegs.
Good, the terrible list is revealing lots of information already

 

[pharphis]

I forgot to bold, so just in case,
vote: sathoris

 

[Sathoris]

People need to realise this isn't mafia! Stealthing through the game is what's going to win the game for the assassin. Scumhunting isn't because you put yourself at risk to people who don't understand the voting trick here..

 

[pharphis]

People need to realise this isn't mafia! Stealthing through the game is what's going to win the game for the assassin. Scumhunting isn't because you put yourself at risk to people who don't understand the voting trick here..

I don't understand what you're saying in the second sentence here.
However, while true that stealthing gives the guards less info to work with, the assassin could easily just be as involved as possible knowing that being a lurk is suspicious.
I mean, if you were the assassin then wouldn't you say exactly what you have said about stealth, simply because you have been involved?

 

[Bad Ash]

I don't understand what you're saying in the second sentence here.
However, while true that stealthing gives the guards less info to work with, the assassin could easily just be as involved as possible knowing that being a lurk is suspicious.
I mean, if you were the assassin then wouldn't you say exactly what you have said about stealth, simply because you have been involved?

Vote: Pharphis

for now. I think the quote above epitomises my feelings for the time being. Might be over posting to compensate something....

 

[Kestegs]

People need to realise this isn't mafia! Stealthing through the game is what's going to win the game for the assassin. Scumhunting isn't because you put yourself at risk to people who don't understand the voting trick here..

Yea, I think I know what you mean, and we're not doing good.

However, being inactive is also detrimental to the good guys. Every day the assassin survives greatly increases his probability of winning.

 

[pharphis]

I set a bit of a trap and Sath fell for it. Solar didn't respond carefully enough, either. I think Kestegs figured me out, which is why I deemed him to be innocent for now. Of course, we still have lots of time to find someone else.

 

[omgwtfbbqpwned]

The Duke fled. Nobody tried stopping him.

What if the Duke was the Assassin and the King's already dead?

 

[pharphis]

haha, very funny jimmy.

 

[omgwtfbbqpwned]

Vote: kestegs

 

[Kestegs]

What if the Duke was the Assassin and the King's already dead?

Noob.

Vote: kestegs

Noob.

 

[Bad Ash]

this game is tough. Lotta luck involved.

I want to break down some strategy too but feel like Sath did and that it would only help the assassin.
Sath could be the kind of player who would drop a line like that and have it be for the purpose of deflecting heat. kestegs is also on my radar as well.then again pharphis :

I set a bit of a trap and Sath fell for it. Solar didn't respond carefully enough, either. I think Kestegs figured me out, which is why I deemed him to be innocent for now. Of course, we still have lots of time to find someone else.

heres my only beef with this...if you are the assassin, its so much easier to make a statement like this. you can try to deflect attention by calling people out, and gain credibility at the same time by saying you think someone is clean.

Can you explain carefully with why you think kestegs is clean without revealing if you think he is or is not the king for obvious reasons?

 

[pharphis]

At first Kestegs didn't like my list because he thought it was just a poor attempt at a distraction from you all lynching myself. Then he changed his mind after presumably thinking about it a bit, and went for Sathoris because (presumably) Sath didn't agree with me.
I don't want to say much more than that.

 

[Bad Ash]

Okay, I see your point. Scum hunting is just vastly different from normal mafia is what I meant. I think the longer the game goes on the easier it will be to scum hunt though.

And yes, it was a weird thing to say. I had a reason to say it, but I've forgotten what it was by now.

Did you remember why you said "goodbye sir" yet?

Unvote: pharphis

 

[Kestegs]

Did you remember why you said "goodbye sir" yet?

Unvote: pharphis

Yes, because I wasn't sure he was a guard yet.

 

[Goryani]

[Sathoris] and kegs seem to disagree, which I find odd. When humans are playing a game like this I think you can always do better than random with good reads on people.

I was saying I disagree with both you and Sath about scum hunting.

Sath seems to be of the idea that scum hunting is not very useful, and you seem to agree with him from your post above. To me this seems like a hope to get lucky plan instead of try to get rid of the assassin plan, and makes me suspicious.

Also, the goodbye sir just seemed like an odd thing to say.

Flip flop between Sath+kegs disagreed to Sath+kegs agreed?

People need to realise this isn't mafia! Stealthing through the game is what's going to win the game for the assassin. Scumhunting isn't because you put yourself at risk to people who don't understand the voting trick here..

:thumbup:

I don't understand what you're saying in the second sentence here.
However, while true that stealthing gives the guards less info to work with, the assassin could easily just be as involved as possible knowing that being a lurk is suspicious.
I mean, if you were the assassin then wouldn't you say exactly what you have said about stealth, simply because you have been involved?

onder:

Can you explain carefully with why you think kestegs is clean without revealing if you think he is or is not the king for obvious reasons?

You're as bad as[SUB]h[/SUB] Solar. The only possible scenario I can think of, where it's acceptable to ask this question, is if you think pharphis is the assassin. STRONGLY think so. Yet I see an unvote just 2 posts later.

Unvote: Solar Ice
Vote: Bad Ash

 

[omgwtfbbqpwned]

Sure, why not.

Unvote: kestegs
Vote: Bad Ash