Create Your Own Role Mafia game

[Solar Ice]

Didn't help that we didn't lynch any mafia either haha, so when you analyze the people on their death bed, they all seemed similar.
!

I was not lynched but I was Mafia, and it was (unfortunately) obvious. People could have tried to made the correct links from there. Gwaihir was at one point spot on about my interaction or lack thereof with fellow Mafia.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Also, thanks for getting me killed, Gwaihir. I appreciate that.

 

[MartinLong]

I was not lynched but I was Mafia, and it was (unfortunately) obvious. People could have tried to made the correct links from there. Gwaihir was at one point spot on about my interaction or lack thereof with fellow Mafia.

But with case, you need more than something like "interactions". The evidence was obviously there, but other targets were higher on the list apparently.

 

[Solar Ice]

Whats up with that? Why were you guys so set on killing me? I was pretty much protected from most night actions I was the Mime (copied the reflector), the reflector, and then last laugh. It was crazy.

At that point it was between targeting you, Gwaihir or Caluin. I felt that Gwaihir would be protected that Night and after Caluin's timeline case on Moar swung the heat away from us (we were taking heavy fire at that point :x), it would have made sense to keep him around.

That left you. We did not know you were mime (or at the very least I did not see any hints about that), so we targeted you because your Nk would likely go through. You picked the right role to copy.

I was under a time pressure as well at that time, only got online like an hour before the Nk/role actions deadline were to be submitted.

Turns out Gwaihir was the only NK choice out of our considerations that would have kept our numbers. Targeting Caluin would have killed thefranklin I think, based on the fact that he collected blood from himself with the forensic scientist, when he actually targeted Caluin.

But you can read it in more detail in the Mafia QT after it is posted

 

[Solar Ice]

But with case, you need more than something like "interactions". The evidence was obviously there, but other targets were higher on the list apparently.

Of course, more than interactions are needed and it is not solid by any means but something to go on in any case.

 

[Bad Ash]

Gory def. deserves some credit for the tarot cards as well. A good double effort.

 

[flubbucket1]

Thanks for hosting Goryani.

I'm sure it was easy as cake.

 

[Gwaihir]

Bah, I sucked this game. I had kestegs pegged, but Sath and Franklin fooled me. Well done, both of you. Also, I was responsible for the Kingmaker role.

Also, thanks for getting me killed, Gwaihir. I appreciate that.

You made the kingmaker role? No apologies then!

In my defense, I was trying to protect you.

I was not lynched but I was Mafia, and it was (unfortunately) obvious. People could have tried to made the correct links from there. Gwaihir was at one point spot on about my interaction or lack thereof with fellow Mafia.

Sigh. Of the 3 people I wanted lynched, 1 was not mafia, and kegs was #4. So I go for the lynch of the one townie in the group. I was tempted to go with Moar and flubb on the last day to vote Sath, but then I saw Sath was the spammer, so I did not switch. Too bad all my first guesses were so off.

 

[Gwaihir]

Cootie Detector - interesting role, would like to see it come back.

Dr. Frankenstein - what is this, I don't even? Great idea, and made this game very interesting!

Extra Seat Bus Driver - BA, had to be you. Got the mime last night, and was going to mime the bus driver in your honor, after switching the lynch train to you.

Forensic Scientist - I really, really like this role for a normal game. If someone is looking to include a weaker investigative role, this seems like a ton of fun. When mafia can get it, the usefulness goes to almost zero, as they can mess with it so easily

Kingmaker - fascinating role, although just so damn deadly in the hands of mafia.

The Last Laugh - another fascinating role, actually pretty balanced in this game. Really liked it. Sorry Mal

Meet Joe Black - Well played with this one SI. Perfect use.

Mime - Not quite as interesting as I had hoped, but seemed fun. glad I at least got my own once.

Paris Hilton - very creative spin on a somewhat lovers role. Had to read it several times to get it though.

Politician - this would be a great role to incude as in other games as well - does a townie dare use it?

Reflector - Thanks for getting us our one mafia kill!

The Spammer - agreed, make it non-consecutive, but overall made the game very interesting.

Tarot Psychic - wow. tons of work here, and who doesn't love a good scientist role?

 

[pharphis]

Vote: Sathoris

You wouldn't let up on Moar the entire game. Sheesh.

Interesting game to read! Wish I was in it, and I think all the roles were pretty great ideas

 

[thefranklin]

Thanks for hosting Gory. Great role ideas.

I am surprised I was the only one who thought ML spammed way too much that day as not the spammer. And no one got my claims ( which was the point until I wanted to lynch ML. I did plan on getting it, but the wife got off work early. that is one phone call you don't want to get, lol.

The spammer was quite a lovely distraction, it saved sath 3 times. I include the time Moar was saved, her lynch might have given him one too many scum points.

Ankeli and Moar had some good reads early. Grats to Gwahir for noticing the pack of mafia connections.

Wish we would have went for the complicated plan, would have been epic. I wouldn't have thought Sath to get king again!

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

At that point it was between targeting you, Gwaihir or Caluin. I felt that Gwaihir would be protected that Night and after Caluin's timeline case on Moar swung the heat away from us (we were taking heavy fire at that point :x), it would have made sense to keep him around.

That left you. We did not know you were mime (or at the very least I did not see any hints about that), so we targeted you because your Nk would likely go through. You picked the right role to copy.

I was under a time pressure as well at that time, only got online like an hour before the Nk/role actions deadline were to be submitted.

Turns out Gwaihir was the only NK choice out of our considerations that would have kept our numbers. Targeting Caluin would have killed thefranklin I think, based on the fact that he collected blood from himself with the forensic scientist, when he actually targeted Caluin.

But you can read it in more detail in the Mafia QT after it is posted

Wow, so I was one of the first three considered for a NK, I almost feel privileged but then again it was a small game, and you obviously couldn't target goryani so maybe not.

Meet Joe Black - Well played with this one SI. Perfect use.

I was actually pretty pleased with that myself, it worked just as it should have, it can be used to create confusion, or give the town the extra edge by having that additional person to discuss/vote for one more day. In the right scenario it could tip the scale either way but it was subtle at the same time. I actually toyed with making it more powerful with Goryani and he suggested a double vote ability on the next day phase but we ultimately decided against it. Unfortunately the mafia got to utilize it and ended up getting ankeli lynched which I wasn't to happy about.

 

[Bad Ash]

No Gwaihir...the extra seat bus driver was not me. Although I enjoyed the role.

 

[MartinLong]

No Gwaihir...the extra seat bus driver was not me. Although I enjoyed the role.

It was a good role! So much craziness with it.

 

[Goryani]

Hmm also, I have to say. With all the townies we lynched, why the lack of good arguments to live? From my memory and point of view, when someone was getting lynched, they didn't really do anything but say "well, im going to flip town, so shame on you".

Was it just me?

Ankeli didn't go quietly. He named 3 of 4 mafia (though he named a couple townies as well in the end). I don't recall any discussion from remaining townies regarding Ankeli's flip nor the accuracy of his scumdar.

Malevolent didn't go quietly either. He locked on target and created a spam wall high enough to ensure his target was lynchable despite having the spammer role. Again, I don't recall any discussion from the remaining townies (though Mal's alignment remaining hidden probably influenced that).

Little to no followup after the first two mis-lynches doesn't exactly give hope to future mis-lynch targets.

 

[Goryani]

I thought the role submissions were fantastic. I wouldn't be at all upset to see any of these roles return. Even roles which had to be declined were also good (some were overpowered, some were duplicates and some just didn't work with the "roles rotate randomly with anyone" setup).

I'll work up a table of roles and actions for each day and post them somewhere.

 

[Goryani]

Day 1 Actions

Submissions:

• Politician Bribe (Moar) - kestegs must vote Sathoris
• Paris Hilton (flub) - chooses Solar Ice as BFF
• Mime (Pyro) - mimics Reflector

Side Effects and Info:

• Last Laugh (Mal) - killer is Martin Long

Night 1 Actions

Submissions:

• reflector (CG)
• mime reflector (pyro)
• bus driver (BA) - BA, Moar, flub
• politician roll block (Moar) - Ankeli
• mafia NK (Solar Ice) - kill Pyrotechnician
• Dr. Frankenstein (Gwaihir)- swap Mal and Moar
• Forensic Scientist (thefranklin) - Collect from CG, no Lab action
• Kingmaker (ML) - Sathoris is king
• Tarot Psychic (kestegs) - give Sun to Gwaihir
• Cootie Detector (Ankeli)

Night Action Resolution:

1. thefranklin's collect was reflected to thefranklin
2. Solar Ice's NK was reflected to Solar Ice
3. Gwaihir's reanimate was bussed from Moar to flub
4. Ankeli's Cootie Detector was blocked

Final Actions:

• reflector (CG)
• mime reflector (pyro)
• bus driver (BA) - BA, Moar, flub
• politician roll block (Moar) - Ankeli
• mafia NK (Solar Ice) - kill Solar Ice
• Dr. Frankenstein (Gwaihir)- Reanimate Mal and flub
• Forensic Scientist (thefranklin) - Collect from thefranklin, no Lab action
• Kingmaker (ML) - Sathoris is king
• Tarot Psychic (kestegs) - give Sun to Gwaihir
• Cootie Detector (Ankeli) - blocked

Side Effects and Info:

1. Solar Ice dies. Solar Ice is Meet Joe Black. Meet Joe Black delayed death is triggered. No death N1. Solar Ice will die at the end of D2. Solar Ice receives delayed death notification. Solar Ice keeps Meet Joe Black role for D2.
2. Cootie Detector is blocked - no results sent.
3. Last Laugh replaces Paris in the role rotation. Paris doesn't die (NK or lynch) so the BFF mourning isn't triggered. Dr. Frankenstein cooldown triggered and can't be used again till N3. Malevolent is now Paris. Malevolent can't return via Last Laugh.
4. Forensic Scientist Inventory:
   • N1 = thefranklin
5. Politician Roleblock now has 2 charges
6. Reflector uses up the 1x kill reflect

 

[Goryani]

Day 2 Actions

Submissions:

• King (Sathoris) - no action sent in
• Sun Tarot Card (Gwaihir) - activated, night 2 is skipped
• Mime (MartinLong) - mimic Cootie Detector
• Politician Bribe (Ankeli) - Moar must vote Sathoris

Side Effects and Info:


Night 2 Actions

These aren't the night actions you are looking for.

 

[Goryani]

Day 3 Actions

Submissions:

• Mime (MartinLong) - mimic Cootie Detector

Side Effects and Info:

Night 3 Actions

Submissions:

• bus driver (kestegs) - kestegs, Moar, CG
• mafia NK (kestegs) - Pyrotechnician
• Dr. Frankenstein (Sathoris)- swap flubb and Malevolent
• Forensic Scientist (Gwaihir) - collect kestegs, analyze N1 & N3
• Kingmaker (flubbucket) - appoint Sathoris as king
• Tarot Psychic (thefranklin) - give High Priestess to Pyrotechnician
• Cootie Detector (Caluin Graye, Martin Long)

Night Action Resolution:

1. Gwaihir's collect is redirected to Moar

Final Actions:

• bus driver (kestegs) - kestegs, Moar, CG
• mafia NK (kestegs) - Pyrotechnician
• Dr. Frankenstein (Sathoris)- swap flubb and Malevolent
• Forensic Scientist (Gwaihir) - collect Moar, analyze N1 & N3
• Kingmaker (flubbucket) - appoint Sathoris as king
• Tarot Psychic (thefranklin) - give High Priestess to Pyrotechnician
• Cootie Detector (Caluin Graye, Martin Long)

Side Effects and Info:

1. Pyrotechnician dies. Pyro is the Last Laugh. Pyro's killer is kestegs. As long as Pyro can return to the game, he keeps the High Priestess card.
2. Cootie Detector results (sent to CG and ML): CG, flubbucket, kestegs, Moar, Pyro, Sathoris
3. Dr. Frankenstein - Paris Hilton replaces Kingmaker in the role rotation. Malevolent is now the Kingmaker. Dr. Frank on cooldown and can be used again N5.
4. Forensic Scientist Inventory
   • N1 = thefranklin
   • N3 = Moar
5. Forensic Scientist Lab Action: Analayze N1 and N3 - NO MATCH

 

[Goryani]

Day 4 Actions

Submissions:

• Paris Hilton (Sathoris) - BFF = Caluin Graye
• Mime (Moar) - mimics Cootie Detector

Side Effects and Info:

1. BFF dies. Next Paris chooses a new BFF

Night 4 Actions

Submissions:

• bus driver (Gwaihir) - CG, flubb, ML
• mafia NK (kestegs) - ML
• Dr. Frankenstein (MartinLong) - swap Sathoris with Pyro
• Forensic Scientist (kestegs) - collect flubbucket, clean N1
• Tarot Psychic (Caluin Graye) - give thefranklin High Priestess
• Cootie Detector (flubbucket, Moar)

Action Resolution:

1. mafia NK redirected to CG
2. kestegs collect redirected to ML
3. ML's Dr Frankenstin swap failed because it was on cooldown
4. Caluin Graye's Tarot reading failed because that card was not in the deck

Final Actions:

• bus driver (Gwaihir) - CG, flubb, ML
• mafia NK (kestegs) - CG
• Forensic Scientist (kestegs) - collect ML, clean N1
• Cootie Detector (flubbucket, Moar)

Side Effects and Info:

1. CG dies.
2. Cootie Detector results (sent to flub and Moar): CG, flub, ML
3. Forensic Scientist Lab Action: clean N1
4. Forensic Scientist Inventory:
   • N1 = cleaned
   • N3 = Moar
   • N4 = ML