Create Your Own Role Mafia game

[MartinLong]

You're not psychic are you?

I can predict that I'll do doing yardwork shortly. That's about my limitations as a novice psychic.

Yes, Moar should be lynched, I'm convinced she's mafia as I'm convinced Mal was mafia.

Noted.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Do you really need me to tell you that? Without looking at the cards I can think of three a lot more useful than the no day mafia card..

Need? No. I was interested in your input, preferably one that wasn't full of venom and snark. I wanted your viewpoint on why specific cards would be better than keeping a killer card out of the hands of mafia. But this here tells me what I wanted to know, so thank you anyways.

 

[thefranklin]

I only have a short time to post. I've read through and have a hard time understanding the suspicion aimed at me. If you've read my posts I've been very forthcoming and have played quite townie. I've answered questions and volunteered information.

I also believe Malevolent and Solar Ice were scum and we may only have two scum left. I'm not understanding kestegs not wanting to lynch today and Moar's not wanting to vote today. All this LYLO MYLO BO DEE OH DOE is becoming a distraction and no lynch in no info. If I am lynched I will flip town, but at least the town will have some information.

No lynch is no information and that just seems foolish to me. Doesn't this end in a couple of hours???

I agree you have played townie, which is why I am so suspicious of you. Hmmm.

And your second two paragraphs are exactly what I would say if I was mafia and I handed my teammate king.

 

[Gwaihir]

Therefore, (and here's the important part!), tonight I will try giving out the 'Skip a day phase' tarot card. I'm the fortune teller. I plan on giving it to the towniest person in the thread, but I'd rather not name who. My hope is two-fold: It lands in the hands of a townie who will never, ever, ever use it, while simultaneously proving or disproving my thoughts about franklin.

And if my fears are confirmed and the card is already out there, well, then the game is pretty much lost already anyways.

I realize there's a pretty darned good chance the card might fall in the hands of mafia anyways. If you want to try talking me out of this, now's the time.

Yikes, this is scary. I think the idea is ok, except for the problem of the bus driver. The driver will be trying to move a townie to a mafia - so if you both choose the same townie, then you end up giving it to a very scummy person. Assuming it is not out there already, and assuming you are town, we have at least 2 more days of lynching before it can be used. I think there may be better options for handing out cards, but I trust your judgement.

I won't vote today. If Gwaihir just made it up, then gratz to him.

Made up what? flubb being suspicious I can take credit for pointing that out. As for the MYLO voting isssue, CG was the one who pointed it out, credit goes to him there.

Dangerous play, but it does sound fun. If I did hand the no day card last night, it would most likely get used tonight, right?

This is true, I can't see if being saved.

Rawr, ferocious roar.

Guess we'll see what happens tomorrow then. Still taking any further complaints or input, however. I realize this is a stupid amount of risky plan, but I think it's worth it to keep it out of naughty hands.

I completely see this as you being Simba rawring at that little beetle. Now just have to hope it doesn't result in a wildebeest stampede.

So many roles I don't want mafia to get it is scary.

 

[Sathoris]

Need? No. I was interested in your input, preferably one that wasn't full of venom and snark. I wanted your viewpoint on why specific cards would be better than keeping a killer card out of the hands of mafia. But this here tells me what I wanted to know, so thank you anyways.

You knew what type of response you would get.. Posing questions that town and mafia will give the same answer to are useless.

 

[Caluin Graye]

You knew what type of response you would get.. Posing questions that town and mafia will give the same answer to are useless.

Well, like I said earlier:

Many times when I ask someone a question, I'm more interested in how they respond than what they respond with.

It wasn't about the answer. It was entirely about how you deliver the answer. And the way you speak to the town is quite telling. You don't ask us to trust you with your King powers; you instead shout and berate at the town for not following your lead. You speak abusively and derogatorily, and when questioned about anything, throw it back in the face of the person posing the question. You continually bark up Moar's tree, but I've seen absolutely no effort at scum hunting beyond that from you. You're settling for the easy lynch, telling people that their reads and ideas are dumb, but offering nothing else of your own.

In other words - you're playing like scum who wants to cruise to the easy win. Whether you are scum or not, I don't know. But that's how you're playing, so that's how I'll treat you.

Also, I'm still sort of irritated that you didn't bother to post until early this morning. Shortly before glibb deigned us with his presence. I wouldn't be surprised one bit to learn that mafia has day talk and you wanted to confer with glibb before finally stepping forward.

 

[Kestegs]

Maybe something like:

A: Kegs
B: Moar
C: CG

My underlying assumptions:
I believe CG to be town (atm), CG would be a priority on scum hit list.
I believe you are scum.
And B, for safety, if Kegs is targeted, no one dies. This case would also say that Kegs was town as he would have been targeted by scum.

In the time it took you to write this, you could have explained your choice again. Why so difficult?

So you'd pick the same targets as I did but I'm scummy for it. Lol.

Not being difficult, I just don't fancy repeating myself. I already explained it and answered questions regarding it early in this day phase.

Here and there.

I agree with this. It could also be the case that Sath and flubb are both scum, but for Sath to with 'town points' he will not interfere with his scum buddies death. It's a idea I'm throwing out there.

I think flubb is the best target for today all in all,
Vote: flubbucket

So you are either convinced that Sath is town or that we are not in mylo. Which is it?

And not that I disagree on flubb necessarily, just on your timing.

So you thought CG unlikely to be killed. Why would CG be the best reasoning there, instead of someone who has gotten some heat like myself or Moar?

Who did you think was mafia yesterday?

If we have 3 mafia (MYLO), and Sath is mafia, a lynch today loses us the game unless a bus driver guesses correctly on one of the following 2 nights.

To me, yes. He play yesterday made her less suspicious. The fact that Solar went after Moar a few times makes me less suspicious. The fact that Solar went after Mal, and the reasoning for me finding Moar suspicious was in large part related to Mal being mafia, makes her less suspicious. So overall, Moar is actually not at the top of my list anymore.

Exactly. At 3-3 we keep playing. If anyone misvotes, mafai can pile on to win. Otherwise they can nightkill for the win.

Not quite, as there could still be a bus for the win. But it is way more likely to get a mislynch and have them win.

I couldn't put moar on two seats, I'm a bus driver not a magician. In hindsight I should have put moar before me so I would be guaranteed safe, but it's the same likelihood of stopping a kill either way.

I believe Mal to be mafia so you *as mafia* could just not vote and he'd be alive. So you get townie points for that.

Mafia bus and they don't. Going after people on D1 is very vague and unless you're very outspoken, means nothing. Her play yesterday has just as much scum vibe to it. This is exactly what I was afraid of. Her complete scummyness of the first few days is being laughed off and she's getting a free card. GG

GG.


been busy at work, but I'll try to pop in one last time before day end.

 

[Sathoris]

Well, like I said earlier:

It wasn't about the answer. It was entirely about how you deliver the answer. And the way you speak to the town is quite telling. You don't ask us to trust you with your King powers; you instead shout and berate at the town for not following your lead. You speak abusively and derogatorily, and when questioned about anything, throw it back in the face of the person posing the question. You continually bark up Moar's tree, but I've seen absolutely no effort at scum hunting beyond that from you. You're settling for the easy lynch, telling people that their reads and ideas are dumb, but offering nothing else of your own.

In other words - you're playing like scum who wants to cruise to the easy win. Whether you are scum or not, I don't know. But that's how you're playing, so that's how I'll treat you.

Also, I'm still sort of irritated that you didn't bother to post until early this morning. Shortly before glibb deigned us with his presence. I wouldn't be surprised one bit to learn that mafia has day talk and you wanted to confer with glibb before finally stepping forward.

The way I post later has always been the same and suits me well as scum or town. It may not be the most friendly, but I'm not insulting anyone or attacking them personally. The fact that two people entrusted me with the king power means I don't radiate scum cruising to everyone so I don't feel the need to suddenly change my repsonse just because you want a long story of me explaining why what card would be best. You know which cards are best. You proposed to send out a different card, I voiced my disagreement. I always give an answer in my responses, and as something you apparently spend a lot of time on reading, you'd know that.

I'm convinced Malev and Moar are scum so I feel I've delivered my part of the scumhunting this game. It's become clear (beyond reason to me) that most of you disagree on Moar so I'll compose myself and start anew. But not until today did it became obvious Moar wasn't going to be lynched.

And I'm irriated you discussed the potential king for 12 hours when you full well knew the king would claim eventually, why waste that time speculating on something you needn't to? Besides I simply didn't have time to post untill I did. Not my fault you're choice of topic stalled the discussion untill I showed up.

 

[Sathoris]

Some pretty bad spelling in there

 

[Caluin Graye]

And I'm irriated you discussed the potential king for 12 hours when you full well knew the king would claim eventually, why waste that time speculating on something you needn't to? Besides I simply didn't have time to post untill I did. Not my fault you're choice of topic stalled the discussion untill I showed up.

But you did have time to stop by and drop a vote on Moar though, right?

 

[Gwaihir]

I couldn't put moar on two seats, I'm a bus driver not a magician. In hindsight I should have put moar before me so I would be guaranteed safe, but it's the same likelihood of stopping a kill either way.

That would make for an interesting twist. But I am curious who you thought was scum, mostly because if I was bus driver, I would think I would try to bus a kill onto scum as opposed to a death immune person.

The way I post later has always been the same and suits me well as scum or town. It may not be the most friendly, but I'm not insulting anyone or attacking them personally. The fact that two people entrusted me with the king power means I don't radiate scum cruising to everyone so I don't feel the need to suddenly change my repsonse just because you want a long story of me explaining why what card would be best.

True, 2 people did give you king, but to be fair that could be mafia buddies keeping it in the family, especially if I am right about flubb.

Some pretty bad spelling in there

Oh man, if we start punishing spelling I am going to get myself a perma ban.

 

[Sathoris]

But you did have time to stop by and drop a vote on Moar though, right?

24 hours earlier yes, I thought Flubb might want to reveal his reasoning first. And that was before the whole discussion started.

 

[Kestegs]

That would make for an interesting twist. But I am curious who you thought was scum, mostly because if I was bus driver, I would think I would try to bus a kill onto scum as opposed to a death immune person.

True, 2 people did give you king, but to be fair that could be mafia buddies keeping it in the family, especially if I am right about flubb.

Oh man, if we start punishing spelling I am going to get myself a perma ban.

moar was the person I found most scummy.

CG: if your theory is right and Franklin is scum then this game is likely already over.

 

[Goryani]

Day 4 Ends!
​

All quiet on the Western front.

---

Nobody was lynched.

Final Vote Count:
Moar (1) - Sathoris
flubbucket (1) - MartinLong
MartinLong (1) - thefranklin

 

[Goryani]

Day 5 Begins!
​

No story again today.

Caluin Graye died.

---

Day 5 starts as of the timestamp on this post. D5 lasts the normal 48 hours.

D5 ends on Monday at 5:00 pm EST (22:00 GMT). Votes and daytime actions after that time won't count.

Players Alive:

1. kestegs
2. flubbucket
3. Sathoris
4. Gwaihir
5. MartinLong
6. Moar
7. thefranklin

There are 7 players alive. It takes 4 votes to lynch and 5 votes to lock.

 

[Goryani]

Roles have been randomized and sent out. Game on.

 

[Gwaihir]

Well, I failed. I was the bus driver. Targets:

A: Caluin Graye
B: flubbucket
C: MartinLong

I figured mafia would not target ML as the spammer, but they outguessed me.

My thought have not changed from yesterday. I still think flubb is the most suspicious person, both because SI completely ignored him and the fact that he was not targeted for an NK when it seems like he would have been a very good option for it.

 

[Goryani]

Last night flubbucket informed me that his ISP is blocking this site. He will have limited connectivity.

 

[Kestegs]

I was the forensic scientist.

I collected a sample from the previous night's crime scene, Pyro.

I analyzed it to N1 (Franklin)

results: Negative

 

[thefranklin]

Last night flubbucket informed me that his ISP is blocking this site. He will have limited connectivity.

Scumtell!

I was the spammer yesterday.