Create Your Own Role Mafia game

Exactly. He'd do better to not mention it and not expose him to comments and others trying to twist his words.

And here you have another comment you an reply to. ;)


Thanks Moar, haha still quite a few to go. If we are at lylo tomorrow and he claims to have handed out the card and gets hits buddy to verify he did not get it, it is a certain mislynch of me. And game over. Pre-emptively stating his plans make him look more townie than me, exactly like a mafia would want on the final play.
 
1. To look townie.

Not much point in looking townie if your actions would cause the game to be over.

You never answered your thoughts on the bus driver. I would assume rather take the chance they redirect a kill because we can find who the redirected card to?

Something like that. I'm operating under worst case scenario, which means you are indeed scum and our only option to survive is redirect a kill back to the scum.
 
Thanks Moar, haha still quite a few to go. If we are at lylo tomorrow and he claims to have handed out the card and gets hits buddy to verify he did not get it, it is a certain mislynch of me. And game over. Pre-emptively stating his plans make him look more townie than me, exactly like a mafia would want on the final play.

You made me count now. ;)
 
Not much point in looking townie if your actions would cause the game to be over.



Something like that. I'm operating under worst case scenario, which means you are indeed scum and our only option to survive is redirect a kill back to the scum.

I agree with the second part, disagree with the first. If you are scum and pull shenanigans tonight, of course it behooves you to look more town than me, to end the game, for your victory. You are a sleeping dragon.
 
I only have a short time to post. I've read through and have a hard time understanding the suspicion aimed at me. If you've read my posts I've been very forthcoming and have played quite townie. I've answered questions and volunteered information.

I also believe Malevolent and Solar Ice were scum and we may only have two scum left. I'm not understanding kestegs not wanting to lynch today and Moar's not wanting to vote today. All this LYLO MYLO BO DEE OH DOE is becoming a distraction and no lynch in no info. If I am lynched I will flip town, but at least the town will have some information.

No lynch is no information and that just seems foolish to me. Doesn't this end in a couple of hours???
 
Caught Moar's misvote doesn't help.
Ensuring a lynch didn't help? :dontknow: You'd have rather a no-lynch eh? Interesting.

He has close to double the amount of posts of everyone, and please note that I am still voting for him. Hint, hint. I just can't do it, I tried my hardest.
Funny. What are you doing right now? Why are you so eager to pass me.
 
You people are going to be the literal death of me. Voting is a bad move right now.

Yesterday, I alluded to a scenario that I promised I would speak of at a later time. Now is that time.

What if Franklin is scum? Giving out the tarot card to Pyro seems like a very coincidental series of events. He just happened to pick the person who was both not driven and was killed, so as to not verify his claim. Additionally, if the next Tarot Psychic handed out a card, it would likely be the doctor card, and since unused cards are returned to the deck, he's in the clear.

In the mean time, perhaps he gave out a different card. Like the 'skip a day phase' card. Perhaps he gave it also to a scum buddy, such as flubbucket, knowing he wouldn't be bus driven, and would show up under Cooties due to the Frankenstein switch.

This is off the wall, I know. But; it's something I would do if I were mafia in his shoes. Therefore, I can't discount the fact that it is something he would do too.

Therefore, (and here's the important part!), tonight I will try giving out the 'Skip a day phase' tarot card. I'm the fortune teller. I plan on giving it to the towniest person in the thread, but I'd rather not name who. My hope is two-fold: It lands in the hands of a townie who will never, ever, ever use it, while simultaneously proving or disproving my thoughts about franklin.

And if my fears are confirmed and the card is already out there, well, then the game is pretty much lost already anyways.

I realize there's a pretty darned good chance the card might fall in the hands of mafia anyways. If you want to try talking me out of this, now's the time.

Stupid idea. If the card was given out we'd notice it and probably lose. If the card wasn't given and you're judgement is off we'd lose again. How about you give a card that helps us not lose?
 
You people are going to be the literal death of me. Voting is a bad move right now.

Yesterday, I alluded to a scenario that I promised I would speak of at a later time. Now is that time.

What if Franklin is scum? Giving out the tarot card to Pyro seems like a very coincidental series of events. He just happened to pick the person who was both not driven and was killed, so as to not verify his claim. Additionally, if the next Tarot Psychic handed out a card, it would likely be the doctor card, and since unused cards are returned to the deck, he's in the clear.

In the mean time, perhaps he gave out a different card. Like the 'skip a day phase' card. Perhaps he gave it also to a scum buddy, such as flubbucket, knowing he wouldn't be bus driven, and would show up under Cooties due to the Frankenstein switch.

This is off the wall, I know. But; it's something I would do if I were mafia in his shoes. Therefore, I can't discount the fact that it is something he would do too.

Therefore, (and here's the important part!), tonight I will try giving out the 'Skip a day phase' tarot card. I'm the fortune teller. I plan on giving it to the towniest person in the thread, but I'd rather not name who. My hope is two-fold: It lands in the hands of a townie who will never, ever, ever use it, while simultaneously proving or disproving my thoughts about franklin.

And if my fears are confirmed and the card is already out there, well, then the game is pretty much lost already anyways.

I realize there's a pretty darned good chance the card might fall in the hands of mafia anyways. If you want to try talking me out of this, now's the time.
Risky plan, but your experience in mafia will hopefully lend out to you picking a townie. We are in a tight situation, so I the risk is worth it IMO.


No need to mention it if he was mafia. Then he'd just give it to a buddy and lie about which card he gave out. They can agree on which card was given out. Buddy uses it the day after and we are done in.
Agreed, CG if mafia, wouldn't need to make up this plan.


I only have a short time to post. I've read through and have a hard time understanding the suspicion aimed at me. If you've read my posts I've been very forthcoming and have played quite townie. I've answered questions and volunteered information.

I also believe Malevolent and Solar Ice were scum and we may only have two scum left. I'm not understanding kestegs not wanting to lynch today and Moar's not wanting to vote today. All this LYLO MYLO BO DEE OH DOE is becoming a distraction and no lynch in no info. If I am lynched I will flip town, but at least the town will have some information.

No lynch is no information and that just seems foolish to me. Doesn't this end in a couple of hours???
Day ends in 2 hours. No one seems to have made much progress on finding scum - even if we wanted to now, we are in no place to make a lynch.
 
My last second vote made me look town? *scratches head*

I believe Mal to be mafia so you *as mafia* could just not vote and he'd be alive. So you get townie points for that.

To me, yes. He play yesterday made her less suspicious. The fact that Solar went after Moar a few times makes me less suspicious. The fact that Solar went after Mal, and the reasoning for me finding Moar suspicious was in large part related to Mal being mafia, makes her less suspicious. So overall, Moar is actually not at the top of my list anymore.

Mafia bus and they don't. Going after people on D1 is very vague and unless you're very outspoken, means nothing. Her play yesterday has just as much scum vibe to it. This is exactly what I was afraid of. Her complete scummyness of the first few days is being laughed off and she's getting a free card. GG
 
Ensuring a lynch didn't help? :dontknow: You'd have rather a no-lynch eh? Interesting.


Funny. What are you doing right now? Why are you so eager to pass me.

If we got an answer on Mal's alignment, it would be much better. Doesn't hurt, but doesn't help in my eyes.

And as for the second part of your post, really? I will just let you stew on that one. I can see why scum without a certain role is playing confused.
 
Mafia bus and they don't. Going after people on D1 is very vague and unless you're very outspoken, means nothing. Her play yesterday has just as much scum vibe to it. This is exactly what I was afraid of. Her complete scummyness of the first few days is being laughed off and she's getting a free card. GG
Valid views, but as you've asked me, I'll turn the tables around. You think moar is the most scummiest alive? Just curious.
 
If we got an answer on Mal's alignment, it would be much better. Doesn't hurt, but doesn't help in my eyes.
Lets analyze your post then,

Just seems scummy today. Not quite paying attention to most things, paying close attention to some things, etc.
Not paying attention to most things. What are the 'most things' and the 'somethings'?

I looked over some points, haven't we all?
Caught Moar's misvote doesn't help.
Ok, neutral point there, you're words.

He has close to double the amount of posts of everyone
Leading in posts makes me scummy. Hmm.

And as for the second part of your post, really? I will just let you stew on that one. I can see why scum without a certain role is playing confused.
Oh, don't both answering, it was rhetorical ;)
 
Agreed, CG if mafia, wouldn't need to make up this plan.

Disagree, it is an awesome plan if he is mafia. Why not? He can hand the card out and cause a mislynch in one play. Does this plan make him mafia? Of course not, I just want you to realize both sides of it.
 
Leading in posts makes me scummy. Hmm.

You weren't just leading when I made that post, you were Olympic USA basketball vs Nigeria. And yes, the mafia would see great value to making sure that the person with the unspoken of role was allowed to fulfill its prophecy. If there are 3 mafia left, that one person is 20% of their NK choices.
 
Disagree, it is an awesome plan if he is mafia. Why not? He can hand the card out and cause a mislynch in one play. Does this plan make him mafia? Of course not, I just want you to realize both sides of it.

Oh but I do. And I see it the same way others see it. CG doesn't tell us the plan, gives it to mafia. Tonight, they kill. Day skipped, next night they kill. In the next Day, it's a 3v3 or 4v2. We would still be no better position to find mafia.

Clearly telling us this plan doesn't confirm he's town. Only death will show that, or "the stars" card.
 
Back
Top