flubbucket1
New member
So Pyro why not choose kingmaker? Seems like a powerful role to mime, though your logic seemed reasonable enough.
Create Your Own Role Mafia game
- Thread starter Goryani
- Start date
It's not a targeted ability, the role post says "In short: you are given a list of players who were targeted by someone, anyone, that night. You're not told who did the targeting nor what roles targeted each victim."
I got nothing. As the more observing ones of you might have noticed, Moar joined me on my vote for today, so you now know my role for today as well. I have nothing to hide, and want to see Sathoris dead by the end of the day now that he isn't protected by the spammer role. Thank you for your (in)voluntary vote, Moar.
As for if you choose not to lynch me, which is the right bet, who would you like for me to block the coming night?
flubbucket1
New member
That seems fair enough. I guess I would have figured that out had I read the role with my brain in gear....derp
And as stated you were blocked, awesome :unimpressed:
And as stated you were blocked, awesome :unimpressed:
Notes on the Sun -
Roles will Randomize after day phase.
Today counts for Dr. Franky's cooldown.
100% this.
Bus driver claim also would be good to hear at this point.
only 2 possibilites here:
1) You lie and are Jack Black, you die tonight, end of problem.
2) Ankeli was hitman, Moar had a great block
3) Mafia decided to go with a no kill
We know if SI is lnot teling the truth if he dies today.
I would love to see this role in a future game. The forced voting mechanic would be a really fun role as a mafia power role, and a great dilemma as town. I would not shed any tears for its removal here though.
I agree Moars last vote was suspicious, but I don't get What ML being last vote and kingmaker has to do with anything
...I think you have a misunderstanding. Dr. Frank would have removed your role from the game, and put last laugh back in the random pool for todays draws. It has no effect on you specifically.
Yourself? Dangit, I thought I got rid of this role. Current options are no NK and you were blocked trying to NK. One of these seems way more likely. Getting rid of the politician for real is just an added bonus.
Vote: Ankeli
Roles will Randomize after day phase.
Today counts for Dr. Franky's cooldown.
100% this.
Bus driver claim also would be good to hear at this point.
only 2 possibilites here:
1) You lie and are Jack Black, you die tonight, end of problem.
2) Ankeli was hitman, Moar had a great block
3) Mafia decided to go with a no kill
We know if SI is lnot teling the truth if he dies today.
Oh man, Gwaihir! How could you! The Politician was my proud creation!(with help from Goryani, of course.)
I would love to see this role in a future game. The forced voting mechanic would be a really fun role as a mafia power role, and a great dilemma as town. I would not shed any tears for its removal here though.
I agree Moars last vote was suspicious, but I don't get What ML being last vote and kingmaker has to do with anything
...I think you have a misunderstanding. Dr. Frank would have removed your role from the game, and put last laugh back in the random pool for todays draws. It has no effect on you specifically.
It's not a targeted ability, the role post says "In short: you are given a list of players who were targeted by someone, anyone, that night. You're not told who did the targeting nor what roles targeted each victim."
I got nothing. As the more observing ones of you might have noticed, Moar joined me on my vote for today, so you now know my role for today as well. I have nothing to hide, and want to see Sathoris dead by the end of the day now that he isn't protected by the spammer role. Thank you for your (in)voluntary vote, Moar.
As for if you choose not to lynch me, which is the right bet, who would you like for me to block the coming night?
Yourself? Dangit, I thought I got rid of this role. Current options are no NK and you were blocked trying to NK. One of these seems way more likely. Getting rid of the politician for real is just an added bonus.
Vote: Ankeli
MartinLong
New member
(I awake from my alcohol induced coma)
I'm puzzled as well flubb. Where is the connection?
Moar mis-voted
I came in after work, saw we had 6 (post count was two posts above mine), needed 7 (Moar would have been 7 if it counted) for the lynch. Voted Mal.
Me, I was kingmaker, and I picked Sath, as I believed he was town, but... I see his has a couple votes on him now, so maybe I misread D1?
Mal being last laugh ... How is this related?
Caluin Graye
New member
"One... two... five!"
"Three, sir! Three!"
I can't see mafia going with a no kill. There'd be no point to it this early in the game.
Therefore, the logical conclusion is to lynch Ankeli. If Solar is lying for some reason, then that situation will resolve itself.
I feel that Moar is scummy, but if Ankeli flips scum then that'll go a long ways to clearing her name.
Kingmaker would be one of the worst roles to mimic. That would effectively double the chance of giving the King to a scum player at no benefit to the town. Why would you suggest that?
I got nothing. As the more observing ones of you might have noticed, Moar joined me on my vote for today, so you now know my role for today as well. I have nothing to hide, and want to see Sathoris dead by the end of the day now that he isn't protected by the spammer role. Thank you for your (in)voluntary vote, Moar.
As for if you choose not to lynch me, which is the right bet, who would you like for me to block the coming night?
Seeing as how it's come out that Sathoris is the king today, and he can simply redirect the lynch off of himself should it come to that, how do you feel about wasting Moar's vote? Keeping in mind the reasons given yesterday when Moar asked why it was bad to have forced kestegs to waste his vote in a similar manner.
You may have believed Sath to be town, but was he the most townie person? Out of everyone playing the game, is Sathoris currently the most townie looking player in your eyes? If not, why did you choose Sathoris over that particular person(s)?
Caluin Graye
New member
Soooo.... to repeat the question:
With Sathoris being king and having the ability to redirect the lynch off of himself to anyone he wants, you're going to simply throw your vote away instead of trying to identify any other scum players?
flubbucket1
New member
Caluin Graye, Why are you answering a question posed to Pyro??
MartinLong
New member
Yes. I chose the most town person in my eyes as to give it the best chance of going to town.
So far, from D1, I looked at play styles. How did they sync up with their past town and/or mafia play styles.
There are groups who look town no matter what, groups who look scummy all the time, people I have no read on yet, and then based off past playing, who seems to be acting on their mafia or town playstyle.
Of the 11 choices, yes he seemed to been most fitting.
flubbucket1
New member
My thoughts regarding the kingmaker ML Moar hoot nanny, though possibly convoluted, are the collusion of players attempting to make sure a role stays or goes someplace planned.
Caluin Graye
New member
Because, to me, it sounded like you were subtly hinting that today's mime should copy the kingmaker role, and I wanted to point out that it is a bad thing to do that.
flubbucket1
New member
I appreciate your explaining game mechanics to me, (honestly) but the question was directed to Pyro for a reason.
I don't fully understand the kingmaker role, but I wanted his take on his decision making.
I don't fully understand the kingmaker role, but I wanted his take on his decision making.
Kestegs
Active member
It's not a targeted ability, the role post says "In short: you are given a list of players who were targeted by someone, anyone, that night. You're not told who did the targeting nor what roles targeted each victim."
I got nothing. As the more observing ones of you might have noticed, Moar joined me on my vote for today, so you now know my role for today as well. I have nothing to hide, and want to see Sathoris dead by the end of the day now that he isn't protected by the spammer role. Thank you for your (in)voluntary vote, Moar.
As for if you choose not to lynch me, which is the right bet, who would you like for me to block the coming night?
So you are claiming politician today, and that you forced moar to vote for sath?
But that role was removed.
So either you didn't get roleblocked, and said you did, or Frankenstein got roleblocked and didn't actually revive the last laugh role.
Either way you're lying about something.
vote: Ankeli
Win, and lol at my typing abilities.
Everything else I agree with completely
Roleblock is possible, but there is a way more likely explanation. Maybe BA can help with that?
Kestegs
Active member
I don't see how the bus driver would cover both of those scenarios. Either way BA needs to disclose his targets asap.
Kestegs
Active member
Further thought says there may be a way I didn't think about actually. So I could be wrong.
flubbucket1
New member
Something else to consider is the possibility of two "reflectors" in play as well as the busdriver.
How on earth do you consider the role removed kestegs?
Ladies and gentlemen, your mafia: Sathoris, kestegs, Solar Ice and a 4th I can't quite figure out yet.
And yes, I'll be wasting my vote on Sathoris. The fact that he was the kings wasn't available when I made Moar vote for him, or sent the PM. Gogo lynch me fast then, I'll enjoy watching a town this blind to the obvious fall apart in two or three days.
Ladies and gentlemen, your mafia: Sathoris, kestegs, Solar Ice and a 4th I can't quite figure out yet.
And yes, I'll be wasting my vote on Sathoris. The fact that he was the kings wasn't available when I made Moar vote for him, or sent the PM. Gogo lynch me fast then, I'll enjoy watching a town this blind to the obvious fall apart in two or three days.
flubbucket1
New member
kestegs, Sathoris I'm following, not necessarily agreeing, but following. But why Solar Ice??
