Create Your Own Role Mafia game

Oh man, Gwaihir! How could you! The Politician was my proud creation! :P (with help from Goryani, of course.)

It's power is best utliized by scum. It is really good for them, though. (we almost saw its use to perfection last night and yesterday) Good thing there are the same number of roles as players right now.

Ankeli is down to Paris Hilton or Cootie Detector, assuming Sath wasn't bsing us about being the spammer. Only the Cootie detector could be blocked if I have it correct outside of bus driving.


Moar: you are starting to sound a lot like you did last game. Your theories state that Sath and Kestegs are mafia or not. It does not include the "and/or" which can appear to the observor that you know which answer is correct. And your use of the bribe took Kestegs' play completely out of the day. It was a voting restriction, where he now couldn't make is own decision on top of it being a wasted vote based on one persons own thinking, which the town cannot depend on being just. Since he didn't have to make his own decision, you gave him a free pass to check out for the rest of the day, stifling any discussion he could have added, whether it be good or bad for himself and helpful/not-helpful to the town. Hence well done to Gwahir for removing it from the role list, in addition to the flat out role block which is a tough one to use for the town, especially in this game.
 
Okay I made it to work, just finished my coffee and one read through of the thread. I need to do a small bit o' work and I'll be back with some questions and comments.
 
Okay here is my problem with Moar's vote. I only have a few minutes so I'm only dealing with this one item now while I can think straight about it.

Moar had a vote for Malevolent at post #252. It wasn't right (because of previous kestegs vote) and included an odd comment about "Can't do it right anyway." MartinLong then votes (the last vote) for Malevolent at post #253.

MartinLong was kingmaker yesterday.

Malevolent was Last Laugh yesterday.

It seems too convenient.
 
Caluin Graye, your timeline post #243 seemed very well thought out. How do you feel about it now?

And Pyro, your choice of the reflector also seems practically perfect in every way.

Why not choose kingmaker??
 
Vote Count:
Ankeli (2) - Moar, Solar Ice
Sathoris (1) - Ankeli

Vote count updated through post #307.

There are 12 players alive. It takes 6 votes to lynch and 7 votes to lock.
 
As I said last night, I don't have time for commenting today because of guests. And somebody is lying by quite a lot.
 
I'm reading through and from your posts Moar, I'm gonna guess you think Solar Ice might be lying?? Is there and OMGU lied sentiment attached to this? Why not vote for him if you think so?
 
I am reeeeeally bored and have had toooo much coffee. So sad no one is awake to make conversation with me.

I'm also curious about thefranklin's results. However, those really won't do much good, 1) if he's a bad guy 2) unless we can compare them to another set of results

Any comments?

Most likely not....

Okay I'm outta here.....for a bit
 
Lots of posts, I will put out my claim before I get to them.

I was Dr. Frank yesterday, I asked several questions about the role and got these answers:

Removing Last laugh from Mal while he is dead causes him to be out of the game
Removing Last laugh from Mal while he is dead will not cause his alignment to be revealed
The role from the live character is "stored" in Mal, and can be switched back in if Mal is targeted at a later date
It is possible to bring back the reflector with this power (reflector does not trigger when dead)

I targeted Moar and Mal. Assuming Moar was not driven, we should have the politician out of the game.


In other news, I received the Sun last night, and see no reason why I should not use it today. I will wait about 24 hours in case people feel otherwise, but at that point I will submit the order to remove the night phase.

Unvote: Ankeli
Vote: Sathoris

I'm reading through and from your posts Moar, I'm gonna guess you think Solar Ice might be lying?? Is there and OMGU lied sentiment attached to this? Why not vote for him if you think so?

No, not Solar Ice. I can't have been targeted last night if we understand the Frankenstein role correct.
 
Hmmm....I might have been targeted by the bus driver as well. That would be an explanation also. Now I've got to go and finish cooking. Guests arriving in an hour.
 
Well that's interesting. I don't get a scum vibe from Solar Ice. However, I'm curious how you can be so sure your previous role can still be in the game. I'm sincerely not picking on you so please don't take it in a mean spirit. They are many ways things can't possibly add up, and I also have more questions than answers. Actually I'm not sure I have any answers...


I hope dinner and hostessing go well.
 
Sorry if it seems I'm going back to far, catching up on the previous day phase things...

Remember that there is a chance that the role could get resurrected with the tarot cards. I'm surprised that the last few pages (minus Mals spam) have solely revolved around catching the one with the spammer role.

@All - Mal. Can we just smack him up and claim it was in self-defense? That's pretty American ain't it?

America, where we invade your country and slap people, because we can. But seriously, no offense to Mal, it was just the last time I was going to be able to look at the thread after my posts and it was a bunch of nothing so I was a bit frustrated.

This was directly after her first quote I quoted earlier, and highlighted a bit about the part where she was calling out Mal for not following rules. To me it came across as scum trying to get a modkill on town. If you read this far. now read the bolded part. Now read the unbolded part. Since no one did that, the unbolded part can seem like mafia whining about their numbers being leaked. But I like to see things my way, so no big deal.

I also kind of see it like mafia whining about the number of them being leaked, but then again I would be upset too if that was information that the town really shouldn't have had so I can't really hold that as a stance.

the misquote was just that Moar has very obviously made himself connected to Mal, which holds no water whatsoever unless the roles I skimmed have some kind of day talk which is entirely possible

Just because they have or did not have day talk does not mean that they are not connected. I'm pretty sure the mafia are going to play as a team regardless of whether they have spoken to eachother yet...

Is posting a naked butt against forum rules? Cause I was just looking for pics to show how lazy I felt when I should have read all the roles thoroughly, and there was a dude laying naked sunbathing and I for some reason found this hilarious.

I require this picture for statistical analysis. Post it.

A warning? Really? Also, this quote ^ was in response to me, and it's sole purpose is to make amends to me, and that is something Sathoris never does. Has never done, will never do. Not the Sathoris I've played with, and butted heads with on more than one occasion. On those occasions, that Sathoris has been pro-town, and he's lashed out on me harder than I took it to him. Not this Sathoris. This Sathoris is mafia.

Soo? because Sathoris isn't cramming his views down our throat hes mafiso? I guess you would know more than me.

And that has been my fear. Normal games don't have all the roles in the open, we don't all claim our roles and actions eveyr day. We get by on scumhunting! Take the time to get reads on people and remember their approaches. I'm not saying we should ignore the roles, just dont get over dependent on them. Which has been my whole point this first day....

I'm still ok with you giving us stories :p. We have become dependent on their being roles or stories built into the game that help us analyze certain situations. To move away from something like that in a heavily role dependent game would be difficult. It also wouldn't be very smart because any information from a role is going to help us in some way as long as we pick out the important parts and pull what we need and move on to actual scum hunting.

Mal is at lynch right as of me typing this. I could lock him to avoid anybody switching to me. I won't do that though. I explained multiple times why i did what I did. I also said that i did it the wrong way around and should have had Sathoris vote for kestegs. If you don't believe me then go ahead and lynch me.

Can't do it right anyway.

Vote: Malevolent

Just want to note this to myself that a blatent reluctance to vote for him followed by a vote about half an hour later or whenever just seems so out of place to me. I think the part that gets me the most is that if you have a certain view, stand by it, and thats definately not what happened here.
 
Back
Top