Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Gwaihir said:
omg - do you have anything useful to say today, or are you sticking to spam still? Yesterday you said you thought cdm was town. Where did that come from? Is there any reason you did not prosecute anyone else?
Click to expand...

never said he was town. just asked why we were on a CDM lynch train.

in conclusion, i'd be happy to lock cdm today if he can't defend himself.

also, wolololololololololol priest power
 
Djm: Any special reason you chose cdm over omg?

FoE: Not going to quote post 490, but fractions are killers! (sorry, lame typo joke)
 
kestegs said:
I don't see much reason to believe at least half of the people are town.
Click to expand...

Who were the players that you did not believe to be Town at the time of this post?

kestegs said:
No, you are wrong. I didn't find any of them scummy enough to vote for. I said I would only would vote for bpc, but it seemed pointless.
Click to expand...

Finding someone "not scummy enough" means that you find them scummy at least in part.

What stopped you from voting for any of the players up for prosecution if you find them scummy even in part?

Why was it pointless to vote for BPC?

kestegs said:
I did pressure him, he ignored everything I said and so I left it be and waited. As far as foe not being the same, see above.
Click to expand...

While you are busy preparing answers to questions posed to you, please point out precisely in what posts in Twilight you pressured Malevolent and where he ignored you. Why did you not follow up these posts?

In which posts did you pressure FredOfErik, regarding your "see above" reply?

kestegs said:
I fingered male as scum after his first post, it was really obvious. That post wasn't sarcastic at all, his final twilight post made it super obvious. Interesting that you didn't put that together until after last night though. And if you think I said that I thought half the people were scum you need to read that over again.
Click to expand...

This sounds like you know exactly which post you are referring to and are scrambling to save some face.

At this point you are my number 1 Scum suspect along with Ankeli, with Coju following a very close third.
 
FredOfErik said:
Dude.. We have ~30 hours left. And mal showed up almost immediately and (tried) to defend him self. Aside from locking someone this fast without giving him even a chance to defend himself being sorta rude (especially since he let us know last day phase that he is busy IRL), we are still only 2 votes away from a lock and only one away from a lynch. We have plenty of time to lynch him and I will be around to revote. I just don't see any reason at all to lock him yet.
Click to expand...

Absolutely this.

it bears repeating: Why are you urging to lock CDM now with more than half a Day phase to go, Coju?
 
coju said:
I thought the prosecute/prostate was majority rules. Didn't realize it had to be a certain number of votes like a vote 1 mechanic. OMG may be lynch proof. omg may be the batman.
Click to expand...

This is the second time you are fishing for Batman....
 
flubbucket said:
Sure. I have made slips and such, but I'm kind of a boob. I just hadn't seen it in that light. I'm still trying to keep an open mind regarding the "one or two mafia groups" chatter. Got so many lines drawn I'm getting vertigo.
Click to expand...

What "slips" are you referring to?
 
I've never played with omg before, and I thought that cdm was really suspicious because of the prosecute and lack of posting.
 
FredOfErik said:
Unvote: crawlingdeadman

Didn't realize he was that close to a lock. No point in locking him just yet, I would like to at least give him a chance to defend himself. That being said, if he actually has a defense, he needs to show up sooner rather than later.
Click to expand...

Yea...you're scum. I agree that he doesn't need to be locked early, it's the way you said it.

thefranklin said:
Djm: Any special reason you chose cdm over omg?

FoE: Not going to quote post 490, but fractions are killers! (sorry, lame typo joke)
Click to expand...

You ignored my question. I'm waiting.

Solar Ice said:
Who were the players that you did not believe to be Town at the time of this post?



Finding someone "not scummy enough" means that you find them scummy at least in part.

What stopped you from voting for any of the players up for prosecution if you find them scummy even in part?

Why was it pointless to vote for BPC?



While you are busy preparing answers to questions posed to you, please point out precisely in what posts in Twilight you pressured Malevolent and where he ignored you. Why did you not follow up these posts?

In which posts did you pressure FredOfErik, regarding your "see above" reply?



This sounds like you know exactly which post you are referring to and are scrambling to save some face.

At this point you are my number 1 Scum suspect along with Ankeli, with Coju following a very close third.
Click to expand...

I'm answered those questions enough times, pay attention. The reason I didn't vote is because I didn't feel strongly enough. The reason I didn't vote for bpc is because by the time I decided I would vote for him it was late and he wasn't going to get lynched anyways.

I'll get the post later, I'm barely keeping up with the thread as it is. I thought it was his first post, but obviously I realize it wasn't. I don't know exactly what the post said, I just remember exactly how much it made me think he was scum.

Now I'm not sure if you're actually scum or not, and if you are which one of the people on your scum list is your partner. I'm guessing ankeli.
 
kestegs said:
Yea...you're scum. I agree that he doesn't need to be locked early, it's the way you said it.
Click to expand...

Yea.. So this is the second time I get the "not what you said, the way you said it"-scum argument thrown at me, and I have no clue what part of the post that's supposedly scummy looking. I can't really disprove the argument as the argument is basically non-existing. All I can do is redirect you to my next post where I answer cojus "don't unvote, only 6 hours left" post and explain my reasoning for it further.
 
Lol @ the "I don't see the case" guy calling someone scum on the basis of delivery.

And kegs you are barely paying attention yet know when I didn't answer a question from 15 hours ago? Antagonize and see reactions is the answer.
 
So sayingomg may be the Batman is fishing?
Well,, i guess from another perspective it could be considered that.
 
Gwaihir said:
Missed a quote here - Jason, I am curious why you think djb is likely to be scum? If there is one team, why would he bus 2 of his own? If there are 2 how could he know who the others are?



The prosecute was actually still very helpful - it gave us a voting record. If we get flips on those people, it tells us something about the people who voted them.

Specifically, if omg or BA are lynched




Back to rolefishing a again it seems. What is your point in adding either of those on?

This has been a different game - this is twice we have almost had a lock before I actually catch up on the thread.

omg - do you have anything useful to say today, or are you sticking to spam still? Yesterday you said you thought cdm was town. Where did that come from? Is there any reason you did not prosecute anyone else?
Click to expand...

I added those last lines bc Batman may be lynch proof / xshot: that being the reason omg didn't get lynched.
That being my line if thinking
 
coju said:
I added those last lines bc Batman may be lynch proof / xshot: that being the reason omg didn't get lynched.
That being my line if thinking
Click to expand...

What are your reasons for believing that normal lynch mechanics didn't apply to prosecute votes?
 
coju said:
I added those last lines bc Batman may be lynch proof / xshot: that being the reason omg didn't get lynched.
That being my line if thinking
Click to expand...

To make sure I understand what you are saying:

1) you thought that the lynch was by majority
2) you thought that omg should have been lynched based off of the numbers
3) you thought the reason he was not lynched was that he was Batman, and lynch immune.

Is that what you were trying to say?

If so - why did you immediately jump to a pro-town role for him avoiding lynch? Why not an anti-town?
 
FredOfErik said:
Yea.. So this is the second time I get the "not what you said, the way you said it"-scum argument thrown at me, and I have no clue what part of the post that's supposedly scummy looking. I can't really disprove the argument as the argument is basically non-existing. All I can do is redirect you to my next post where I answer cojus "don't unvote, only 6 hours left" post and explain my reasoning for it further.
Click to expand...

Scum rarely come out and tell you that they're scum. It's almost always the way you say things that dictates how people perceive you.

Read your post assuming you're town and then again assuming you're scum. You are coaching cdm and asking him to give you a good reason not to lynch him.

thefranklin said:
Lol @ the "I don't see the case" guy calling someone scum on the basis of delivery.

And kegs you are barely paying attention yet know when I didn't answer a question from 15 hours ago? Antagonize and see reactions is the answer.
Click to expand...

When did I ever say I was barely paying attention?

coju said:
I added those last lines bc Batman may be lynch proof / xshot: that being the reason omg didn't get lynched.
That being my line if thinking
Click to expand...

Yes, that's not the way the lynch even worked.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top