Zombies invade Atlantis. Stargate zombie Mafia game.

Yes, that all assumes BA is telling the truth. However, if we lynch you, and we see you're *not* a zombie, we instantly know he's lying to us. You are the proof we'd need to know the truth about BA's role. If you are a zombie, we still don't know his affiliation, but we do know he's probably not lying about his role.
 
It's amusing that Bad Ash is the one who gives us evidence that Jcakes lied yesterday but Jcakes is voting me. I guess that's his only move. Moar has said she believes Bad Ash, so Jcakes can't go after the source that outed him, and since I'm the only other person someone might vote for, his attack predictably comes to me.

I believe Bad Ash that CGB was a zombie, which means you lied to us yesterday Jcakes. That makes you a zombie, and it's really quite as simple as that. Bad Ash put his life on the line to out you because if you flip as a pro-town zombie detector then that puts Bad Ash on the hot seat. With only one mislynch this game, I highly doubt scum are looking to trade 1 for 1 at this point, so yes I believe Bad Ash.
 
Yes, that all assumes BA is telling the truth. However, if we lynch you, and we see you're *not* a zombie, we instantly know he's lying to us. You are the proof we'd need to know the truth about BA's role. If you are a zombie, we still don't know his affiliation, but we do know he's probably not lying about his role.

If BA is right about Jcakes it doesn't necessarily clear him of lying. While it shows that his role works, there would still be question about allegiance.
 
I can come up with justification for shooting everyone except for korial.

1. Laarz-scum working with BA, not actually dr.
2. Bad Ash-mafia role cop using town to flush out the competing faction
3. flubbucket-potential zombie now
4. AnnualAntAnswers-potential zombie now
5. Jcakes-gonna lynch anyways most likely, but likely zombie
6. Moar-godfather who made an early role claim designed to keep themselves from being lynched.
7. Drixx-godfather or zombie now
8. korialstraz-android ability that was used to protect the cop makes him seem about as town as is possible.
9. IWantToUseNumbersInMyName-claimed vig, still alive for some reason after so long, scum with BA

So yeah...there are multiple different scenarios encapsulated in that list that can't all be true, but there is definitely cause for shooting almost anyone.
You are indeed a blood thirsty rascal aren't you??

I will admit CoolGuyBad was not the night kill I expected. Between a claimed doctor (Laarz), claimed role cop(Bad Ash), claimed vigilante(IWanttohavetheLongestNameintheGame) I can see much better targets.

I'm not a zombie.
 
Interesting, unfortunately it is your word against mine and we have no proof either way. Other than the fact that CGB died last night and you apparently investigated him.

Like all investigators that out somebody, the play is to kill the person who is outed as scum. If they flip scum (or zombie, in your case) that reinforces that the investigator is telling the truth. If the outed person flips town, then the next person to go is the claimed investigator. If Bad Ash is lying, we'll know it at the end of the day and he goes tomorrow.

First point: Not surprised given how much you want to trust BA like I demonstrated yesterday

Second point: I didn't realise you wanted me to investigate you.

When testing an investigator you lynch the person they out as scum.

Also, how could you not realize I put myself out to be tested when I said "I'll submit to the Jcakes test" in a post quoting you?

Third Point: TIME ZONE - My last post was at 10PM, the next post was at 1AM (I went to bed just before then), I got up at 7am (day ends at 7:30 am for me) checked to see if we had a lock and/or if a train hand changed 0 time for any comments, but nice trying to make me look scummy cos of my time zone .....

I didn't say anything about your time zone.

Again this all assumes that BA is telling the truth.

If he's not, we kill him tomorrow. With 4 dead anti-town (counting CGB) and a dead neutral, you really think BA is looking to trade his life for yours?

Can you please explain are so called gutsy play? The way I see what you are thinking is our gutsy play is the following

1. DJ claims zombie giving up
2. CGB and I claim zombie medic and zombie investiagor

that's a plan........ If I was a zombie and was on the same team, the better play would be for me to claim to investigate DJ reveal him as Zombie and gain town points. What you are stating that a zombie team did made absolutely no sense.

I don't know why your team played it the way you did, but what I do know is that DJ was a zombie, CoolGuyBad claimed to be able to cure zombies but in fact was a zombie, and you claimed to have investigated him and said he wasn't a zombie. Talking about what would have been "the better play" is sheer WIFOM. At the end of the day CGB was lying and you vouched for him, which puts the crosshairs squarely on you.

The most amusing part of your defense is that you're attacking the wrong person. I believe Bad Ash when he reports CGB was a zombie because I don't see any reason he would trade himself for you. Since you claim your mechanic works by people quoting you, any zombie can simply avoid quoting you so you present absolutely zero danger to anti-town if you're telling the truth. If Bad Ash were scum and was going to get us to kill someone with fake info, why would he pick you? It makes no sense.

Your response just cements your guilt. Instead of questioning the person who outed you, you chose to come after me because you know if you make it a choice between Bad Ash and you, you're going to hang.
 
Which is not to say that I would be opposed to lynching Jcakes since I find all the zombie claims fishy and it seems likely that CGB lied about his claim. But let's make sure to distinguish definite facts from suspicions.
 
Drixx keeps on claiming some kind of conspiracy theory between me, DJ and CGB.

Here is the way I see it:
1. DJ gave up, not sure why
2. CGB and I claimed zombie related roles
3. I investigated CGB, because I was not sure about his claim
4. I get a not-zombie result
5. CGB ends up dead overnight
6. BA conveniently claims to have investigated CGB and he came up zombie

So far BA has provided no proof that he is who he says he is, yet people seem to take him at his word. Drixx keeps on pushing his idea of a Zombie team pulling a play yesterday, one that makes no sense. I feel that I am being massively set-up here.
Vote: Drixx

I asked before and I'll ask again.

Why wouldn't I just say I investigated you and that you came back zombie? Would be so much cleaner and I'd love to have been able to do it
 
You are indeed a blood thirsty rascal aren't you??

I will admit CoolGuyBad was not the night kill I expected. Between a claimed doctor (Laarz), claimed role cop(Bad Ash), claimed vigilante(IWanttohavetheLongestNameintheGame) I can see much better targets.

I'm not a zombie.

Paranoid, not bloodthirsty. :) But yes, absolutely better targets out there. Although I guess the obvious targets would only give them, at best, a 67% chance of killing someone. If they go outside that set of possible targets, they're pretty likely to hit. It's either a desperate move, or a very confident one. Either they're so close to winning they can afford to let doctors, role cops, and vigilantes run around in exchange for certain kills, or they're so close to losing they can't afford to fail.
 
Interesting, unfortunately it is your word against mine and we have no proof either way. Other than the fact that CGB died last night and you apparently investigated him.



First point: Not surprised given how much you want to trust BA like I demonstrated yesterday

Second point: I didn't realise you wanted me to investigate you. And your plan makes 0 sense.

Third Point: TIME ZONE - My last post was at 10PM, the next post was at 1AM (I went to bed just before then), I got up at 7am (day ends at 7:30 am for me) checked to see if we had a lock and/or if a train hand changed 0 time for any comments, but nice trying to make me look scummy cos of my time zone .....



Again this all assumes that BA is telling the truth.



Can you please explain are so called gutsy play? The way I see what you are thinking is our gutsy play is the following

1. DJ claims zombie giving up
2. CGB and I claim zombie medic and zombie investiagor

that's a plan........ If I was a zombie and was on the same team, the better play would be for me to claim to investigate DJ reveal him as Zombie and gain town points. What you are stating that a zombie team did made absolutely no sense.

So the zombies are able to recruit town power roles then?

Drixx keeps on claiming some kind of conspiracy theory between me, DJ and CGB.

Here is the way I see it:
1. DJ gave up, not sure why
2. CGB and I claimed zombie related roles
3. I investigated CGB, because I was not sure about his claim
4. I get a not-zombie result
5. CGB ends up dead overnight
6. BA conveniently claims to have investigated CGB and he came up zombie

So far BA has provided no proof that he is who he says he is, yet people seem to take him at his word. Drixx keeps on pushing his idea of a Zombie team pulling a play yesterday, one that makes no sense. I feel that I am being massively set-up here.
Vote: Drixx

Soooo I have no proof to say I am who I say I am, except the fact that I learned that someone you used your role to claim CBG as clearly "non zombie" was actually a zombie. Thats a helluva lot more proof than anything you've done because the only evidence of your role in action out there was wrong.
 
I asked before and I'll ask again.

Why wouldn't I just say I investigated you and that you came back zombie? Would be so much cleaner and I'd love to have been able to do it

quite simple, because when I flip as exactly what I claim to be you can point to the remote possibility that CGB was recruited overnight. Whereas if you come straight out and claim that I am a Zombie and I flip as what I say I am, then you are obviously lying.
 
BA, there's really no proof for you. :P I tend to view with skepticism investigations that occurred on people who are conveniently now dead and thus cannot respond. Luckily for us though, if we kill Jcakes we'll know right away if we can trust that particular result...as i was saying before though, that still doesn't mean you're town. :) I'm leaning town for you, but mafia role cop saving his side time by having the town lynch zombies seems pretty reasonable as well.
 
Vote: Drixx

Hey Cakes,

So you think Drixx is a zombie? Or are you just forgetting that you made up a role that supposed to be beneficial to the town by catching zombies by having someone you vote post your quote.

Dont care about that anymore?
 
BA, there's really no proof for you. :P I tend to view with skepticism investigations that occurred on people who are conveniently now dead and thus cannot respond. Luckily for us though, if we kill Jcakes we'll know right away if we can trust that particular result...as i was saying before though, that still doesn't mean you're town. :) I'm leaning town for you, but mafia role cop saving his side time by having the town lynch zombies seems pretty reasonable as well.

Yes, the point of my post was NO DUH. There's no proof for any of us. The person with the most proof is korial because BPC was a robot. That doesn't mean that korial is town either (not saying korial is scum).

I have my proof. I have my results and I have my alignment and role. Cakes saying you have no proof is stupid. He has no proof either, stop trying to discredit me with obvious statements.
 
quite simple, because when I flip as exactly what I claim to be you can point to the remote possibility that CGB was recruited overnight. Whereas if you come straight out and claim that I am a Zombie and I flip as what I say I am, then you are obviously lying.

I'll take credit for your lynch 100%. If you are town I will be shocked and won't push it off as "oh hey I had a read on CBG so *shrug* my bad!" I'll say "Jcakes cleared CBG as non-zombie with the use of his role, and CBG was a zombie. So clearly the zombies can recruit town power roles and oh, btw the way thanks for hosting TC cause the game is over now because the zombies can recruit town power roles"
 
When testing an investigator you lynch the person they out as scum.

Also, how could you not realize I put myself out to be tested when I said "I'll submit to the Jcakes test" in a post quoting you?

I misread it, like I said I tend not to read everything you say as I usually get bored halfway through the WoT.

I didn't say anything about your time zone.

You asked why I stopped posting, The answer was time zone.


If he's not, we kill him tomorrow. With 4 dead anti-town (counting CGB) and a dead neutral, you really think BA is looking to trade his life for yours?
4 dead anti-town, but only one mafia dead. Probably worth it for them.

The most amusing part of your defense is that you're attacking the wrong person. I believe Bad Ash when he reports CGB was a zombie because I don't see any reason he would trade himself for you. Since you claim your mechanic works by people quoting you, any zombie can simply avoid quoting you so you present absolutely zero danger to anti-town if you're telling the truth. If Bad Ash were scum and was going to get us to kill someone with fake info, why would he pick you? It makes no sense.

Your response just cements your guilt. Instead of questioning the person who outed you, you chose to come after me because you know if you make it a choice between Bad Ash and you, you're going to hang.

I still think BA is scum, I also think you are scum and on the same team. You two are definitely linked despite BA trying to distance. I know that Moar is more likely to want to kill you than BA this way I am more likely to get scum killed than have myself a townie killed.

Why would he pick me? Because I am an easy target, enough people doubt me already that all he needs to do is fabricate a small amount of info and I am gone.
 
Hey Cakes,

So you think Drixx is a zombie? Or are you just forgetting that you made up a role that supposed to be beneficial to the town by catching zombies by having someone you vote post your quote.

Dont care about that anymore?

I am not 100% sure that we have any zombies left, I think Drixx is scum and a good lynch target so I went that way. Relatively easy for anyone to dodge me now anyway. You'll note that Drixx dodged it, quoted every post of mine except that one.
 
quite simple, because when I flip as exactly what I claim to be you can point to the remote possibility that CGB was recruited overnight. Whereas if you come straight out and claim that I am a Zombie and I flip as what I say I am, then you are obviously lying.

Why did you delete the part of the quote where I ask you if you think zombies can recruit town power roles? Why would you throw a vote on Drixx without even discussing with the town who we want cleared as a zombie? If you have a role that CLEARS ZOMBIES why would you throw a vote regardless of who everyone thinks you should use it on?
 
Back
Top