Forum Mafia - The Dark Tower Game Thread

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

@NUMBERS: Why you claim? And isn't he from Hearts in Atlantis?

If there are indeed roles from other books, then we need to look out for characters like IT.

He's in hearts in atlantis, and the song of Susannah I believe. I claimed so everyone would know your alignment cop on gwahir could be trusted.

 

[pharphis]

He's in hearts in atlantis, and the song of Susannah I believe. I claimed so everyone would know your alignment cop on gwahir could be trusted.

Fortunately I think anyone in the mason group can be trusted. Still, good to know as we've had little to know read on you.

The person you gave a gift to previously would not like one this night, but it would be awesome if you could give something to one of us again

 

[flubbucket1]

I find everything offensive. Mostly my own posts! Perhaps it is because I'm old or perhaps it's because I'm a jerk....meh whatever. Jerk!!

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

Of course what hes saying could be trusted, but if we accept flub as town, then we have contradictory claims. Just wanted to clear up any uncertainty from it since right now were deciding if we should trust gwahir or not.

 

[TheMouseT]

I'm making a longer post; I wanted to react to things and attempt to say more.

Another interesting/surprising thing: Sath was part of The White. I definitely did not think that, he seemed pretty scummy to me this game.

I thought Sath was part of the red too. I guess posts can be deceiving.

I want others to vote. I will vote again later if needed for lock ofc, but I'm trying to consider vote mechanics again. I would like one of the newer players to lock him and I'd like it to happen within 24 hours if we can pull it off.

BTW the gory locking thing is why he requires another lynch. As a member of the katet I locked and blah blah we have to deal with him again.

gory, want to vote for someone for WIFOM's sake? cmonnnn

I know its been over 24 hours, but what would be the purpose of having one of the newer players lock?

I may gain a NK immunity or an additional lynch immunity. My choice.



Well, I was really hoping to save this for Mordred if I could figure out who it was, but because I like the town, I will use it now.

Kill: Bad Ash

I would recommend voting for another person.

Vote: Goryani

Also, I don't understand phar. Because you locked gory, he did not die?

I think I'm willing to trust this. If BA doesn't die, then we will have an alligator from peter pan for a bit longer, tic tock.

BTW, Numbers, I'd much rather mouse take your place for any locking actions that we may plan out. I think you're very likely to be town.

Mouse, do you think we should lynch BA, Gory or someone else and why do you think so?

you're said VERY little this game.

I think we should lynch Gory or talk about other players possibly being mafia. I'm very curious about Laarz and his role in the game. Gory seems pretty harmless at this point, but since robots can be repaired in real life, I would imagine that somehow robots can be repaired in mafia too. I feel it would be the safe move to lynch Gory. Does your post mean you would like me to lock because you feel I may not be town? I'm confused on how to interpret that line of your post.

 

[Caluin Graye]

And Caluin Graye is Red.
<snip>
Does that just about sum it all up??

Except for the fact that I'm not actually red, that two if your investigations have been proven wrong, and my flip will reveal a third wrong investigation...?

Yeah, that's about it.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Unvote: Bad Ash
Vote: Goryani

Risk versus reward, whatever. I still think we're being played here. Something stinks to high heaven about this.

 

[pharphis]

Stink it does.

Mouse,
Yes, I'm suspicious of you and I think by now you should be able to come up with a small list of non-confirmed scum which you think are scum, and non-masons which you think are town. The reason for you locking is just because I find you more suspicious than zauper and numbers, and there are plenty more hidden mechanics that could be in play involving lynch/lock. Ofc, when I made that post I was talking about BA lynch specifically, but why not try this method on the gory lynch as well?

Is he locked, yet? Who was the first/last voter so far?

also it's been much less than 24 hours, not over 24.

 

[Kestegs]

Except for the fact that I'm not actually red, that two if your investigations have been proven wrong, and my flip will reveal a third wrong investigation...?

Yeah, that's about it.

What two were proven?

 

[Caluin Graye]

What two were proven?

His first two. He got an Unfound result on BA, who flipped red. He then got a Red result on Gwaihir, who claims Unfound and also investigated as such by another investigative role.

 

[BipolarChemist]

@Zauper: You're quiet, what's with that?

 

[flubbucket1]

Three red results in a row, and one of which I know to be false. I think your investigations are flawed.

I believe this statement. At the time of this post we all knew Bad Ash was of The Red. So yes one of my results was flawed.

Well, then you're either lying or your results are wrong. I'm of the White. Arra, a VT.

I do not believe this statement. Not one bit.

Unvote: Bad Ash
Vote: Goryani

Risk versus reward, whatever. I still think we're being played here. Something stinks to high heaven about this.

If we weren't totally focused on ridding the town of Bad Ash and Goryani I would make sure you were lynched. After this business is taken care of I will make you my #1 focus. My vote will be on you period. My PM stated irrefutable which is quite sound evidence is it not? Get your house in order because here comes the reaper!!!

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

My thoughts so far.


1: flubbucket-claims detective, results don't match flips.
2: pharphis-Claimed Roland Deschain, White, mason
5: Kestegs-flipped Jake Chambers, White, resurrected, mason
6: Moar-Over it. VT
7: BiPolarChemist-Claimed and confirmed Mason
8: Laarz-Claim Jailkeeper, could be the mysterious silencer, silencing could be a (very logical, imo)side effect of the jail keeping. Wasn't mentioned by Laarz though, so unlikely.
11: Bad Ash-Flipped Jack Andolini, Red
12: Noammr-quiet, no read, hasn't even voted except for the obvious gory lynch on D3
13: djmbbandie-also quiet,
14: Goryani-flipped Andy, red, 1/2 lynched
15: Caluin Graye-flub reported as red, might be wrong.
16: Phillinnicus-vocal, flub reported as white, which might be wrong.
17: Jcakes-claimed oy, white, mason,
18: Coju-quiet, voted for someone who didn't get lynched every day except the obv gory lynch.
19: IWanttoUseNumbersinMyName-Claimed White, Ted Brautigan
20: TheMouseT-quiet all around
21: Zauper-Very vocal day 2, quiet since, not sure.
22: Gwaihir-Unfounded, claimed survivor, 1x lynch/nk avoidance+alleged kill




White:flubbucket, pharphis, kestegs, BPC, Jcakes, Numbers


Red: Goryani, Bad Ash,


Leaning red: Laarz


Leaning white: Moar, djmbbandie, Coju,


Neutral: Gwaihir


Unsure: Phillinicus, Noammr, TheMouseT, Zauper


Flubbucket, I guess your previous investigation results the wording was identical, just lacking the word irrefutable?

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

Caluin Graye also belongs under Red, sorry, missed him completely when I compiled that.

 

[flubbucket1]

...............<Snip>.................


Flubbucket, I guess your previous investigation results the wording was identical, just lacking the word irrefutable?

Yes. Drixx is being quite coy with his responses to my PMs. (And I'm sure he's loving every minute of it.) But the investigation results from Caluin Graye and Phillinnicus have been "irrefutable" and "no other conclusion than" respectively, whereas my results from the others were merely "conclusions."

 

[Jcakes1]

If he doesn't die then Gwaihir is scum trying to keep the strongman ability in play, but i'm finding this difficult to reconcile...

Given we are fairly certain that Gwai is a Neuter, I think it is 'safe' to assume that BA is killed tonight. Hard to know for sure, but as I said in our QT I think the reward outweighs the risk.

I agree. I still feel like there are some missing pieces in play here.
So you're thinking we should trust Gwaihir and go after Gory?

I agree.

I don't trust him though.
Gotta mistrust a neutral who claims to act purely out of townie sentiment...especially if he's telling the truth about his bonus (we'd need three lynches to actually kill him?!).

It seems to me that you are playing a lot of follow the confirmed townies..... I am not sure we've had many actual thoughts from you.

Except for the fact that I'm not actually red, that two if your investigations have been proven wrong, and my flip will reveal a third wrong investigation...?

Yeah, that's about it.

You claimed VT correct? I must say I am surprised that there are any VTs in game.

My thoughts so far.


1: flubbucket-claims detective, results don't match flips.
2: pharphis-Claimed Roland Deschain, White, mason
5: Kestegs-flipped Jake Chambers, White, resurrected, mason
6: Moar-Over it. VT
7: BiPolarChemist-Claimed and confirmed Mason
8: Laarz-Claim Jailkeeper, could be the mysterious silencer, silencing could be a (very logical, imo)side effect of the jail keeping. Wasn't mentioned by Laarz though, so unlikely.
11: Bad Ash-Flipped Jack Andolini, Red
12: Noammr-quiet, no read, hasn't even voted except for the obvious gory lynch on D3
13: djmbbandie-also quiet,
14: Goryani-flipped Andy, red, 1/2 lynched
15: Caluin Graye-flub reported as red, might be wrong.
16: Phillinnicus-vocal, flub reported as white, which might be wrong.
17: Jcakes-claimed oy, white, mason,
18: Coju-quiet, voted for someone who didn't get lynched every day except the obv gory lynch.
19: IWanttoUseNumbersinMyName-Claimed White, Ted Brautigan
20: TheMouseT-quiet all around
21: Zauper-Very vocal day 2, quiet since, not sure.
22: Gwaihir-Unfounded, claimed survivor, 1x lynch/nk avoidance+alleged kill




White:flubbucket, pharphis, kestegs, BPC, Jcakes, Numbers


Red: Goryani, Bad Ash,


Leaning red: Laarz, CaluinGraye


Leaning white: Moar, djmbbandie, Coju,


Neutral: Gwaihir


Unsure: Phillinicus, Noammr, TheMouseT, Zauper


Flubbucket, I guess your previous investigation results the wording was identical, just lacking the word irrefutable?

I'd personally put Coju leaning Red, Glib is not confirmed white yet either but probably leaning white. I'd trust him over CG. I think the whole CG / BA stuff D1 could be mafia distancing. From what I remember when I played mafia with CG is that he likes to distance himself.

 

[Phillinnicus]

I may not be here for the rest of the day phase, but hopefully I can at least pop in at the end.

I'm putting all my faith into Gwaihir to be telling the truth, but I don't really feel safe in doing so. If he is telling the truth, and is pro-town, then I'll apologize later. Otherwise, (told you so!)

 

[pharphis]

You claimed VT correct? I must say I am surprised that there are any VTs in game.

(except mafia fake claims) + moar

 

[Jcakes1]

BTW, Numbers, I'd much rather mouse take your place for any locking actions that we may plan out. I think you're very likely to be town.

Mouse, do you think we should lynch BA, Gory or someone else and why do you think so?

you're said VERY little this game.

One could say ..... he's been as quiet as a mouse.

I never read the QTs, way too long.

Also OT: BA, who is that in your avatar? What is happening in that pic? I feel like it's so fitting to your personality right now.

You think normal QTs are long, you should see ours. We had to ask for another one cos we filled the first one up .....

All these resurrections...

Anything more to add coju?

I may not be here for the rest of the day phase, but hopefully I can at least pop in at the end.

I'm putting all my faith into Gwaihir to be telling the truth, but I don't really feel safe in doing so. If he is telling the truth, and is pro-town, then I'll apologize later. Otherwise, (told you so!)

Heh. I honestly think this is our best chance of success, worst case scenario the mafia have a strongman for one night (and we know Gwai is scum), best case scenario 241 baby.

I intend to vote for Goryani at some stage, but I will wait until tomorrow. I want to see Mouse, Zauper of Laarz lock Gory if possible.

 

[Jcakes1]

(except mafia fake claims) + moar

you believe Moar? On what basis?