Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Looking at this,

Players dead:

Drixx - Killed Night 1
Malevolent - Lynched Day 1, Mr. Freeze (Dr. Victor Fries) – Mafia – Freeze! (Roleblocker)/Poisoner
Pharphis - Died Day 1
Valhauros - Killed Night 2
flubbucket - Lynched Day 2, The Scarecrow (Professor Jonathan Crane) - Mafia - Fear Monger
Ankeli - Died Day 2
djmbbandie - Killed Night 3
Solar Ice - Killed Day 3, Two-Face (Harvey Dent) – Mafia - Inverter (X-shot)/Coin Flip (X-shot)
coju - Lynched Day 3, Bane – Mafia – Strongman (X-shot)/Hitman
Jason Maher - Died Day 3
FredOfErik - Lynched Day 4, Unknown
crawlingdeadman - Died Day 4
Noodle - Died Day 4
omgwtfbbqpwned - Mod killed Day 4, Red Hood (Jason Todd) – Town – Day Vigilante (X-shot)
FredOfErik - Alive Day 5
Gwaihir - Lynched Day 5, Poison Ivy (Pamela Isley) – Mafia – Seductress/Poisoner/Hitman
Goryani - Died Day 5
FredOfErik - Lynched Day 6, The Joker – Mafia – The Last Laugh/Poisoner/Hitman
thefranklin - Died Day 6

The nk's stopped after coju's lynch, It appears to me that flub, SI and coju were on one scum team and Male,Gwaihir and FoE were on another, with no nk's its possible that even tho Gwaihir and FoE were hitmen that they only used the poison to avoid being watched, I feel that we do have another poisoner, which would make 7 scum, does 8 scum seem a little on the high side?
 
Kestegs and Laarz are completely unlynchable in this game. I feel like kestegs could be apart of one of the most ridiculous fake mason groups ever, but at this point in this game it isnt going to be tested. I still find it absurd that Laarz and kestegs are both still alive. There is no logical sense for that happening at all. Kestegs doesnt watch himself and Laarz has been telling his doc saves pretty handidly.

The thing that is ridiculous is if laarz and kestegs are a team considering how many mafia have been killed.

I can understand a BPC lynch, but I feel like something fishy is going on and I dont like it.
 
I thought last laugh was last person to vote for you died which is uber WIFOM for thefranklin. tried googling it and couldnt find it though
 
Bad Ash said:
Kestegs and Laarz are completely unlynchable in this game. I feel like kestegs could be apart of one of the most ridiculous fake mason groups ever, but at this point in this game it isnt going to be tested. I still find it absurd that Laarz and kestegs are both still alive. There is no logical sense for that happening at all. Kestegs doesnt watch himself and Laarz has been telling his doc saves pretty handidly.

The thing that is ridiculous is if laarz and kestegs are a team considering how many mafia have been killed.

I can understand a BPC lynch, but I feel like something fishy is going on and I dont like it.
Click to expand...

I agree that something fishy seems to be going on. There really is no good reason for me to be alive. Well, actually I thought of one. Since poison is delayed I could still watch myself get poisoned and we would know the next day. The poison team isn't taking risks like that I noticed. They were just trying to thin down the votes.

Laarz and me being a team is just silly. CG explained why there was no real way that could work earlier.
 
Bad Ash said:
Man my scumdar just pings everything you say CG. And did we ever discover if we had three robins or just two?
Click to expand...

It's okay for you to be wrong from time to time.

Assuming that everyone was telling the truth, we had three Robins and one ex-Robin.

Bad Ash said:
I thought last laugh was last person to vote for you died which is uber WIFOM for thefranklin. tried googling it and couldnt find it though
Click to expand...

This is what you seek.

Noodle was the last vote on FoE. Noodle then dies to poison. FoE then comes back to life. Makes perfect sense.

Solar Ice and Gwaihir are very unlikely to have been on the same mafia team, as one is listed as poisoner and one is not. Both were 'caught' by kestegs. (Yes, I know JM cop'd SI, but kestegs leaked the info) For kestegs to be scum, there are either three mafia teams (Nope!), or he bussed the crap out of one of his own team mates from out of nowhere.

The more likely answer is that he is simply out WIFOM'ing the poisoners. If he watches himself and they poison him, then he can reveal his killer before he dies at the end of the day.

Therefore, the last scum lies between BPC, Moar, or myself.
 
Bad Ash said:
I thought last laugh was last person to vote for you died which is uber WIFOM for thefranklin. tried googling it and couldnt find it though
Click to expand...

In the roles madness game I think (?) We had this role and they took someone out in their place if they were lynched iirc.
 
As stated previously I cant really argue against a BPC lynch with moar next, just doesnt feel like it should be this cut and dry
 
Other than thinking that my claim seems off, I don't see much in the way of anything concrete with showing that I'm scum. With the absurd number of power roles in the game, it should be easy to believe that there are multiple vigs on the towns side, especially with the number of poisoners on the Mafia side. My claim is 100% truth, I have no more powers and I am basically vanilla townie at this point. You've heard me claim this multiple times, so none of what I have said is news.

If I do get lynched today, good luck town, but frankly I think Moar is your man (hehe). I believe her role sounds the most scummy, especially with the stealing. I don't know much about the comic book batman universe, so I couldn't pick out any characters that could meet the description.

My lynch order at this point is Moar then CG, a bit of a change of heart from yesterday, mainly due to my review of the past days. I don't know about CG, but his nightwing story seems fairly legit to me and I can see why he might not have wanted to reveal that right away.

So for now,

Vote: Moar

I don't know if it will even make a difference.
 
BipolarChemist said:
Other than thinking that my claim seems off, I don't see much in the way of anything concrete with showing that I'm scum. With the absurd number of power roles in the game, it should be easy to believe that there are multiple vigs on the towns side, especially with the number of poisoners on the Mafia side. My claim is 100% truth, I have no more powers and I am basically vanilla townie at this point. You've heard me claim this multiple times, so none of what I have said is news.

If I do get lynched today, good luck town, but frankly I think Moar is your man (hehe). I believe her role sounds the most scummy, especially with the stealing. I don't know much about the comic book batman universe, so I couldn't pick out any characters that could meet the description.

My lynch order at this point is Moar then CG, a bit of a change of heart from yesterday, mainly due to my review of the past days. I don't know about CG, but his nightwing story seems fairly legit to me and I can see why he might not have wanted to reveal that right away.

So for now,

Vote: Moar

I don't know if it will even make a difference.
Click to expand...

So we shouldn't lynch you because we don't have any concrete evidence? Good plan, let's lynch moar for the same reason then?

Why does the number of poisoners relate to the number of town vigs we should have?

"Good luck town" yea, that sounds like someone who isn't trying to help the town.
 
BPC, i think you tried to kill me not so much because I was the doc but because you thought I would be someone that could help Batman, you could have went after SI, whom kegs had said was scum but you choose me because I didn't do a full claim quick enough, you may not have been the one to go after me it could have been one of your pardners, who knows, but you claimed it.
 
I seriously just jumped the gun on using my power that night. I based my decision on myself, among others, thinking the claim was weak, as well as some interesting comments from others, namely omg's comment about coming after the person who claimed Alfred. Also, didn't omg kill SI that day? Really I wish I had used the power on FoE and I had considered it, but I ended up going with you.

Frankly, it was me being stupid and maybe not entirely thinking it through. I actually wish I had saved my power for a little later.
 
kestegs said:
Why do I always get stuck with all the lurkers?
Click to expand...

There's not much left to be said. I would like to hear Moar's thoughts before I cast a vote. BPC's post has a very defeated tone to it.

Laarz said:
BPC, i think you tried to kill me not so much because I was the doc but because you thought I would be someone that could help Batman, you could have went after SI, whom kegs had said was scum but you choose me because I didn't do a full claim quick enough, you may not have been the one to go after me it could have been one of your pardners, who knows, but you claimed it.
Click to expand...

I've said this before, but I'll reiterate: The reason I found BPC's actions most scummy is that Laarz and I both claimed on the same day, but neither of us revealed our ability. Laarz claimed Alfred, I claimed Nightwing. BPC confronted Laarz, shot at Laarz, yet ignored me.

So while I say "He shot the doctor", it's really short hand for - "He focused solely upon trying to kill the person who had the more likely to be doctor claim, while simultaneously ignoring the other guy who claimed in a similar fashion but has a less likely chance to be someone who can prevent our kills."
 
I am so so very tired, but I think I read all messages now. I fell asleep in the middle of it about 2 hours ago.

In my mind Laarz and kestegs are both town. I will not vote for either of them. So it's either BPC or CG who is the last scum out there. BPC claimed his attempted NK early (if I remember right), probably because he tried to do damage control. CG claimed a role that is "not an implausible scum claim" (according to the link he gave). I tend more towards voting for BPC right now, but I am not sure. I will follow Laarz and kestegs unless I think they are completely off.
 
BipolarChemist said:
I seriously just jumped the gun on using my power that night. I based my decision on myself, among others, thinking the claim was weak, as well as some interesting comments from others, namely omg's comment about coming after the person who claimed Alfred. Also, didn't omg kill SI that day? Really I wish I had used the power on FoE and I had considered it, but I ended up going with you.

Frankly, it was me being stupid and maybe not entirely thinking it through. I actually wish I had saved my power for a little later.
Click to expand...

Why ignore my questions?
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top