Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Guess no one caught my, "if you want to be my lover" post....

And Jason, that has to be one the most absurd thing's I've seen here. You don't trust djbambi? What makes you think he's scum?
No thoughts that a doc saved him? No thoughts of a bus?
 
Anyway, let's see if his info is good a second time. This feels so good after the wya he hounded me last game:

Vote: crawlingdeadman
 
djmbbandie said:
Never mind, I found it.

Vote: crawlingdeadman

I am disturbed by your gas canister.
Click to expand...

Two for two? Someone is legacy shopping.

Vote: crawlingdeadman

@djmbbandie - You don't have to claim first thing every day. There are benefits to waiting a bit. I like to wait around half a day.
 
Sorry, excitement to actually contribute something is getting me this round. Next day I'll hold off for a while (If I live to see it).
 
Goryani said:
That wasn't Ankeli's only coincidence.



This post assumes multiple, independent mafia, like in ASOFAI. It definitely doesn't follow the "1 mafia, 1 night kill" paradigm.
Click to expand...

Goryani said:
The timing of pharphis death is..... interesting. I didn't see a day kill attempt so I don't think it's a dayvig. Looks like a poison mechanic.
Click to expand...
You have many knowledge Mr. Sparkle. Seriously though, would you paint Ankeli so obvious and awkward??

coju said:
Guess no one caught my, "if you want to be my lover" post....

And Jason, that has to be one the most absurd thing's I've seen here. You don't trust djbambi? What makes you think he's scum?
No thoughts that a doc saved him? No thoughts of a bus?
Click to expand...
The notion of lovers isn't so far fetched. However, poisoning might be an option. Poison Ivy is a Batman enemy right? So she could have poisoned and it took until end of day.

Jason Maher said:
Yes, those thought occurred to me. As did the thought that he might be playing us.
Click to expand...
This really seems unlikely. Vote: crawlingdeadman

Jason Maher said:
Day 2 is usually plum time for me. :)
Click to expand...
At my age I'm more of a prune person....with a Metamucil chaser, Boffo!
 
kestegs said:
I think any painting of ankeli would be awkward, obviously.
Click to expand...

Dude, I'm a stunner.

As for being too obvious, what, isn't it? Adding 1+1 in freeze ray being a role blocking mechanism, and assuming that more people than 1 "should" die during a night/day phase in a game this big for the mafia to have any chance was kind of self explainatory for me.

As for voting, gas doesn't sound too nice.

Vote: crawlingdeadman

If dj is scum hunting other (s)cum, who cares? He's currently doing a *****in' job for the town in it.
 
Solar Ice said:
Always pro lynch? Really?

You not vote for OMG to help secure the lynch, explaining that you did not see the case. You did not, in fact, vote for anyone out of the prosecution candidates during the entire course of the Day. The logical conclusion I can make is that you think they are all Town enough to not vote for. Am I correct, kestegs?
Click to expand...

Yes? No?

Or did by bringing up three topics in your next two posts, you hoped you could ignore answering?
 
Malevolent said:
finally the game has started!

the interogate/prosecute sounds interesting, makes the twilight phase more about strategy and less about general banter.
Click to expand...

kestegs said:
I fingered male as scum after his first post, it was really obvious. That post wasn't sarcastic at all, his final twilight post made it super obvious. Interesting that you didn't put that together until after last night though. And if you think I said that I thought half the people were scum you need to read that over again.
Click to expand...

Franklin asked you about post 27 not his final post of Twilight or any other post. What in Malevolent's first post(above for reference) made it obvious to you that he was Mafia?

You are scrambling.
 
kestegs said:
I fingered male as scum after his first post, it was really obvious. That post wasn't sarcastic at all, his final twilight post made it super obvious. Interesting that you didn't put that together until after last night though. And if you think I said that I thought half the people were scum you need to read that over again.
Click to expand...
What was so scummy about this post?

Malevolent said:
finally the game has started!

the interogate/prosecute sounds interesting, makes the twilight phase more about strategy and less about general banter.
Click to expand...

And if that post was scummy, then why not FredofErik's post right before it, which said basically the exact same thing?

If you had strong suspicions that Male was scum during Twilight, then why didn't you vote to Interrogate him? You placed a vote for Ankeli at one point. Why Ankeli over Male?

More over, why did you not pressure Malevolent at all during Twilight past a single "Male is scum!" post?

Ankeli said:
If dj is scum hunting other (s)cum, who cares? He's currently doing a *****in' job for the town in it.
Click to expand...

Precisely!

[STRIKE]Vendetta!: Ankeli[/STRIKE]
Vote: crawlingdeadman

Oops, sorry. Total force of habit.
 
I'm also curious why we couldn't muster cooperation for a second lynch at end of last day phase. Obviously can't ask Valhauros or pharphis, but why didn't Goryani, coju, Noodle or Bad Ash change their vote? I'm not gunning for omgwtfbbqpwned, but it is a shame to not be able to garner information when it is available. Does it make the interrogate/prosecute/vote/ sort of a wash?? Or is someone trying to protect someone??
 
I wish I could drop another vote for FoE cause I still think he's anti-town. Ugh. Part of me hopes for a great explanation from cdm so I can do just that!
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top