Create Your Own Role Mafia game

[Goryani]

The Forensic Scientist was a victim of the RNG. It was placed in town hands only twice and during one of those times night was skipped.

In retrospect, I would have liked to see the Forensic Scientist end up a little more scary for the mafia. The original version probably would have done nicely, given how many times mafia had it.

By the way, kestegs got lucky. He fibbed about his N4 target and action with the Forensic Scientist. He collected from flubbucket instead of collecting from a crime scene. It turns out flubbucket was targeted by someone else, so the Cootie Detector couldn't detect the lie. I think kestegs claimed before the Cootie Detector.

 

[Solar Ice]

Also, I am totally fine with sharing the Mafia QT. Any objections from the rest of the Mafiosi?

Glib do you want to share our Paris chat? I am cool with it as well.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Man, I was really hoping someone would lynch a mafiso so I could be brought back in the game. For all of those that were debating what happened to the protection card, even though I died, I retained it since I had a chance to be brought back, so when CG tried to send it out again it would have failed since I was still in possesion of it.

I really wish I had more time to post the first few days, but of course as soon as I had more time I was killed off. Either way, great game, very creative roles, but no one got a good read anywhwere it seemed, there were random thoughts everywhere but no one was really pushing them, the debate between Sath and Moar dragged on for days, it was crazy.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Also, gieb Dead QT, its driving me crazy being dead but not able to read it!

 

[Goryani]

You can't have it.

I'll leave it to members of the other chats to share their links.

 

[MartinLong]

The Forensic Scientist was a victim of the RNG. It was placed in town hands only twice and during one of those times night was skipped.

In retrospect, I would have liked to see the Forensic Scientist end up a little more scary for the mafia. The original version probably would have done nicely, given how many times mafia had it.

By the way, kestegs got lucky. He fibbed about his N4 target and action with the Forensic Scientist. He collected from flubbucket instead of collecting from a crime scene. It turns out flubbucket was targeted by someone else, so the Cootie Detector couldn't detect the lie. I think kestegs claimed before the Cootie Detector.

Agreed. It would seemingly be a much better townie role in place of a cop/watcher/tracker. Interesting about kegs and lucky just as much!

 

[Solar Ice]

Man, I was really hoping someone would lynch a mafiso so I could be brought back in the game. For all of those that were debating what happened to the protection card, even though I died, I retained it since I had a chance to be brought back, so when CG tried to send it out again it would have failed since I was still in possesion of it.

I really wish I had more time to post the first few days, but of course as soon as I had more time I was killed off. Either way, great game, very creative roles, but no one got a good read anywhwere it seemed, there were random thoughts everywhere but no one was really pushing them, the debate between Sath and Moar dragged on for days, it was crazy.

Ha! You already did enough damage to us as it is. And you want to come back to do even more?

it took twO bullets and you still did not die!

 

[MartinLong]

Man, I was really hoping someone would lynch a mafiso so I could be brought back in the game. For all of those that were debating what happened to the protection card, even though I died, I retained it since I had a chance to be brought back, so when CG tried to send it out again it would have failed since I was still in possesion of it.

I really wish I had more time to post the first few days, but of course as soon as I had more time I was killed off. Either way, great game, very creative roles, but no one got a good read anywhwere it seemed, there were random thoughts everywhere but no one was really pushing them, the debate between Sath and Moar dragged on for days, it was crazy.

I was curious about the last laugh.

I was the last to lynch Mal, but the Last Laugh was switched around and ended up at Pyro. So from what I saw, if I died, would Pyro have come back?

 

[MartinLong]

Hmm also, I have to say. With all the townies we lynched, why the lack of good arguments to live? From my memory and point of view, when someone was getting lynched, they didn't really do anything but say "well, im going to flip town, so shame on you".

Was it just me?

 

[Bad Ash]

Thanks for hosting Gory! Sorry for being an awful townie town. I had kegs pegged though maybe?

I created Tarot psychic. A Lovers card would have been in play if the paris hilton role was not created

 

[Bad Ash]

Hmm also, I have to say. With all the townies we lynched, why the lack of good arguments to live? From my memory and point of view, when someone was getting lynched, they didn't really do anything but say "well, im going to flip town, so shame on you".

Was it just me?

Because the role didnt dictate alignment. In normal mafia saying "im a cop" holds so much weight because if true you are almost certainly town. In this game, what could you say?

 

[Goryani]

I was curious about the last laugh.

I was the last to lynch Mal, but the Last Laugh was switched around and ended up at Pyro. So from what I saw, if I died, would Pyro have come back?

^ There were more questions about that subject than any other role interaction.

When Malevolent was lynched as Last Laugh, his chance at return ended when Dr. Frankenstein took away his Last Last role. When Pyro was killed as the last laugh, kestegs was the hitman. Pyro would have returned upon a kestegs death.

 

[Solar Ice]

Hmm also, I have to say. With all the townies we lynched, why the lack of good arguments to live? From my memory and point of view, when someone was getting lynched, they didn't really do anything but say "well, im going to flip town, so shame on you".

Was it just me?

I agree, people went down way too easily. Would have loved to see some counter-cases made to swing the trains.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Bah, I sucked this game. I had kestegs pegged, but Sath and Franklin fooled me. Well done, both of you. Also, I was responsible for the Kingmaker role.

 

[Kestegs]

Good game! Had a great time playing


Go ahead and give out QT.


I'll read the dead QT later when I have more time.


I skill have to say that this game was actually fairly balanced I think. Would have been different if the town hadn't decided to make everyone role claim the following day though. We had so many roles that we could have abused if we didn't have to claim the next day. I mean I really felt like I had no choice but to give out that no night night card on D1.

Good work to moar and ankeli especially, they had us pegged pretty hard at times

 

[Kestegs]

Hmm also, I have to say. With all the townies we lynched, why the lack of good arguments to live? From my memory and point of view, when someone was getting lynched, they didn't really do anything but say "well, im going to flip town, so shame on you".

Was it just me?

Nope, I felt the same way. Not that I was complaining.

 

[Solar Ice]

Because the role didnt dictate alignment. In normal mafia saying "im a cop" holds so much weight because if true you are almost certainly town. In this game, what could you say?

Still, you know that you are Town. Surely there was enough to make a case on another player, or at least give it a try?

Ankeli tried a bit but it was interpreted as "flailing" (and I can see why). In his counters, he did not make concrete points about why so and so is scum, just accused. That said, he tried more than most, I think

 

[MartinLong]

Thanks for hosting Gory! Sorry for being an awful townie town. I had kegs pegged though maybe?

I created Tarot psychic. A Lovers card would have been in play if the paris hilton role was not created

There were some really nice cards in that deck! Very creative.

Because the role didnt dictate alignment. In normal mafia saying "im a cop" holds so much weight because if true you are almost certainly town. In this game, what could you say?

Building case really. It is tough when the townie is backed up against the wall, but everyone time I see a "give up" I just suspect that we did the right thing. I mean, look at Mal's last number of games when he was mafia and getting lynched and that's what I feel.

^ There were more questions about that subject than any other role interaction.

When Malevolent was lynched as Last Laugh, his chance at return ended when Dr. Frankenstein took away his Last Last role. When Pyro was killed as the last laugh, kestegs was the hitman. Pyro would have returned upon a kestegs death.

Hmm. Touche, quite complex. I was thinking, if I was killed, then pyro would come back and we would be on for another day!

I agree, people went down way too easily. Would have loved to see some counter-cases made to swing the trains.

Didn't help that we didn't lynch any mafia either haha, so when you analyze the people on their death bed, they all seemed similar.

Bah, I sucked this game. I had kestegs pegged, but Sath and Franklin fooled me. Well done, both of you. Also, I was responsible for the Kingmaker role.

What a chaotic role that is!

 

[Kestegs]

SI: I actually realized about 5 minutes into the game that I should have done what you said and made the restriction only non consecutive posts. and then later that day Mal showed us why

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Ha! You already did enough damage to us as it is. And you want to come back to do even more?

it took twO bullets and you still did not die!

Whats up with that? Why were you guys so set on killing me? I was pretty much protected from most night actions I was the Mime (copied the reflector), the reflector, and then last laugh. It was crazy.

I was curious about the last laugh.

I was the last to lynch Mal, but the Last Laugh was switched around and ended up at Pyro. So from what I saw, if I died, would Pyro have come back?

That Dr. Frankenstein move made it impossible for Mal to come back. So the role functioned as normal when I died. If a mafiso had the Dr. Frank role later down the line they could have done the same thing that happened to Mal to stop me from coming back, but it would have been a complete scum move, although all night actions were pretty much impossible to prove, so they probably would have been ok.

Hmm also, I have to say. With all the townies we lynched, why the lack of good arguments to live? From my memory and point of view, when someone was getting lynched, they didn't really do anything but say "well, im going to flip town, so shame on you".

Was it just me?

No, definately not you, I think I read the "welp I'm town, cya." line way to much in this game.