(KindofMafia) Assassin in the Castle!

[Kestegs]

That was supposed to say wise not wide.

Well, it's an endorsement none the less. It's obvious now why the mafia won so easily last game, your scum hunting is dreadful .
Good bye my leige.

(last post before work, so I probably won't be able to post before night fall. I'm guessing I'm locked in)

Who's scum hunting? And this is totally different, there is no association, no powers, no nothing.

Goodbye sir.

 

[pharphis]

Okay, I looked at the least and everyone has spoken at least once. Good.
I came up with a list of possible assassins.
1. Bad Ashat
2. Solar Ice
3. Sathoris
4. kestegs
5. Gwaihir
6. MartinLong
Martin will be removed if we don't win after his lynch.

 

[Solar Ice]

You just listed everyone in the game , barring Goryani, yourself and ThunderCat. Any reason that you left out those? What makes you so special that you can not be the assassin?

 

[Sathoris]

Okay, I looked at the least and everyone has spoken at least once. Good.
I came up with a list of possible assassins.
1. Bad Ashat
2. Solar Ice
3. Sathoris
4. kestegs
5. Gwaihir
6. MartinLong
Martin will be removed if we don't win after his lynch.

I've already got you as backup for the assassin and I don't think it's going to take many people to convince to lynch you next if Martin isn't the assa.

 

[Caluin Graye]

MartinLong [5]: Sathoris; Bad Ash; pharphis; Solar Ice; kestegs
Solar Ice [1]: MartinLong
kestegs [1]: Goryani
Sathoris [1]: Gwaihir

Meaning MartinLong is locked. Lynch is in about an hour.

 

[Solar Ice]

I've already got you as backup for the assassin and I don't think it's going to take many people to convince to lynch you next if Martin isn't the assa.

It will not take much to convince me, although I think that should ML flip Guard (and it is looking likely that he will as he has not attempted a kill on his "deathbed"), Kestegs should have a very close look at.

 

[pharphis]

TC because if he was the assassin then he wouldn't be replaced by CG (assuming he will be). Myself obviously because why would I list myself as the assassin?

 

[pharphis]

Forgot to explain Gory. It's because of the last thing he said in post 85

"As long as there are players trying to find the assassin, the assassin's vote is never "needed" under these voting rules."
That coupled with the fact that he didn't jump on the martin train immediately afterwards.

 

[Caluin Graye]

First order of business:
[STRIKE]I need a replacement. First person to send me a PM requesting the spot will get it. I'll update this when the spot is filled.[/STRIKE]

omgwtfbbqpwned replaces TC.

Second order:

-------------------

The accusations came quickly. Motives, tenure, and even lineage were all called into question. Nothing was off limits. Heated exchanges of words were backed up with the wild gesturing of swords and daggers. It was a kettle drum about to explode.

Then someone slipped, made a wrong move or said something wrong. What it was specifically has been lost in the years since, but most agree that it does not really matter. What does matter is that he was the first killed, descended upon by frightened, maddened souls who wanted vengeance.

They found none this hour. MartinLong, loyal guard of the King, citizen of Caltopia, was unceremoniously cut to ribbons.

Eight men remain.

-------------------

Next lynch occurs in 24 hours. Votes are reset.

 

[Sathoris]

TC because if he was the assassin then he wouldn't be replaced by CG (assuming he will be). Myself obviously because why would I list myself as the assassin?

Terrible logic that doesn't even make sense.

Forgot to explain Gory. It's because of the last thing he said in post 85

"As long as there are players trying to find the assassin, the assassin's vote is never "needed" under these voting rules."
That coupled with the fact that he didn't jump on the martin train immediately afterwards.

That is more scummy than townie and I must've missed it. Again on dangerous terms here, but the assa's vote is the only thing we could nail him on next to general postings (which without tangible leads or tells or association there is nothing to crack down on except again posts about voting). The assassin would be wise to not post as that means we cannot possible find him except randomly, which I'm guessing this game is going to boil down to. Random lynches until we hit the assa who if caught decides to kill the possible king.

So instead of absolving Gory that should put him on top of anybody's list right now.

 

[Sathoris]

Vote: Goryani

 

[Gwaihir]

TC because if he was the assassin then he wouldn't be replaced by CG (assuming he will be). Myself obviously because why would I list myself as the assassin?

Why would CG not replace the assassin? That role seems pretty needed for the game to continue.

 

[Kestegs]

TC because if he was the assassin then he wouldn't be replaced by CG (assuming he will be). Myself obviously because why would I list myself as the assassin?

Nobody would list themselves, so we obviously are all innocent? Just looks like you are trying to make a list that we can all look at that doesn't include you.

I think cg would have replaced any role.

 

[Gwaihir]

That is more scummy than townie and I must've missed it. Again on dangerous terms here, but the assa's vote is the only thing we could nail him on next to general postings (which without tangible leads or tells or association there is nothing to crack down on except again posts about voting). The assassin would be wise to not post as that means we cannot possible find him except randomly, which I'm guessing this game is going to boil down to. Random lynches until we hit the assa who if caught decides to kill the possible king.

So instead of absolving Gory that should put him on top of anybody's list right now.

To me it seemed like Gory was making a statement of fact - assassin never actually needs to vote. Not sure why this should make him top of list suspicious.

Also I think there is still scum hunting involved here. Still works similar to a mafia game in this regard with a small killing faction trying to hide from a larger town one. Harder to separate as assassin has no teammates, but other things still apply like lynching a lurker, and with only one assassin, we only need to pick correctly once.

You and kegs seem to disagree, which I find odd. When humans are playing a game like this I think you can always do better than random with good reads on people.

Vote: kestegs

 

[Kestegs]

Upon further thought I am inclined to believe that gory and Ph are not the assassin but that sath may be.

vote: sathoris

 

[Kestegs]

You ninjad me there.

To me it seemed like Gory was making a statement of fact - assassin never actually needs to vote. Not sure why this should make him top of list suspicious.

Also I think there is still scum hunting involved here. Still works similar to a mafia game in this regard with a small killing faction trying to hide from a larger town one. Harder to separate as assassin has no teammates, but other things still apply like lynching a lurker, and with only one assassin, we only need to pick correctly once.

You and kegs seem to disagree, which I find odd. When humans are playing a game like this I think you can always do better than random with good reads on people.

Vote: kestegs

So because I disagree with sath I am scum? I don't get your logic there.

 

[Goryani]

I came up with a list of possible assassins.

Lists are very bad in this game. ESPECIALLY after a lock but before the lynch occurs.

You just listed everyone in the game , barring Goryani, yourself and ThunderCat. Any reason that you left out those? What makes you so special that you can not be the assassin?

Asking for justification of lists is worse.

Vote: Solar Ice

That is more scummy than townie and I must've missed it. Again on dangerous terms here, but the assa's vote is the only thing we could nail him on next to general postings (which without tangible leads or tells or association there is nothing to crack down on except again posts about voting). The assassin would be wise to not post as that means we cannot possible find him except randomly, which I'm guessing this game is going to boil down to. Random lynches until we hit the assa who if caught decides to kill the possible king.

So instead of absolving Gory that should put him on top of anybody's list right now.

Oh the irony.

 

[Bad Ash]

holy all over the place batman.

I agree PH list is pretty bogus for many reasons, the main one that was already stated was it 75% of the players.

Also, why wouldn't TC replace the assassin? I feel like the others do that CG would replace every player in the game. Its a small sample size as it is.

 

[Sathoris]

Oh the irony.

Not as much, but it's the helpful kind.

 

[Caluin Graye]

I think cg would have replaced any role.

This is correct. Me replacing TC should not be indicative of his role or alignment.

[STRIKE]Still looking for someone, BTW.[/STRIKE]

Found.