Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Who are your top choices for today then? As far as I can tell you've not voted yet today.

Should have preview-edited to answer this right away.

Top choices are in my post above, but can't make up my mind since both are new players. Also I did vote for Pyro, but I believe the reason for that was our missunderstanding regarding my post.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

@korial I am not sticking with anything. You said no, and I agree I dont think you have a posting restriction. My vote fell on you for the reasons I posted with the vote.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Hey, I'm alive, pretty cool, huh?

So, fundamentally, I'd say the spammers are 500% more likely to be mafia; we should start with them because everyone knows scum always benefit from hiding information with oceans of spam and confusion. Therefore, I'll be always willing to vote for any of these on principle: Skjolde, Kestegs, Jcakes and Autti. On the other hand, I won't vote for Glib unless there is substantial proof, because otherwise a lot of mocking potential would be lost.

Fascinating that you would say that. Have you already forgotten Noodle's game (what, game before last?)? I was the only one who had a post count above 10 before day 5 if I remember correctly. I think it is just as likely to have mafia among the lurkers as it is in the spammers.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I think I will be able to look in again in a few hours, but just in case ...

Vote: Skjolde

I see where folks are coming from concer?ning Autti, and would be willing to switch, if necessary.

_______________

Message to any new players we have - my first two mafia games here saw me dead on Night 1/Day 1. If a new guy gets lynched on his first day, all I can say is, it ain't personal, it's just business. :nod: Better luck next time! :yes:
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

@korial I am not sticking with anything. You said no, and I agree I dont think you have a posting restriction. My vote fell on you for the reasons I posted with the vote.

Oh. Well then I don't understand what that reason is, and I assume since you haven't clarified by now you won't. So I'll just wait and see what happens in this regard.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

So its a good thing you didn't actually make the major slip up then? Would hate to reveal that you are mafia?


I know, probably nothing, but the wording of that response bugs me a bit.






....


Holy crap I can't believe I did not know that. You have just saved me a significant amount of time. I have been going back and using the search function on pages where I thought the quote came from. Thanks!


The wording bugs me too (@Kori:)




Hey, I'm alive, pretty cool, huh?


So, fundamentally, I'd say the spammers are 500% more likely to be mafia; we should start with them because everyone knows scum always benefit from hiding information with oceans of spam and confusion. Therefore, I'll be always willing to vote for any of these on principle: Skjolde, Kestegs, Jcakes and Autti. On the other hand, I won't vote for Glib unless there is substantial proof, because otherwise a lot of mocking potential would be lost.


Regarding the dream, I think that the story gave it away very clearly, so I find weird that some would try to dismiss it and I find weirder that there is some much speculation, with so little information to go through; to me, it seems a clear attempt to divert attention. Regarding Glibby, using a different font and taking things out of context to make the player seem more scummy, a tactic he used before as mafia, makes me believe he might have the same alignment as the previous game.


Jcakes apparent take on the dream mechanic, his suggestion of not having a lynch on D1, and his subsequent relative silence, despite being a spammer lvl70, took him to the top of my list, but Autti's performance won the race (faked noob behavior, pasting terms). I will change my vote if a more suitable train is taking off, though.


Vote: Autti.


Goryani's "That may be an extreme example, but it isn't an isolated incident":
I disagree; If I hadn't been the serial killer the previous game, I'd still have supported not to have a lynch, due to the random nature of the game.


Glibbucket's "Ask those of us who died screaming, murdered in our beds at the hands of a cruel heartless lying sack of crap named Valhauros! No offense":
None taken, Glib.


This post is interesting ....


First point. I personally think fundamentally that lurkers / people that post once per day are 1000% more likely to be scum. This is based on my one game experience though ....


2nd. I personally was speculating on it to try and see if people may slip up and post information that town does not know


3rd. I did explain that I would be unable to post at work and since that time I have posted a fair amount, pressured flubb on his out of context posts.


Speaking of which. I am still not happy with flubb and I personally think he is the best candidate for a D1 lynch. Therefore


Vote: Flubbucket


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Just as an FYI, I missed where Glib made a scum slip that has people voting for him. I've been preoccupied with picking apart Autti and SK's posts. Why exactly are people voting for him again?
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I've been waiting for Autti to show himself again but I'm guessing his "godfather" told him to lay low till the heats off.

He's too suspicious for me.

Vote: Autti
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Just as an FYI, I missed where Glib made a scum slip that has people voting for him. I've been preoccupied with picking apart Autti and SK's posts. Why exactly are people voting for him again?

I missed it as well...


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I've been waiting for Autti to show himself again but I'm guessing his "godfather" told him to lay low till the heats off.

He's too suspicious for me.

Vote: Autti

So you apparently have info that points to Mafia having day talk? Or what exactly are you trying to get at?

I missed it as well...

Have you guys tried reading the thread? I seriously don't know how you could have missed it.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Votes as of post # 251

Autti(5): [FredofErik], [Asrrin], Ankeli, FredofErik, Valhauros, Bad Ash, Glib
FredofErik(0): [Kestegs], [Ankeli]
Skjolde(5): [Autti], Solar Ice, Caluin Graye, Asrrin, Kestegs, Loz
Kestegs(0): [FredofErik]
Glib(2): [Sathoris], Gwahir, Jcakes
Asrrin(0): [Sathoris]
Jcakes(0): [Goryani]
Goryani(0): [Sathoris]
Korialstarz(0): [Bad Ash]
Pyro(0): [Korialstarz]
Noodle(1): Goryani

12 to Lynch

Roughly 11 and a half hours left.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

The wording bugs me too (@Kori:)

It would bug me too if someone else made a slip up like that, just after saying he was glad he didn't slip up. Can't say anything to change this.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Wow you sure are smart for a townie!
Have to give props for that out of context quote. You almost had me believing I made such a major slip up!
I'm sorry, but that's one hell of a slip. How is it that everyone but two have overlooked this? Thanks to Gwaihir and Solar for bringing this up. This is one of the worst kinds of slips, because it shows how oblivious players can be regarding their roles and alignment.

Unvote: Autti
Vote: Korialstrasz

Gwaihir's "Have you already forgotten Noodle's game (what, game before last?)?":
Was that the SPF game? I wasn't allowed to play; somehow, my sign-up post was deleted, twice.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Just as an FYI, I missed where Glib made a scum slip that has people voting for him. I've been preoccupied with picking apart Autti and SK's posts. Why exactly are people voting for him again?


You will need to click on the arrows to go to the quotes as I don't have the time to embed the posts.


This first post flubb is picking at Kori, by taking complete out of context quotes
Prostate joke?!?!? Now that's below the belt








Wow you sure are smart for a townie!!










Another smarty pants...




What effect do you think it will have??










Nope. I tend to go outside.


THis was my push at him, I included the full section of quote
Nice out of context quote there ....




For reference. The full quote for that section (note it was in a massive WoT responding to multiple people) was in response to.




"I guess my question is if they can chose to use the same dream multiple nights in a row or if its a one and done kind of situation."










When taken out of context the way you did it seems much more scummy, and I was almost ready to jump on kori. Fortunately I checked the quote first...My question to you Flubb is why did you choose to remove the context from what was a small quote anyway?


Flubbs response to my questions


Here are the fundamentals as I understand them (feel free to correct me). The goal of the game is to stay alive whether you are town or mafia. If you are mafia you kill the town. If you are town, you hunt mafia by any means available. Be that poking, prodding, needling, quoting, harassing etc… The goal of which is to expose them to the town and then lynch them. If I see something concerning, I will shine a light on it. If they are innocent then there is nothing to hide.


With all sincerity I say I’m not cold blooded, but Kestegs would you want to lynch a new guy if you thought he was a mafia?


@Goryani-I don’t like it at all!


As a point of interest (not horn blowing AT ALL). In the WIFOA game, in the final day, the remaining few were convinced Valhauros and FoE were townie. I knew Valhauros was the SK and even quoted and threw a vote on him at one point. So no assumptions of innocence and Glibbwagons misquoting may actually continue….darn those torpedoes!!!










Oh, and Glib says all mafia wear thongs...


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Skjolde and Autti, both with five votes each. Of the two, I'm leaning towards Skjolde. I'm willing to cut Autti a little slack for being brand new to the game - I know that doesn't change the odds that he's scum, but it would be real easy for a brand new player to come across as suspicious when they're actually town. I don't feel real strongly about it, though - If either gets close to a lynch / lock, I'll cast my vote.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Edit: @ Val.

I noticed it as well and raised it slightly(see my quote that Kori quoted above yours).. At the time, I was more preoccupied by Flubbs out of context quote editing

I'm sorry, but that's one hell of a slip. How is it that everyone but two have overlooked this? Thanks to Gwaihir and Solar for bringing this up. This is one of the worst kinds of slips, because it shows how oblivious players can be regarding their roles and alignment.

Unvote: Autti
Vote: Korialstrasz

Gwaihir's "Have you already forgotten Noodle's game (what, game before last?)?":
Was that the SPF game? I wasn't allowed to play; somehow, my sign-up post was deleted, twice.

nope it was a community game, you were mafia. At one point I posted the lurkers and the bottom 4 posters were all mafia ....
http://www.purediablo.com/forums/showthread.php?822787-Till-Death-do-us-part-Forum-mafia-game

No it was in here and it was hosted by TC actually.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I'm sorry, but that's one hell of a slip. How is it that everyone but two have overlooked this? Thanks to Gwaihir and Solar for bringing this up. This is one of the worst kinds of slips, because it shows how oblivious players can be regarding their roles and alignment.

Unvote: Autti
Vote: Korialstrasz

Gwaihir's "Have you already forgotten Noodle's game (what, game before last?)?":
Was that the SPF game? I wasn't allowed to play; somehow, my sign-up post was deleted, twice.

Thanks to you and Jcakes fro going back to find quotes.

As for the game, you were playing, I unvoted you to prevent you from getting lynched, although it was TC's game not Noodles:
http://www.purediablo.com/forums/showthread.php?822787-Till-Death-do-us-part-Forum-mafia-game


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Noodle.... any commentary on his relative silence since early on. Not really the tactic of a newbie, unless they were receiving some "coaching"
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I have to go to work very soon, I may be back in time for Days end. Personally I think we should lynch one of:
1. Flubb: just purely for his attempt to misquote and mislead people
2. Korial: Seems to be making a lot of slip ups, incluidng the one Val / Gwaihir raised. That said he is cooperating a lot more and answering peoples questions.
3. Skjolde: I don't like the capital I and some of his other posts. Don't have as big a feeling on SK as others do though. Possibly because I spend time with him in the OT threads and no his posting style.
4. Autti: I give him a bit of newcomer slack, but still looks a little scummy.
5. Val: Policy vote for last game (even though I wasn't there) :D

anyway I g2g, with luck I will be able to post tonight.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top