OT: The SPF Mafia Game Round Three

So close ... we really narrowed it down to muzz vs goltar. We should of lynched someone yesterday. Oh well.

I say the game need some rules changes, it's too easy for the mafia right now. Revealing a person role after his death would be a good idea.

Thanks to Skoolbus for hosting this, takes a lot of patience!
 
GoHabsGo said:
So close ... we really narrowed it down to muzz vs goltar. We should of lynched someone yesterday. Oh well.

I say the game need some rules changes, it's too easy for the mafia right now. Revealing a person role after his death would be a good idea.

Thanks to Skoolbus for hosting this, takes a lot of patience!
Click to expand...


Rashiminos said:
Well, all I can really say about not revealing townie/mafia upon death is that I hope the Cop is born under a lucky sign, else the mob is winning the charm.
Click to expand...

Post 13 agrees with you pre-game :smiley:


 
Well, from the looks of it, the two non-CD mafia had opportunity to be active the first night, but the CD was AWOL. However, I couldn't get a lynch on it. Maybe next time people will listen, especially if I make a better approach.
 
I didn't know you were the other mason xduckster, but it was obvious Jaedhann was a mason when we lynched him.

skoolbus said:
As everyone leaves, a careful observer would notice the peculiar absense of one member of the town...

Jaedhann was lynched.
Click to expand...

And I don't know if I was the first (well, technically second, since you already knew xduckster) to figure it out, but I was the first to post anything about it.

goltar25 said:
Now who would the missing person be? Being a peculiar absence, I doubt it's CDRToast, as his absence is to be expected. The only other logical scenario I can see would be if Jaedhann was a mason and the other mason wasn't present.
Click to expand...

Oh, and if reveals are done next time, I like how skoolbus did the one about Jaedhann, make it something not too obvious, but a good hint. Or what I had suggested before the game, wait a few days before revealing.



 
I was concentrating on other people at the time. I don't think I can stress how important Sint's lynch was...

I also happened to mention SiTro twice in the will by mistake, meant Cygnus the second time, but oh well...

EDIT:

Rashiminos said:
I'll just say you mentioned muzzz only once in that way.
Click to expand...

I believe it was mostly ignored?



 
I kind of screwed up the murder on night one. Sint pm'ed a list to me and the other mafia I believe stating who he wanted to murder, I can't remember the wording because I deleted it several weeks ago, but I should have just gone with what he said when I didn't hear from the others.

Also, Sir Lister was the doctor and Jrla was the vigilante.
 
Dang, I had Moar and Sint, no clue on Muzz... wtg mafia

Next round, let's have quicker days, and reveals... town hasnt won in three tries :-/

If not reveals... how about no PMing except to the DM? That makes it possible to read into people's comments intead of simply guessing right left and center.
 
Darn, I thought that the townies going to win when Godfather Sint was finally taken out and Moar also. I guess getting the last one is always the most difficult.

Officer Nikon was right but no one listened ... Shame! :tongue:

I agree that role reveal and/or lynch by most votes at deadline would help the townies get a fighting chance. Those no lynch days really killed them (pun intended).
 
Zhao_Yue said:
Darn, I thought that the townies going to win when Godfather Sint was finally taken out and Moar also. I guess getting the last one is always the most difficult.

Officer Nikon was right but no one listened ... Shame! :tongue:

I agree that role reveal and/or lynch by most votes at deadline would help the townies get a fighting chance. Those no lynch days really killed them (pun intended).
Click to expand...

I was trying to tell them to lynch every day...

And I don't think someone has confirmed Nikon being the cop...


 
Congrats to Jaago, muzzz and Nikon ... well played.

I dug up my last post:

I have no problems lynching Jaago. I also think Sint is innocent. The quieter ones are also on my suspicious list: muzzz, moar, skunk.

Vote Jaago.
Click to expand...
Voted to lynch the VI, missed Sint completely, but got the other two mafia right :smiley:

Who was the cop, and whom did (s)he identify each night? Who was the witness? The townies with roles didn't show up at all, and that defnitely hurt us.

I'm in for the next round. Hopefully we can make it go a bit quicker. Only the first 2-3 days need to be long, methinks.

Edit: If Nikon was the cop, he has no business gloating. He REALLY blew it ...
 
Last edited:
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top