Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

[Malevolent]

to sum it up for you phar, before i go out for the day-

1- dj claims rolecop and says i am mr freeze, then votes me
2- i try to open his mind to other possibilities
3- he ignores me and persists
4- i explain more thouroughly , ask him questions and counter attack/vote
5- he ignores and persists
6- i try to get him to awnser question
7- he is still ignoring

see the general trend?

 

[Malevolent]

i have to go out for the next few hours,
still want these question awnsered DJ
1- why did you claim so early?
2- you said you thought i was town, why investigate me then?

 

[coju]

I'm confused with this exchange.

I followed it purrfectly.

 

[Kestegs]

@kestegs- when somebody claims to know my role and then votes me, its hardly rolesishing for me to say rolecop....

@dj- i can understand, and tbh in your position i would probably do the same thing if i got the results that you have. I just ask that you consider that this game is probably very role-heavy, and there are many many possibilities why you think i am the freeze guy.

also- if you got the impression that i am town yesterday then why did you investigate me? seems like a large amount of you case is flawed

He didn't even claim role cop. Role chip wouldn't even give they kind of info anyways. You also assume thus hadn't is very power role heavy. You shouldn't have that kind of information unless you are on a team of people.

AAAAND- dj, if you really are a sane town rolecop, then why would you claim so early? wouldnt youwait till you had more infoirmation first? because now i highly doubt you will survive very long in this game, and not be very helkpful to the town.

and as we all know- rolecop is a role usually given to the mafia, while town cops get alignment cops.
This makes me think that you looked around your scum-buddies, saw that you were missing the iconic villian Mr Freeze, and decided to claim rolecop so you could get an easy townie lynch today. you even chose a relatively weak player like me so it would be easier to convince the rest of the town to get me....

Vote: djmbbandie

And there it is. You fought it as long as you could, but you just had to call him scum and vote. You move from he's a confused townie to being convinced he's scum in a matter of a paragraph. Your second paragraph is about the most illogical reasoning I've seen. If DJ is scum he's almost guaranteed to either get lynched today or tomorrow with that claim.

And I just don't see DJ trying to pull off this extremely high risk gambit.

 

[Caluin Graye]

soft claiming rolecop eh?

AAAAND- dj, if you really are a sane town rolecop, then why would you claim so early?

and as we all know- rolecop is a role usually given to the mafia, while town cops get alignment cops.
This makes me think that you looked around your scum-buddies, saw that you were missing the iconic villian Mr Freeze, and decided to claim rolecop so you could get an easy townie lynch today. you even chose a relatively weak player like me so it would be easier to convince the rest of the town to get me....

@kestegs- when somebody claims to know my role and then votes me, its hardly rolesishing for me to say rolecop....

thanks for COMPLETELY IGNORING MY QUESTION BTW
tbh, you do you to admit that rolecops are 95% of the time scum. and i am not letting you off the hook so easily , awnser the questios...

1- dj claims rolecop and says i am mr freeze, then votes me

I count five times you call DJ a rolecop. I count zero times where DJ claims rolecop. There are a myriad of ways that DJ could have gotten his information, some common, some possibly unique to this game. Yet you focus specifically on the scenario that DJ is a rolecop. Why is this?

@dj- i can understand, and tbh in your position i would probably do the same thing if i got the results that you have.

If you agree with the actions that DJ has taken thus far, then why are you so adamant that he rethink his actions?

 

[Noodle]

Meow.

I followed it purrfectly.

Did we just see competing Catwoman claims?

 

[coju]

Did we just see competing Catwoman claims?

i guess so, as i was copying bambi

 

[djmbbandie]

Point number one: I have no idea how to play this role

Point number two: I'm helping the town. How about you?

Point number three: If I have to pull a Leo, I will.

 

[Kestegs]

What's a Leo?

I hope you're not going to flash us, that only works for Leo.

 

[Goryani]

So... it goes T N D T N D etc?

View attachment 4308 ?

 

[pharphis]

View attachment 4308 ?

lol close enough.

 

[Goryani]

@bipolar- any chance you could provide some reasoning for your vote yesterday?

The vote in 242?

 

[Goryani]

It's kinda weird too, because reading through all your posts yesterday you seemed pretty town. Of course this could be a mafia tactic, but I'm on my second game, so I still really don't know how to play well .

Did you interrogate Malevolent because be seemed pretty town yesterday? Did you do whatever it is you may have done to Malevolent because he seemed pretty town yesterday?

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Point number three: If I have to pull a Leo, I will.

LOL. As mod of this game I am so telling leo on you.

 

[thefranklin]

I am entertained. My thoughts will start with me a bit longer, don't want to give away any ideas.

 

[pharphis]

LOL. As mod of this game I am so telling leo on you.

mod confirmed role that dj is role cop, or something!!!!!!111111!!

Yes, I'm just kidding.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Yeah that post doesn't confirm anything, nice try pharphis.

I'm not sure what a "pull a leo" is but I'm sure her response will be priceless.

 

[Valhauros]

Djmbbandie's "Care to enlighten me about your freeze ray?":
I assume you saw him use this "Freeze Ray", so I assume he's Mr. Freeze. Do you know his target?

Malevolent's "I must have been bussed or something":
I think this is were you made your slip. I can't believe that you trust that claiming to have been bussed, after been barely prodded, and with so little information, is going to work. A definitive despair move.

Malevolent's "When somebody claims to know my role and then votes me, its hardly rolefishing":
He didn't claim to know your role. He claimed to know your action made the previous phase. You shout "Role cop" without addressing what a Role Cop does. Give it up, you were caught and now you must pay.

Malevolent's "As we all know, rolecop is a role usually given to the mafia":
Bold statement, but made with the sole purpose to shift the direction of the discussion. I'm not certain that you are mafia, but you're the best bet for today's lynch. If you turn town, then we have a locked down scum in Djmbbandie.

Vote: Malevolent.

Djmbbandie's "Point number three: If I have to pull a Leo, I will":
You will have to elaborate a bit.

 

[Malevolent]

i will admit that i have played a very aggressive defence, however my points are still valid.

 

[djmbbandie]

I did it off a hunch I got when he got mad that I interrogated him yesterday. I was thinking that I might not live through twilight because I posted so few times and the mafia tend to kill either new people or strong players...

@ Val: I have no idea what his target is. I just know he has a freeze ray.

Oh, and read up the second game ( I think Leo played in). It has something to do with Krazyivan.

Sorry Leo! I'm a noob at this too!