Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

Malevolent said:
well, i know that 4 mafia is standard for a 20 man game, so the extra 3 people might give an extra mafia, howver 6 is probably possible, i think that 7 is excessive though.
Click to expand...

4 scum in 20 is on the low end. Very low. If there are only 4 mafia then there will be almost as many neutrals. Or a second mafia. Or a SK.

Malevolent said:
if mafia dont know each other yet then then we are able to interrogate without fear that the mafia can control it as easily you say, and we might acatually have a mafia up for interrogation/prosection, if hey DO know each other then you are correct, and we really cant expect to get a scum lynch tommorow with that system.
Click to expand...

There was a gap between when role PMs were sent and when twilight started. I'm sure flubb remembers it. I think that gap was approximately the length of a normal night phase. I will assume mafia were chillaxing and plotting in their QT unless Pyro tells us otherwise.
 
I wouldn't assume they got to talk before twilight, but I've never been on a scum team where I didn't know my partners names.
 
I don't know if I should be glad or offended that I haven't been chosen for interrogation.

It's not like I have become good at fooling everyone or anything.
 
bipolar chemist, i re-looked through your posts and not one of them has anything valid or reasoned in it, its all complete garbage, then you place an unreasoned vote. EXPLAIN YOURSELF ( yeah val's post was fairly scummy, but a quote and vote aint gonna cut it mate)

Interrogate: BipolarChemist
 
Oh holy crap, the twilight phase had some action in it. I've been busy hauling the rest of the snow off from around the house and watching after gf's kid, I'll read up later tonight (hope there's still time?)
 
just beware that i am going to sleep now, and i probably wont wake up before day end, hope nothing important happens over night.
 
Goryani said:
The who is the most important part. The who will decide the if. Who can be prosecuted? That will be decided by a plurality vote and it's clear not everyone is using the plurality vote as a plurality vote.
Click to expand...

So you would rather discuss the mechanic than have input on who we choose? Sounds scummy.

What if the two we choose from tomorrow were up to my sole discretion? Would you not want to give me your input? Would you refuse to vote tomorrow because you (if you are town) don't know my alignment?
 
Gwaihir said:
...................

So what exactly were you trying to do with that post?



How did you arrive at the 4-5 mafia estimate?
How would knowing if mafia receive names change your opinion on how to use interrogate?
Click to expand...
Malevolent's fuzzy math leaves me scratching my head as well, and also because I read Goryani's post restating usual ratio. Also the whole concept of asking if mafia are or have ever been in touch with each other sounds so much like a dumb blond act. I can hardly focus from the rolling of the eyes.

Jason Maher said:
I have a similar feeling about Interrogate this game. I think the only way mafia is subject to prosecution tomorrow is if there are separate mafia teams. Some are treating interrogate as a normal vote (majority vote rules). Some are treating it as an investigation tool. Some are treating it as a joke vote. I don't think anyone is treating it as a plurality lynch vote.

All well and good, but is there a point lost in there somewhere? What do you actually advocate that we do?
Click to expand...

So you think there are multiple mafia?


Go on.....seems plausible. Would multiple serial killers be too far fetched? I did see Valhaurous has shown his baby killin' face...;)

Goryani said:
4 scum in 20 is on the low end. Very low. If there are only 4 mafia then there will be almost as many neutrals. Or a second mafia. Or a SK.



There was a gap between when role PMs were sent and when twilight started. I'm sure flubb remembers it. I think that gap was approximately the length of a normal night phase. I will assume mafia were chillaxing and plotting in their QT unless Pyro tells us otherwise.
Click to expand...

I'm sorry, what was that??

I couldn't hear you.

Someone was kicking me while I was down.....

Have some more snow!!
 
thefranklin said:
So you would rather discuss the mechanic than have input on who we choose?
Click to expand...

Incorrect. I would rather discuss the mechanic than not discuss the mechanic. I would rather discuss the mechanic before giving input.

thefranklin said:
What if the two we choose from tomorrow were up to my sole discretion? Would you not want to give me your input?
Click to expand...

In that case I'd say create some ties to have the widest possible pool for prosecution tomorrow. I thought Mal's idea was brilliant.

thefranklin said:
Would you refuse to vote tomorrow because you (if you are town) don't know my alignment?
Click to expand...

Nope. D1 has real votes and therefore real reactions and therefore real scumhunting.
 
Goryani said:
D1 has real votes and therefore real reactions and therefore real scumhunting.
Click to expand...

There hasn't been any scumhunting going on today/twilight? Or just by you?
We've all just been waving our whistles around tooting them, I guess.

On the topic of spam and OT during day one, I've recently acquired a new whistle, and let me tell you, I thought I had been given a fake one since there wasn't a little metal ball in there and the coach was tooting his like no other. It wasn't until I big bad wolf'd it that I was able to really make some noise. That learning experience may actually come into play this game.
Oh, remember this song?
 
(that's so creepy, all those people 'dancing' and 'jigging'. I wouldn't recommend watching that version of the 'song')
 
Goryani said:
There was a gap between when role PMs were sent and when twilight started. I'm sure flubb remembers it. I think that gap was approximately the length of a normal night phase. I will assume mafia were chillaxing and plotting in their QT unless Pyro tells us otherwise.
Click to expand...

No discussion was allowed before game start.

Count as of #192:
Noodle(3): JasonMaher, Bad Ash, Drixx
BipolarChemist(3): crawlingdeadman, pharphis, Malevolent
Bad Ash(2): coju, Noodle
omgwtfbbqpwned(1): flubbucket
crawlingdeadman(1): Solar Ice
Drixx(1): thefranklin, (Goryani)
Solar Ice(1): FredOfErik
Valhauros(1): BipolarChemist
 
Pyrotechnician said:
No discussion was allowed before game start.

Count as of #192:
Noodle(3): JasonMaher, Bad Ash, Drixx
BipolarChemist(3): crawlingdeadman, pharphis, Malevolent
Bad Ash(2): coju, Noodle
omgwtfbbqpwned(1): flubbucket
crawlingdeadman(1): Solar Ice
Drixx(1): thefranklin, (Goryani)
Solar Ice(1): FredOfErik
Valhauros(1): BipolarChemist
Click to expand...
This is what I thought.

Gory, have you ever seen a game without an announced night start where mafia had time to chat before the game began? I've yet to see something like that, though I've played way fewer games than you.
 
flubbucket said:
Malevolent's fuzzy math leaves me scratching my head as well, and also because I read Goryani's post restating usual ratio. Also the whole concept of asking if mafia are or have ever been in touch with each other sounds so much like a dumb blond act. I can hardly focus from the rolling of the eyes.
Click to expand...
my bolding

Agreed entirely.

Thoughts, male?
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top