Gods of Ancient Greece. Forum mafia game.

Explanation being the mafia are wiped out most likely. Tomorrow we should have two night kills is my guess from two serial killers. Just my theory though
 
FredOfErik said:
This. Every role revealed so far has been a power role -> our claimed watcher has not seen a single night action in 5 attempts. I'm having a hard time believing this.
Click to expand...

What's so difficult to believe about this? There have been many claims of X-shot abilities, it's not like everybody has a PR and is using it every night, unless you think otherwise?
 
pharphis said:
Meant to ask this yesterday.
Zokar, who do you think is town? If you already answered korial then I missed it.
Who do you think is scum?


@all, do we have any explanation of why there were no NKs?
Click to expand...

Town, I have no clue other than me (not that anybody believe that anyway lol)
You and FoE I do not think are mafia, though that does not exclude either or both of you being SK.
Scum, everybody who is pushing hard to lynch me for the last few days.
 
Bad Ash said:
Explanation being the mafia are wiped out most likely. Tomorrow we should have two night kills is my guess from two serial killers. Just my theory though
Click to expand...

what makes you think this? If JCakes was the last mafia, then there is no benefit for him to say anything about his thoughts about SKs, it would seem likely that he said what he said to help the last remaining mafia member(s) by saying what was said but still not risking any of his remaining faction.
 
Zokar said:
Why would you have preferred me to watch BA? Did you plan on doing something to him? Did you assume he was the best target or something?
Click to expand...

The first and third questions have the same answer. He is a claimed mason and has access to the names of the dead. Your last two watches are so much closer to being scum than they are town.

If you don't think he is the most important town right now, then you either think he is scum or you are scum yourself. This goes for everybody, really.
 
well no kill tonight would lean towards mafia being dispersed. Other reasons possible? Sure, but it is also possible all the groped mafia are gone.

we had 4 night kills one night, than 3 on the other night. Moar is an "every other" voter apparently, which opens the door to "every other" actions as well.

its just a theory, but I believe it to be true.

I could be persuaded to let zokar live because I am finding a lot of other people scummy and am fairly confident based on the kills that we arent hunting 1 person anyway. If zokar is town we have 2 more deaths tomorrow if my theory is true and then we are in trouble.
 
Zokar said:
In what way?
Click to expand...

Well, they both are up there on my scum list. Go back and look at things. Take a closer look at FoE especially. Who do you think is scum right now? My top three are FoE, Korial, Pharphis. Yet those are the most town to you. I can believe all of you being on the same team, opposing CG, JCakes, Gory, etc. Your team gets two kills every other night. Sounds plausible.

Zokar said:
I am not convinced he is town.
Click to expand...

How long ago did he claim and spew out the names of the dead? There are two possibilities to explain the perception of his claim: 1. There is one mafia and they killed everyone, and he is a part of that or 2. He is telling the truth.

How can we come to that conclusion? If he was bs'ing us on his names, the real killers would be trying to lynch him like crazy because they know it would bring them a ton of town cred.
 
thefranklin said:
How long ago did he claim and spew out the names of the dead? There are two possibilities to explain the perception of his claim: 1. There is one mafia and they killed everyone, and he is a part of that or 2. He is telling the truth.

How can we come to that conclusion? If he was bs'ing us on his names, the real killers would be trying to lynch him like crazy because they know it would bring them a ton of town cred.
Click to expand...

So, if he's telling the truth that makes him town?
Why can't a SK tell the truth in this situation?
Or is the assumption that SKs with his ability is OP and so you're excluding him from being SK on that basis?
 
FredOfErik said:
Well, this is conveniet.

Thanks for the kind words CG, however:

Vote: CG

I am Ares.

I would describe my role as a sort of JOAT. Amongst other one shot abilities I am one time lynch immune and (was) a one time coroner - hence my questions about reads on dead people yesterday. I have more abilities, but since knowing more details shouldn't benifit town in anyway, I'm gonna keep them to myself for know. I decided to use the coroner ability last night, partly because of our complete lack of information, partly because of this quote by what I thought was a dying man:



I had a real hard time deciding on which of the 4 kills from N2 to decide on. I ended up on CG, somewhat randomly, somewhat because of the answers I received to my question yesterday.

I was told that he is Cronos, Mafia Bodyguard.
Click to expand...

pharphis said:
I can believe that! teehee

Vote: Caluin Graye
Click to expand...

1. Why would FoE claim one time lynch immune? Why would a townie need that?
2. Couple that with Pharphis's ability to screw with investigations. Do you really think that is one shot?
3. Pharphis's vote came instantly after FoE's claim. Strangely, this is also after he caught JCakes fake claiming. Why in the world would one townie trust another person with a claim like that before something he did himself and knows for sure?

I am not sure which one to vote for. Almost.

Vote: FredOfErik
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top