Gods of Ancient Greece. Forum mafia game.

I think you should at the very least tell us who you've targeted on previous nights. If you're not, you're essentially hiding information the town needs to make connections between players.

It even helps us narrow down the hitman of a given night by 1 player, which is becoming more and more important.
 
Not acceptable at this stage of the game. You theoretically have two people who have not performed night actions and that's two people who can be cleared on the list of players. I don't even think coming forward at this time will change my opinion of you

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
 
Thought:
Maybe Gory was multi-shot vig but was redirected? That could help explain an extra kill.
If we already have a dead bus driver it could be 1-shot.
I see no WIFOM for a role able to detect night kills being alive over a lurker like corax and a who the heck knows what with Ankeli when a bus driver is reportedly already dead and there are 3 deaths during a night which almost guarantees no doc save considering at least 1 confirmed mafia is already dead.
Who said a bus driver was dead?


Zokar, did you get a result other than "no action" last night?
 
Re: Information

Alive players:
1. kestegs
2. Bad Ash
3. Pyrotechnician
4. Jcakes
5. FredOfErik
6. korialstraz
7. thefranklin
8. pharphis
9. Zokar
10. Moar
11. Laarz

Dead Players:
1.Gwaihir - Killed on Night 1
2.Leopold Stotch - Killed on Night 2
3.Solar Ice - Killed on Night 2
4.Sathoris - Killed on Night 2
5.MartinLong - Killed on Night 3
6.Caluin Graye - Cronus / Mafia Bodyguard / Anti Town - Lynched on Day 3
7.Goryani
8.Ankeli
9.corax

TC, is there a reason that it doesn't say "killed N4" next to Gory, Ank and Corax?
I haven't really been paying attention to the details in that list until now, and I'm just making sure you either forgot or were just waiting to add in the details.
 
I think you should at the very least tell us who you've targeted on previous nights. If you're not, you're essentially hiding information the town needs to make connections between players.

It even helps us narrow down the hitman of a given night by 1 player, which is becoming more and more important.

Oops. I think I confused Tracker and Watcher here.
I still think the information is extremely helpful, if not as direct as tracker info would be.

Also, I don't know if I actually typed this yet, but we need to know who YOU think is worth watching, and ask you questions. We need connections between you and other players, and if you give us nothing and are killed, what will the town have to show for it?
 
Fine....

MartinLong -> nobody visited
Goryani -> unable to watch
Zokar -> nobody visited
FredOfErik -> nobody visited
pharphis -> tell you next game day if I'm alive
 
Lol. Ridiculous. On many levels. Phar and zokar are telegraphing scum connection. This game is crazy with the night kills. I have too many people I think are scummy and that included foe and phar before you posted that.

Hermes was the apparent bus driver so you can try to think of another excuse o
Phar if you can

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2
 
Re: Information

TC, is there a reason that it doesn't say "killed N4" next to Gory, Ank and Corax?
I haven't really been paying attention to the details in that list until now, and I'm just making sure you either forgot or were just waiting to add in the details.

one of them will probably come back to life tomorrow and he just doesn't want to have to edit more than he needs to LOL!!
 
Lol. Ridiculous. On many levels. Phar and zokar are telegraphing scum connection. This game is crazy with the night kills. I have too many people I think are scummy and that included foe and phar before you posted that.

Hermes was the apparent bus driver so you can try to think of another excuse o
Phar if you can

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

Sorry if I missed it, but who told us Hermes was a bus driver? how do we know?

Another excuse? I'm bouncing around ideas because it's just the two or three of us tonight. Do you have any better ideas?


Zokar,
Are you not going to tell us at the end of today after everyone is done claiming their actions, assuming anyone claims actions?
 
Zokar,
Are you not going to tell us at the end of today after everyone is done claiming their actions, assuming anyone claims actions?

I just posted my results.
I'll post results first post of each day.
You all can do with that whatever you want.
 
Re: Information

TC, is there a reason that it doesn't say "killed N4" next to Gory, Ank and Corax?
I haven't really been paying attention to the details in that list until now, and I'm just making sure you either forgot or were just waiting to add in the details.

Yes, there is a reason. I forgot :)
 
Hey, most of my argument has already been stated.

1. Z is a watcher. There was already a mafia bodyguard, so they have some power roles.
2. Withholding his targets. He doesn't want to be tracked or found out in any way, like a role that tells someone all of whom was targeted last night.
3. He is still alive, with as many kills as there are, there would have been some 33% chance that Z would have watched one of them (and this number goes up higher if scum have other targeting roles). That risk is too high to let Z live when we all know Cakes is a lynch today.

Vote: JCakes

4. No scum hunting, only role fishing and defensive posting. Within 20 minutes he can post something to my snide remark above, yet has offered nothing all game.
5. He is still alive, ML, Corax, Ank were all killed before a claimed town watcher, hilarious. Plus, do you think any of his watches were successful, especially with Corax and Ank going down?
6. Calling out a watched target, great job. Just trying to find something lamist to put in there.
 
These night killings are getting out of hand. Tbh it's one of the wackier games I've been in so far (in terms of making sense of the night kills), so I can't make heads or tails of this.

I can't help but wonder if there should've been four kills tonight instead of 3. At least then it would be consistant. Or did we get a confirmation that the mafia bodyguard was elite mafia bodyguard (and thus 4 kills is the abnormal night)?

My brain is shutting down, time for some sleep. I'll be traveling to Oslo tomorrow, I've already informed TC about it, and will send him a PM if I feel I won't be able to contribute this day phase. Hopefully I can contribute a bit, but don't expect posts full of quotes, I'll be reading and posting from the phone a bit.

Paragraph 1: Hey guys, I'm town.
Paragraph 2: Trying waaaaaaay to hard to act like you don't know what is going on. I don't buy it, the town knows more than that. Why are you trying to portray that you know less than the town?
Paragraph 3: Safe travel.
 
Re: Information

Ok well I said I would be back to say who I think the SK is. I am sure you guys are just ignoring me, but I am going to post anyway (besides finding the SK is a common goal for mafia and townies).

My team has been responsible for one and only one kill each night.
N1 we killed Gwaihir
N2 we killed Sathoris
N3 we killed Martin Long
N4 we killed .... yeah like I'll tell you that :p

On N2 there was 4 kills one of them we were responsible for, one of them (SI) gory was responsible for and two of them were unknowns. I sent the kill in that night so CG was not killed by a PGO. The person I think killed him was the person who revealed his role the following reasons. I understand if you don't trust me, but if it gets to late in the game and he is still alive, don't give him a free pass like you did Val and SI.

I am Ares.

I would describe my role as a sort of JOAT.

I was told that he is Cronos, Mafia Bodyguard.

One Ares
wikipedia said:
he often represents the physical or violent aspect of war, in contrast to the armored Athena, whose functions as a goddess of intelligence include military strategy and generalship
Physical / Violent - fits SK better than a JoAT with coroner ability.

Two the Joat claim. We (the mafia) have already killed a JoAT, doubt there are two out there.

Three "Cronus, Mafia Bodyguard" - that is in exactly the same format as the night flips we get.

Vote: Caluin Graye

Yesterday, I asked TC what information would be revealed upon my lynch. He told me. It was more detailed than a shortened name. I have an X-shot ability. Not only would that have been revealed upon my lynch, but the X would be specified. To borrow from CG's cop example, my lynch would have revealed something similar to: 1-shot rolecop or 2-shot cop or 3-shot namecop.

CG's initial claim of elite bodyguard showed detail I was expecting. FOE's counterclaim of mafia bodyguard also showed detail I was expecting. CG's responses to FOE's counter-claim did not show detail I was expecting. Contrary to CG, FOE didn't back down from the detailed role name even when given a chance to. I believe FOE.

Four: Actually I think the reason Gory voted CG is the information was presented the same way his result from a kill was represented (remember he hadn't claimed vigi just yet) => looks more likely that FoE is the SK.

So JCakes is definitely scum.
Caluin Graye was Cronos
Leopold Stotch was Athena
Sathoris was Poseidon
Solar Ice was Hermes
Gwaihir was Apollo
Martin Long was Dionysus

JCakes gotta go. and yes that is Zeus only ability. So I am a sitting duck for sure.

Phar being bus driven is plausible, but it had to have been with someone who didnt die and gory is claiming it was solar ice so he didnt switch him with himself I guss. If theres another driver might be useful to get some more info on the matter.

Five :BA is already a coroner what need is there for a one-shot coroner. Admittedly FoEs ability gives more information.

Six: One other thing I will mention about the SK is it is likely they have 2-kills on the even nights and 0 on the odd, or there are two SKs that both only operate on even nights. (not to do with FoE, but relevant nonetheless).
Don't want to make it too easy for you. One thing I just noticed its after every day with multiple kids moar had a vote restriction. Coincidence? I think not. For the record we are only responsible for one kill per night

Oh please, I don,t even have a single kid!

Seriously, you are just trying to get me lynched again so you will live another day for your scum buddies?

My vote won,t count today, but I will cast it anyway, all of you can see that It,s true.

Could somebody please post a link to the claim list again. I lost it due to stupid network here and having to restart the iPad.

Vote: Jcakes

The only reason I bring it up is because of the coincidence between the timing of your post restriction and the extra night kills. If FoE is not SK then you are. The reason I brought you up first, is there is a chance that people tried to lynch you today. I think today you are less likely to be unlynchable.

Ok that is it on the SK stuff, just wanted to say this.

@Pharphis: I am so tempted to play another game, if I was guaranteed mafia I would just so I could clear my VENDETTA! That is twice in as many games that you caused my death......

JCakes gotta go. and yes that is Zeus only ability. So I am a sitting duck for sure.
Cakes has to go today, but I am going to wait to vote. I dont like FoE saying not to even though he flipped flopped.

Gory was Xena
Corax was Aphrodite
Ank was Prometheus.

I was also a part of a mason group. I am wondering if anyone else is? I am not revealing yet who was in it, and dont want anyone else to reveal who is in theres (yet)

One of my oddball theories is this is a game of masons and everyone is in a group. Want to see if it holds any water.

If gory was town I see absolutely 0 reason why he wouldnt kill JCakes. I dont like that whatsoever.

Korial is big on my scum list as well.

And now I see why you keep trying to convince us to kill you. You are part of a Mason group and not actually a coroner (just relay the info), I am guessing you have an on Death ability). Although you used the phrase were ... hmmm.


On Gory failing to kill me last night, it is funny you are overlooking the obvious way a mafia team stops peoples abilities :p. That is not to say we have that ability, but we may :p

Ok that's it goodbye everyone:wave:. Please don't ignore what I have to say about the SK, it is the one area we have a common goal.
 
Re: Information

Paragraph 1: Hey guys, I'm town.
Paragraph 2: Trying waaaaaaay to hard to act like you don't know what is going on. I don't buy it, the town knows more than that. Why are you trying to portray that you know less than the town?
Paragraph 3: Safe travel.

1: I've stated that earlier as well. Why point it out?
2: Because of the information overload. Haven't had time to sit down and read all of it properly. Also I never take notes, so I'm going off of what I have in my head.
3: Thanks! It's been snowing most of the day. So delays, slippery roads and all that funny stuff during winter times. >_<
 
Back
Top