Create Your Own Role Mafia game

[flubbucket1]

As I believe SI and Malev were scum I don't think we're in mylo.



Because no one wanted to copy Malev and spam worthless stuff. Odds are you're not the spammer today thought.

Vote: Moar



This still accurate, Flubb?

Those were the list of suspects from Solar Ice in the Night Chat.

I'm not really that convinced, no. He has an identical voting record to me I think, and I didn't disagree with any of the cases made. But the fact remains that he's helped convince people that people are scum and they've gotten lynched. That doesn't make him mafia though.

I do not agree this exonerates Caluin Graye....or you for that matter.

To an extent. It's either implied and will be proven when flubby and Sath post. Or, there is a liar amongst us.

A liar in a mafia game.....:surprise:

@Flubb, when you decide to post here. Want to give us an explanation for avoiding the thread?

I hope I can access the site when I get home today!!

Also I'm more akin to Mercutio (mindless babbling and all), so I'm neither a Capulet nor Montague....but I digress

Sathoris was my choice of King. If you look at my questions of him and his posts/voting, I became convinced of his townie-ness. I hate this seems rushed and is based on only one read through, but if I read something else later I will post again.


any questions I missed??

 

[Gwaihir]

Well, now that flubb has shown up, I should put out the question that I asked myself once the day started and CG pointed out Pyo was last laugh.

Why is flubb alive?

Put yourself in the shoes of mafia last night - 9 people left. They are not targeting themselves, so that leaves 6-7. Of those 6-7, they don't target the spammer, so that means 5-6. They don't want to target last laugh, bus driver, and possibly mime(depending on what it mimics). That means that as a random shot, odds seem to beonly 50-80% for actually permanently killing the target, and there is a chance it gets driven back on them.

So why would they not kill flubb?
1) flubb would not be driven, he claimed kingmaker
2) Nothing else could protect him, it would be a sure kill.
3) flubb has not had any pressure on him besides one poke by BA, so mafia would not want him alive for that
4) flubb was kingmaker - if they kill him and he chooses mafia as king, they may be able to use kingmaker today unknown if they can confuse cootie detector

Instead they took a chance on pyro. Turns out, he can make it back into the game. And while this is obviously not proof flubb is mafia, mafia generally try to avoid risks. My money is on flubb being mafia.

 

[Kestegs]

Those were the list of suspects from Solar Ice in the Night Chat.

I do not agree this exonerates Caluin Graye....or you for that matter.

A liar in a mafia game.....:surprise:

I hope I can access the site when I get home today!!

Also I'm more akin to Mercutio (mindless babbling and all), so I'm neither a Capulet nor Montague....but I digress

Sathoris was my choice of King. If you look at my questions of him and his posts/voting, I became convinced of his townie-ness. I hate this seems rushed and is based on only one read through, but if I read something else later I will post again.

any questions I missed??

I never meant to imply that it exonerates or condemns either one of us. Thought I made that pretty clear.

Well, now that flubb has shown up, I should put out the question that I asked myself once the day started and CG pointed out Pyo was last laugh.

Why is flubb alive?

Put yourself in the shoes of mafia last night - 9 people left. They are not targeting themselves, so that leaves 6-7. Of those 6-7, they don't target the spammer, so that means 5-6. They don't want to target last laugh, bus driver, and possibly mime(depending on what it mimics). That means that as a random shot, odds seem to beonly 50-80% for actually permanently killing the target, and there is a chance it gets driven back on them.

So why would they not kill flubb?
1) flubb would not be driven, he claimed kingmaker
2) Nothing else could protect him, it would be a sure kill.
3) flubb has not had any pressure on him besides one poke by BA, so mafia would not want him alive for that
4) flubb was kingmaker - if they kill him and he chooses mafia as king, they may be able to use kingmaker today unknown if they can confuse cootie detector

Instead they took a chance on pyro. Turns out, he can make it back into the game. And while this is obviously not proof flubb is mafia, mafia generally try to avoid risks. My money is on flubb being mafia.

That's an interesting idea, and fairly logical.

I would add that there is extra motivation to kill flubb as then whoever gets the king role wouldn't have to claim it.

 

[Gwaihir]

I never meant to imply that it exonerates or condemns either one of us. Thought I made that pretty clear.

That's an interesting idea, and fairly logical.

I would add that there is extra motivation to kill flubb as then whoever gets the king role wouldn't have to claim it.

Yeah see #4. Only thing that stops that is the cootie detector.

 

[MartinLong]

Sorry, this was bugging me.

http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/262200.html

Knowledge is power!

I am indeed the King. Don't think that changes anything. We agreed to switch the kingmaker out of the game to avoid a king to alter lynches. I suggest we proceed the way we intented. I won't alter a lynch unless we locked the spammer, or perhaps if I'm feeling vengeful, when I'm locked.

Nonetheless this shouldn't affect our normal scum hunting. Vote stays on moar for now, but these last pages have been interesting to read..

And which role should be brought back do you think?

Well I'm back from Denver (I could live there) :nod:

I had no access and for some reason was unable to get the site to pull up at home last night or this morning. I will start reading here at work while boss isn't looking and hopefully comment later.

Checks out.

Well, now that flubb has shown up, I should put out the question that I asked myself once the day started and CG pointed out Pyo was last laugh.

Why is flubb alive?

Put yourself in the shoes of mafia last night - 9 people left. They are not targeting themselves, so that leaves 6-7. Of those 6-7, they don't target the spammer, so that means 5-6. They don't want to target last laugh, bus driver, and possibly mime(depending on what it mimics). That means that as a random shot, odds seem to beonly 50-80% for actually permanently killing the target, and there is a chance it gets driven back on them.

So why would they not kill flubb?
1) flubb would not be driven, he claimed kingmaker
2) Nothing else could protect him, it would be a sure kill.
3) flubb has not had any pressure on him besides one poke by BA, so mafia would not want him alive for that
4) flubb was kingmaker - if they kill him and he chooses mafia as king, they may be able to use kingmaker today unknown if they can confuse cootie detector

Instead they took a chance on pyro. Turns out, he can make it back into the game. And while this is obviously not proof flubb is mafia, mafia generally try to avoid risks. My money is on flubb being mafia.

What do you mean he would not be driven?

I agree with the rest, but what still is on my mind is Kegs choice of Bussing.

A:Kegs
B:Moar
C: CG

Makes sense from a town POV that Moar would be B, so no one would die (claimed spammer). But CG as C? If CG was town, I would think that he would be high on the target list (what game was it where he died before speaking?).

Now there is two ways to look at this,
Kegs chose CG b/c he knows CG is scum and wouldn't be targeted, so Kegs safe
Kegs chose CG b/c he know CG won't be targeted, so Kegs is safe

That choice to me screams scum.

 

[Sathoris]

And which role should be brought back do you think?

Hardly relevant for today's lynch choice.

 

[Gwaihir]

What do you mean he would not be driven?

town bus driver would not select flubb.

flubb claimed kingmaker based on the plan that it could be removed from the game by Dr. Frank. A bus driver swapping flubb would be mafia trying to keep the king in the game.

I agree with the rest, but what still is on my mind is Kegs choice of Bussing.

A:Kegs
B:Moar
C: CG

Makes sense from a town POV that Moar would be B, so no one would die (claimed spammer). But CG as C? If CG was town, I would think that he would be high on the target list (what game was it where he died before speaking?).

Now there is two ways to look at this,
Kegs chose CG b/c he knows CG is scum and wouldn't be targeted, so Kegs safe
Kegs chose CG b/c he know CG won't be targeted, so Kegs is safe

That choice to me screams scum.

Interesting. kegs, why did you choose CG as a target?

 

[Gwaihir]

Hardly relevant for today's lynch choice.

True. I am more curious why you chose to bring back Paris over the other roles. Any particular reason?

 

[Sathoris]

True. I am more curious why you chose to bring back Paris over the other roles. Any particular reason?

Paris is a vanilla role that can't alter anything.

 

[Kestegs]

Knowledge is power!

And which role should be brought back do you think?

Checks out.

What do you mean he would not be driven?

I agree with the rest, but what still is on my mind is Kegs choice of Bussing.

A:Kegs
B:Moar
C: CG

Makes sense from a town POV that Moar would be B, so no one would die (claimed spammer). But CG as C? If CG was town, I would think that he would be high on the target list (what game was it where he died before speaking?).

Now there is two ways to look at this,
Kegs chose CG b/c he knows CG is scum and wouldn't be targeted, so Kegs safe
Kegs chose CG b/c he know CG won't be targeted, so Kegs is safe

That choice to me screams scum.

Who would you have chosen in my shoes?

town bus driver would not select flubb.

flubb claimed kingmaker based on the plan that it could be removed from the game by Dr. Frank. A bus driver swapping flubb would be mafia trying to keep the king in the game.

Interesting. kegs, why did you choose CG as a target?

Already explained that, go read it if you want to know.

 

[Moar]

Well, now that flubb has shown up, I should put out the question that I asked myself once the day started and CG pointed out Pyo was last laugh.

Why is flubb alive?

Put yourself in the shoes of mafia last night - 9 people left. They are not targeting themselves, so that leaves 6-7. Of those 6-7, they don't target the spammer, so that means 5-6. They don't want to target last laugh, bus driver, and possibly mime(depending on what it mimics). That means that as a random shot, odds seem to beonly 50-80% for actually permanently killing the target, and there is a chance it gets driven back on them.

So why would they not kill flubb?
1) flubb would not be driven, he claimed kingmaker
2) Nothing else could protect him, it would be a sure kill.
3) flubb has not had any pressure on him besides one poke by BA, so mafia would not want him alive for that
4) flubb was kingmaker - if they kill him and he chooses mafia as king, they may be able to use kingmaker today unknown if they can confuse cootie detector

Instead they took a chance on pyro. Turns out, he can make it back into the game. And while this is obviously not proof flubb is mafia, mafia generally try to avoid risks. My money is on flubb being mafia.

I can buy this. It would mean that Sathoris is mafia as well and we can't lynch tonight. I don't like no lynch days though it is a must if Gwaihir is right. The thing to figure out now is if Gwaihir is scum or not.

 

[thefranklin]

Knowledge is power!


And which role should be brought back do you think?

Checks out.


What do you mean he would not be driven?

I agree with the rest, but what still is on my mind is Kegs choice of Bussing.

A:Kegs
B:Moar
C: CG

Makes sense from a town POV that Moar would be B, so no one would die (claimed spammer). But CG as C? If CG was town, I would think that he would be high on the target list (what game was it where he died before speaking?).

Now there is two ways to look at this,
Kegs chose CG b/c he knows CG is scum and wouldn't be targeted, so Kegs safe
Kegs chose CG b/c he know CG won't be targeted, so Kegs is safe

That choice to me screams scum.

How are those notes working out for you? Don't worry, its a rhetorical question.

 

[thefranklin]

I can buy this. It would mean that Sathoris is mafia as well and we can't lynch tonight. I don't like no lynch days though it is a must if Gwaihir is right. The thing to figure out now is if Gwaihir is scum or not.

To me, if flub is dirty, Sath is more than likely not. Why would they have the choice of king out in the open like that? Why would Sath have removed the king from the game (unless he is lying about the Paris role, hmm). True that Gwahir could be making all that up as a long winded wifom thingy. I noticed he didn't vote for it, and it does seek like some good sound logic.

 

[MartinLong]

Hardly relevant for today's lynch choice.

Yet, relevant for tonight's Frankenstein.

town bus driver would not select flubb.

flubb claimed kingmaker based on the plan that it could be removed from the game by Dr. Frank. A bus driver swapping flubb would be mafia trying to keep the king in the game.

Rightio. Role switch. This makes your theory even more legitimate.

 

[Sathoris]

Yet, relevant for tonight's Frankenstein.

Okay, who do you want to bus tonight? Who do you want to take a DNA sample from? Who do you want to Mime tonight? What cards should the psychic give out? All relevant for tonight, right?

 

[MartinLong]

Who would you have chosen in my shoes?

Maybe something like:

A: Kegs
B: Moar
C: CG

My underlying assumptions:
I believe CG to be town (atm), CG would be a priority on scum hit list.
I believe you are scum.
And B, for safety, if Kegs is targeted, no one dies. This case would also say that Kegs was town as he would have been targeted by scum.

Already explained that, go read it if you want to know.

In the time it took you to write this, you could have explained your choice again. Why so difficult?

 

[MartinLong]

How are those notes working out for you? Don't worry, its a rhetorical question.

Here and there.

To me, if flub is dirty, Sath is more than likely not. Why would they have the choice of king out in the open like that? Why would Sath have removed the king from the game (unless he is lying about the Paris role, hmm).

I agree with this. It could also be the case that Sath and flubb are both scum, but for Sath to with 'town points' he will not interfere with his scum buddies death. It's a idea I'm throwing out there.

I think flubb is the best target for today all in all,
Vote: flubbucket

 

[Sathoris]

So flubb living through the night and picking me as king is more voteworthy than Moar's entire track record?

 

[MartinLong]

Okay, who do you want to bus tonight? Who do you want to take a DNA sample from? Who do you want to Mime tonight? What cards should the psychic give out? All relevant for tonight, right?

Please, do go on.... But I retract my previous statement. With you being 'King' today, when I wrote that message, I thought 'kingmaker' was still in the game. But it's not. This role just confuses me. :banghead:

 

[MartinLong]

So flubb living through the night and picking me as king is more voteworthy than Moar's entire track record?

I've never seen Moar as a likely suspect for scum. So, yes?