Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Alright this is going no where and its going there fast. We have less then an hour and a half. Is there anyone that is going to make a sound decision here so we don't have a no lynch situation?

Vote: Sathoris

I thought he was scummy yesterday and still don't feel good about him. I see Laarz as the next best if anyone sees that as a better option.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

kestegs said:
You are right on that reasoning I suppose. Gwihir is a much safer lynch and still offers us good info.
Click to expand...
Ahh, the "safer lynch" and "lynch for information" arguments.

Sathoris said:
This is all theoretical untill we reach the point where the mafia might outnumber town. In that case there aren't a lot of people left. In which case Gwaihir, if telling the truth, will work towards his own wincon and will play towards his wincon, not the town's. While a townie will always have the town's interest at heart. Town > Neutral
Click to expand...

Yes, but I hope the 'mafia might outnumber the town' scenario won't happen. Lynching a non-mafia Gwaihir actually helps that scenario come to pass. Town > Neutral >>>>>> Anti-town.

kestegs said:
Confirmed as having a cop roll, yes. Confirmed as being town, no.
Click to expand...

There was this one innocent investigation result that seems to say otherwise...

LozHinge the Unhinged said:
Top three town (obviously not including me)
<Pyro>

I actually don't have a top three town list, but if forced, I would include Pyro in this.
Click to expand...

What places Pyro on your top three town list (but only if you were forced to include three)?

flubbucket said:
RlyehExiled said:
Day 3
Bad Ash(0): [Ankeli]
Valharous(5): [Sath], Lozhinge the unhinged, [fred], noodle, [kegs],laarz, [koral], bad ash, Coju
Sathoris(0): [Pyrotech]
Coju(0): [Goryani]
Koral(9): fred, caluin graye, goryani, ankeli, sath, pyrotech, Kegs, Gwahir, Valhauros
Click to expand...
I find this worth pointing out. Valhauros was not mafia correct??
Click to expand...

I'm pretty sure all the votes for Val, aside from coju, occurred BEFORE Freddo claimed and shared the cop result of korial. I'm also pretty sure Val was 1 vote away from lynch/lock. I wonder how long Val was at L-1 (time wise). All it took was one more mafia vote, or one Gwaihir vote and this would be a much different game. One confirmed anti-town is on that list (korial). One possible anti-town is on the list (Noodle). Sath, Loz, keg, laarz have been fingered by multiple players as suspicious and they are all on the list. I think it possible that ALL remaining anti-town are on the list of players voting Valh.

Unvote: Pyro
Vote: kestegs

kestegs exhibits many behavior benefiting scum and he has more votes than Pyro. I'd still vote for Pyro. I'd also vote for Loz. I think one of the three is the best vote for today.

Caluin Graye said:
We don't know that. Some may assume that, but don't know it. What makes you positive he was not mafia? You have information available to you that we don't?
Click to expand...
I believe there was a cop result by coju.

LozHinge the Unhinged said:
When I voted Val, the feeling was that he was a good lynch target. IIRC, the next time I saw the thread, korial had been locked. <shrug>
Click to expand...
The town's feeling or YOUR feeling?

Gwaihir said:
Just saw this, I will read other posts after I respond.
1) Do my wards actually do anything - no, except possibly confuse people
2) Will I be informed when I win, if I am blocked, if I am bussed- I am informed as soon as I win. As for the others, he was unsure as he did not intend for me to have an informational role, but the info did directly relate to my win condition. He said he would try to figure out a compromise if it happened. (I did receive a pm on night 2 that I was blocked)
3) Can my role be stolen, and if it does do I retain my win condition - No comment (most worrisome answer ever)
4) Can I win after death (If I am dead and all other people have wards, if Ankeli's claimed power handed one out, etc) - No, I must be alive to win.
Click to expand...
Thanks. WHEN did you ask each question?



 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Well we need a lynch and I'm sure as hell not going to vote myself and Gwaihir seems to be off the table. Kestegs will do.

Unvote: Gwaihir
Vote: Kestegs
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

I am OK with a kegs lynch today. Or any lynch for that matter. I will vote switch as required - is there time? I think we are near day's end or is it another 24 hours?

To answer Gory's question, the town's. I have failed to get a decent read on anyone throughout this game.
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Goryani said:
I'm pretty sure all the votes for Val, aside from coju, occurred BEFORE Freddo claimed and shared the cop result of korial. I'm also pretty sure Val was 1 vote away from lynch/lock. I wonder how long Val was at L-1 (time wise). All it took was one more mafia vote, or one Gwaihir vote and this would be a much different game. One confirmed anti-town is on that list (korial). One possible anti-town is on the list (Noodle). Sath, Loz, keg, laarz have been fingered by multiple players as suspicious and they are all on the list. I think it possible that ALL remaining anti-town are on the list of players voting Valh.
Click to expand...

It looks like korial unvoted Val (705) before BA voted Val (711) and before FoE claimed (715). Therefore, Val was never at L-1 but he did spend a lot of time at L-2.



 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

LozHinge the Unhinged said:
I am OK with a kegs lynch today. Or any lynch for that matter. I will vote switch as required - is there time? I think we are near day's end or is it another 24 hours?

To answer Gory's question, the town's. I have failed to get a decent read on anyone throughout this game.
Click to expand...

Perhaps the Zoolander school could help...


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Laarz said:
Now thats just confusing again Gwaihir 4) Can I win after death (If I am dead and all other people have wards, if Ankeli's claimed power handed one out, etc) - No, I must be alive to win.
Click to expand...

Hmm I am trying to be clear. Again my win condition:

1) Be alive
2) everyone left has a holy ward

I specifically asked RE about condition 1, as condition 2 can happen if I am dead. His response was both need to exist concurrently.

Pyrotechnician said:
So are you saying you rather see the scum win?
Click to expand...

I just want to win, and if that mean everyone has to hold my wand, so be it.


Goryani said:
Thanks. WHEN did you ask each question?
Click to expand...

Not sure if pasting time stamps breaks no copy/paste pm rule, so not doing it. RE, could you rule on this?

Questions 1 and 2 were at the beginning of the game.
Question 3 and 4 were at the same time after you claimed role thief and Ankeli claimed Necromage.


 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

So you need to be alive at the end of the game? and everyone alive needs to have one of your wards?
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

kegs was not actually as high on my list as Sath, but if it means we get a lynch today, I would vote for him.

Vote:kestegs

I think that is L-1?
 
Re: Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

Gwaihir needs to be alive, and everyone else who is alive needs to have received a token from him. Then Gwaihir wins. Presumably the game carries on until the mafia are all dead or the mafia outnumber the living.

My interpretation. Maybe I got something right this game?
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top