OT: Mafia game
- Thread starter Aman
- Start date
Puresummon
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Well I am certainly open to suggestions. How was CC able to leave a note if he was killed? I am confused.
Well I am certainly open to suggestions. How was CC able to leave a note if he was killed? I am confused.
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
WOW
I sure wish IntelX would have put up a better defense! At least it looks like we are down to 1 killer?
Even though CC was wrong about IntelX, I do kinda agree about Sitro and the
Also wondering why Orphan is so quiet? He self proclaimed "Mason", but has yet to get it proved and has seemed to have quit posting?
WOW
I sure wish IntelX would have put up a better defense! At least it looks like we are down to 1 killer?
Even though CC was wrong about IntelX, I do kinda agree about Sitro and the
Should be no way to know who the bomb was unless he was going off someone else's previous post?
Also wondering why Orphan is so quiet? He self proclaimed "Mason", but has yet to get it proved and has seemed to have quit posting?
Re: OT: Mafia game
From my understanding, being a mason means that I cannot post the first vote on the day (being too tired). In the previous day no-one had posted a vote before I went to bed. Then it seemed like alot of people made posts and the night ended before I woke up the next morning. I was going to vote for IntelligentX in the previous day but I saw that the point was moot when I woke up anyway.
By my count we have the following people left:
Orphan
Sitro
PureSummon
Flip10thMtn
I've heard nothing of the roles of you three. Since we're nearing the end of the game, perhaps someone wants to post what their role and we might be able to work out who's townie and who's not.
From my understanding, being a mason means that I cannot post the first vote on the day (being too tired). In the previous day no-one had posted a vote before I went to bed. Then it seemed like alot of people made posts and the night ended before I woke up the next morning. I was going to vote for IntelligentX in the previous day but I saw that the point was moot when I woke up anyway.
By my count we have the following people left:
Orphan
Sitro
PureSummon
Flip10thMtn
I've heard nothing of the roles of you three. Since we're nearing the end of the game, perhaps someone wants to post what their role and we might be able to work out who's townie and who's not.
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Sitro/Orphan
Certainly not pointing fingers, just posting early thoughts of this day, hoping for answers and got them.
Orphan
I understand missing the vote due to RL, happened to me too.
Sitro
I expected you had garnered your belief in the bomb from a previous post(er) - just wanted to hear it from you.
Townies:
Sitro self-proclaimed way back in post #92
Orphan self-proclaimed Mason in #285
I don't think Pure has claimed anything, but I haven't checked the most recent posts.
I'm a plain Townie. I've kept my mouth shut to survive. As I said before it seemed those that posted alot were quickly eliminated, no matter what role they had.
Sitro/Orphan
Certainly not pointing fingers, just posting early thoughts of this day, hoping for answers and got them.
Orphan
I understand missing the vote due to RL, happened to me too.
Sitro
I expected you had garnered your belief in the bomb from a previous post(er) - just wanted to hear it from you.
Townies:
Sitro self-proclaimed way back in post #92
Orphan self-proclaimed Mason in #285
I don't think Pure has claimed anything, but I haven't checked the most recent posts.
I'm a plain Townie. I've kept my mouth shut to survive. As I said before it seemed those that posted alot were quickly eliminated, no matter what role they had.
Puresummon
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
The reason I have not claimed a role so far is that I am a pure townie and I have not had a reason to post it. At this point I just hope we can find something to go on and it turns out right.
The reason I have not claimed a role so far is that I am a pure townie and I have not had a reason to post it. At this point I just hope we can find something to go on and it turns out right.
Re: OT: Mafia game
Great, so we're 4 townies left. Perhaps Aman should finish the game now
Some quick thoughts.
And no, there's no-one left to verify my mason claim. I can say for certain that none of you three are masons because the others in my group are already dead. I was right in saying that Liquid fabricated the "autopsy" idenfitication of Zhao as a mason though.
Flip10thMtn, you seem to agree with alot of people. In Post 80, you've followed Thyiad's lead and voted for me (first vote). In post 234 you followed PureSummon's lead and voted for Vorstelman (second vote). In post 319 you followed CC's lead and voted for IntelligentX (third vote). It could be a tactic to stay under the radar, and probably something a mafia might do.
I'll post some thoughts on the other two later.
Great, so we're 4 townies left. Perhaps Aman should finish the game now
Some quick thoughts.
And no, there's no-one left to verify my mason claim. I can say for certain that none of you three are masons because the others in my group are already dead. I was right in saying that Liquid fabricated the "autopsy" idenfitication of Zhao as a mason though.
Flip10thMtn, you seem to agree with alot of people. In Post 80, you've followed Thyiad's lead and voted for me (first vote). In post 234 you followed PureSummon's lead and voted for Vorstelman (second vote). In post 319 you followed CC's lead and voted for IntelligentX (third vote). It could be a tactic to stay under the radar, and probably something a mafia might do.
I'll post some thoughts on the other two later.
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Orphan
I do admit to being a crowd follower... reason being (as stated before) this is my first game. My only other experience was as a spectator to a game quite a few months ago here in the Community Forum. I do not frequent the SP forum and didn't even know there were games going on there too.
Most players in this game seemed to know the others playing and were using (multiple) past games for thier "take" on others. I have no such experience so as a newb was relying on the more experienced for help. Unlike this game the previous game I watched (from afar) the roles were pre-set before "game-on" so at least you knew what you we up against. I had expected the same in this game but things had changed. No complaint, just a surprise to me.
As far as using "mafia tactics" - Again it's my first game, I really don't know who uses what tactics. From my point of view, trying to go through this logically - "he who posts alot dies". That has been show this entire game to be true. For proof, You, Pure and I haven't posted much and are still alive.
Orphan
I do admit to being a crowd follower... reason being (as stated before) this is my first game. My only other experience was as a spectator to a game quite a few months ago here in the Community Forum. I do not frequent the SP forum and didn't even know there were games going on there too.
Most players in this game seemed to know the others playing and were using (multiple) past games for thier "take" on others. I have no such experience so as a newb was relying on the more experienced for help. Unlike this game the previous game I watched (from afar) the roles were pre-set before "game-on" so at least you knew what you we up against. I had expected the same in this game but things had changed. No complaint, just a surprise to me.
As far as using "mafia tactics" - Again it's my first game, I really don't know who uses what tactics. From my point of view, trying to go through this logically - "he who posts alot dies". That has been show this entire game to be true. For proof, You, Pure and I haven't posted much and are still alive.
Puresummon
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Flip,
I can certiainly appreciate your position as this is also my first game. I have done alright following everything up until the last day or so. Now I essentially have no reads on anyone left alive, and I keep rereading the thread trying to pick something up to no avail.
Flip,
I can certiainly appreciate your position as this is also my first game. I have done alright following everything up until the last day or so. Now I essentially have no reads on anyone left alive, and I keep rereading the thread trying to pick something up to no avail.
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Orphan
To answer your questions more directly: (I'm going off memory, I'm at work and left my game notes at home)
1:
Post 80 I agreed with Thyiad and voted you. My only reason is stated in the header of the post "Mod VS Mod". Not a good reason but wanted to see what "Shook-out". I had plenty of time to change my vote. As the day progressed it seemed Liquid was a lock - I didn't agree (he had me fooled like the others) so I didn't change. Then at the last minute Nolecub got locked and I didn't agree with this either. I didn't figure an un-vote without a re-vote was worth it plus my vote was a "moot" - the only one left against you.
2:
Vorste coming out as "Cop" so early seemed odd (to more than just me), then he was caught lying. Pure just happened to post what I was thinking and I didn't really know which vote I was. I just though he was "dirty" and probably lying all along so voted him and didn't plan on changing unless something really solid came out.
3:
Non-vote I tried to check as much as I could but RL got in the way. I could have jumped on the band-wagon tail-end but Liquid was locked and had pretty much admited he was mafia. Didn't see the need.
4:
I actually found it difficult to read the previous posts(CC & IntX) before I voted. With all the copies and quotes I wasn't sure where the vote count was at but had a suspision of IntX. I voted at 11:44 (my time) with the game ending at 12:20. I just wanted to get my vote in before time ran out, I didn't realize I was the lock. Everyone has said the town "should" get a lynch in and that a "no lynch" is bad and that's why I did the late vote. I really though I was vote #2, not #3.
Orphan
To answer your questions more directly: (I'm going off memory, I'm at work and left my game notes at home)
1:
Post 80 I agreed with Thyiad and voted you. My only reason is stated in the header of the post "Mod VS Mod". Not a good reason but wanted to see what "Shook-out". I had plenty of time to change my vote. As the day progressed it seemed Liquid was a lock - I didn't agree (he had me fooled like the others) so I didn't change. Then at the last minute Nolecub got locked and I didn't agree with this either. I didn't figure an un-vote without a re-vote was worth it plus my vote was a "moot" - the only one left against you.
2:
Vorste coming out as "Cop" so early seemed odd (to more than just me), then he was caught lying. Pure just happened to post what I was thinking and I didn't really know which vote I was. I just though he was "dirty" and probably lying all along so voted him and didn't plan on changing unless something really solid came out.
3:
Non-vote I tried to check as much as I could but RL got in the way. I could have jumped on the band-wagon tail-end but Liquid was locked and had pretty much admited he was mafia. Didn't see the need.
4:
I actually found it difficult to read the previous posts(CC & IntX) before I voted. With all the copies and quotes I wasn't sure where the vote count was at but had a suspision of IntX. I voted at 11:44 (my time) with the game ending at 12:20. I just wanted to get my vote in before time ran out, I didn't realize I was the lock. Everyone has said the town "should" get a lynch in and that a "no lynch" is bad and that's why I did the late vote. I really though I was vote #2, not #3.
Re: OT: Mafia game
Well, I guess it's another non-vote for me, as I suspect the day will end before I get up tomorrow and based on how the mason role was handled in the previous games I cannot initiate a vote (and no-ones voted for anyone yet). I hope you guys get to lynch someone today, preferably a killer.
Well, I guess it's another non-vote for me, as I suspect the day will end before I get up tomorrow and based on how the mason role was handled in the previous games I cannot initiate a vote (and no-ones voted for anyone yet). I hope you guys get to lynch someone today, preferably a killer.
Re: OT: Mafia game
Oh, before I head to bed, my thoughts on the last two people:
Sitro, you've never really claimed to be a townie as far as I can remember. You're post at 92 is pretty much just a mock of Nolecub's claim at being a townie, and hardly something to hold to grain. Similar to Liquid_Evil's fabrication of Zhao being a mason, you seem pretty confident when you claim Dash was the bomb, though it could have been Spigot (unless I missed something that proved otherwise).
PureSummon, you've never really done anything to stand out to me, which makes me pretty suspicious at most, and wary at least. It's how some Mafia members have won the previous games, and it's one of the easiest (and unfortunately) most effective tactics of the game.
Basically, I'm suspicious of the lot of you :wink3:
Oh, before I head to bed, my thoughts on the last two people:
Sitro, you've never really claimed to be a townie as far as I can remember. You're post at 92 is pretty much just a mock of Nolecub's claim at being a townie, and hardly something to hold to grain. Similar to Liquid_Evil's fabrication of Zhao being a mason, you seem pretty confident when you claim Dash was the bomb, though it could have been Spigot (unless I missed something that proved otherwise).
PureSummon, you've never really done anything to stand out to me, which makes me pretty suspicious at most, and wary at least. It's how some Mafia members have won the previous games, and it's one of the easiest (and unfortunately) most effective tactics of the game.
Basically, I'm suspicious of the lot of you :wink3:
Re: OT: Mafia game
If only I could have come up with this sooner. Voting tables:
Day 1 (Nolecub, Doctor)
Liquid_Evil: Nolecub, Orphan, Vorstelman, Soylentred, DiiLegend, Kertin$
Orphan: Flip10thMtn
Nolecub: Liquid_Evil, BobTheWarrior, Ray Patean, Puresummon, Thyiad, Crowd Control, SiTro, Zhao_Yue
Not Voting: Intelligent X
Day 2 (Vorstelman, Paranoid cop)
Vorstelman: Liquid_Evil, Ray Patean, Crowd Control, BobTheWarrior, SiTro, Puresummon, Flip10thMtn
Liquid_Evil: Thyiad, Vorstelman, Orphan, Intelligent X, Soylentred
Day 3 (Liquid_Evil, Mafia)
Liquid_Evil: Ray Patean, Intelligent X, Crowd Control, Puresummon, SiTro, Orphan
Ray Patean: Liquid_Evil, BobTheWarrior
Not Voting: Flip10thMtn
Day 4 (Intelligent X, Townie)
Intelligent X: Crowd Control, Puresummon, Flip10thMtn
Not Voting: Orphan, SiTro
Day 5 (???)
???
I've bolded the names of those of us left alive. Odd to see our placing in the votes that lynched Liquid_Evil.
The name that stands out to me is that of Flip10thMtn. Day 1 he votes for someone based on Thyiads "Mod vs. Mod" post and leaves it there throughout the next half of the day as the only voter on Orphan. (Thyiad initially voted for Orphan, but changed to Liq, and finally to Nolecub) Day 2 he casts the vote on Vorstelman that lynched him. Day 3 he doesn't vote. It may be significant that on that day we lynched a mafioso, it could have been an intentional non-vote to try and stall the lynch train on his partner in crime. Yesterday he again casts the lynching vote on a plain townie. I don't think any of this behaviour has been helpful to the town, and comparing it to the voting strategies of the rest of us left alive, I believe you to be most likely to be mafia.
Puresummon, your thoughts?
Vote: Flip10thMtn
If only I could have come up with this sooner. Voting tables:Day 1 (Nolecub, Doctor)
Liquid_Evil: Nolecub, Orphan, Vorstelman, Soylentred, DiiLegend, Kertin$
Orphan: Flip10thMtn
Nolecub: Liquid_Evil, BobTheWarrior, Ray Patean, Puresummon, Thyiad, Crowd Control, SiTro, Zhao_Yue
Not Voting: Intelligent X
Day 2 (Vorstelman, Paranoid cop)
Vorstelman: Liquid_Evil, Ray Patean, Crowd Control, BobTheWarrior, SiTro, Puresummon, Flip10thMtn
Liquid_Evil: Thyiad, Vorstelman, Orphan, Intelligent X, Soylentred
Day 3 (Liquid_Evil, Mafia)
Liquid_Evil: Ray Patean, Intelligent X, Crowd Control, Puresummon, SiTro, Orphan
Ray Patean: Liquid_Evil, BobTheWarrior
Not Voting: Flip10thMtn
Day 4 (Intelligent X, Townie)
Intelligent X: Crowd Control, Puresummon, Flip10thMtn
Not Voting: Orphan, SiTro
Day 5 (???)
???
I've bolded the names of those of us left alive. Odd to see our placing in the votes that lynched Liquid_Evil.
The name that stands out to me is that of Flip10thMtn. Day 1 he votes for someone based on Thyiads "Mod vs. Mod" post and leaves it there throughout the next half of the day as the only voter on Orphan. (Thyiad initially voted for Orphan, but changed to Liq, and finally to Nolecub) Day 2 he casts the vote on Vorstelman that lynched him. Day 3 he doesn't vote. It may be significant that on that day we lynched a mafioso, it could have been an intentional non-vote to try and stall the lynch train on his partner in crime. Yesterday he again casts the lynching vote on a plain townie. I don't think any of this behaviour has been helpful to the town, and comparing it to the voting strategies of the rest of us left alive, I believe you to be most likely to be mafia.
Puresummon, your thoughts?
Vote: Flip10thMtn
Re: OT: Mafia game
Orphan: Too much faith in someone making up their own roles I think:
Orphan: Too much faith in someone making up their own roles I think:
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
Ok
My take:
Orphan comes out as a townie with a role on post 285. He should have been a target from then on - yet he's still alive? There's been 3 deaths since, why is he still alive?
I guess I don't have the "rule-book" because I don't see where a mason cannot vote first? They have the ability to talk with other masons during the night portion and that's it. Not a power role but a townie role none the less.
Sitro
I explained my votes to Orphan, I guess that's all I can do.
One thing in my defense:
The last person taken out was Crowd Control. He claimed
If I'm a killer, why would I eliminate someone who thinks I'm a townie?
I know it's a bit thin to accuse Orphan just because he's still alive, but that's all I can do for now;
Vote: Orphan
Ok
My take:
Orphan comes out as a townie with a role on post 285. He should have been a target from then on - yet he's still alive? There's been 3 deaths since, why is he still alive?
I guess I don't have the "rule-book" because I don't see where a mason cannot vote first? They have the ability to talk with other masons during the night portion and that's it. Not a power role but a townie role none the less.
Sitro
I explained my votes to Orphan, I guess that's all I can do.
One thing in my defense:
The last person taken out was Crowd Control. He claimed
If I'm a killer, why would I eliminate someone who thinks I'm a townie?
I know it's a bit thin to accuse Orphan just because he's still alive, but that's all I can do for now;
Vote: Orphan
Flip10thMtn
New member
Re: OT: Mafia game
SiTro
I think you missed my point? I'm not saying "Since CC thinks I'm a townie I must be one". I know he made mistakes as we all did.
I'm saying if I was mafia why would I kill him - He already thinks I'm a townie so you would think "logically" I'd want to keep him around?
Here's another post (#311):
I still think Orphan is pulling a "fast-one", and is our last Mafia. I'm keeping my vote.
SiTro
I think you missed my point? I'm not saying "Since CC thinks I'm a townie I must be one". I know he made mistakes as we all did.
I'm saying if I was mafia why would I kill him - He already thinks I'm a townie so you would think "logically" I'd want to keep him around?
Here's another post (#311):
I still think Orphan is pulling a "fast-one", and is our last Mafia. I'm keeping my vote.
