Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
- Thread starter Ray Patean
- Start date
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
Darn no editing....
We have Sin looking at those who voted early for Hey, looking to throw off suspicion, and you (me also) looking at those who jumped on the wagon late.
That got me thinking...who voted in the middle.....SiTro!!!!!! Care to defend yourself on positioning perfectly straddling the fence???
Anyways, I'm through listening to you aman. Just the fact that you are still alive bugs me enough.
Darn no editing....
We have Sin looking at those who voted early for Hey, looking to throw off suspicion, and you (me also) looking at those who jumped on the wagon late.
That got me thinking...who voted in the middle.....SiTro!!!!!! Care to defend yourself on positioning perfectly straddling the fence???
Anyways, I'm through listening to you aman. Just the fact that you are still alive bugs me enough.
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I merely pointed out you can't just look at one part of the vote. Im alive because the mafia can't risk not getting a kill and until they figure exactly what i am capable of it's best to leave me alone and try and strike at the right point.
You seem to be attacking quite a few people, almost like you are panicking.
From earlier, a no lynch would definitely not be in the interest of the town.
I merely pointed out you can't just look at one part of the vote. Im alive because the mafia can't risk not getting a kill and until they figure exactly what i am capable of it's best to leave me alone and try and strike at the right point.
You seem to be attacking quite a few people, almost like you are panicking.
From earlier, a no lynch would definitely not be in the interest of the town.
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
The town is too keen on flagging up where they voted on the Hey bandwagon.
"I can't be mafia, I voted for the last one!"
"I voted before you, I can't be mafia less!"
"No, I voted before that, too!"
"I voted first!"
"And I voted before that too!"
"...Shut up."
Seriously. Can I remind people that we've only found one mafia player so far, it's dangerous to assume that Ankeli was even anything but pro-town and that we can rest easy now.
We still have mafia players out there and even a lone agent is just as deadly as a group.
People need to find better ways of finding mafia than when and how they voted. Especially as the very start of a lynch train is the wrong place to look for a townie. Completely opposite, in fact.
I'm not disappearing from the game, don't worry - the town still has a chance. What I was suggesting to Soy was that we both stop arguing with each other because in all honesty I'm getting tired of explaining my thinking only to be met with the criticism that my logic is faulty. It's the only point she ever makes against me and the conversation was running in circles so much that someone had to end it at some point.
Unfortunately she doesn't seem the kind to forgive. Not only am I still being accused of accusing even after I unvoted her, she continues to insult me, essentially saying I'm stupid and unable to reason. IMO that's a pretty poor defense in these kinds of games. There's differences between believing someone to be a townie, finding someone suspicious and believing someone to be mafia. Unfortunately (for me at least, probably Zhao too), she doesn't seem to make this distinction.
My loss, I guess.
Soylentred:
You had no reason to drag me into this post at all except to further slander me. I have suggested to you already that we leave each other alone for the time being but you make no acknowledgement of that post and continue to fling these insults in my direction.
Please stop.
You've made your point. I'm a stupid dim-witted individual who is clearly reason deficient based on the fact that I happened to find some of your behaviour indicative of a mafia player.
But I've still contributed more to the town in this round than you have in two games. Even if we disregard the fact that you single-handedly gave the game to the mafia last round.
I suggest you stop harassing a decidedly pro-town player for simply trying to win the game and return to said activity yourself.
Once again, all the best.
SiTro.
The town is too keen on flagging up where they voted on the Hey bandwagon.
"I can't be mafia, I voted for the last one!"
"I voted before you, I can't be mafia less!"
"No, I voted before that, too!"
"I voted first!"
"And I voted before that too!"
"...Shut up."
Seriously. Can I remind people that we've only found one mafia player so far, it's dangerous to assume that Ankeli was even anything but pro-town and that we can rest easy now.
We still have mafia players out there and even a lone agent is just as deadly as a group.
People need to find better ways of finding mafia than when and how they voted. Especially as the very start of a lynch train is the wrong place to look for a townie. Completely opposite, in fact.
I'm not disappearing from the game, don't worry - the town still has a chance. What I was suggesting to Soy was that we both stop arguing with each other because in all honesty I'm getting tired of explaining my thinking only to be met with the criticism that my logic is faulty. It's the only point she ever makes against me and the conversation was running in circles so much that someone had to end it at some point.
Unfortunately she doesn't seem the kind to forgive. Not only am I still being accused of accusing even after I unvoted her, she continues to insult me, essentially saying I'm stupid and unable to reason. IMO that's a pretty poor defense in these kinds of games. There's differences between believing someone to be a townie, finding someone suspicious and believing someone to be mafia. Unfortunately (for me at least, probably Zhao too), she doesn't seem to make this distinction.
My loss, I guess.
Soylentred:
You had no reason to drag me into this post at all except to further slander me. I have suggested to you already that we leave each other alone for the time being but you make no acknowledgement of that post and continue to fling these insults in my direction.
Please stop.
You've made your point. I'm a stupid dim-witted individual who is clearly reason deficient based on the fact that I happened to find some of your behaviour indicative of a mafia player.
But I've still contributed more to the town in this round than you have in two games. Even if we disregard the fact that you single-handedly gave the game to the mafia last round.
I suggest you stop harassing a decidedly pro-town player for simply trying to win the game and return to said activity yourself.
Once again, all the best.
SiTro.
MassiveSin
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I was actually pointing to the coronor... they would know the roles of who was killed at night.... not a cop... you nvestagates the living
I was actually pointing to the coronor... they would know the roles of who was killed at night.... not a cop... you nvestagates the living
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I voted for Hey because I thought I could see what Aman was getting at. Then I went back and read through the thread again. Hey's behaviour did not match with what I expect from a townie.
So I voted for him.
After my vote, Hey's non-attempts at defending himself only helped to reassure me that it was the right choice. Although I hinted that I would have considered unvoting him, I was already too suspicious of him from his prior actions.
Could you explain why you find people in the middle of a vote suspicious? And I mean in a stronger sense than your last post. Until then I'm of the opinion that you decided you were going to paint me suspicious and then provide reasoning with that as a conclusion.
For reference, it's normally better to make your reasoning first and then check if there's anyone who fits your conclusions.
I voted for Hey because I thought I could see what Aman was getting at. Then I went back and read through the thread again. Hey's behaviour did not match with what I expect from a townie.
So I voted for him.
After my vote, Hey's non-attempts at defending himself only helped to reassure me that it was the right choice. Although I hinted that I would have considered unvoting him, I was already too suspicious of him from his prior actions.
Could you explain why you find people in the middle of a vote suspicious? And I mean in a stronger sense than your last post. Until then I'm of the opinion that you decided you were going to paint me suspicious and then provide reasoning with that as a conclusion.
For reference, it's normally better to make your reasoning first and then check if there's anyone who fits your conclusions.
MassiveSin
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
who investigates the living
who investigates the living
MassiveSin
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I do not know for certain, but I conclude since there was a power role such as the Crooked FBI agent a couter balance would be approprate.
I do not know for certain, but I conclude since there was a power role such as the Crooked FBI agent a couter balance would be approprate.
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
Ah. The fairness fallacy.
You're aware that each time in the past the Coroner role has been mentioned it was the creation of a mafia player?
I know I'll get slated for suggesting parallels between previous games, but it's been a grand day for references so far and apparently it's contagious.
If this idea offends you, ignore this post.
Ah. The fairness fallacy.
You're aware that each time in the past the Coroner role has been mentioned it was the creation of a mafia player?
I know I'll get slated for suggesting parallels between previous games, but it's been a grand day for references so far and apparently it's contagious.
If this idea offends you, ignore this post.
MassiveSin
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I'm not easily offened & you haven't done so.
You do have a habbit of bringing up past games for slighting targets or makeing points.
However,to you question, no I did not. I did not read other threads that in depth, I skimed (especially in SPF). And I would refer to it as a balancing fallacy not fairness. It would make sense with 2 roles the princess that when lynch criples the town and the FBI which also cripples their would be one for the town. It could be that the "deflector is this balance...*tips hat to Aman who wears that banner* but I was crossing my fingers for another...
I'm not easily offened & you haven't done so.
You do have a habbit of bringing up past games for slighting targets or makeing points.
However,to you question, no I did not. I did not read other threads that in depth, I skimed (especially in SPF). And I would refer to it as a balancing fallacy not fairness. It would make sense with 2 roles the princess that when lynch criples the town and the FBI which also cripples their would be one for the town. It could be that the "deflector is this balance...*tips hat to Aman who wears that banner* but I was crossing my fingers for another...
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I was being sarcastic. I dont like the fact that we are all over the place while the mafia (where ARE you Bob?) are sitting back laughing.
I was being sarcastic. I dont like the fact that we are all over the place while the mafia (where ARE you Bob?) are sitting back laughing.
ogogo on ice
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
Well, with all of the going ons, not sure I can find one person who tops my suspect list. But as I said earlier, Bob's massive absence is possibly hurting the town just as much I think. Hopefully I'll be able to check to see if he can explain himself before voting closes, but until then:
Vote: BobtheWarrior
Well, with all of the going ons, not sure I can find one person who tops my suspect list. But as I said earlier, Bob's massive absence is possibly hurting the town just as much I think. Hopefully I'll be able to check to see if he can explain himself before voting closes, but until then:
Vote: BobtheWarrior
Soylentred
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
Sorry I got accused of making suppositions based on previous games but I have to answer that. (you notice some get called out for the same things they do?)
The last game what I did won the game for the town except for the fact that the person I was told was townie was mafia. How can I be blamed for telling people to trust him when I was told by the host to trust him. Other than the traitor bit my actions sealed the win for the town.
I am not fighting with you - there is no point but please don't use your non logic on me anymore if you don't want me to call it non logic.
You were told what people thought of your chart earlier and you dragged it out again twice. I guess we disagree on your contribution when you refer to the chart as what you have to contribute.
And what I said was true - what spigot did was outline exactly what happened in an objective way.
Anyway -nuff said.
Sorry I got accused of making suppositions based on previous games but I have to answer that. (you notice some get called out for the same things they do?)
The last game what I did won the game for the town except for the fact that the person I was told was townie was mafia. How can I be blamed for telling people to trust him when I was told by the host to trust him. Other than the traitor bit my actions sealed the win for the town.
I am not fighting with you - there is no point but please don't use your non logic on me anymore if you don't want me to call it non logic.
You were told what people thought of your chart earlier and you dragged it out again twice. I guess we disagree on your contribution when you refer to the chart as what you have to contribute.
And what I said was true - what spigot did was outline exactly what happened in an objective way.
Anyway -nuff said.
Soylentred
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I agree we need a lynch and I am also irked by bob's non presence.....
vote BobtheWarrior
I agree we need a lynch and I am also irked by bob's non presence.....
vote BobtheWarrior
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
My final post this day during my invigorating cup of coffee, as I said earlier I can't spend a lot of time on this today.
Jaago needs to be unvoted so here
UNVOTE:JAAGO
Aman wouldn't say something like that without a reason.
On the Bobthewarrior bandwagon because he's not active,that's not enough reason for a vote now. Why not friedbanananaaaz for that matter, haven't seen much of him either. Maybe I even missed another non-cotributor while skimming, but I think we can base our vote on more than inactivity at this point.
About my hey-vote I hope it is clear why I postponed my voting for him, even in the final hours, I thought I could get more out of him after he had a good night sleep, and thought I could use the locking vote as leverage. But he had apparantly given up altogether before that. Before that I had doubts that we were just punishing someone who seems a bit younger than most.
My vote for this day (it will stay this way) will go to
vote:NOLECUB
for trying to force upon us the idea that there is only one mafioso left. Yeah, let's assume that and all claim our roles and weed out that one mafia now! Did noone see that action as suspicious?
Spigot, although your long post seems objective there are some assumptions in there that are not. I did not implie jaago was a traitor day one. Aman did not point to me as being the doctor in that post, he already cleared that up, but I thought that would be rather obvious, his post just followed after mine. I also did not hint at knowing something about jaago with the he who smelt it remark, I'm not the "big nose" this game, I just said it was convenient to point at a suspicious voting pattern of others first, clearing himself of suspicion in a "I admit it, so I'm clean" kind of way.
My final post this day during my invigorating cup of coffee, as I said earlier I can't spend a lot of time on this today.
Jaago needs to be unvoted so here
UNVOTE:JAAGO
Aman wouldn't say something like that without a reason.
On the Bobthewarrior bandwagon because he's not active,that's not enough reason for a vote now. Why not friedbanananaaaz for that matter, haven't seen much of him either. Maybe I even missed another non-cotributor while skimming, but I think we can base our vote on more than inactivity at this point.
About my hey-vote I hope it is clear why I postponed my voting for him, even in the final hours, I thought I could get more out of him after he had a good night sleep, and thought I could use the locking vote as leverage. But he had apparantly given up altogether before that. Before that I had doubts that we were just punishing someone who seems a bit younger than most.
My vote for this day (it will stay this way) will go to
vote:NOLECUB
for trying to force upon us the idea that there is only one mafioso left. Yeah, let's assume that and all claim our roles and weed out that one mafia now! Did noone see that action as suspicious?
Spigot, although your long post seems objective there are some assumptions in there that are not. I did not implie jaago was a traitor day one. Aman did not point to me as being the doctor in that post, he already cleared that up, but I thought that would be rather obvious, his post just followed after mine. I also did not hint at knowing something about jaago with the he who smelt it remark, I'm not the "big nose" this game, I just said it was convenient to point at a suspicious voting pattern of others first, clearing himself of suspicion in a "I admit it, so I'm clean" kind of way.
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
It's a photo of me.
I've reread bob's posts in this game, I actually get a townie-vibe out of them. Besides, I think if bob was mafia, he would have NK'ed me night one because I claimed his role in the previous game. :tongue:
I agree that nolecub claiming that there is only one mafia left is almost a mafia-claim. Couldn't get there before you, erwwd.
Unovote: Bob
Vote: Nolecub
It's a photo of me.
I've reread bob's posts in this game, I actually get a townie-vibe out of them. Besides, I think if bob was mafia, he would have NK'ed me night one because I claimed his role in the previous game. :tongue:
I agree that nolecub claiming that there is only one mafia left is almost a mafia-claim. Couldn't get there before you, erwwd.
Unovote: Bob
Vote: Nolecub
friedbananazzzz
New member
Re: Mafia: The Gangland Massacre
I know I won't get back in time before end of day, so here's my vote... (I'll be sleeping thanks to my drinking on St Pat's day :grin
I don't like people that lay too low.
Vote: Bob
@Erwwwd: I've posted a bit more than he has, at least I contribute something.
I know I won't get back in time before end of day, so here's my vote... (I'll be sleeping thanks to my drinking on St Pat's day :grin
I don't like people that lay too low.Vote: Bob
@Erwwwd: I've posted a bit more than he has, at least I contribute something.
