Gods of Ancient Greece. Forum mafia game.

[FredOfErik]

Vote: FredOfErik

Was the purpose of quoting me really nothing but OMGUS?

 

[Zokar1]

Was the purpose of quoting me really nothing but OMGUS?

No, it was a reminder to me of some of the reasons why I decided not to change my mind about you and Moar.

 

[FredOfErik]

No, it was a reminder to me of some of the reasons why I decided not to change my mind about you and Moar.

Feel free to share.

 

[FredOfErik]

And tell me how my opinions affect your opinion about Moar.

 

[Zokar1]

Feel free to share.

Vote: Zokar

Here's for hoping some of you may have changed your mind about me.

Why? We strip your one time immunity and you want us to just turn around and go away? My guess, you're SK and your immunity was provided to ensure that you were not killed off too early.

On my lynch: if I have understood you all correctly, you suspect me of being an SK or part of another group that can only kill every other night? If so, I suggest you do not lynch me today, as if, even if your suspicions were correct, I couldn't do any harm tonight.

I do not like this logic at all. It assumes that we have knowledge of the mechanics of your SK role. We don't. I'd rather see you dead tonight.

And tell me how my opinions affect your opinion about Moar.

Further I think we have at least one SK - my guess would be Moar.

About the only thing I agree with you about... you're both SK.

 

[ThunderCat]

the world isn't ending tomorrow, i promise.

Burn the witch!!!!!111oneeleven

 

[FredOfErik]

I do not like this logic at all. It assumes that we have knowledge of the mechanics of your SK role. We don't. I'd rather see you dead tonight.

No. I'm just summing up what you think about my SK role - I'm very aware about the mechanincs of my role and it is not an SK role.

1. You are the ones that are saying I'm SK.
2. We have pretty good evidence that any SK/second scum fraction can only kill every other day, as Jcakes claimed that his fraction was indeed responsible for one kill each night.

Even if you were to be right about your suspicions of me, there would be no reason to lynch me today.

But I understand why you would disagree with this logic - after all it seems like your next in line..

 

[Zokar1]

No. I'm just summing up what you think about my SK role - I'm very aware about the mechanincs of my role and it is not an SK role.

1. You are the ones that are saying I'm SK.
2. We have pretty good evidence that any SK/second scum fraction can only kill every other day, as Jcakes claimed that his fraction was indeed responsible for one kill each night.

Even if you were to be right about your suspicions of me, there would be no reason to lynch me today.

But I understand why you would disagree with this logic - after all it seems like your next in line..

So, let me get this straight... you are taking JCakes at his word... a proven scum? Uhhuh.... yeah, I'm not changing my vote today, thanks.

 

[FredOfErik]

So, let me get this straight... you are taking JCakes at his word... a proven scum? Uhhuh.... yeah, I'm not changing my vote today, thanks.

Yes.

So did most of you - he was the first person to voice suspicion about me being an SK, and I would consider it fair to say, the reason that you tried to lynch me yesterday. As others before me have said (only at those points it was used against me, which was totally cool for all of you) he had no reason to lie about the information he shared.

Your last post is useless as an argument. Getting desperate much?

 

[Zokar1]

What is there to be desperate about? I already said I was prepared to die today. Unlike you, I don't mind being lynched. The town will finally not have to deal with my dysfunctional role and they can get back to actually trying to kill the rest of you bad guys.

 

[FredOfErik]

What is there to be desperate about? I already said I was prepared to die today. Unlike you, I don't mind being lynched. The town will finally not have to deal with my dysfunctional role and they can get back to actually trying to kill the rest of you bad guys.

In a game with only 7 player left and 3 NKs the previous night any town player should be desperate of not getting lynched - we should be getting quite close to mylo or lylo, so lynching a town player could prove pretty catastrophic. Of course I mind being lynched.

But what I think you are desperate about is the fact that you are the last member of your mafia team alive and about to lose the game on behalf of you and your former buddies.

 

[Zokar1]

In a game with only 7 player left and 3 NKs the previous night any town player should be desperate of not getting lynched - we should be getting quite close to mylo or lylo, so lynching a town player could prove pretty catastrophic. Of course I mind being lynched.

But what I think you are desperate about is the fact that you are the last member of your mafia team alive and about to lose the game on behalf of you and your former buddies.

Well, when I flip town, you'll be next. No sweat off my back.

 

[Moar]

My vote won,t count today, but I will symbolically cast it at the end of this post. I would have preferred a Zokar lynch yesterday because I think he,s scum. I went with FoE because of the masons and because he,s not clear town to me. I recall a post which was clearly scummy right after he delivered the result for CG. I think we absolutely need to lynch him again tonight. He claimed 1 shot lynch immune, but what if it is lynch immune every other day? Then it would make sense for him to get us to lynch somebody else today. He,d be immune next day. I would think this quite possible. I can,t be lynched but killed evey other night and I am town. I wouldn't think it impossible for TC to have an antitown role that is can,t be NKed and can be lynched only every other day. I,d guess SK there.


Vote: FredofErik

 

[FredOfErik]

My vote won,t count today, but I will symbolically cast it at the end of this post. I would have preferred a Zokar lynch yesterday because I think he,s scum. I went with FoE because of the masons and because he,s not clear town to me. I recall a post which was clearly scummy right after he delivered the result for CG. I think we absolutely need to lynch him again tonight. He claimed 1 shot lynch immune, but what if it is lynch immune every other day? Then it would make sense for him to get us to lynch somebody else today. He,d be immune next day. I would think this quite possible. I can,t be lynched but killed evey other night and I am town. I wouldn't think it impossible for TC to have an antitown role that is can,t be NKed and can be lynched only every other day. I,d guess SK there.


Vote: FredofErik

Aside from the fact that you again are basing some crazy theory on absolutely nothing, can you answer this question:
Why would I claim 1-shot lynch immune, if I was really lynch immune every other day? I can't come up with a reason.

 

[Moar]

Because you are antitown and obviously don,t want the town to know the truth.

 

[korialstraz]

Every lynch reveal has been a power role.
Every claim has been a power role (not a single VT yet).
Lots of kills -> lots of anti-town powers -> should mean lots of town PRs for balance.

No prove, but I would call it a fair assumption.

I'm basically a VT, so there ya go.

 

[Kestegs]

Why? We strip your one time immunity and you want us to just turn around and go away? My guess, you're SK and your immunity was provided to ensure that you were not killed off too early.

I do not like this logic at all. It assumes that we have knowledge of the mechanics of your SK role. We don't. I'd rather see you dead tonight.

About the only thing I agree with you about... you're both SK.

I agree, the fact that he is pushing us to wait on his lynch until tomorrow is disturbing to say the least.

My vote won,t count today, but I will symbolically cast it at the end of this post. I would have preferred a Zokar lynch yesterday because I think he,s scum. I went with FoE because of the masons and because he,s not clear town to me. I recall a post which was clearly scummy right after he delivered the result for CG. I think we absolutely need to lynch him again tonight. He claimed 1 shot lynch immune, but what if it is lynch immune every other day? Then it would make sense for him to get us to lynch somebody else today. He,d be immune next day. I would think this quite possible. I can,t be lynched but killed evey other night and I am town. I wouldn't think it impossible for TC to have an antitown role that is can,t be NKed and can be lynched only every other day. I,d guess SK there.

Vote: FredofErik

Maybe both sk's are lynchable only on certain days, or maybe they both have a 1 shot immunity.

 

[Laarz]

My vote won,t count today, but I will symbolically cast it at the end of this post. I would have preferred a Zokar lynch yesterday because I think he,s scum. I went with FoE because of the masons and because he,s not clear town to me. I recall a post which was clearly scummy right after he delivered the result for CG. I think we absolutely need to lynch him again tonight. He claimed 1 shot lynch immune, but what if it is lynch immune every other day? Then it would make sense for him to get us to lynch somebody else today. He,d be immune next day. I would think this quite possible. I can,t be lynched but killed evey other night and I am town. I wouldn't think it impossible for TC to have an antitown role that is can,t be NKed and can be lynched only every other day. I,d guess SK there.


Vote: FredofErik

Sort of the opposite of you huh? So if he is anti-town, that would make you pro-town? or just his counterpart.

Everytime there is multi death nights someone brings up lovers,could there really be that many in this game or just someone sowing confusion?

Lets all sing!!!

"Joxer theMighty
Roams through the countryside
He never needs a place to hide
With Gabby as his sidekick
Fighting with her little stick
Righting wrongs and singing songs
Being mighty all day long
He's Joxer-he's Joxer the Mighty"

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

It looks like some kind of connection between Moar and FoE, she has sure been pushing hard to go after the penguin:scratchchin:

Hm, interesting thought indeed. But then again, maybe you are just slipping by enjoying your time killing everyone while lurking away.

This was actually my exact list of people I was trying to decide to watch.

*sigh*

N1 -> MartinLong -> nobody visited
N2 -> Goryani -> unable to watch
N3 -> Zokar -> nobody visited
N4 -> FredOfErik -> nobody visited
N5 -> korialstraz -> nobody visited
N6 -> pharphis -> nobody visited

*sigh*

so, somebody is messing with my results, there is a ninja, or there is a mistake in my results... maybe somebody else has a better explanation, but as I see it, I'm prepared to die today.

The ninja role is the only role that I am aware of that cannot be watched/tracked. But your results once again, sound completely unbelievable.

Well, there is only one thing to do today and that is the follow up lynch of FoE. Anything else would be idiotic.

Hm, interesting how yesterday you were more for a Zokar lynch. Not that I disagree at this specific time but what a very quick change for someone who was so reluctant to vote yesterday.

Just to make sure, I asked TC if the results were accurate and not a mistake, he said it was accurate. So... yeah...

Did you really send a pm to TC? Thats the question. WIFOM everywhere.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Vote: Zokar

Here's for hoping some of you may have changed your mind about me.

Let's just look at Zokar's claim. He has watched 6 people, 6 nights, in a game that is apparently stuffed with PRs. Not a single result. Last night he even watched one of those that were killed - still no result. I simply cannot believe that.

However, I can see why he would come forward with the pharphis result - the "don't you think I would've chosen a better lie?" defense actually can be used as a decent defense against people calling you scum. To me it doesn't look like a town player that is frustrated about his role not working - it looks like a scum player that's heading towards a lynch either today or tomorrow and is becoming desperate.

On my lynch: if I have understood you all correctly, you suspect me of being an SK or part of another group that can only kill every other night? If so, I suggest you do not lynch me today, as if, even if your suspicions were correct, I couldn't do any harm tonight.

On the game setup: I still think we have mafia left - and I believe Zokar to be a part of that. Further I think we have at least one SK - my guess would be Moar.

Every lynch reveal has been a power role.
Every claim has been a power role (not a single VT yet).
Lots of kills -> lots of anti-town powers -> should mean lots of town PRs for balance.

No prove, but I would call it a fair assumption.

I know kegs pointed this out already but a game stuffed full of power roles? We have lynched two scum so far (and they are the only two lynches we have actually had), a bodyguard and a resurector. I know those sound like great roles for a scum team but if thats all they have then its really not all that great if you put some thought into it.

Other than that from whats been said so far we have or had a bus driver and a vig (both based on Gorys claim), a coroner, a broken watcher (supposively), a one shot blood swap thingy (supposively), a messed up tree stump (also supposively), and a team of 3 masons. Oh, and we cant forget your one shot coroner/one shot lynchproof/whatever thing of yours.

How are you getting a game stuffed full of power roles off of this? What do you know that we don't? A lot of the roles listed above don't even target, or if they do most of them don't target every night. I still doubt Zokars results and he is on my short list, but I doubt you being town more.

In a game with only 7 player left and 3 NKs the previous night any town player should be desperate of not getting lynched - we should be getting quite close to mylo or lylo, so lynching a town player could prove pretty catastrophic. Of course I mind being lynched.

But what I think you are desperate about is the fact that you are the last member of your mafia team alive and about to lose the game on behalf of you and your former buddies.

Working it out, lynch today, 6 left.
Night, should be one kill following the pattern, 5 left.
Tomorrow, lynch, 4 left.
Night, possibility of 3 kills, 1 left?

Not really a good outcome, but I'm still willing to hedge my bets on you.

My vote won,t count today, but I will symbolically cast it at the end of this post. I would have preferred a Zokar lynch yesterday because I think he,s scum. I went with FoE because of the masons and because he,s not clear town to me. I recall a post which was clearly scummy right after he delivered the result for CG. I think we absolutely need to lynch him again tonight. He claimed 1 shot lynch immune, but what if it is lynch immune every other day? Then it would make sense for him to get us to lynch somebody else today. He,d be immune next day. I would think this quite possible. I can,t be lynched but killed evey other night and I am town. I wouldn't think it impossible for TC to have an antitown role that is can,t be NKed and can be lynched only every other day. I,d guess SK there.


Vote: FredofErik

And now on the day that you can't vote, you are all for voting for FoE, amazing.