Forum Mafia - The Dark Tower Game Thread

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

Post of the game goes to. . . glibflubbet

I don't care whether Noammr or CG is lynched. By the looks of it CG may not be able to be lynched until the rest of his team is dead but who knows. Unless this game is being run by a 3rd faction we have several (boring) days to do this.

CG, want to eat me, tonight? I know you want to

Indeed, I don't particular care either way myself. screw it, let's go with what we know(which, btw, we only know because *he* told us, and because our unreliable detective claims it is so).

Unvote: Noammr
Vote: Caluin Graye

 

[Moar]

I am not going to vote Noamr before 24 hours have passed. I don't understand why everybody thinks that Laarz was the silencer. Is there any concrete evidence for that?

I am more in favour of a CG lynch. He's so obviously trying to get us to think that he can't be lynched that I at least want to try to lynch him once. He's a good player and will think through every post he makes. He knows how to guide the sheep and how to get the reaction he wants.

As I said before I don't believe Gwaihir in his "I have to kill Mordred" wincon. The last time somebody said that he was mafia and tried to save his behind from lynch. (Ender's game, Gory, I think)

My lynch list:
CG: admitted scum
Gwaihir: not town, don't believe his claim of "must kill Mordred" and two failed kill attempts
coju: don't believe his claim since my char is in the game as well
Noamr: not town

 

[flubbucket1]

............... He knows how to guide the sheep ..............

I'm going to bed now, work tonight.

Remember, baa means no!!

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

A lynch of cg with gwai locking it seems like the strongest play.

 

[Drixx]

Updated Laarz's flip info.

 

[Phillinnicus]

Laarz is confirmed silencer since he was revealed to be Dandelo, a vampire who has taken Patrick Danville's tongue out. It just makes sense that he is the silencer, and coincides with my claim to be Patrick.

 

[pharphis]

The problem I have with this is that f Gwaihir were dead how would we win? I'm thinking safest bet is to have on of the katet, probably myself, perform the lock.

Ofc, what happens if CG locks?

Too many possibilities. I need to reread story to see if Gwaihir's miss-kill flavour actually points out that Mordred was his target or someone else.

 

[Moar]

The problem I have with this is that f Gwaihir were dead how would we win? I'm thinking safest bet is to have on of the katet, probably myself, perform the lock.

I don't think that is a good idea. I'd rather do the locking. A mason group is a very strong thing for town.

 

[Gwaihir]

As I said before I don't believe Gwaihir in his "I have to kill Mordred" wincon. The last time somebody said that he was mafia and tried to save his behind from lynch. (Ender's game, Gory, I think)

Hmm. So out of curiosity, do you think I am unfound or mafia? I have been investigated as each, but one seems more reliable than the other. If neutral, do you think I am just a plain survivor or am hiding a different win condition?

The problem I have with this is that f Gwaihir were dead how would we win? I'm thinking safest bet is to have on of the katet, probably myself, perform the lock.

Ofc, what happens if CG locks?

Too many possibilities. I need to reread story to see if Gwaihir's miss-kill flavour actually points out that Mordred was his target or someone else.

I really hope there are multiple ways to have mafia die. If I was the only way to defeat Mordred, that would be a silly game setup, as the death of a neutral should never make a town unable to win.

After seeing what happened when the robot got lynched again, I can't say I am particularly eager to lock, but am willing to do so. As for it making a difference, who knows?

I would really hope that if there are lock requirements, mafia locking mafia would be a death. Otherwise it becomes a timing game that one side does not know they are playing.

As for my targets, I was all over that The flavor was:

(BA) Elsewhere, Walter Padick screamed in fury as his face took on the form of a horned demon. His prey, it seems, has escaped him.

(CG) Elsewhere in the night, The Walkin' Dude finds that his prey isn't so easily killed.


Doesn't really give any indication either way unfortunately.

 

[Moar]

I think you are either scum or have an anti-town wincon as a neutral. I do not at all believe that you are trying to help town.

 

[Noammr]

if Gwaihir can kill again he should totally do it to Noammr unless noammr will fully reveal any information he has.CG has put the spotlight on him (and this doesn't look intentional imo) and he was only eager to share limited information about his role to us.

flubb, do you have any results?

Oh, for crying out loud...
I gave you practically all the info I could give without spelling it out for the mafia to use.

But fine, whatever:
There are several characters which will end the game in the mafia's favor if killed. Every night I can either investigate and detect whether this connection is present or one-shot protect each character I find.

Now explain to me why it was necessary?

Yeah, he's power hungry and wholly amoral, but he's not part of the red really. He's on his own side.

He's also kinda represents pure evil, no?
Still not buying Gwaihir's claimed win-con.

Moar is of The White.

Why investigate Moar?

The problem I have with this is that f Gwaihir were dead how would we win? I'm thinking safest bet is to have on of the katet, probably myself, perform the lock.

Ofc, what happens if CG locks?

Too many possibilities. I need to reread story to see if Gwaihir's miss-kill flavour actually points out that Mordred was his target or someone else.

I have a counter-offer; how about I lock? Story could confirm my role for you guys.
If there's a downside to this, I don't see it.

I think you are either scum or have an anti-town wincon as a neutral. I do not at all believe that you are trying to help town.

Oh, I agree.

 

[pharphis]

Can you explain how you win as a neutral?

Also, if the game ends with a specific character kill (Roland, anyone?) then I don't want to play that game. What if you were killed N1 or lynched D1? If there are several players who mafia can kill then it's only a waiting game for mafia to win no matter how you spin it.

 

[Moar]

So you get a complete flip on investigation? Or just that there is that connection present or not?

 

[Noammr]

Can you explain how you win as a neutral?

Also, if the game ends with a specific character kill (Roland, anyone?) then I don't want to play that game. What if you were killed N1 or lynched D1? If there are several players who mafia can kill then it's only a waiting game for mafia to win no matter how you spin it.

I share the win if the mafia win in a standard way.
As for your second comment - that's better left for when we know exactly how the game was balanced.

So you get a complete flip on investigation? Or just that there is that connection present or not?

Neither.
If there is a connection I get a confirmation along with a name-flip. No role info.
Do you understand why I was reluctant to explain this in detail?

I gotta say phar, your reaction to my claim was super frustrating. I feel you were so focused on your trapstigation that you never stopped to consider I might actually be telling the truth.

 

[pharphis]

Your claim just reeks so hard of "lynch me and town loses" it's ridiculous.

Does your ability have a name?

 

[pharphis]

Also, whether my rxn was good or bad, I really like the idea and label of trapstigation. Cute!

Btw the reason I went for it at all is our mason group hasn't had a town read on you all game.

 

[Moar]

I share the win if the mafia win in a standard way.
As for your second comment - that's better left for when we know exactly how the game was balanced.



Neither.
If there is a connection I get a confirmation along with a name-flip. No role info.
Do you understand why I was reluctant to explain this in detail?

I gotta say phar, your reaction to my claim was super frustrating. I feel you were so focused on your trapstigation that you never stopped to consider I might actually be telling the truth.

So you share a win with the mafia. I will vote you now for sure.

So you just get a name and alignment flip? So how do you know I am 100% who I said I am? According to what you just said you wouldn't know that I am a VT.

 

[Moar]

Once again I hit the wrong button.

I do not think Noamr is who he tries to be. He advanced to a shared 2nd place on my lynch list.

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

Oh, for crying out loud...
I gave you practically all the info I could give without spelling it out for the mafia to use.

But fine, whatever:
There are several characters which will end the game in the mafia's favor if killed. Every night I can either investigate and detect whether this connection is present or one-shot protect each character I find.

Now explain to me why it was necessary?



He's also kinda represents pure evil, no?
Still not buying Gwaihir's claimed win-con.



Why investigate Moar?



I have a counter-offer; how about I lock? Story could confirm my role for you guys.
If there's a downside to this, I don't see it.



Oh, I agree.

Interesting and rather complicated situation there. I still say we go after CG today, and flub investigates Noammr tonight. If Noammr comes back anything but unfound, and CG is lynched successfully, then we lynch Noammr tomorrow. If Cg is lynched successfully and Noammr comes back as unfound, we lynch coju.

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

Oh, and yes, Walter Podick is pure evil. But the red represents anarchy. The complete dissolution of all that is, with the faint hope that their works will survive and they can shape the world in their image afterward. Walter Podick wants everything to stay the same, but with him as god. Makes more sense to me as neutral than red.