Forum Mafia - The Dark Tower Game Thread

[flubbucket1]

Moar is of The White.

 

[Jcakes1]

My personal opinion is that we lynch noammr today.

 

[Gwaihir]

Gwaihir, you have terrible aim.

Apparently.

I don't think CG is mordred, or he would have been killed by Gwaihir. At least that's my assumption.

I do think Noammr is Mordred, though.

I am less sure on this. As seen on the wiki, my character has problems killing Mordred by himself apparently.

Ah of course. Yeah, so either lynch is fine. Gwai, so what happened with your kill attempt? you get any feedback?

Yeah. My kill should have been able to kill anyone. It was dodged the first day so it was not used. On the second day it was "insufficient" to kill CG, but used up.

if Gwaihir can kill again he should totally do it to Noammr unless noammr will fully reveal any information he has.CG has put the spotlight on him (and this doesn't look intentional imo) and he was only eager to share limited information about his role to us.

Nope, I was informed that my vig shot was used up.

*Munch* I'm sorry, but Gwa-*crunch*-ihir is a bit... busy... at the moment. *SLURP* I invited him for dinner, and he was SOOO deliciously willing to *CHOMP CHOMP CHOMP* indulge me.

I am not dead yet at least. Was really hoping that shot would work better.

Also, reading through the night story at the end of yesterday, there must be a Randall Flagg in this game. He's known as the walking dude. I've read The Stand so I know some info about him.

That is me, Walter Padick is another name for Randall. See the previous day's story for additional confirmation.

My personal opinion is that we lynch noammr today.

I still like going for CG. Just because he was kill immune does not mean he is lynch immune, and I think going for confirmed scum is better than taking a shot at lynching Noammr.

Vote: Caluin Graye

 

[flubbucket1]

So you all finally want to lynch someone I confirmed scum about a year ago. Well okay, I guess I can get onboard with that. Still seems kinda sketchy...... Vote: Caluin Graye

 

[pharphis]

So you all finally want to lynch someone I confirmed scum about a year ago. Well okay, I guess I can get onboard with that. Still seems kinda sketchy...... Vote: Caluin Graye

We've had confirmed scum for that entire year, though.

 

[Caluin Graye]

I am not dead yet at least. Was really hoping that shot would work better.

Food should not be talking whilst being eaten!

 

[Jcakes1]

I really disagree on lynching cg today hard to explain while phone posting

 

[IWantToUseNumbersInMyName]

Vote: Noammr

Just...a feeling. Unfortunately, no real logic to support this, but it just feels like the right thing to do.

 

[flubbucket1]

Hey I've got an idea. :idea: Let's wait and see if Bad Ash comes back from the dead and we'll lynch him. I've got no real logic to support this and it's hard for me to explain it while smashing my face into the keyboard.

 

[coju]

Why are you eating people, Caluin Graye! That is not nice!
Vote: Noammr

 

[Jcakes1]

Hey I've got an idea. :idea: Let's wait and see if Bad Ash comes back from the dead and we'll lynch him. I've got no real logic to support this and it's hard for me to explain it while smashing my face into the keyboard.

Why do you want to lynch CG so much? I understand the pride thing (given that you revealed him to be scum) but I am not sure it is the right thing to do. Noammr is obv scum as can be seen in Pharphis's post.

I'll explain the context, Noammr claimed a neutral that had to stop other win conditions. Pharphis pointed out to Gwai that Noammr could be modred, CG comes out and protects Noammr by giving Gwai the info that Modred is of The Red, thus subtly turning Gwai away from attempting to shoot Noammr. For me, this little interaction coupled with the fact that CG appears to really want to be lynched turns me to want to vote Noammr.

@Gwai: I understand why you want to lynch CG (given you believe him to be Mordred), but this is one of the areas where you being neutral means you have other goals than town. For me the best way to guarantee that you help us is to lynch Mordred last, that way you are essentially a townie. This isn't my only reason for thinking we should take out Noammr (the above paragraph explains my main reasoning), but it is a nice additional one.

 

[flubbucket1]

Nope it's not pride. I just like to bet on a sure thing instead of taking random shots in the dark.....pun intended

 

[pharphis]

Drixx, is the flip you gave us on Laarz the entire thing we're getting? It doesn't say if he had an ability or not.

 

[Zauper]

Flub: we know Noammr is non-town. No shot in the dark there.

Vote: Noammr.

 

[flubbucket1]

Nope, I used the two I received in the same night. If you sent another I didn't get it because of palaver.

I don't think CG is mordred, or he would have been killed by Gwaihir. At least that's my assumption.

I do think Noammr is Mordred, though.

Assumption...

Well, if we go off of the glee CG displayed when we lynched laarz and shot him, I'd be inclined to think that he's mordred, and thought due to the lore, any kill from walter on mordred would get walter killed. Any reason why Noammr could be telling the truth, and dj could just be a lurking red? Or rather, any reason why you feel dj is above suspicion?

I'd be inclined to think...

I'm sure mafia have figured it out already so why not.

dj is the last katet member.
/wave dj

I don't think we can base everything on the lore (ie town can lose, and walter can also not die). It looks as though Gwaihir's kills will only work on mordred, so CG cannot be Mordred since he was targeted.

I bet CG is the Crimson King, since we haven't seen him yet.

More guessing...

I'm pretty sure Noammr has to be red. Not enough reds otherwise. 22 players and 5 scum sounds right, if the scum avoid death/detection for 5 days they can take over the game from that point. with only 4 scum they need to avoid detection for like 7 days before they have the vote advantage to swing the game.

I'm pretty sure...

So that story just 100% confirmed me as town if any of you tightbottoms are still wondering. Kudos to Drixx for sweet role creation, I thought the Patrick-Dandelo combo was really cool/balanced.

I feel like if we try and lynch CG today we'll be sorely disappointed when it doesn't work. I have an itch that he just wants to keep everyone's attention while his last little minion is running around doing his bidding.

I don't think CG can be lynched or killed while his other scummates are left. It's just a feeling I'm getting.

I just say we lynch Noammr and hope for the best.

I won't be voting until after 24 hours though.

Feelings, nothing more than feelings...

My personal opinion is that we lynch noammr today.

Personal opinions

I really disagree on lynching cg today hard to explain while phone posting

Some sort of hard to explain...explanation...

Vote: Noammr

Just...a feeling. Unfortunately, no real logic to support this, but it just feels like the right thing to do.

Feelings....Whooooa Feelings

Why do you want to lynch CG so much? I understand the pride thing (given that you revealed him to be scum) but I am not sure it is the right thing to do. Noammr is obv scum as can be seen in Pharphis's post.

I'll explain the context, Noammr claimed a neutral that had to stop other win conditions. Pharphis pointed out to Gwai that Noammr could be modred, CG comes out and protects Noammr by giving Gwai the info that Modred is of The Red, thus subtly turning Gwai away from attempting to shoot Noammr. For me, this little interaction coupled with the fact that CG appears to really want to be lynched turns me to want to vote Noammr.

@Gwai: I understand why you want to lynch CG (given you believe him to be Mordred), but this is one of the areas where you being neutral means you have other goals than town. For me the best way to guarantee that you help us is to lynch Mordred last, that way you are essentially a townie. This isn't my only reason for thinking we should take out Noammr (the above paragraph explains my main reasoning), but it is a nice additional one.

An attempt at critical feelings...

Flub: we know Noammr is non-town. No shot in the dark there.

Vote: Noammr.

We also know Caluin Graye is non-town.



I wish I could get some logic to wash all this down, because it's a bit hard to swallow.

Can ya' feel me??


I'm not trying to save anyone's life, but what are you all trying to do here?!?!?! Ya' buncha Steel Magnolia watchin' nancy boys.

 

[pharphis]

Assumption...

I'd be inclined to think...

More guessing...

I'm pretty sure...

Feelings, nothing more than feelings...

Personal opinions

Some sort of hard to explain...explanation...

Feelings....Whooooa Feelings

An attempt at critical feelings...

We also know Caluin Graye is non-town.



I wish I could get some logic to wash all this down, because it's a bit hard to swallow.

Can ya' feel me??


I'm not trying to save anyone's life, but what are you all trying to do here?!?!?! Ya' buncha Steel Magnolia watchin' nancy boys.

Post of the game goes to. . . glibflubbet

I don't care whether Noammr or CG is lynched. By the looks of it CG may not be able to be lynched until the rest of his team is dead but who knows. Unless this game is being run by a 3rd faction we have several (boring) days to do this.

CG, want to eat me, tonight? I know you want to

 

[Caluin Graye]

Drixx, is the flip you gave us on Laarz the entire thing we're getting? It doesn't say if he had an ability or not.

If I told you what his ability was, would you believe me?

 

[Caluin Graye]

CG, want to eat me, tonight? I know you want to

I'll be heading to Taco Bell tonight for Fourth Meal, but I think I can probably squeeze you in for dessert.

 

[TheMouseT]

I don't care whether Noammr or CG is lynched. By the looks of it CG may not be able to be lynched until the rest of his team is dead but who knows. Unless this game is being run by a 3rd faction we have several (boring) days to do this.

Yay I can post again! Pharphis, why do you think CG may not be lynchable?

 

[Gwaihir]

Food should not be talking whilst being eaten!

Say it with me CG:

"Fish are friends, not food."

I'll explain the context, Noammr claimed a neutral that had to stop other win conditions. Pharphis pointed out to Gwai that Noammr could be modred, CG comes out and protects Noammr by giving Gwai the info that Modred is of The Red, thus subtly turning Gwai away from attempting to shoot Noammr. For me, this little interaction coupled with the fact that CG appears to really want to be lynched turns me to want to vote Noammr.

@Gwai: I understand why you want to lynch CG (given you believe him to be Mordred), but this is one of the areas where you being neutral means you have other goals than town. For me the best way to guarantee that you help us is to lynch Mordred last, that way you are essentially a townie. This isn't my only reason for thinking we should take out Noammr (the above paragraph explains my main reasoning), but it is a nice additional one.

I am actually not so sure on CG being Mordred. Highest likelihood I think, but really can't be sure.

I understand your position on keeping neutrals in line, and there is a decent chance that Noamrr is mafia. But I need to fufill my survivor condition as well, so I need to play with town anyways. And what if Noamrr is actually unfound? Could just be a waste of a day. How many days are you willing to avoid lynching CG just because someone came up with this theory that he is lynch immune until all other mafia are dead?

Side note - who came up with that, and what proof is there? I find that to be a very long shot theory.

I still think the best idea is to see what we are up against in CG. The most likely bad scenario to me is that he has some sort of lynch immunity like the robot. Heck, maybe me being the locker makes a difference (or maybe it gets me killed ) It may finish the game. If it doesn't, or if we have a problem with the lynch, then we can look for remaining mafia.

Flub: we know Noammr is non-town. No shot in the dark there.

Vote: Noammr.

We also know CG is mafia, which I would think would be way more pressing.