Create Your Own Role Mafia game

[Moar]

To me, if flub is dirty, Sath is more than likely not. Why would they have the choice of king out in the open like that? Why would Sath have removed the king from the game (unless he is lying about the Paris role, hmm). True that Gwahir could be making all that up as a long winded wifom thingy. I noticed he didn't vote for it, and it does seek like some good sound logic.

Because we are at mylo assuming that Mal was town. If one of them gets lynched tonight, they'd switch the lynch and with a sucessful NK they win. Well, it would be 6 players then. Even if the town is united it's 3-3. How would a tie be handled?

A town king could ruin that pretty well by switching to one of them. I don't think the mafia would risk that.

 

[MartinLong]

Because we are at mylo assuming that Mal was town. If one of them gets lynched tonight, they'd switch the lynch and with a sucessful NK they win. Well, it would be 6 players then. Even if the town is united it's 3-3. How would a tie be handled?

A town king could ruin that pretty well by switching to one of them. I don't think the mafia would risk that.

Not really a tie, but town loss.
Town looses when they can't lynch mafia. At 3-3 in day, then no lynch, mafia night kills. Etc.

 

[Sathoris]

I've never seen Moar as a likely suspect for scum. So, yes?

Were it not for your last second vote for Malev to ensure a lynch I'd be convinced you're scum. But then again, did you know Moar's vote wouldn't count?

 

[thefranklin]

Okay, who do you want to bus tonight? Who do you want to take a DNA sample from? Who do you want to Mime tonight? What cards should the psychic give out? All relevant for tonight, right?

Except the Frankenstein role. Not relavent tonight, haha.

 

[MartinLong]

Were it not for your last second vote for Malev to ensure a lynch I'd be convinced you're scum.

My last second vote made me look town? *scratches head*

But then again, did you know Moar's vote wouldn't count?

Yes. Gory's vote count was one or two posts above moars IIRC. Moar had a vote already on Kegs, but no unvote before Mal.

 

[Gwaihir]

Already explained that, go read it if you want to know.

So you thought CG unlikely to be killed. Why would CG be the best reasoning there, instead of someone who has gotten some heat like myself or Moar?

Who did you think was mafia yesterday?

To me, if flub is dirty, Sath is more than likely not. Why would they have the choice of king out in the open like that? Why would Sath have removed the king from the game (unless he is lying about the Paris role, hmm). True that Gwahir could be making all that up as a long winded wifom thingy. I noticed he didn't vote for it, and it does seek like some good sound logic.

If we have 3 mafia (MYLO), and Sath is mafia, a lynch today loses us the game unless a bus driver guesses correctly on one of the following 2 nights.

So flubb living through the night and picking me as king is more voteworthy than Moar's entire track record?

To me, yes. He play yesterday made her less suspicious. The fact that Solar went after Moar a few times makes me less suspicious. The fact that Solar went after Mal, and the reasoning for me finding Moar suspicious was in large part related to Mal being mafia, makes her less suspicious. So overall, Moar is actually not at the top of my list anymore.

Because we are at mylo assuming that Mal was town. If one of them gets lynched tonight, they'd switch the lynch and with a sucessful NK they win. Well, it would be 6 players then. Even if the town is united it's 3-3. How would a tie be handled?

A town king could ruin that pretty well by switching to one of them. I don't think the mafia would risk that.

Exactly. At 3-3 we keep playing. If anyone misvotes, mafai can pile on to win. Otherwise they can nightkill for the win.

Not really a tie, but town loss.
Town looses when they can't lynch mafia. At 3-3 in day, then no lynch, mafia night kills. Etc.

Not quite, as there could still be a bus for the win. But it is way more likely to get a mislynch and have them win.

 

[MartinLong]

Not quite, as there could still be a bus for the win. But it is way more likely to get a mislynch and have them win.

Ah touche. Writing that one down!

 

[thefranklin]

Vote: MartinLong

Just seems scummy today. Not quite paying attention to most things, paying close attention to some things, etc. Caught Moar's misvote doesn't help. He has close to double the amount of posts of everyone, and please note that I am still voting for him. Hint, hint. I just can't do it, I tried my hardest.

 

[Caluin Graye]

You people are going to be the literal death of me. Voting is a bad move right now.

Yesterday, I alluded to a scenario that I promised I would speak of at a later time. Now is that time.

What if Franklin is scum? Giving out the tarot card to Pyro seems like a very coincidental series of events. He just happened to pick the person who was both not driven and was killed, so as to not verify his claim. Additionally, if the next Tarot Psychic handed out a card, it would likely be the doctor card, and since unused cards are returned to the deck, he's in the clear.

In the mean time, perhaps he gave out a different card. Like the 'skip a day phase' card. Perhaps he gave it also to a scum buddy, such as flubbucket, knowing he wouldn't be bus driven, and would show up under Cooties due to the Frankenstein switch.

This is off the wall, I know. But; it's something I would do if I were mafia in his shoes. Therefore, I can't discount the fact that it is something he would do too.

Therefore, (and here's the important part!), tonight I will try giving out the 'Skip a day phase' tarot card. I'm the fortune teller. I plan on giving it to the towniest person in the thread, but I'd rather not name who. My hope is two-fold: It lands in the hands of a townie who will never, ever, ever use it, while simultaneously proving or disproving my thoughts about franklin.

And if my fears are confirmed and the card is already out there, well, then the game is pretty much lost already anyways.

I realize there's a pretty darned good chance the card might fall in the hands of mafia anyways. If you want to try talking me out of this, now's the time.

 

[Moar]

I won't vote today. If Gwaihir just made it up, then gratz to him.

 

[Moar]

You people are going to be the literal death of me. Voting is a bad move right now.

Yesterday, I alluded to a scenario that I promised I would speak of at a later time. Now is that time.

What if Franklin is scum? Giving out the tarot card to Pyro seems like a very coincidental series of events. He just happened to pick the person who was both not driven and was killed, so as to not verify his claim. Additionally, if the next Tarot Psychic handed out a card, it would likely be the doctor card, and since unused cards are returned to the deck, he's in the clear.

In the mean time, perhaps he gave out a different card. Like the 'skip a day phase' card. Perhaps he gave it also to a scum buddy, such as flubbucket, knowing he wouldn't be bus driven, and would show up under Cooties due to the Frankenstein switch.

This is off the wall, I know. But; it's something I would do if I were mafia in his shoes. Therefore, I can't discount the fact that it is something he would do too.

Therefore, (and here's the important part!), tonight I will try giving out the 'Skip a day phase' tarot card. I'm the fortune teller. I plan on giving it to the towniest person in the thread, but I'd rather not name who. My hope is two-fold: It lands in the hands of a townie who will never, ever, ever use it, while simultaneously proving or disproving my thoughts about franklin.

And if my fears are confirmed and the card is already out there, well, then the game is pretty much lost already anyways.

I realize there's a pretty darned good chance the card might fall in the hands of mafia anyways. If you want to try talking me out of this, now's the time.

Do it if you trust your read. Don't do it if you don't trust your read. Easy as that. If the mafia gets their hands on the card we have lost. I think it's a good play, if you are confident in your read.

 

[thefranklin]

You people are going to be the literal death of me. Voting is a bad move right now.

Yesterday, I alluded to a scenario that I promised I would speak of at a later time. Now is that time.

What if Franklin is scum? Giving out the tarot card to Pyro seems like a very coincidental series of events. He just happened to pick the person who was both not driven and was killed, so as to not verify his claim. Additionally, if the next Tarot Psychic handed out a card, it would likely be the doctor card, and since unused cards are returned to the deck, he's in the clear.

In the mean time, perhaps he gave out a different card. Like the 'skip a day phase' card. Perhaps he gave it also to a scum buddy, such as flubbucket, knowing he wouldn't be bus driven, and would show up under Cooties due to the Frankenstein switch.

This is off the wall, I know. But; it's something I would do if I were mafia in his shoes. Therefore, I can't discount the fact that it is something he would do too.

Therefore, (and here's the important part!), tonight I will try giving out the 'Skip a day phase' tarot card. I'm the fortune teller. I plan on giving it to the towniest person in the thread, but I'd rather not name who. My hope is two-fold: It lands in the hands of a townie who will never, ever, ever use it, while simultaneously proving or disproving my thoughts about franklin.

And if my fears are confirmed and the card is already out there, well, then the game is pretty much lost already anyways.

I realize there's a pretty darned good chance the card might fall in the hands of mafia anyways. If you want to try talking me out of this, now's the time.

This is a good idea to test me. Tough call if this is something the town should buy off on, because you have not been the most towniest person alive. Your "I think they are the most town" could easily turn out to be your mafia buddy, and/or trying to set me up tomorrow for a lynch which would end the game. Additionally, I am very surprised you did not call for a no bus drive night then, or did you think that would make you incredibly scummy? There are 8 people left and 3 bus driven choices, so a 33% chance that it gets shifted around.

Dangerous play, but it does sound fun. If I did hand the no day card last night, it would most likely get used tonight, right?

 

[Moar]

This is a good idea to test me. Tough call if this is something the town should buy off on, because you have not been the most towniest person alive. Your "I think they are the most town" could easily turn out to be your mafia buddy, and/or trying to set me up tomorrow for a lynch which would end the game. Additionally, I am very surprised you did not call for a no bus drive night then, or did you think that would make you incredibly scummy? There are 8 people left and 3 bus driven choices, so a 33% chance that it gets shifted around.

Dangerous play, but it does sound fun. If I did hand the no day card last night, it would most likely get used tonight, right?

No need to mention it if he was mafia. Then he'd just give it to a buddy and lie about which card he gave out. They can agree on which card was given out. Buddy uses it the day after and we are done in.

 

[thefranklin]

Are you saying CG has no reason to mention his plan if he is mafia?

 

[Caluin Graye]

This is a good idea to test me. Tough call if this is something the town should buy off on, because you have not been the most towniest person alive. Your "I think they are the most town" could easily turn out to be your mafia buddy, and/or trying to set me up tomorrow for a lynch which would end the game.[/quote]

Admitted. But, then I should ask - if I were scum, why would I bother telling you my plans? I would just do it without any input.

Additionally, I am very surprised you did not call for a no bus drive night then, or did you think that would make you incredibly scummy? There are 8 people left and 3 bus driven choices, so a 33% chance that it gets shifted around.

Dangerous play, but it does sound fun. If I did hand the no day card last night, it would most likely get used tonight, right?

You answered your own concern. If you did already hand out the no-day card and it was used, then a lucky bus drive during one of those nights is our only hope to surviving another day.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Drat. Hate when I mess up quote formatting. I trust the post is still readable.

 

[thefranklin]

Admitted. But, then I should ask - if I were scum, why would I bother telling you my plans? I would just do it without any input.

You answered your own concern. If you did already hand out the no-day card and it was used, then a lucky bus drive during one of those nights is our only hope to surviving another day.

1. To look townie.
2. Agreed. I am surprised it took someone this long to think of this plan. I would want to do the same thing if I was in your shoes. It is why Gwahir tested my DNA for N1, if I were him I would have just tried sampling me again anyways.

 

[thefranklin]

Drat. Hate when I mess up quote formatting. I trust the post is still readable.

I understood where the break was.

 

[thefranklin]

You never answered your thoughts on the bus driver. I would assume rather take the chance they redirect a kill because we can find who the redirected card to?

 

[Moar]

Are you saying CG has no reason to mention his plan if he is mafia?

Exactly. He'd do better to not mention it and not expose him to comments and others trying to twist his words.

And here you have another comment you an reply to.