Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

BTW: If Ray is NK'd I will also push as hard as possible to lynch sitro tomorrow if wicked is the cop. It is a lie and it isnt a good one.

Wicked: Noodle locked you because he is mafia. He wanted to guaruntee that a townie was killed before we could all change our minds and lynch a mafia and end the game today.

I again seriously hope a mafia member wouldnt call out his other mafia member in the thread while there is day still going on. I am aggresive about it because it would be the stupidest thing for anyone to believe lol. Especially after Sitro was revealed as mafia and he is saying he bus drove with Ray...So that makes me, noodle, ray, sitro all left for the last 2 mafia spots. one will die today, the other was called out by the Cop and thats Sitro. Lets get him tomorrow and win this game!
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

let's see if anyone else claims the bus driver role as well. There were 3 night kills, giving a certain chance of them being one of them. Also, do the mafia get to know the role of the person they killed? If so, sitro would know the bus driver was killed, and he could use it in case he was ever suspected of anything.

I specifically asked for role claims at the beginning of this day, no one dared to put a role up, which is sad. Sitro, claiming busdriver at the start of the day wouldn't have done anyone harm, so there was no reason to hide it.
You're also not responding to my question on who you swapped and why you swapped them.

I'm not really buying it..

I'd like to hear the opinions from everyone else on this (perhaps there's another power role somewhere?)
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

bad ash: i'm agreeing with you on noodle, there's a fair chance he is mafia.

about sitro, we can never be 100% sure, but there's really only a small chance of him really being the bus driver.

I love how ray claims to ban himself form the next 5 mafia games if he turns out not to be townie. That's really something a mafia would say :p

let's hope there's some activity going on for the rest of the day
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

oh btw bad ash: NK-ing ray would be the stupidest move ever now.. whoever the mafia is will probably stay to their trick of killing the least agressive people in the game
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

wickedswami said:
oh btw bad ash: NK-ing ray would be the stupidest move ever now.. whoever the mafia is will probably stay to their trick of killing the least agressive people in the game
Click to expand...

I was just clarifying that there is more than 1 person willing to kill Sitro in case it happened.

People wont role claim just because you told them too lol, and it is too bad you are dead cause we could use your vote tomorrow. As far as not being sure about Sitro, other than your cop claims have you been sure about anything? It is hard to be SURE, all we can do is have reasonable doubt to make a decision and make it. Sitro has a cop who had him comeup mafia and then is trying to cover it up. Even if Sitro switched roles with anyone, it would be our best day lynch yet in this game because he has come up Mafia from a cop investigation



 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

Lets say I'm mafia and know for sure that a bus driver claim is safe because they've been nk'ed by this point.

Why would I start laying down hints that I was the bus driver from the start? Hoping that the bus driver would be nk'ed soon and be a viable cover? Remember that the bus driver would have to have been nk'ed in that case, it'd be pretty stupid to role claim something that had been revealed to the town.
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

Yeah, SiTro won't kill me off. His only hope for the mafia to win is that I'm alive and he can convince everyone to vote for me.
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

i'm afraid you are correct, we'll probably have to go for it.

anyway, i WILL show up as a cop tonight (why would i still lie??) and people can decide after that.

Sitro, please answer my question i stated earlier, this will help us know wether you are to be trusted or not (don't take too long for it, it'll just make you look more guilty)

again: who else did you swap, and what were your reasons for all your swaps?
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

ray: i'd advise you to take one for the town and kill yourself :p that way we win for sure..
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

If you were laying down hints, it was to set up a role claim later in the game. If you never NK'd the bus driver, or the bus driver was lynched, then its no big deal, and you'll have another role to claim....exactly like when you wanted to set up a possible Cop role claim when we were mafia together last game.
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

if there's any kind of power role still out there possible of making a hit, kill either ray or nitro.. (certain games include vigilantes etc)
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

What do people think about me getting myself modkilled for the town to win? I know its lame, but I'd rather have the town win then let SiTro get the glory.

We've got 7 people alive now. Two are going to die tonight, leaving us 5. I'll kill myself leaving 4 (SiTro, xvart, SiTro and Luda), the NK will leave us with three...the two living townies will just have to lynch SiTro and we'll win.
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

you're forgetting the possibility of a SK, allthough the idea of there really being one is looking less and less believable for me.

You also posted sitro twice in your lineup, you forgot bad ash

modkilling is lame indeed, but now that you've mentioned it, i'm afraid NOT doing it will result in you being voted mafia It would be a nice bluff anyway, and you've already shown us you're prepared to place yourself in risky situations (day one)

i say we let bad ash, luda and xvart vote on it
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

Ray Patean said:
What do people think about me getting myself modkilled for the town to win? I know its lame, but I'd rather have the town win then let SiTro get the glory.

We've got 7 people alive now. Two are going to die tonight, leaving us 5. I'll kill myself leaving 4 (SiTro, xvart, SiTro and Luda), the NK will leave us with three...the two living townies will just have to lynch SiTro and we'll win.
Click to expand...

lets discuss this further tomorrow after we see how everything unfolds.

@Sitro, I agree with Ray, last game the 3 of us were mafia together, and you made the same claims last game. its fun to do crazy claims early on. And no one took you seriously becausey ou werent night killed. If i knew the identity of a busdriver and was mafia, I would kill them vs a non role knowing townie as soon as i could



 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

we are only assuming at this point that there are 2 more mafia members (noodle and sitro) where there could be 4. or 3 and a SK or 4 and a SK for all we know the town could have already lost. Best to not modkill at this exact moment. Lets make sure Wicked is the cop and noodle is mafia and then we will see how tomorrow unfolds
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

might be a good idea indeed. dno about the SK anymore, the fact that we got 2 docs and mafia can be killed as well (and it seems to be 1 townie, 1 mafia, 1 townie, 1mafia) makes it look more like aman's doing.
If noodle isn't mafia, the game is lost anyway, but still..

small sidenote:
12) I won't be telling you the starting roles, upon lynch that persons role will be revealed, people that get nk'd their roles will only be known to the mafia
Click to expand...
this means that, if sitro had killed the bus driver, he'd know the bus driver was dead, and he was safe to claim the role.
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

wickedswami said:
might be a good idea indeed. dno about the SK anymore, the fact that we got 2 docs and mafia can be killed as well (and it seems to be 1 townie, 1 mafia, 1 townie, 1mafia) makes it look more like aman's doing.
If noodle isn't mafia, the game is lost anyway, but still..

small sidenote:

this means that, if sitro had killed the bus driver, he'd know the bus driver was dead, and he was safe to claim the role.
Click to expand...

this is irrelevant because thre could be more than 1 bus driver, and possibly there were 0 bus drivers in this game (even though aman loves them apparently) it is just Sitros way. regardless of who has been killed even if he was townie he probably would have role claimed bus driver lol



 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

I can't be bothered to re-iterate my thoughts on intentional mod-killing. IMO it cheapens the game for all players.

I've been saying all along I think there's multiple bus drivers in this round. It'd certainly be believable for me, given the host.

I'm also hoping we have a surviving vigilante or such. Though it'd have to be a one shot role else surely we'd have seen evidence of their activity before now?
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

sitro, the only thing that might save you is telling us who you bus-drove and why you did it. You're just stalling

i'm more and more certain about the fact that you are in fact the mafia.
Even though ray's mod-kill might've been a bluff, you failed on responding to it properly, resulting in you being the mafia

probably my last post in the game: GG town (i hope)
 
Re: Community Forum Mafia Game #2 Live or Die

It'll cheapen the game SiTro because it'll prove you are lying and win the game for the town.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top