Is it possible that one mafia team is wiped out?
Mal didn't fake claim. flubbbucket didn't fake claim. coju didn't fake claim. SI faked a claim but wasn't a charcter associated with Batman.
Mal could have faked Drixx' role.
flubbucket could have faked the roles of Drixx, pharphis or Valhauros.
coju could have faked the roles of Drixx, pharphis, Valhauros, Ankeli or djmbbandie.
SI could also have faked the roles Drixx, pharphis, Valhauros, Ankeli or djmbbandie.
Makes me think. What does anyone else think?
My thoughts for this post only assume that there are two teams, the poisoner is the hitman for Team #2, poison is a night ability.
Jason Maher was poisoned and killed.
kestegs claims JM part of Mason group.
Therefore, if kestegs were to be lying and part team #2, then Jason Maher would not have been part of his team. This does not hold up, therefore we can safely presume that kestegs is not mafia team #2.
coju was hitman for team #1. If kestegs was mafia team #1, then that'd make Noodle, Jason Maher, CDM, and coju all team #1 as well. I suppose it is possible that CDM is team #2, but then that'd make Flubbucket team #1, so either way, that makes for a five man team. This does not seem likely to me, so we can then safely presume that kestegs is not mafia team #1.
Therefore, kestegs is, in my eyes, confirmed town at this point, as is Noodle. (Side tangent: Single mafia team and scumstegs would mean coju; SI; Flub; Male; stegs; Noodle; Jason, CDM. Eight scum; that's a bit high, seems very unlikely to me.)
Bad Ash is a semi-verified treestump, as votes will not land on him. Remove him from the mix.
Moar claims to have stolen a serving platter from Laarz. Laarz hasn't yet chimed in whether or not he had a serving platter to steal in the first place. Let's assume for a moment that he hasn't said anything because there's no contradiction. So either Moar and Laarz are both scum, or both have fairly decent alibis for last night. Additionally, Moar visited someone the night someone else died via poison.
omgwtfbbqpwned shot someone during the day. Also, he's likely to get mod-killed, so he's a non-factor. (Sad; didn't really want him to simply stop playing.)
Laarz has been seen visiting people at night who haven't died.
Gwaihir has proven multiple times that he can control a person's vote.
BPC was tracked on Night 3, with no result. Admitted to having tried to kill Laarz, and Laarz confirms a self-protect. Probably not the poisoner. I still think he's scum.
All of the above people are off the list.
Goryani claims tracker. Most reliable result is seeing Jason Maher visit Goryani. It's possible that Goryani took an educated guess after having killed JM and gotten the cop result. Unlikely. But possible. I highly doubt Gory is poisoner, but there remains a possibility, therefore he stays on the list.
I have no verifiable claim. I've been "tracked" by one person, and shown to not have used an ability that night, even though someone still died. Still, no claim means I'm a good candidate.
Crap, running out of time. Gotta be fast now.
CDM could have claimed a redirect action from someone else on his team. None of the scum flips so far have really fit someone who switches targets, though. Actually, maybe SI's Inverter? Possible.
FoE: No time, he's getting lynched anyways.
thefranklin has no verifiable claim yet. I highly suggest having him prove his ability tomorrow, and if he doesn't follow through, lynch him for it.
TL
R; poisoner is FoE, Franklin, Goryani, CDM or me. That would be my preferred lynch order. I still think only one mafia team, and poisoner is SK variant.
