Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

[Gwaihir]

Gwaihir claimed a daytime ability

Just to be clear: I target at night to get people to follow my vote during the day.

Was I that obvious, I think you are right tho.

Like I said I am Alfred Pennyworth, my alignement is Town and my role is Doctor, and for those who will ask,

n1-protected Goryani
n2-protected djmbbandie
n3-protected Gwaihir
n4-wifom

It seems I read this wrong. I thought Alfred was a likely doc, and found it odd you did not claim yesterday, as it would have been obvious to mafia who you were. I figured you might have been mafia who stole the name, but was worried to claim the actual role of doc as kegs hinted he knew a likely possibility for who it was. With kegs confirming your story, I believe you.

To answer your question, yes. For the duration of the day, you will follow my voting pattern.

 

[thefranklin]

Good analysis, quite the chuckle about taking responsibility for SI.

My power is submitted during the day, so I would add bpc and foe to my list.I also thought I voted BA that first day, but not sure I waited for a Pyro count before changing.

 

[thefranklin]

I am an armless, legless hobo who doesn't want to go down the path of Anarky!



Well, its thefranklin or CG then. I have zero actions whatsoever and have been off the player list for days. If I was able to kill during the night that would be absurd and I believe the mafia would agree with me.

You wouldn't happen to be talking to the mafia at night, would you? That's the feeling this post gives me.

 

[Bad Ash]

You wouldn't happen to be talking to the mafia at night, would you? That's the feeling this post gives me.

Nope. The point of what I said was that I am expecting mafia QT threads to say "yea right" to my ability to kill. It was always a long shot I tried to sell as best as I could in hopes of getting any kind of night action targeted my way in order to help the town. I highly doubt it worked, but will be very pleased if it did.

 

[Bad Ash]

And apparently I have arms, but no legs. I was a henchman for the villain Anarky, but being legless and not able to afford a wheelchair, I've drifted into obscurity while rolling around on a wheeled food tray. Tough life. If anyones got a drink, I'd take one. And please do not read into this as it would be detrimental to the town. I can understand if there is a reason to want to, but c'mon, I wouldn't be off the player list if I was aligned to anyone. The only reason I am coming forward is the defense of "two vigilantes seems far fetched" to get someone lynched. I have no idea anyone's role and am not defending the person, just the statement.

 

[Bad Ash]

And lastly (dont need to clutter the thread, but will respond to questions if asked), I geuninely was going to claim cop to get noodle killed until I rechecked and was aligned with the town and not neutral. Oh well, will have to wait another game.

 

[Laarz]

I am an armless, legless hobo who doesn't want to go down the path of Anarky!



Well, its thefranklin or CG then. I have zero actions whatsoever and have been off the player list for days. If I was able to kill during the night that would be absurd and I believe the mafia would agree with me.

A question BA,Are you saying that you posted that phrase in this thread to activate your stumpage other than just now? I seem to have misplaced glasses, so could you kindly point it out to me?

 

[Bad Ash]

I'm out of town till tomorrow and busy so no clue what's happening in the game. Don't sink to Anarky! While I'm gone

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

HEHEHEHEHEHEEHHE POST #420. Smoke it up. I am sure Noodle is firing up a blunt just reading this.

 

[Kestegs]

Howdy everyone. Before I begin, I'd like to say that I have really enjoyed playing this game, especially "yesterday" (how do you refer to the previous game day and not make it confusing?). BPC and OMG in particular have shown me a fun way to play. Gwaihir, Gory, and a few others have shown me how a good player would play, but I doubt I'll ever be that, so I'll emulate BPC/OMG from now on. Yay!



I've read that answering questions aimed at other people is scummy, but this made me laugh so much. DC = Detective Comics = first comic Batman was ever in? Detectives investigate... pretty easy conclusion to reach. He's Sherlock Holmes, Houdini, and a kung fu master all in one, I'd think his powers would/could be pretty diverse and include investigating, a death avoidance effect, and/or some sort of capture mechanism.

I never knew that was what DC stood for

And apparently I'm an idiot for asking that question... I didn't naturally associate Batman with watcher, but I guess it makes sense.

I was Moar, so she. I have no clue if she was talking about one or several persons, or who that might be - hence the question.



I don't (not didn't) know if they are notified or not. Are as in the general sense; was, am, will be. Way to twist my words.

Why I think batman is an investigative role? I guess that him being a crime fighter and the main character, him also having a PR that potentially is investigative isn't a guess you would've made? Besides, I'm not talking about batman's role, I'm talking about the ability of the bat mask. Once again, you're twisting my words.

I'm not twisting anything, you said something and then contradicted yourself.

And if you mean that I should know whether or not they are notified because I targetted myself - I only received one PM and that said I had successfully delivered the item to myself. I didn't get a separate PM saying that I had received it.

That sounds pretty hoaky. You got a pm saying you successfully delivered the item to yourself but I thought you should get another pm saying you received it. And this somehow means you may not have received the item, because you didn't already receive a pm saying you got the item. Your story has more holes than SI's head.

I disagree. I have a very good reason not to divulge my role. I will not, under any circumstances, be telling the town what my role or ability is. If this bothers the town, then they best start lynching me.

In the mean time:
Vote: Bipolar

He admits to attempting to kill someone. There are two other self claimed vigs in the game, one of which is proven. The reason he gives for attempting to kill Laarz is shady enough, but doesn't mention me at all, even though how I claimed is very similar to how Laarz claimed.

Appears to me that the mafia spotted the doctor, tried to kill him, and then came forward with a weak defense early due to both a watcher and a tracker being alive.

I agree with this analysis.

You wouldn't happen to be talking to the mafia at night, would you? That's the feeling this post gives me.

Really? A mafia tree stump? How would we kill him? Even if he were aligned with mafia....who cares?

 

[Kestegs]

Gwaihir: can you vote please, to confirm Laarz being politicianed?

 

[Bad Ash]

amen. Frankie is high on my scum list.

 

[Gwaihir]

I disagree. I have a very good reason not to divulge my role. I will not, under any circumstances, be telling the town what my role or ability is. If this bothers the town, then they best start lynching me.

In the mean time:
Vote: Bipolar

He admits to attempting to kill someone. There are two other self claimed vigs in the game, one of which is proven. The reason he gives for attempting to kill Laarz is shady enough, but doesn't mention me at all, even though how I claimed is very similar to how Laarz claimed.

Appears to me that the mafia spotted the doctor, tried to kill him, and then came forward with a weak defense early due to both a watcher and a tracker being alive.

Actually, this is a good point. No NK last night, Laarz self targets, and BPC claims being able to kill. Suspicious timing.

Assumption.... the poisoner is a hitman with no non-killing abilities (abilities like strongman/ninja are allowed but abilities like tracker are not).

CDM had a mostly verifiable action N2 with swapping himself with flubb.
Laarz was seen targeting several players, none of whom died that night or the next day phase.
BPC was tracked but didn't do anything N3. Also admits targeting Laarz N4 but expects Laarz to be dead.
BA claimed to have tried to use a night action but no alibi is available.
FOE was tracked but didn't do anything N4 and didn't have a role for Moar to copy/steal N1.
kestegs watched several nights and is mod confirmed having a role which wouldn't be the poisoner.
Gwaihir claimed politician and we've seen a politician type vote this game.
Goryani is me.
omg is being sekretive but he breadcrumbed a dayvig kill while no one else took credit for SI's death.
Moar was watched and party hosted as having an ability that wouldn't be the poisoner.
thefranklin has claimed a role that isn't the poisoner but there is no confirmation (yet).
Noodle is being vouched for by kestegs.
CG is being mysterious and hasn't claimed anything.

Based on the above assumption, the poisoner might be BA, thefranlin or CG. If the poisoner has ninja-like abilities, that opens the possibility of BPC and FOE.

Hmm. CG and thefranklin have both seemed town to me this game. But with CG, I can never tell if he is mafia. upon thinking of claims, what really bugs me is the number of Robins. There really was only ever 1 Robin at a time, correct? The first one (CG's claim) became his own superhero I think (Nightwing?), but why would the other two both be Robin? There was also the whole "if I am dead, I guess I will mess with the town" part from yesterday which was odd.

thefranklin is my top suspect based off voting, role claims, and play. That would be followed by FOE, and then BPC.

Gwaihir: can you vote please, to confirm Laarz being politicianed?

Yeah, I can do that.

Vote: thefranklin

 

[Kestegs]

Thanks.

I've thought Franklin was a bit scummy most of the game, but I always seem to think that.

CG is tough, but I'm leaning towards town right now.

Preferably I'd like to see either foe or moar getting lynched today.

 

[FredOfErik]

That sounds pretty hoaky. You got a pm saying you successfully delivered the item to yourself but I thought you should get another pm saying you received it. And this somehow means you may not have received the item, because you didn't already receive a pm saying you got the item. Your story has more holes than SI's head.

Either I have not received it OR my targets are not informed when they receive an item. I'm not sure why you take for granted that they would be? The items grants passive abilities, so they can potentially work without the owner knowing - that was my whole reasoning for bringing this up.

 

[thefranklin]

amen. Frankie is high on my scum list.

You are a henchman, eh? We have a watcher, tracker, and doc yet you throw out bpc and foe instantly? That does not add up, this is Batman, the nights get shut down and criminals resort to the day. Plus, there was a lot of talk after the last "wifom role" game about a mafia stump, so why not.

 

[Bad Ash]

Ok let's just say I am.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

 

[Bad Ash]

Sigh. Hit send accidentally. Lets just say I am a mafia treestump. I am not but if I was what would you like the town to do about it? Also I pushed for omg to kill solar and people to vote. Coju so I'd be a pretty terrible stump.

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

 

[Kestegs]

People should start voting for their top suspect.

vote: Fredoferic

we've got like 5.5 hours until day end.

 

[Caluin Graye]

People should start voting for their top suspect.

I'm of the opinion that Franklin needs to demonstrate his power.

 

[thefranklin]

CG: I have to use my power the first 24 hours of the day. I have not done it yet due to my conservatism in not wanting to take the choice out of the town. And then if I lose the town really learns nothing.

BA: All I said was "felt like scum" and you went nuts. You have been very jumpy with everything you have said anyways, /ignore.

I am still reading on who I vote, thinking BPC or FoE. I do think if one had an NK they should have looked a little closer to not kill the doc, but then Gwahir did the same thing with his power. I guess Gwahir would have lost it if his target died?