thefranklin
Well-known member
Right, you stole it.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game
- Thread starter Pyrotechnician1
- Start date
Right, you stole it.
Right, you stole it.
No, I didn't steal it. He would have been able to use it had he lived. I just see if people do something and if they do something I get a shot of whatever they are doing.
Caluin Graye
New member
Why did you think Batman would have an investigative role?
Have to agree with CDM; that's a pretty hilarious question.
Caluin Graye
New member
I would like to get back to Moar and I both being Bruce Wayne/Batman girlfriends and how I really dont think Pyro (with all the characters he has to chose from) would pick two. Moars claimed power is also pretty nifty and doesn't really fit into the theme of what I've read of Silver. It seems like more of a thief ability. Thief = Catwoman who at best is a neutral.
If Moar were to be lynched and flipped as who she says she is, should the town then proceed to lynch you the next day?
crawlingdeadman1
New member
This .Right, you stole it.
crawlingdeadman1
New member
That, or you could do me today and when I'm found out to be who I say I am, she's next, right?If Moar were to be lynched and flipped as who she says she is, should the town then proceed to lynch you the next day?
crawlingdeadman1
New member
I mean of course I'd like to survive longer if it'll benefit, but I think someone in the dead thread in the mini mafia game said something along the lines of "when did it become more about surviving than winning" something like that. I'd like to survive, but if lynching me provides crucial information, why not?
Caluin Graye
New member
There is zero reason for anyone not to divulge their information at this point and if someone refuses we should lynch them
I disagree. I have a very good reason not to divulge my role. I will not, under any circumstances, be telling the town what my role or ability is. If this bothers the town, then they best start lynching me.
In the mean time:
Vote: Bipolar
He admits to attempting to kill someone. There are two other self claimed vigs in the game, one of which is proven. The reason he gives for attempting to kill Laarz is shady enough, but doesn't mention me at all, even though how I claimed is very similar to how Laarz claimed.
Appears to me that the mafia spotted the doctor, tried to kill him, and then came forward with a weak defense early due to both a watcher and a tracker being alive.
Was I that obvious, I think you are right tho.
Like I said I am Alfred Pennyworth, my alignement is Town and my role is Doctor, and for those who will ask,
To mafia, it should be obvious by process of elimination. They either think you are the doc or SK/mafia.
Alfred is the role I penciled in as most likely to be the doc and Laarz' behavior fits. I can't fathom a town aligned vigi taking aim at Laarz.
thefranklin
Well-known member
BS Gory, a town aligned omg would do it.
(joke BTW)
(joke BTW)
I mean of course I'd like to survive longer if it'll benefit, but I think someone in the dead thread in the mini mafia game said something along the lines of "when did it become more about surviving than winning" something like that. I'd like to survive, but if lynching me provides crucial information, why not?
What that your thought process N2?
BS Gory, a town aligned omg would do it.
(joke BTW)
omg would fake it, definitely.
I disagree. I have a very good reason not to divulge my role. I will not, under any circumstances, be telling the town what my role or ability is. If this bothers the town, then they best start lynching me.
In the mean time:
Vote: Bipolar
He admits to attempting to kill someone. There are two other self claimed vigs in the game, one of which is proven. The reason he gives for attempting to kill Laarz is shady enough, but doesn't mention me at all, even though how I claimed is very similar to how Laarz claimed.
Appears to me that the mafia spotted the doctor, tried to kill him, and then came forward with a weak defense early due to both a watcher and a tracker being alive.
Well I won't be proven as I was lying. I am just a treestump. Was hoping to try and get a mafia target of any sort on me at some point. Of course with a Doc, Batman, Batwoman, Tracker, and Vig, I have to realize that the odds of that happening ar better .1%-.5%
OMG could still be a vig, I am not sure, but don't want him to go down if only for the reason that "there's two claimed vigis"
Typed this up earlier, but apparently did not hit post.
So you can either use your ability to discover and mimic an active ability, or you can use an ability you collected previously?
FOE was the last name missing from my list.
I targeted Laarz.
So you have items but do not know what they do? What items do you have, and what do you expect they do?
I always thought a bus driver was a town role, with the occasional one shots given to mafia, because it is so powerful in their hands. How many times have you played with a mafia bus driver?
Anyways, took a closer look at voting records last night:
1. crawlingdeadman - Voted mafia 2 times. ussure, sketchy claim
4. Laarz - has never voted mafia. unsure, light claim
6. BipolarChemist - voted mafia once. unsure, sketchy claim
9. FredOfErik - voted mafia twice, interrogated once. Feels townie, but scketch claim today
10. kestegs - voted mafia twice Feels townie, townie claim
14. Gwaihir - voted mafai once
16. Goryani - voted mafai once Feels townie, townie claim
18. omgwtfbbqpwned - voted mafia twice, forced a third time. DK mafia. feels scummy, but very townie actions.
19. Moar - voted mafai 3 times. Unsure, sketchy claim
20. thefranklin - has not voted mafia. Feels townie, townie claim
22. Noodle - voted mafai once. Feels townie, townie claim
23. Caluin Graye - voted mafai three times. Feels townie, light claim
Of the two who have never voted mafia, I felt that Laarz was more likely to be mafia than thefranklin.
Scum list:
FOE - claim seems odd. We need more details
Laarz - Lurks, has not voted mafia
cdm - odd claim.
Moar - odd claim.
thefranklin - never voted mafia.
Nobody since I could only use one ability. It's an either/or thing. I chose the shot of dj's ability.
So you can either use your ability to discover and mimic an active ability, or you can use an ability you collected previously?
Yea, I plan on giving that out in a bit, but first, had everyone claimed? I seem to remember someone not claiming yet but I never made a list.
Sounds a bit like you expected you were watched. Anyone else wanna admit to visiting Laarz?
FOE was the last name missing from my list.
I targeted Laarz.
As for my claim, I am Lucius Fox and am an Inventor. I have a list of gear that (according to my PM) provides different passive abilities. Every second night (starting from N1), I get to choose a piece of gear from the list and give it to someone - however, I do not know what the gear does, so I can only guess by judging it on its name.
On N1 I didn't send in my night action due to a combination of RL and (mainly) forgetting about it.
I used my power N3, but am going to hold on to the specific details for now.
So you have items but do not know what they do? What items do you have, and what do you expect they do?
Redirector is rarely a town role. Same with Bus Driver; it's usually a mafia role that is occasionally given to the town for WIFOM purposes. Your comment about it being used in a mafia manner is absolutely true, but, his comments directly led to capturing a different scum. That would only make sense if there are two mafia teams - otherwise, he bussed his own partner for no good reason.
If CDM were to be lynched and flipped scum, I'd take that as absolute proof of multiple mafia teams. He'd be my fourth choice for today; Moar, BPC, and FoE (in that order) before him.
I always thought a bus driver was a town role, with the occasional one shots given to mafia, because it is so powerful in their hands. How many times have you played with a mafia bus driver?
Anyways, took a closer look at voting records last night:
1. crawlingdeadman - Voted mafia 2 times. ussure, sketchy claim
4. Laarz - has never voted mafia. unsure, light claim
6. BipolarChemist - voted mafia once. unsure, sketchy claim
9. FredOfErik - voted mafia twice, interrogated once. Feels townie, but scketch claim today
10. kestegs - voted mafia twice Feels townie, townie claim
14. Gwaihir - voted mafai once
16. Goryani - voted mafai once Feels townie, townie claim
18. omgwtfbbqpwned - voted mafia twice, forced a third time. DK mafia. feels scummy, but very townie actions.
19. Moar - voted mafai 3 times. Unsure, sketchy claim
20. thefranklin - has not voted mafia. Feels townie, townie claim
22. Noodle - voted mafai once. Feels townie, townie claim
23. Caluin Graye - voted mafai three times. Feels townie, light claim
Of the two who have never voted mafia, I felt that Laarz was more likely to be mafia than thefranklin.
Scum list:
FOE - claim seems odd. We need more details
Laarz - Lurks, has not voted mafia
cdm - odd claim.
Moar - odd claim.
thefranklin - never voted mafia.
Caluin Graye
New member
I always thought a bus driver was a town role, with the occasional one shots given to mafia, because it is so powerful in their hands. How many times have you played with a mafia bus driver?
I think a more accurate question would be - "How many games have you read with a mafia bus driver?"
While I only play here, I read games from other sites. Everywhere else, bus driver is given to mafia about 75% of the time. Here, it's given to town about 65 to 75%. (I'm roughly guesstimating, as I really don't have the inclination to go through all my old games and count them up)
Follow up:
Though, it appears that Mafia Wiki disagrees with me. I may be suffering a case of confirmation bias.
Well I won't be proven as I was lying. I am just a treestump. Was hoping to try and get a mafia target of any sort on me at some point. Of course with a Doc, Batman, Batwoman, Tracker, and Vig, I have to realize that the odds of that happening ar better .1%-.5%
OMG could still be a vig, I am not sure, but don't want him to go down if only for the reason that "there's two claimed vigis"
BA, how did you activate your stumpage?
Assumption.... the poisoner is a hitman with no non-killing abilities (abilities like strongman/ninja are allowed but abilities like tracker are not).
CDM had a mostly verifiable action N2 with swapping himself with flubb.
Laarz was seen targeting several players, none of whom died that night or the next day phase.
BPC was tracked but didn't do anything N3. Also admits targeting Laarz N4 but expects Laarz to be dead.
BA claimed to have tried to use a night action but no alibi is available.
FOE was tracked but didn't do anything N4 and didn't have a role for Moar to copy/steal N1.
kestegs watched several nights and is mod confirmed having a role which wouldn't be the poisoner.
Gwaihir claimed politician and we've seen a politician type vote this game.
Goryani is me.
omg is being sekretive but he breadcrumbed a dayvig kill while no one else took credit for SI's death.
Moar was watched and party hosted as having an ability that wouldn't be the poisoner.
thefranklin has claimed a role that isn't the poisoner but there is no confirmation (yet).
Noodle is being vouched for by kestegs.
CG is being mysterious and hasn't claimed anything.
Based on the above assumption, the poisoner might be BA, thefranlin or CG. If the poisoner has ninja-like abilities, that opens the possibility of BPC and FOE.
CDM had a mostly verifiable action N2 with swapping himself with flubb.
Laarz was seen targeting several players, none of whom died that night or the next day phase.
BPC was tracked but didn't do anything N3. Also admits targeting Laarz N4 but expects Laarz to be dead.
BA claimed to have tried to use a night action but no alibi is available.
FOE was tracked but didn't do anything N4 and didn't have a role for Moar to copy/steal N1.
kestegs watched several nights and is mod confirmed having a role which wouldn't be the poisoner.
Gwaihir claimed politician and we've seen a politician type vote this game.
Goryani is me.
omg is being sekretive but he breadcrumbed a dayvig kill while no one else took credit for SI's death.
Moar was watched and party hosted as having an ability that wouldn't be the poisoner.
thefranklin has claimed a role that isn't the poisoner but there is no confirmation (yet).
Noodle is being vouched for by kestegs.
CG is being mysterious and hasn't claimed anything.
Based on the above assumption, the poisoner might be BA, thefranlin or CG. If the poisoner has ninja-like abilities, that opens the possibility of BPC and FOE.
BA, how did you activate your stumpage?
I am an armless, legless hobo who doesn't want to go down the path of Anarky!
Assumption.... the poisoner is a hitman with no non-killing abilities (abilities like strongman/ninja are allowed but abilities like tracker are not).
CDM had a mostly verifiable action N2 with swapping himself with flubb.
Laarz was seen targeting several players, none of whom died that night or the next day phase.
BPC was tracked but didn't do anything N3. Also admits targeting Laarz N4 but expects Laarz to be dead.
BA claimed to have tried to use a night action but no alibi is available.
FOE was tracked but didn't do anything N4 and didn't have a role for Moar to copy/steal N1.
kestegs watched several nights and is mod confirmed having a role which wouldn't be the poisoner.
Gwaihir claimed politician and we've seen a politician type vote this game.
Goryani is me.
omg is being sekretive but he breadcrumbed a dayvig kill while no one else took credit for SI's death.
Moar was watched and party hosted as having an ability that wouldn't be the poisoner.
thefranklin has claimed a role that isn't the poisoner but there is no confirmation (yet).
Noodle is being vouched for by kestegs.
CG is being mysterious and hasn't claimed anything.
Based on the above assumption, the poisoner might be BA, thefranlin or CG. If the poisoner has ninja-like abilities, that opens the possibility of BPC and FOE.
Well, its thefranklin or CG then. I have zero actions whatsoever and have been off the player list for days. If I was able to kill during the night that would be absurd and I believe the mafia would agree with me.
