This I believe. I targeted FoE N1 and he didn't use an activated ability so he did not give out an item that night. If batstegs knows an item was given out, then FoE is scum and fake role claiming.
Vote: FoE
Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game
- Thread starter Pyrotechnician1
- Start date
This I believe. I targeted FoE N1 and he didn't use an activated ability so he did not give out an item that night. If batstegs knows an item was given out, then FoE is scum and fake role claiming.
Vote: FoE
Trying to take out my vote before it can be registered? Scummy beyond scummy. Someone else needs to vote BA to test.
Last night I tracked FoE. No result.
N2 I tracked Jason Maher. Jason Maher targeted me. Jason Maher's first post of that day was something along the lines of "can anyone remind me why they thought Goryani was scum?" It's a bit obvious what Jason's role was even without knowing he targeted me.
Jason Maher's first post of D3 was directed toward SI and referenced fruit. Again, it looked like communication with someone.
Then Jason admitted talking to kestegs N1. I suspect Jason they set up the simple first post of the day code to communicate results to kestegs (which was in turn known to the other masons).
Which came first, the chicken or the egg?
Do you think cdm not very scummy and then think there is only a single mafia or do you think there is a single mafia and therefore cdm isn't so scummy?
thefranklin
Well-known member
How does Coju, Moar, and SI being the last three votes on flub fit into your one mafia theory?
I find your last two posts reeking of LAMIST.
FredOfErik
New member
I gave an item to myself. More specifically, I gave "the Bat-mask" to myself. I picked the bat-mask in the hopes that the ability would be something along the lines of me "seeing through the eyes of batman". Specifically I'm hoping that this will allow be to either receive some form of investigative info. However, I still haven't received any info on what exactly it does and since it's passive I don't know when I will learn anything.
I chose to do so for several reasons:
- obviously, as I said, I hope the mask gives some sort of investigative info
- I am the only person that I know with certainty is town - hence, if anybody should get investigative info, I would prefer it to be me rather than anyone else
- the "Bat-mask" was one of the more mysterious items on the list. I don't know whether or not it is less or more powerful than some of the other more obvious items, but well.. It seemed exciting
- Having abilities is fun
I have not received any info from the mod other than a message basically saying that the item delivery was successful. Seen in hindlight I guess using my ability in someway that could possibly confirm me as town would be more useful than whatever my ability does in itself. Alas, I didn't do so.
If you're so sure I am scum then why kill goryani instead of me?
That's a lot of assumptions.
FredOfErik
New member
I did not expect that. Either you were redirected/bus driven, blocked or it is not possible to track somebody visiting themselves.
?Vote: Bad Ash
Caluin Graye
New member
Second one. Single mafia, therefore CDM is not as scummy as others.
I view it as two, probably three mafia deciding to board a train to garner some town credit. Neither Solar nor coju had been discovered, or even had much heat placed on them, and Moar may or may not yet be scum.
Caluin Graye
New member
Why was that not expected? Last night was Night Four. According to your own claim, you should not have been visiting anyone.
FredOfErik
New member
If you assume a single mafia, I don't see how you can still be suspicious of Moar. Why would two persons (moar and coju) from the same scum team both have visited DJ on the same night?
FredOfErik
New member
You are absolutely right, I misread Gory's post.
Caluin Graye
New member
Without knowing what roles the mafia have and what those roles do, I cannot answer this question.
FredOfErik
New member
OK, so let me ask in another way..
Can you come up with/have you ever seen any role that a scum team could possess that would benefit by targeting a player that is already being killed by their own strongman?
Caluin Graye
New member
I can imagine a ton of roles, yes. No, I'm not going to speculate uselessly.
Standard roles? Roleblocker springs to mind. Obviously that doesn't appear true in this case, but it sets a precedent.
Or maybe Moar just isn't scum and we shouldn't lynch her today. I can admit that I may have been wrong about her.
FredOfErik
New member
Oh my shot was a joke. A paranoid guy asked for it
You're joke seem to have basically forced a tracker to claim his results.
FredOfErik
New member
My point is, that I don't know if we only have a single mafia team nor if Moar is scum, but to me it doesn't seem likely that both are the case.
thefranklin
Well-known member
How often does someone who does things every other night get it confused with last night? Wanna bet he was doing something last night?
thefranklin
Well-known member
The above makes no sense to me either, no idea what I was thinking.
Assuming the poisoner targets at night....
N3:
cdm claimed he was VT since he used his 1x ability
Laarz has no claim
bpc claimed not using his 1x ability and was tracked not doing anything
BA claimed he tried to kill coju but was blocked
FoE claimed to give himself the batmask
kestegs watches djm
Gwaihir claimed a daytime ability
Goryani tracks bpc
omg claimed a 2x vigi and appears to use it D3
Moar is seen targeting djm by multiple sources
thefranklin claims a daytime ability
Noodle claims no ability other than mason
Caluin Graye has no claim
If everyone that has claimed is telling the truth, then either Laarz or CG is the poisoner.
N3:
cdm claimed he was VT since he used his 1x ability
Laarz has no claim
bpc claimed not using his 1x ability and was tracked not doing anything
BA claimed he tried to kill coju but was blocked
FoE claimed to give himself the batmask
kestegs watches djm
Gwaihir claimed a daytime ability
Goryani tracks bpc
omg claimed a 2x vigi and appears to use it D3
Moar is seen targeting djm by multiple sources
thefranklin claims a daytime ability
Noodle claims no ability other than mason
Caluin Graye has no claim
If everyone that has claimed is telling the truth, then either Laarz or CG is the poisoner.
Somebody is really trying to get the FoE issue to go away...
FoE claimed he could give items away and forgot to do it N1 (my ability confirms that he didn't use any activated ability that night), batstegs says he knows an item had been given away N1. So FoE is lying about his role claim which means he's scum.
Unless batstegs is really scumstegs and I do not believe that.
FoE claimed he could give items away and forgot to do it N1 (my ability confirms that he didn't use any activated ability that night), batstegs says he knows an item had been given away N1. So FoE is lying about his role claim which means he's scum.
Unless batstegs is really scumstegs and I do not believe that.
