Baldur's Gate Mafia Game

Ankeli has informed me earlier today that he is unable to continue participating in this game. I am looking for a replacement for him.

Zemaj and Smancer have not posted in this Day phase. Both are prodded regarding rule 13.

13) You will get mod killed if you are inactive (at least 1 **contributive **post per day phase).


The Day phase ends in 3 hours 07 minutes. Both or either will be mod killed if they do not post before that time or inform me of their absense.
 
Bad Ash said:
Basically this. But it sounds like he is still feigning town.

If kestegs is mafia and we don't lynch pharphis we need to do it tomorrow. I see no other reason for kestegs to act like town now.

Also @gory what do you think about noodles "this game sucks" post if kestegs is town?

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...

BA,if kegs flips town what would be your opinion of ph if he does survive today?
 
pharphis said:
Finally! A REASON!
This at least makes sense. I see it differently, though. Not a prod to a team mate, but to someone who needs to explain themselves quickly so we can decide whether or not to believe him and move on. His case is pretty cut and dry: Either his story matches up or it's crap. Seems like it's crap.

Assume kegs is scum:
Here's a question I believe I've already asked but is more or less rhetorical: Who in their right mind is going to prod their team mate D1 to come up with some crappy story who is almost guaranteed to be lynched? Keep in mind the 2 lynches today ensure that not only will kegs be lynched, but likely any scum partner who "prods" him. See bolded sentence for a reminder.
Click to expand...

If you are both mafia, you could want to try and ride the fence - give yourself a way to get on the train, but not one that really pushed the lynch further if you can avoid it. Anyways, back to the initial quote:

pharphis said:
Not directed at me but I want to add to this. Kegs is in the unfortunate seat of having to explain what his role is, otherwise the town misses out on information. If kegs is mafia then he likely gets lynched, but if he's town then he certainly needs to give up at least some indication of his role, because the mafia know he has a role, and if he's reluctant to tell us then that just makes it likely they will target him.
Click to expand...

pharphis said:
does no one realize my post essentially just says that kegs needs to claim or we lynch him, and that even if he claims we may still need to lynch him?
Click to expand...

Not how I read it, posted above again. You use a quarter of a sentence (bolded) to say how might be mafia and if so will likely be lynched - that does not match the second quote. The rest of the paragraph assumes he is town and talks about what he should do if he is town.

pharphis said:
I will likely vote for kegs (as I said and was totally misinterpreted or deliberately twisted by Pyro) but I wanted to see others post their own opinions. Too often scum slip through by saying "oh obvi scum for the reasons other people gave Vote: Person" and leave it at that.
Click to expand...

pharphis said:
Anyway, I think BPC has been jumping the gun on trying to get me lynched. Pyro outlined these thoughts himself above.
Vote 2: BipolarChemist
Click to expand...

...lol. Not exactly what you said in the first quote, but I still find it amusingly close.

Sathoris said:
Actually Pharphis' first post was that Kegs is likely scum. And your 'connection' during twilight isn't much more than banter. Opportunistic behaviour here unbecoming of you.
Click to expand...

I agree that the twilight converstaion was not much, and does not prove anything - it actually did not make me that suspicious of them. It just seemed like an few odd posts to me, and when I threw a question at it, they both just kinda dropped it. Could have been nothing, but it was enough for me to actually write down that the two might be connected. I mostly posted it because of my earlier comment stating I had them down as possible teammates even in twilight, and I thought it worth expanding on.
 
kestegs said:
I'll entertain this, even though I still think you're scum.
Click to expand...

What do townies do when they think someone is scum? Hint: It's that thing that you're not doing.

You're unwillingness to do that thing is what makes me willing to do it myself.

Unvote 2: FredofErik
Vote 2: pharphis

Other notable people I'd be willing to vote for:
coju: Call it OMGUS if you like, but his single-mindedness upon me is off-putting.
crawlingdeadman: Fly by vote for Jason, vanishing act afterwards.
 
kestegs said:
Pretty sure my vote is already on him. Thanks though.
Click to expand...

My apologies, you did attempt to vote him earlier. (I didn't go back that far; trying to participate while at work and doing three simultaneous server builds doesn't leave much time).

I'm still okay with a pharphis lynch though. I'm fairly positive keggers will flip scum, and the pharphis connection will dominate the discussion of the day. Best to do it now whilst we have the extra lynch.
 
kestegs said:
Obviously you are just twisting my words at this point to make me look bad, but I'll play along. I specifically said that I picked him to so that he would know I was town.
Click to expand...

You said no such thing. This is the first time you so much as hinted you thought CG was town and tried to send him your identity infoz. You even answered the question "why did you vote block CG?" by accepting the premise of the question, which was that you thought CG was scum and tried to vote block him.

Bad Ash said:
Also @gory what do you think about noodles "this game sucks" post if kestegs is town?
Click to expand...

I think if kestegs is town, then if Noodle is scum, it won't be for that reason. Noodle isn't obvtown if kestegs flips town.

If that post were made by anyone other than Noodle, I'd have alarms going off in my head. Calling the game easy because catching scum is easy yet no vote then or later. But Noodle never votes D1 so I dunno how to interpret him saying that.
 
kestegs said:
I'll entertain this, even though I still think you're scum.

My scum list:
Pharphy
Gory
flubly
Laarz
Click to expand...


If you truly think these people are scum,why dont you make your case for each of them, have to wonder if you voting pharphis is an attempt at reverse psychology. I feel better about voting pharphis now.

Vote 2: pharphis
 
Vote 2:

pharphis (8): Pyrotechnician, Sathoris,BipolarChemist, Bad Ash, Gwaihir, Caluin Graye, kestegs, Laarz
Caluin Graye (1): coju
BipolarChemist (1): pharphis

Just under 1 Hour of the Day phase remains.
 
Vote 2: Jason Maher

Given the time left in the day there is pretty much no chance to get him lynched but I still want to call him out. He's done a good job lurking this game as opposed to being active (as townie) in the last game. For all his talk about how two lynches are good for the town, he hasn't followed through with action.
 
Noodle said:
What the hell are you talking about?
Sent from my NookColor using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...

THE GROWN UPS ARE TALKING.

Just over reading into your posts daaaahling.

And I concur gory but I am not sure I like you even bringing it up in the first place.

Noodles post can be interpreted in multiple ways and it's kind of like what eye are you looking at it through. Not sure if that makes sense but you jump very high on my scumdar

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2
 
Bad Ash said:
And I concur gory but I am not sure I like you even bringing it up in the first place.

Noodles post can be interpreted in multiple ways and it's kind of like what eye are you looking at it through. Not sure if that makes sense but you jump very high on my scumdar
Click to expand...

Not even when you ask him? :fortune:
 
Caluin Graye said:
crawlingdeadman: Fly by vote for Jason, vanishing act afterwards.
Click to expand...
Better to remain silent and have people think I'm an idiot than to open it and remove all doubt.

I think it's just me not wanting to make an *** out of myself and do something that loses the game for my team. I still don't like how Jason was posting during twilight, but according to the "old hands" at this game it's just banter if it takes place early in the game.

Like others, I want to know about this:
coju said:
Btw, Pharphis, cG, coju, ghwaihir, and bipolar are all scum. You should lynch them all.
Click to expand...
Just random finger pointing or solid info, what's the source?


Vote 2: pharphis

He was on my list from twilight (again for some 'banter' so take that as you will). I'm still not sure if lynching just for the sake of lynching is what should be done, but it's what I feel is correct in this case.
 
crawlingdeadman said:
Better to remain silent and have people think I'm an idiot than to open it and remove all doubt.

I think it's just me not wanting to make an *** out of myself and do something that loses the game for my team. I still don't like how Jason was posting during twilight, but according to the "old hands" at this game it's just banter if it takes place early in the game.

Like others, I want to know about this:

Just random finger pointing or solid info, what's the source?


Vote 2: pharphis

He was on my list from twilight (again for some 'banter' so take that as you will). I'm still not sure if lynching just for the sake of lynching is what should be done, but it's what I feel is correct in this case.
Click to expand...
You're afraid of making a mistake that will cost "your team" the game this early?
Sounds like mafia to me. I'm glad you came in at the end of the day to get me lynched w/o much input.
 
In hopes of reconsideration on my lynch I'm going to remind gory/BA I know something about them, and that in other words I have an incredibly useful ability.
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top