Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

[Pyrotechnician1]

Count as of#920:

6 to lynch, 7 to lock

Vote:
FredOfErik(1): Moar

 

[FredOfErik]

Somebody is really trying to get the FoE issue to go away...

FoE claimed he could give items away and forgot to do it N1 (my ability confirms that he didn't use any activated ability that night), batstegs says he knows an item had been given away N1. So FoE is lying about his role claim which means he's scum.

for going from the bolded part to the italized part you need to assume five things:

- you are telling the truth
- your info is correct
- kestegs is telling the truth (which I however believe)
- his info is correct
- no other mechanics in the game can cause items to pass around

You are jumping to conclusions instead of basing your arguments on facts. I understand that from what we know, I might look scummy to some, but your argument is still doing nothing but twisting the facts we have and the events we have seen.

 

[FredOfErik]

And I ofc did not mean italized but underlined.

 

[FredOfErik]

Somebody is really trying to get the FoE issue to go away...

Who? Do you think they are my scum partners?

 

[Laarz]

Are you FOSing me CG? or do you just want me to claim? I know I am telling the truth, so either you are the one or some one else is lying, imagine that some one lying in a mafia game.

A much as I dislike doing so, I think I will need to do a full claim today.

 

[Moar]

for going from the bolded part to the italized part you need to assume five things:

- you are telling the truth
- your info is correct
- kestegs is telling the truth (which I however believe)
- his info is correct
- no other mechanics in the game can cause items to pass around
You are jumping to conclusions instead of basing your arguments on facts. I understand that from what we know, I might look scummy to some, but your argument is still doing nothing but twisting the facts we have and the events we have seen.

- you are telling the truth
- your infor is correct

Not important since you yourself said that you didn't use it N1

- kestegs is telling the truth

I believe he's telling the truth.

- his info is correct

None of his info so far has been wrong.

- no other mechanics in the game can cause items to pass around

No evidence for or against it. I do not believe that there was another mechanic though. Roles seem to be pretty unique so far (much based on claims though).

 

[FredOfErik]

- your infor is correct

..........

- no other mechanics in the game can cause items to pass around

No evidence for or against it. I do not believe that there was another mechanic though. Roles seem to be pretty unique so far (much based on claims though).

Why does my info have to be correct? What info have I even shared that could possibly be incorrect assuming that I'm telling the truth?

As you say, no evidence for or against it. However, we have seen items mentioned from three different sources now: Myself, kestegs and DJ. Items seem to be pretty central to the game, so ruling out another mechanic seems pretty ignorant. Helpful if you wanna start an easy lynch train though..

 

[Moar]

Sorry for not being around in the end of the last day phase and the beginning of this. Busy weekend.

As for my claim, I am Lucius Fox and am an Inventor. I have a list of gear that (according to my PM) provides different passive abilities. Every second night (starting from N1), I get to choose a piece of gear from the list and give it to someone - however, I do not know what the gear does, so I can only guess by judging it on its name.

On N1 I didn't send in my night action due to a combination of RL and (mainly) forgetting about it.
I used my power N3, but am going to hold on to the specific details for now.

Yea, plus I know someone who received an item on N1. Guessing this was pharphis' or ankeli's role.

for going from the bolded part to the italized part you need to assume five things:

- you are telling the truth
- your info is correct
- kestegs is telling the truth (which I however believe)
- his info is correct
- no other mechanics in the game can cause items to pass around

You are jumping to conclusions instead of basing your arguments on facts. I understand that from what we know, I might look scummy to some, but your argument is still doing nothing but twisting the facts we have and the events we have seen.

- you are telling the truth
- your infor is correct

Not important since you yourself said that you didn't use it N1

- kestegs is telling the truth

I believe he's telling the truth.

- his info is correct

None of his info so far has been wrong.

- no other mechanics in the game can cause items to pass around

No evidence for or against it. I do not believe that there was another mechanic though. Roles seem to be pretty unique so far (much based on claims though).

As you see here I commented on your last post.

Why does my info have to be correct? What info have I even shared that could possibly be incorrect assuming that I'm telling the truth?

As you say, no evidence for or against it. However, we have seen items mentioned from three different sources now: Myself, kestegs and DJ. Items seem to be pretty central to the game, so ruling out another mechanic seems pretty ignorant. Helpful if you wanna start an easy lynch train though..

You talked about "your info" as in "Moar's info" which was that Moar got no activated ability from FoE N1. It doesn't matter if that's correct or not as you, FoE, yourself said you didn't use your ability N1. It's as simple as you getting caught in trying to claim a role from one of those killed.

 

[FredOfErik]

I'm gonna redirect you back this quote and leave it with that until you come up with an actual argument.

You are jumping to conclusions instead of basing your arguments on facts. I understand that from what we know, I might look scummy to some, but your argument is still doing nothing but twisting the facts we have and the events we have seen.

 

[Kestegs]

Shoot: Goryani



Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2

I hope that's a joke.

This I believe. I targeted FoE N1 and he didn't use an activated ability so he did not give out an item that night. If batstegs knows an item was given out, then FoE is scum and fake role claiming.

Vote: FoE

Possibly, we can't exactly guarantee that though.

Trying to take out my vote before it can be registered? Scummy beyond scummy. Someone else needs to vote BA to test.

Last night I tracked FoE. No result.

N2 I tracked Jason Maher. Jason Maher targeted me. Jason Maher's first post of that day was something along the lines of "can anyone remind me why they thought Goryani was scum?" It's a bit obvious what Jason's role was even without knowing he targeted me.

Jason Maher's first post of D3 was directed toward SI and referenced fruit. Again, it looked like communication with someone.

Then Jason admitted talking to kestegs N1. I suspect Jason they set up the simple first post of the day code to communicate results to kestegs (which was in turn known to the other masons).

Yes, you nailed it. I thought he was being far too obvious, but it's not like I could talk to him anymore. Jason was commissioner Gordan, cop. He didn't investigate n1 due to talking with me. N2 he investigated gory and got a clean result. N3 was solar and a guilty result.

I gave an item to myself. More specifically, I gave "the Bat-mask" to myself. I picked the bat-mask in the hopes that the ability would be something along the lines of me "seeing through the eyes of batman". Specifically I'm hoping that this will allow be to either receive some form of investigative info. However, I still haven't received any info on what exactly it does and since it's passive I don't know when I will learn anything.

I chose to do so for several reasons:
- obviously, as I said, I hope the mask gives some sort of investigative info
- I am the only person that I know with certainty is town - hence, if anybody should get investigative info, I would prefer it to be me rather than anyone else
- the "Bat-mask" was one of the more mysterious items on the list. I don't know whether or not it is less or more powerful than some of the other more obvious items, but well.. It seemed exciting
- Having abilities is fun

I have not received any info from the mod other than a message basically saying that the item delivery was successful. Seen in hindlight I guess using my ability in someway that could possibly confirm me as town would be more useful than whatever my ability does in itself. Alas, I didn't do so.



If you're so sure I am scum then why kill goryani instead of me?



That's a lot of assumptions.

I just don't think I can buy this. More on it in a minute though, gotta make another reference check.

Oh my shot was a joke. A paranoid guy asked for it

Ok, that's good. While I can't guarantee gory is town I expect he is.

How often does someone who does things every other night get it confused with last night? Wanna bet he was doing something last night?

Makes sense to me I think.

Somebody is really trying to get the FoE issue to go away...

FoE claimed he could give items away and forgot to do it N1 (my ability confirms that he didn't use any activated ability that night), batstegs says he knows an item had been given away N1. So FoE is lying about his role claim which means he's scum.

Unless batstegs is really scumstegs and I do not believe that.

Let me clarify just a bit. I'm not 100% sure if I would classify this as an ability or an item. Possibly an item that grants an ability, possibly just straight up ability.

Who? Do you think they are my scum partners?

Partners? Seemed like he was referring to only one person.

Are you FOSing me CG? or do you just want me to claim? I know I am telling the truth, so either you are the one or some one else is lying, imagine that some one lying in a mafia game.

A much as I dislike doing so, I think I will need to do a full claim today.

Probably not the worst idea, I'd expect mafia already know anyways.

 

[Laarz]

Was I that obvious, I think you are right tho.

Like I said I am Alfred Pennyworth, my alignement is Town and my role is Doctor, and for those who will ask,

n1-protected Goryani
n2-protected djmbbandie
n3-protected Gwaihir
n4-wifom

 

[Kestegs]

I used my power N3, but am going to hold on to the specific details for now.

What was the point of waiting?

I do not know whether or not my targets are notified on whether or not they have received an item - I've PM'd the mod about this. All I know is that all items grant some form of passive ability. Whether or not anybody else have received items, I cannot comment on

So, you didn't know if they were notified or not? Wait. What? You targeted yourself!

I gave an item to myself. More specifically, I gave "the Bat-mask" to myself. I picked the bat-mask in the hopes that the ability would be something along the lines of me "seeing through the eyes of batman". Specifically I'm hoping that this will allow be to either receive some form of investigative info. However, I still haven't received any info on what exactly it does and since it's passive I don't know when I will learn anything.

Why did you think Batman would have an investigative role?

 

[Kestegs]

Was I that obvious, I think you are right tho.

Like I said I am Alfred Pennyworth, my alignement is Town and my role is Doctor, and for those who will ask,

n1-protected Goryani
n2-protected djmbbandie
n3-protected Gwaihir
n4-wifom

Between the unclaimed and my info I think it's fairly obvious. Not really your fault.

Laarz is indeed player x. I can't guarantee he is town or the doctor, but it certainly looks that way to me.

 

[Kestegs]

Was I that obvious, I think you are right tho.

Like I said I am Alfred Pennyworth, my alignement is Town and my role is Doctor, and for those who will ask,

n1-protected Goryani
n2-protected djmbbandie
n3-protected Gwaihir
n4-wifom

Actually, would you consider revealing your target? Since there wasn't a kill the mafia likely know who you targeted anyways. Of course they wouldn't both know if there was 2 mafia. Bpc claims to have tried to kill you also.

What do you think? I don't see any downside to it, but I'll leave it up to you.

 

[Laarz]

I had hoped to create a little wifom on my target last night but thinking more about it you are probably right, I protected myself last night.

 

[crawlingdeadman1]

Howdy everyone. Before I begin, I'd like to say that I have really enjoyed playing this game, especially "yesterday" (how do you refer to the previous game day and not make it confusing?). BPC and OMG in particular have shown me a fun way to play. Gwaihir, Gory, and a few others have shown me how a good player would play, but I doubt I'll ever be that, so I'll emulate BPC/OMG from now on. Yay!

Why did you think Batman would have an investigative role?

I've read that answering questions aimed at other people is scummy, but this made me laugh so much. DC = Detective Comics = first comic Batman was ever in? Detectives investigate... pretty easy conclusion to reach. He's Sherlock Holmes, Houdini, and a kung fu master all in one, I'd think his powers would/could be pretty diverse and include investigating, a death avoidance effect, and/or some sort of capture mechanism.

 

[crawlingdeadman1]

I would like to get back to Moar and I both being Bruce Wayne/Batman girlfriends and how I really dont think Pyro (with all the characters he has to chose from) would pick two. Moars claimed power is also pretty nifty and doesn't really fit into the theme of what I've read of Silver. It seems like more of a thief ability. Thief = Catwoman who at best is a neutral.

Vote: Moar

 

[FredOfErik]

Partners? Seemed like he was referring to only one person.

I was Moar, so she. I have no clue if she was talking about one or several persons, or who that might be - hence the question.

So, you didn't know if they were notified or not? Wait. What? You targeted yourself!



Why did you think Batman would have an investigative role?

I don't (not didn't) know if they are notified or not. Are as in the general sense; was, am, will be. Way to twist my words.

Why I think batman is an investigative role? I guess that him being a crime fighter and the main character, him also having a PR that potentially is investigative isn't a guess you would've made? Besides, I'm not talking about batman's role, I'm talking about the ability of the bat mask. Once again, you're twisting my words.

 

[Moar]

I would like to get back to Moar and I both being Bruce Wayne/Batman girlfriends and how I really dont think Pyro (with all the characters he has to chose from) would pick two. Moars claimed power is also pretty nifty and doesn't really fit into the theme of what I've read of Silver. It seems like more of a thief ability. Thief = Catwoman who at best is a neutral.

Vote: Moar

That was dj's ability I used after I gained a shot of it.

 

[FredOfErik]

And if you mean that I should know whether or not they are notified because I targetted myself - I only received one PM and that said I had successfully delivered the item to myself. I didn't get a separate PM saying that I had received it.