I fail to see how claiming after coju is any better than claiming before coju. Either you have a townie reason for targeting djm or you don't. Neither coju nor Moar should enter into that conversation.
Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game
- Thread starter Pyrotechnician1
- Start date
I fail to see how claiming after coju is any better than claiming before coju. Either you have a townie reason for targeting djm or you don't. Neither coju nor Moar should enter into that conversation.
Kestegs
Active member
That's because you don't know. Either way it looks like Cujo is sticking to his cards of immaculate visitation and won't claim.
Kestegs
Active member
I am Batman (Bruce wayne)
I am a watcher. I also have other tricks up my sleeve.
N1: watched goryani: Targeted by Male and (x)
N2: watched DJBarbie: Targeted by Ankeli and (x)
N3: watched DJBarbie: Targeted by Coju and Moar
(x) represents the same person on N1/2
I didn't really think that I should have been included in the list because I only watched him. I also received the exact same list that pyro originally posted in the thread, so it made sense to me. The reason nobody else should have targeted him is because I don't expect there is another watcher and I feel strongly that the doc or jailor targeted him the night before.
I believe that person (x) is likely the doctor. The only issue is why didn't they self target N1? I suppose they could be a jailor instead of a doctor, or just didn't think they'd be killed anyways. It is also possible that Ankeli was the doctor, but I lean more towards him being scum. This is why I fully expected that DJ would die.
I know other things. I'm not really interested in revealing how I know these things right now, but I know them. Here is one of the things I know:
I know that Solar is scum.
I know that I am town, I know that Dj died last night, I think that there are at least 2 night killing factions, I think that both of them targeted Dj last night.
I am a watcher. I also have other tricks up my sleeve.
N1: watched goryani: Targeted by Male and (x)
N2: watched DJBarbie: Targeted by Ankeli and (x)
N3: watched DJBarbie: Targeted by Coju and Moar
(x) represents the same person on N1/2
I didn't really think that I should have been included in the list because I only watched him. I also received the exact same list that pyro originally posted in the thread, so it made sense to me. The reason nobody else should have targeted him is because I don't expect there is another watcher and I feel strongly that the doc or jailor targeted him the night before.
I believe that person (x) is likely the doctor. The only issue is why didn't they self target N1? I suppose they could be a jailor instead of a doctor, or just didn't think they'd be killed anyways. It is also possible that Ankeli was the doctor, but I lean more towards him being scum. This is why I fully expected that DJ would die.
I know other things. I'm not really interested in revealing how I know these things right now, but I know them. Here is one of the things I know:
I know that Solar is scum.
I know that I am town, I know that Dj died last night, I think that there are at least 2 night killing factions, I think that both of them targeted Dj last night.
Kestegs
Active member
thefranklin
Well-known member
CG: did you use an ability N2?
If cdm and Kegs are both the same team, that would be one epic rouse.
Kegs: any specific reason you are convinced that the list of names is due to bandies role?
If cdm and Kegs are both the same team, that would be one epic rouse.
Kegs: any specific reason you are convinced that the list of names is due to bandies role?
BipolarChemist
New member
Hail Satinn, lord of all linens!
Caluin Graye
New member
@kestegs I'd like to add to your post that in the last mini game I was the doctor and targeted someone else on night one instead of myself because it opens up a hell of a lot of WIFOM. And in this game, the doc had perfect reason to target dj and then couldn't again, so I think your reasoning is very plausible that that person could be the doctor
Caluin Graye
New member
No, that makes perfect sense. Watching is a targeted ability, and you targeted DJM. Your name should definitely appear on that list.
If you believe Ankeli to be scum, and (X) to be the doctor, then can I presume that you think Ankeli tried killing DJM on Night Two but was blocked? What about Malevolent and Goryani?
So whom do you suggest we should lynch today; Coju, Moar, or Solar Ice?
Kestegs
Active member
Because I can't think of another logical reason for it. I'd be happy to hear any ideas though.
Just because he was more likely to lie about something that I could catch him in.
Yes, those are good possibilities, and could very well be true.
I realize after looking more closely at my role that it does say target, so I agree. It's not a common situation to come up though, a watcher being watched(or whatever the ability was)
Well, I know solar is scum, so that makes the most sense I'd say, but let's see what plays out.
I still would like a better explanation from Cujo.
Kestegs
Active member
Forgot a bit there:
Yes, I believe ankeli tried to kill DJ, but that's purely speculation.
I don't know about male trying to kill gory. We can assume that (x) didn't try to kill him unless gory has a way to avoid it himself, since we know male didn't save him. Male could have been lying about not trying to kill him, but I don't think it really matters at this point.
Yes, I believe ankeli tried to kill DJ, but that's purely speculation.
I don't know about male trying to kill gory. We can assume that (x) didn't try to kill him unless gory has a way to avoid it himself, since we know male didn't save him. Male could have been lying about not trying to kill him, but I don't think it really matters at this point.
omgwtfbbqpwned
New member
So Batstegs, who am I shooting? Moar, or Coju? Not that I'm going to listen anyways, but go for it.
My suggestion would be Solar Ice seems kestegs has mentioned several times he is adamant he is scum while the others already have some votes making it less of a pain (not that there really is one with a lot of daytime left) to get more votes on a different train.
My two cents no one asked for
BipolarChemist
New member
My two cents no one asked for
Cents? My good sir, you have no sense!
FredOfErik
New member
This is hilarious.
As much as I hate to believe (and admit) it, this isn't the most hopeless roleclaim I've seen so far. Only problem I have with it, is that a watcher that apparently also has other roles seems like a very very strong role. But ofc it is Batman.
I don't think (x) could be a jailer, if you're telling the truth. Then how would DJ had been able to use his power and tell us that he investigated cdm yesterday?
I'm willing to go with this, and after re-reading it and some of you guys' comments, I also feel less secure about Moar's claim. Top priorities are still coju and now apparently Solar too. Hopefully omg will give us a little help to decide.
Unvote: kestegs
If you don't target yourself on night one and are targeted by mafia, they kill you making your role worthless.
BipolarChemist
New member
011011000110111101101100001000000111000001100101011011100110100101110011
Jason Maher
Active member
Batstegs is Batstegs as claimed. Part of my ability is a one night only chat with Batman. I used this on night one, as I figured it would be useful to know who Batman is.
Jason Maher
Active member
So I trust him when he says Solar is scum.
Vote: Solar
Would you like a lemon Solar?
Vote: Solar
Would you like a lemon Solar?
