Batman - The Dark Knight Mafia Game

[Goryani]

I targeted him obviously. In a harmless way though. The reason I targeted him was that he didn't claim who he was or what exactly he did. I couldn't find out the name or alignment, but I could find out what his ability was.

What was your purpose in learning djm's ability?

 

[Kestegs]

I didn't know my character before googling her and I don't know yours. I don't have a lovers bond. What I don't see is why there can't be two different love interests in the game.

Yea, I often use google to find a nice fake claim that isn't likely to be in the game. Gory referenced it below, when I claimed Winthrop the lovely potion giving in owner.

You should ask Kangaxx what role that might be.

*groan*

But what role gets the info that he got about CDM(flubb) and is also a party host, that's a pretty crazy role.

That is just scum talking! Any info town can get is good info. I wish I could have found out more, but I did what I could.

I don't see that as being useful info when you could try to find out some info about somebody who is actually alive.

 

[Goryani]

It is, I truly expected I should not appear on the list. I also should have said that nobody besides me should have been visiting him, but that would have given away more info than I wanted to give.

Your statement, taken at face value, says you have to be a doc if you are town since there is no other reason any town role to target djm. To put it another way, if you aren't a doc, you just admitted you didn't have a town reason to be targeting djm.

But those statements are simply not true. Other town roles would consider djm a good target.

 

[Goryani]

one shot bus like ability (Redirector)

You redirected djm to target flubb?

 

[Goryani]

some abilities like NK are quite telling.

You sound certain you would learn of NK abilities (if present) whereas earlier you said you would only learn something if one used a "hidden" ability that night. That looks contradictory to me. Which is it?

My thinking was that we at least would know what his ability was then.

I take this to mean you think finding out the mechanism of djm's info source is more important than finding out if he or anyone else is scum/town.

 

[Goryani]

*groan*

But what role gets the info that he got about CDM(flubb) and is also a party host, that's a pretty crazy role.

I'm not going to voice my ideas until all the djm targeters have claimed.

 

[Kestegs]

Your statement, taken at face value, says you have to be a doc if you are town since there is no other reason any town role to target djm. To put it another way, if you aren't a doc, you just admitted you didn't have a town reason to be targeting djm.

But those statements are simply not true. Other town roles would consider djm a good target.

Yes, that is a fair statement taken at face value.

What you are not seeing is that: I don't see a reason why any role would target him, since I see no reason why someone would have the same role as me.

 

[Kestegs]

I'm not going to voice my ideas until all the djm targeters have claimed.

Mkay, that's fine.

I will divulge my role after coju does.

 

[coju]

Yea, I do have a very specific reason for believing that.



I know why you messed it up, but this is rather frustrating.



It is, I truly expected I should not appear on the list. I also should have said that nobody besides me should have been visiting him, but that would have given away more info than I wanted to give.



Yea, of course you can, what else would you do?



I love this post. Why are you going after me over coju? He hasn't even claimed and you are ready to lynch me?



Ah, but I think I like your post better, hop on board and see if we can get this train a rollin' before the town can think about it.

This is the most nonchalant post I've ever read. Especially the last part.

I highly doubt with all the characters Pyro has to choose from, he'd pick two generic Batman/Wayne girlfriends.

I also find it suspect that There would be 2 lovers of Bruce in this game.

I don't see why there couldn't be several lovers of Mr. Wayne. He seems like a lady lover. Always chasing tail. Which moar states also below.

What I don't see is why there can't be two different love interests in the game.

My thoughts exactly below.

Your statement, taken at face value, says you have to be a doc

But, kestegs' says that he should not have appeared on that list.

It is, I truly expected I should not appear on the list. I also should have said that nobody besides me should have been visiting him, but that would have given away more info than I wanted to give.

You shouldn't appear on the list, but no one besides you should have visited him. What are you, a serial doc?

 

[coju]

I was shocked to see my name up there. I did not visit djbambi last night. Or the night before.

 

[Kestegs]

I was shocked to see my name up there. I did not visit djbambi last night. Or the night before.

Did someone say you did the night before?

 

[Goryani]

That still doesn't answer my question of why the town needs to know that info on someone that is dead.

Why would anyone consider djm to be dead when they submit their N3 action?

 

[coju]

Did someone say you did the night before?

No, it just sounded good.

Why would anyone consider djm to be dead when they submit their N3 action?

Hmph!

 

[Goryani]

I was shocked to see my name up there. I did not visit djbambi last night. Or the night before.

Then who did you target?

 

[coju]

Then who did you target?

No one. I forgot to do it. Thought about you.

 

[Goryani]

The Scarecrow (Professor Jonathan Crane) – Mafia – Fear Monger

Anyone know what a Fear Monger is?

 

[Goryani]

No one. I forgot to do it. Thought about you.

Are you calling Pyro a liar?

 

[coju]

Yes. .
Or someone went through me to do something. I don't know, as I didn't visit anyone last night.

 

[Bad Ash]

Welp, I am a little annoyed. I tried to kill Coju last night but got the response that I was blocked. The main advantage of my role was in hopes that mafia would choose from the alive list to make a decision and not notice anything was off, but CDM made sure that wouldn't happen. I was all prepared to call for that person to be scum, but I don't think that CDM is shockingly.

What I do think is that there 100% is two mafia. Since I can't think of any reason for a townie to try to use an ability on myself, and what does the mafia have to lose by trying to block someone who could kill them and see if I am targetable? Mr. Freeze is already dead as well, so there is almost definitely two groups unless something got all quirky during the night or there is a jailer with a blocker. My shots are 100% guaranteed to work, so it isn't that.

Why Coju? Because his posts have reeked of scum from the beginning. Even his ones today haven't sat well with me. But:

Why would anyone consider djm to be dead when they submit their N3 action?

I mean...kestegs would be my choice for lynch as of right now. If I was able to vote I would be lynching until I hit at least one mafia from that group and reevaluate the situation (because I almost guarantee there is two).

I don't have a vote, so I won't push this agenda too hard, but I want it out there as that's what I'd do.

 

[Pyrotechnician1]

Are you calling Pyro a liar?

The only person that can call me a liar is my wife! Hey...wait a minute, thats not right....

Count as of #638:

8 to lynch, 9 to lock

Vote:
kestegs(2): Solar Ice, FredOfErik,
Moar(1): crawlingdeadman