Baldur's Gate Mafia Game

I'm making inferences to their alignment based on their behavior. Post 385 and the conversation that followed is about them, not you.

Post 385 serves one purpose to me: you waiting to say "would Solar really pair a watcher and a tracker together?"
 
Post 385 serves one purpose to me: you waiting to say "would Solar really pair a watcher and a tracker together?"

I neither said nor implied anything of the sort. In fact, I said and implied exactly the opposite. I was the first one to bring it up saying it should be talked about. I can't make a "would SI do this...?" response unless someone else talks about it. No. One. Did.
 
By all rights, someone should have pointed to pharphis the mafia watcher and made some insinuation about my tracker claim. It's a connection I expected several to talk about if only to guage my reaction. Only CDM did (though he didn't exactly point out a possible connection between pharphis and I, he did bring up the idea of a mafia tracker). What's that say?

Sounds like you prepared for it.
 
Is it just me, or is Bad Ash just floundering around, randomly targeting people? Townies generally don't do that.
 
Is it just me, or is Bad Ash just floundering around, randomly targeting people? Townies generally don't do that.

Lol. I provided posts for why I would support a Noodle lynch, a Gory lynch and a CG lynch. They are there. If you see them as random then so be it. I can get a rug ready for you.
 
Yes, you seem to be obsessed with lynching me for no apparent reason. I agree. You are completely illogical.

yes no apparent reason except for not voting for Kestegs or Pharphis, and posting extremely similar things to Pharphis and not seeing the repercussions of it.

Careful, you don't want to break your record for posts in the last four games ;)
 
If I had voted for pharphis would I still be a suspect? Please be honest.

No you wouldnt. Quite obviously.

So explain to me how Sathoris is scum then. Convince me anyone else is scum. Do something as opposed to asking questions that answer themselves.
 
No you wouldnt. Quite obviously.

That shouldn't be an "obviously." pharphis was more than scummy enough to have been bussed (though I agree not by kestegs - that would be some seriously messed up reverse psychology).

So explain to me how Sathoris is scum then. Convince me anyone else is scum. Do something as opposed to asking questions that answer themselves.

The lynchpin was how he fished for more information beyond what pharphis provided. Either he's on pharphis team and SI gave pharphis' result only to pharphis and Sathoris is trying to find out the hint pharphis tried to give or he's not on pharphis team, suspects there is more to the pharphis/BA/Goryani situation and wants to learn more.

Beyond that, follow through with your "there are two mafia" theorycrafting. When there are two mafia, there are certain things mafia DON'T talk about for fear of making it easier for the other mafia to identify them (bad because another mafia want them lynched and bad because another mafia might night kill them). Sathoris behavior fits that perfectly. Lots of little bits to follow along that line of thinking, such as his slip about there being two mafia before he ever voiced suspicion of there being two mafia.
 
That shouldn't be an "obviously." pharphis was more than scummy enough to have been bussed (though I agree not by kestegs - that would be some seriously messed up reverse psychology).



The lynchpin was how he fished for more information beyond what pharphis provided. Either he's on pharphis team and SI gave pharphis' result only to pharphis and Sathoris is trying to find out the hint pharphis tried to give or he's not on pharphis team, suspects there is more to the pharphis/BA/Goryani situation and wants to learn more.

Beyond that, follow through with your "there are two mafia" theorycrafting. When there are two mafia, there are certain things mafia DON'T talk about for fear of making it easier for the other mafia to identify them (bad because another mafia want them lynched and bad because another mafia might night kill them). Sathoris behavior fits that perfectly. Lots of little bits to follow along that line of thinking, such as his slip about there being two mafia before he ever voiced suspicion of there being two mafia.

Well as we've discussed a lot of people haven't discussed what they should be right?

If Sath is scum, it's a bussing job on the level on Pharphis from a couple games ago. Wouldn't it?
 
If Sath is scum, it's a bussing job on the level on Pharphis from a couple games ago. Wouldn't it?

Not if it was a bussing of kestegs instead. But before pharphis was Jerome, Sathoris was Jerome. See the Ravenwood Retreat game. If Sathoris was on either kestegs or pharphis team (or both) I think he votes. It's the smart mafia play. I'm wonder who bussed pharphis and how many there were, not "if" someone bussed pharphis.
 
Back
Top