Baldur's Gate Mafia Game

[pharphis]

It seems like cujo is trying to get himself lynched, who in the village tries to do that:scratchchin:

Not you. That potentially explains his weird behaviour

 

[coju]

Well if that happened,it would be a kinda reverse Jerome move wouldn't it:wink:

I wonder if cujo is one of the village people and I don't mean the fireman or the indian

That leaves the cowboy and... oh man...

 

[pharphis]

and the cow girl?

Forum was done for awhile. I'm guessing it wasn't just me?

 

[flubbucket1]

I'm curious - what, if anything, could have kestegs said for you to not vote for him? The way I see it, anything he claims will be circumspect and unverifiable until we lynch him. And we have to lynch him.



Will that arisen time be this game? This last sentence sounds like it'll be this game. What use of bussing does a townie have?



Good call. Let's find out.

Vote: kestegs

I see no reason not to lynch you. As mentioned, anything you claim can really only be verified through a lynch.

As for my second vote, I'm bouncing between pharphis and thefranklin. There was some interesting banter between both of them and kestegs in Twilight. I haven't yet caught up totally with today so I'll come back to this. For now, just to prove that I can vote or not...

Vote2: thefranklin

What I was kind of interested in is what other people would and wouldn't say with regards to the outcome of kestegs exploits.

I'm having a real hard time with the notion someone doesn't even bother reading the Day One story to find out if they were Night Killed or not.

Well there is one reason to not have to read it, right scumbags???

Lol..... I fail at paying attention. Then again everybody has been ignoring the fact that 2 people died.

I've not been ignoring it at all.

Been paying attention as well.

 

[Jason Maher]

After reading the dawn post and deadstegs' response again, all I can say is: fare thee (not) well deadstegs. No way you're not scum. I'll give you a point for trying. Drixx was obviously Winthrop, the Innkeeper. And Im guessing revealing the indentity of his killer was part of his ability.

As for vote 2, no-one jumps out as being overly suspicious. I would like for coju to be a bit more forthcoming on how he knows what he supposedly knows (the identity of 3 players). And I'm not sure how he'd get from my general statement that the sucm would not want two lynches to identifying CG.

 

[Kestegs]

I don't see any evidence you tried to block scum. Not once this game have you discussed CG nor did you mention which mode you tying for. At best you went along with the words I first mentioned. If I suspect someone as scum and try to stop them from doing something, I'm gonna make sure that is known come claim time.

By the way... Why did you not try to let a townie know your identity? If I had the role you claimed I'm pretty sure that would be the route I'd take.

Obviously you are just twisting my words at this point to make me look bad, but I'll play along. I specifically said that I picked him to so that he would know I was town.

It seems like cujo is trying to get himself lynched, who in the village tries to do that:scratchchin:

He always looks that way, it's kinda like his thing.

 

[Sathoris]

As for vote 2, no-one jumps out as being overly suspicious. I would like for coju to be a bit more forthcoming on how he knows what he supposedly knows (the identity of 3 players). And I'm not sure how he'd get from my general statement that the sucm would not want two lynches to identifying CG.

No opinion on Pharphis?

 

[coju]

After reading the dawn post and deadstegs' response again, all I can say is: fare thee (not) well deadstegs. No way you're not scum. I'll give you a point for trying. Drixx was obviously Winthrop, the Innkeeper. And Im guessing revealing the indentity of his killer was part of his ability.

As for vote 2, no-one jumps out as being overly suspicious. I would like for coju to be a bit more forthcoming on how he knows what he supposedly knows (the identity of 3 players). And I'm not sure how he'd get from my general statement that the sucm would not want two lynches to identifying CG.

Forthcoming: Just my opinion. No "Coors Light Cold Hard Facts" or anything like that. Sadly, I'm not the last village idiot... police man. Pharphis, really? You don't know the village people? Cowboy, fireman, policeman, Indian. (After a quick google search... it appears there are more than four village people...
image spoiler

Spoiler

if that image was a fail, then here is the url http://1.bp.********.com/_jbNE0LYId...Wlg0sNM/s1600/Village-People-Fancy-Dress-.jpg

That image also appears to be the same man. After that sentence, I'm not searching that again...
Kestegs does appear scummier and scummier as the day goes on. The main people going after him are good at leading people's thoughts and making others appear scummy -- at least to me. I'm not trying to get lynched, just not trying to lurk.

 

[coju]

guess i forgot about that cussword. b.........t

 

[coju]

What I was kind of interested in is what other people would and wouldn't say with regards to the outcome of kestegs exploits.

I'm having a real hard time with the notion someone doesn't even bother reading the Day One story to find out if they were Night Killed or not.

Well there is one reason to not have to read it, right scumbags???




I've not been ignoring it at all.

Been paying attention as well.

I agree with you here glibbucket. I've actually tried coming up with a case against someone, then had to go back and find the beginning of the day just to realize they had already died ><
Someone mentioned something that brought up this thought: "He didn't need to look because the kill wasn't sent for thefranklin."
But, kegs is locked, now how about a vote 2....
I still believe CG is he best run. Pharphis guarding Kellogg's? Didn't really catch that, but other's have and have expressed opinions on that, and anything against what they say is scum, right? Right.

 

[Kestegs]

Right? right? Right! Right. Right! Right?

cool, I'm locked!

No not really, but it's info for the town at least.

 

[coju]

Right? right? Right! Right. Right! Right?

cool, I'm locked!

No not really, but it's info for the town at least.

Since you're locked, what do you have to say for yourself? If I were you, I'd say the only reason was because the word 'kegs' was used 27 times in the story. I wanted to vote you simply because of that. Then the drixx information superhighway came about.
Question: Did you really use drixx's information to try and save yourself? Who are you, really?

Whooooooo
Rrrrrr
Uuuuuuu?
*Puffffffff*

 

[Kestegs]

I am exactly as I said I was. I don't really have much else to add, I gave all the info I have.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Shouldn't it be "we should lynch us" since he put his own name on the list?

Possibly. Maybe. I don't know. I dun grammaer gud.

2. I acknowledged the post wasn't directed at me, and responded with my OWN opinions. That's acceptable right? I had a thought about keg's position and thought to share it. Somehow everyone is equation "has an opinion about someone" = "trying to save that someone"

I used to do that. It got me lynched on multiple occasions, as both town and mafia. Answering a question aimed at another person before said person answers looks like you're trying to coach them on an answer.

Assume kegs is scum:
Here's a question I believe I've already asked but is more or less rhetorical: Who in their right mind is going to prod their team mate D1 to come up with some crappy story who is almost guaranteed to be lynched? Keep in mind the 2 lynches today ensure that not only will kegs be lynched, but likely any scum partner who "prods" him. See bolded sentence for a reminder.

WIFOM.

It seems like cujo is trying to get himself lynched, who in the village tries to do that:scratchchin:

A jackal! Jackal! It's a jackal! It looks like a jackal! Jackal? Jackal! It's a jackal! Jackal?

I'm having a real hard time with the notion someone doesn't even bother reading the Day One story to find out if they were Night Killed or not.

People make mistakes and forget things occasionally. Get over it.

 

[pharphis]

Posting this for context. Laarz was asking GORYANI this question. Not kegs.

Do you think that kegs killed Drixx?

Not directed at me but I want to add to this. Kegs is in the unfortunate seat of having to explain what his role is, otherwise the town misses out on information. If kegs is mafia then he likely gets lynched, but if he's town then he certainly needs to give up at least some indication of his role, because the mafia know he has a role, and if he's reluctant to tell us then that just makes it likely they will target him.

I used to do that. It got me lynched on multiple occasions, as both town and mafia. Answering a question aimed at another person before said person answers looks like you're trying to coach them on an answer.

Can you explain how I'm coaching goryani to answer a specific way?

does no one realize my post essentially just says that kegs needs to claim or we lynch him, and that even if he claims we may still need to lynch him?

@BPC, how am I trying to subtly save kegs.

 

[Caluin Graye]

Can you explain how I'm coaching goryani to answer a specific way?

does no one realize my post essentially just says that kegs needs to claim or we lynch him, and that even if he claims we may still need to lynch him?

I wasn't accusing, merely clarifying.

 

[pharphis]

I wasn't accusing, merely clarifying.

Okay.

Only like 5 hours left in the day and people are pretty absent.

 

[Sathoris]

Posting this for context. Laarz was asking GORYANI this question. Not kegs.






Can you explain how I'm coaching goryani to answer a specific way?

does no one realize my post essentially just says that kegs needs to claim or we lynch him, and that even if he claims we may still need to lynch him?

@BPC, how am I trying to subtly save kegs.

That's day one for you. One wrong post and you're done for. I'm usually against such lynches and often don't vote on D1. On one hand we have a near confirmed scum lynch on Kegs already, perhaps it's worth the extra risk to lynch on flimy cases. On the other hand, the only interaction pattern on you so far is with Kegs, which is disputed in any case, and his reveal might help us make a decision tomorrow. And while we have plenty of other suspect people, it's still day one and no conviction can be put in any case.

I'm suprised you didn't make this post until now, scum caught for wrong reasons found a loophole?

Apparently this was picked up on as well. I wrote down yesterday that phar and kegs seemed connected and this just further confirms it.

To respond to phar: I found this quiote to be very suspicious for one huge reson - you immediately jump to the idea that kegs is innocent and has to explain himself. Not to the more obvious (to me at least) reason that he is the mafia that killed Drixx. Seems like a prod to a teammate to come up with a story more than a question or accusation at someone who looks guilty.

Actually Pharphis' first post was that Kegs is likely scum. And your 'connection' during twilight isn't much more than banter. Opportunistic behaviour here unbecoming of you.

Maybe it's because I'm seriously reading day one for a change I'm finding it all very suspect.

I've got my eye on you lot!

 

[pharphis]

I am exactly as I said I was. I don't really have much else to add, I gave all the info I have.

How about you let us know what you've found suspicious today like a townie should.

I just realized your pic is different.

 

[Bad Ash]

After reading the dawn post and deadstegs' response again, all I can say is: fare thee (not) well deadstegs. No way you're not scum. I'll give you a point for trying. Drixx was obviously Winthrop, the Innkeeper. And Im guessing revealing the indentity of his killer was part of his ability.

As for vote 2, no-one jumps out as being overly suspicious. I would like for coju to be a bit more forthcoming on how he knows what he supposedly knows (the identity of 3 players). And I'm not sure how he'd get from my general statement that the sucm would not want two lynches to identifying CG.

Basically this. But it sounds like he is still feigning town.

If kestegs is mafia and we don't lynch pharphis we need to do it tomorrow. I see no other reason for kestegs to act like town now.

Also @gory what do you think about noodles "this game sucks" post if kestegs is town?

Sent from my SCH-I535 using Tapatalk 2