Gods of Ancient Greece. Forum mafia game.

If pharphis targeted a PGO and was killed in that manner as I watched him, would I see the PGO or no? I don't know exactly how that works and I'm somewhat confused in general here.
 
There are a few options that I can see.

PGo, as you said, I don't think you would get a result in that situation.
Pharphis was a ninja.
Some kind of lovers role.
And of course that you are just lying.

Who had pharphis claimed? Is there a logical lover we could tie him to?
 
Well, there is only one thing to do today and that is the follow up lynch of FoE. Anything else would be idiotic.
 
And put med down for Zokar lying. Going for spreading confusion now with his result since everybody except me seems to believe his claim.
 
kestegs said:
There are a few options that I can see.

PGo, as you said, I don't think you would get a result in that situation.
Pharphis was a ninja.
Some kind of lovers role.
And of course that you are just lying.

Who had pharphis claimed? Is there a logical lover we could tie him to?
Click to expand...

To clarify, I wasn't suggesting pharphis was a ninja, rather his killer is.

And yes, I could be lying, but I'd like to think that if I was lying I could come up with something better than "hey guys, I got no results on somebody who died, please don't kill me".
 
Moar said:
And put med down for Zokar lying. Going for spreading confusion now with his result since everybody except me seems to believe his claim.
Click to expand...

I've never said in believed Zokar, I just thought foe was a better lynch for yesterday.

Zokar said:
To clarify, I wasn't suggesting pharphis was a ninja, rather his killer is.

And yes, I could be lying, but I'd like to think that if I was lying I could come up with something better than "hey guys, I got no results on somebody who died, please don't kill me".
Click to expand...

Meh, that's just wifom, especially since you've made sure to point it out twice now. That's a hardcore lamist right there.
 
kestegs said:
I've never said in believed Zokar, I just thought foe was a better lynch for yesterday.



Meh, that's just wifom, especially since you've made sure to point it out twice now. That's a hardcore lamist right there.
Click to expand...

O.o I suggested his killer was ninja, you said he was, i thought you misunderstood my point so i clarified... why is that so difficult?
 
Well we can't afford miss-lynches I think. My first thought is delayed kills, that could explain the no result. The way I see it, no result in 6 nights? Seems fishy, on the other side would a mafia risk faking a role and giving no results?
 
Zokar said:
O.o I suggested his killer was ninja, you said he was, i thought you misunderstood my point so i clarified... why is that so difficult?
Click to expand...

I forgot to respond to your first line, my last post was in response to your second part.

Yes, Pharphis wouldn't be the ninja, the killer would be I think.
 
korialstraz said:
This is what I was afraid of before we killed Jcakes. That it wouldn't decrease the amount of deaths the following night. I fealt we were in a good spot having lynched 2 scum, including the resurector, but now? We're not that many people left alive. I'm hoping we only get the 2 extra night kills every other night, gives us more time to work with.
Click to expand...

what made you think we would have this many kills even after a cakes kill?
 
Vote: Zokar

Here's for hoping some of you may have changed your mind about me.

Let's just look at Zokar's claim. He has watched 6 people, 6 nights, in a game that is apparently stuffed with PRs. Not a single result. Last night he even watched one of those that were killed - still no result. I simply cannot believe that.

However, I can see why he would come forward with the pharphis result - the "don't you think I would've chosen a better lie?" defense actually can be used as a decent defense against people calling you scum. To me it doesn't look like a town player that is frustrated about his role not working - it looks like a scum player that's heading towards a lynch either today or tomorrow and is becoming desperate.

On my lynch: if I have understood you all correctly, you suspect me of being an SK or part of another group that can only kill every other night? If so, I suggest you do not lynch me today, as if, even if your suspicions were correct, I couldn't do any harm tonight.

On the game setup: I still think we have mafia left - and I believe Zokar to be a part of that. Further I think we have at least one SK - my guess would be Moar.
 
With the end of the world and all coming up soon, we might need to pause the game for a bit while everyone sorts out their wings / horns.
 
FredOfErik said:
Vote: Zokar

Here's for hoping some of you may have changed your mind about me.

Let's just look at Zokar's claim. He has watched 6 people, 6 nights, in a game that is apparently stuffed with PRs. Not a single result. Last night he even watched one of those that were killed - still no result. I simply cannot believe that.

However, I can see why he would come forward with the pharphis result - the "don't you think I would've chosen a better lie?" defense actually can be used as a decent defense against people calling you scum. To me it doesn't look like a town player that is frustrated about his role not working - it looks like a scum player that's heading towards a lynch either today or tomorrow and is becoming desperate.

On my lynch: if I have understood you all correctly, you suspect me of being an SK or part of another group that can only kill every other night? If so, I suggest you do not lynch me today, as if, even if your suspicions were correct, I couldn't do any harm tonight.

On the game setup: I still think we have mafia left - and I believe Zokar to be a part of that. Further I think we have at least one SK - my guess would be Moar.
Click to expand...
What makes you think the game is "stuffed full of power roles" ?

I do agree that I think we still have mafia and at least 1 sk left.
 
kestegs said:
What makes you think the game is "stuffed full of power roles" ?

I do agree that I think we still have mafia and at least 1 sk left.
Click to expand...

Every lynch reveal has been a power role.
Every claim has been a power role (not a single VT yet).
Lots of kills -> lots of anti-town powers -> should mean lots of town PRs for balance.

No prove, but I would call it a fair assumption.
 
FredOfErik said:
Vote: Zokar

Here's for hoping some of you may have changed your mind about me.

Let's just look at Zokar's claim. He has watched 6 people, 6 nights, in a game that is apparently stuffed with PRs. Not a single result. Last night he even watched one of those that were killed - still no result. I simply cannot believe that.

However, I can see why he would come forward with the pharphis result - the "don't you think I would've chosen a better lie?" defense actually can be used as a decent defense against people calling you scum. To me it doesn't look like a town player that is frustrated about his role not working - it looks like a scum player that's heading towards a lynch either today or tomorrow and is becoming desperate.

On my lynch: if I have understood you all correctly, you suspect me of being an SK or part of another group that can only kill every other night? If so, I suggest you do not lynch me today, as if, even if your suspicions were correct, I couldn't do any harm tonight.

On the game setup: I still think we have mafia left - and I believe Zokar to be a part of that. Further I think we have at least one SK - my guess would be Moar.
Click to expand...

Vote: FredOfErik
 
Log in to Reply / Create Site Account
Remove Ads - Go PurePremium

Latest posts

Back
Top