Create Your Own Role Mafia game

I really can't remember what time I sent it. I did get my night chat PM from Goryani at 1:00 PM CST on Saturday the 13th. So it would have been before then.
 
So you say you feel we were close to someone slipping up and then not even 10 minutes later in the next post you list your targets? What was the reason for suddenly revealing this information?



What I want to know out of all of this is that you knew there was an issue with what was being said, you knew very well that Ankeli could have had the politician role based on your switch targets, and yet you withheld this information and let the town build a case against ankeli in the meantime. Why would someone as town do something like this?

I agree with this. It doesn't feel quite right. There way very much talk about the politician role and why it was good to have it gone. You never mentioned or even hinted at that it might not be gone. Quite some time went before I was awake, reading the PM and changing my vote pretty much right away. Did you post inbetween? Think you did. You definitely knew.


A very coherent drunk post? Was it really a drunk post? WIFOM.

I was really surprised that I managed to write that. Must have taken an hour to get the spelling right. ;)
And yes, I was drunk.
 
The MJB role doesn't rotate or changes hands if the delayed death is triggered according to the description. So Solar had to have it and lied about having it.

Yeah, sorry. Had a really bad day yesterday. Got reminded why I always regret the day after that I got drunk. Overreacted. Done it before and will do it again.

Unvote: Moar

I didn't bold it. Stupid mistake, again.

Unvote: Moar
 
This will make you feel better, why don't you join me?

Unvote: Moar
Vote: flubbucket

My reasoning is the Solar being the BFF comment. I don't like it, I don't trust it, and I think its a link to SI by flub who was paris and wanted to keep his scum buddy close.

Also, If Solar Ice would have been the BFF HE WOULD HAVE LOST HIS JOE BLACK ROLE AND ONLY BEEN THE BFF!

he kept it.

BOOM ROASTED FLUBBY BOY. (unless im wrong)

Moar's issues aside, that shouldn't have any influence on her aligenment. Why would you switch from Moar to Flubb just when she says what she did?

Not seeing the whole Paris debate either, but discussing role actions in depth is a good thing. Right? Right?
 
No night sorta limits "actions" but I am wondering why so little action out of Gwaihir.

But I'm sure he'll have something....plausible?
 
Vote: Ankeli

will show us one way or the other. If hes the politician, we can go for gwaihir. If hes not, then we have a dead mafioso. Simple Simon.

I dont want people to forget about Moar though. My vote would be going for her if it wasnt for Ankeli not reading the thread.

Time stamp 12:37

well, whatever. I shouldnt have made it so obvious, anyways.

Target A: Bad Ash
Target B: Moar
Target C: flubbucket

Flubs role is out of the game and I didnt see him claim one. But AFAWK there was no kill last night and we do have a verified block on Ankeli? Only other options as stated are Mafia targeting Sath or not sending it in on purpose and claiming a block on Ankeli.

Flub a dub dub, whats your role from yest?

Time stamp 17:55. His comment about being close to a slip up was at 17:52. You guys might be on to something.
 
Moar's issues aside, that shouldn't have any influence on her aligenment. Why would you switch from Moar to Flubb just when she says what she did?

Not seeing the whole Paris debate either, but discussing role actions in depth is a good thing. Right? Right?

I don't understand where you are going with this. Is Flub not scum? Also, if they were both mafia, Flub's Bff decision would have come before SI could tell him not to do it.
 
I don't understand where you are going with this. Is Flub not scum? Also, if they were both mafia, Flub's Bff decision would have come before SI could tell him not to do it.

For the record I don't believe Flubb is scum. I don't think the paris/bff discussion has any merit. Flubb simply made SI his bff who turned up scum. Flubb's play is more important to me than the wifom discussion if he chose a mafia teammate as bff.

BA mentioned yesterday that he would vote for Moar were it not for Ankeli. He also said he would go after mafia confirmed Gwaihir when Ankeli flipped politician but decided against it? (If that's been explained, please point me in the right direction, because I'm already confused by the roles rotation) He voted for Moar today for the same reasons he had yesterday, no night action could influence his decision. But after Moar made her quitting post he suddenly switches to flubb with a flimsy reason about the paris thing, which he later goes through great lengths to substantiate. And if I'm not mistaken boils down solely to this:

I dont think trying to reason out something is making a flawed arguement. I am saying if I was mafia, and if I was Paris, I would at least consider making my teammate the BFF. I was wondering if anyone would do the same. How the hell else are we supposed to get information in this game? If everyone in this game would consider making their teammate the BFF, it holds water, and I could STILL be wrong about flubs alignment.

Whether Flubb would pick his mafia teammate as bff or not. Furthermore he mentioned he probably won't change his vote for flubb. Now is that really a better lynch target than Moar?
 
I want to vote for Bad Ash, but I cannot let us forget about Moar's early play that would have gotten anyone lynched were it not for Ankeli with a lynch wish.
 
Thirdly, If we want to just get to the basics of it, if flub was town, there is a 25%-ish chance that he would have picked a mafia member to be the BFF. Plausible odds, but 70% ish chance he chose a townie and he didnt (the remaining 5% is because flub is a town member in this scenario)

And I even forgot this little gem of evidence.
 
Gonna follow precedent here:

Vote: Moar


not reading the thread is scummy -.- (as Ive been reminded by quite a few people)

Paris has been removed from the game. Also, I think you've been the scummiest of the players alive and this is snowballed by us not knowing mal role, and you "fake" voting for Mal.

Here he votes for me partly because not reading the thread is scummy. The reason he assumed that is that I asked if there was a Paris D2. I asked that to see if the D1 claims from Gwaihir and him were correct. Trying to get me off his back? Trying to stiffle further questions about him and his role?

Time stamp 12:37



Time stamp 17:55. His comment about being close to a slip up was at 17:52. You guys might be on to something.

Please see post 506 for the quote from BA. There his reason for voting Ankeli is that he didn't read the thread.
Looking similar and very flawed.
 
Please see post 506 for the quote from BA. There his reason for voting Ankeli is that he didn't read the thread.
Looking similar and very flawed.


You are directing me to read my own post? Nice, you caught me, I probably didn't do that the first time through while typing it. I guess the first paragraph is the one I find the most important, when he knows he switched around the player with the politician role with his own bus driving. As for the not reading the thread comment, don't know what he is trying to say there. Just paint your name a little blacker?
 
I agree with this. It doesn't feel quite right. There way very much talk about the politician role and why it was good to have it gone. You never mentioned or even hinted at that it might not be gone. Quite some time went before I was awake, reading the PM and changing my vote pretty much right away. Did you post inbetween? Think you did. You definitely knew.

I was really surprised that I managed to write that. Must have taken an hour to get the spelling right. ;)
And yes, I was drunk.

You're post made me think about how we discussed how bad the politician was for town all day. We all knew that there was a way to remove roles with dr Frank. So what does BA the bus driver do? He targets the person with that role.

Time stamp 12:37

Time stamp 17:55. His comment about being close to a slip up was at 17:52. You guys might be on to something.

Pedit: Franklin covered my thoughts on this post actually.
 
You are directing me to read my own post? Nice, you caught me, I probably didn't do that the first time through while typing it. I guess the first paragraph is the one I find the most important, when he knows he switched around the player with the politician role with his own bus driving. As for the not reading the thread comment, don't know what he is trying to say there. Just paint your name a little blacker?

I'm sorry. I see that my post is unclear. I meant to point everybody at your post for the quote from BA to understand what I was trying to say. It should have been there instead of your post. I'll dig it up and repost.
 
Time stamp 12:37

Time stamp 17:55. His comment about being close to a slip up was at 17:52. You guys might be on to something.

Never mind before, I forgot what I was getting at (can't see previous posts while typing on my phone).

BA tried to get a train going on ankeli knowing the whole time that the politician role could still be out there due to his switch. Or he should have known at least.
 
You're post made me think about how we discussed how bad the politician was for town all day. We all knew that there was a way to remove roles with dr Frank. So what does BA the bus driver do? He targets the person with that role.

Very good catch! It was clear that I had it.
 
Back
Top